SPAGHETTI BOWL OF MARINE UNDERSEA CABLES: PROTECTING CONNECTIVITY AND COMMUNICATIONS

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
1 Video View·Mar 19, 2026
28th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Philippines🇵🇭- February 3-4, 2025
-Dr. Lee Jaehyon
Principal Fellow, Center for Regional Studies, The Asian Institute for Policy Studies (live streaming)
We now have the opportunity to hear from Dr. Lee Jeon,
the principal fellow at the Center for Regional Studies
at the Asian Institute for Policy Studies.
This will be a live stream regarding the spaghetti
bowl of marine undersea cables protecting connectivity
and communications.
Dr. Jeon, the floor is yours.
Thank you very much.
Thank you to the Congress of the Philippines
for having me in this forum this afternoon.
I'm really sorry for not attending the forum in person.
I wish I could, because this morning, the temperature here
in Seoul was like minus 12 degrees.
And still, we are recording minus 7 degrees
in the afternoon.
So I guess the temperature in Manila will be much warmer.
Anyway, let me introduce myself just briefly.
As I introduced, my name is Jaehyun Lee.
I'm a principal fellow at the ASEAN Institute.
Basically, I can't say that I'm an expert on the undersea
underwater cable issue.
But I'm more an expert on Southeast Asian affairs
and international relations surrounding
Southeast Asian countries, as well as ASEAN.
But I am developing my research interest
into many non-traditional security issues,
including this undersea cable issue.
So probably, I could cover some regional implications
of this undersea cable issue.
That is why I was invited to this forum.
I got like 15 minutes.
So I have to hurry up a little bit.
In my presentation, I will cover three different topics.
The first of all, I have to mention
why undersea cable matters.
I have to mention the importance of undersea cable.
There are two different implications
for the civilian and the military
and conflict situation.
Basically, we are so much dependent on undersea cable
for our communication and daily life.
It is like the air we breathe every day.
So for example, this one like online meeting
that I have today is all thanks to the undersea cable
connecting different countries across the border.
And the emails we are sending, receiving,
they're all dependent on this undersea cable,
as well as the SMS.
And the business sectors increasingly is dependent
on the undersea cable for the communication
and commercial activities, not to mention e-commerce
and online bankings.
And also the national critical infrastructure
for the whole nation is increasingly dependent
on undersea cable for the communication, transactions
and data flows.
For example, smart grid for electricity allocation,
controlling transportation in the bustling major cities
and smart mobility, major national infrastructure,
which is controlled remotely or centrally via online.
It's all thanks to undersea cable.
So if there is a serious damage in the undersea cable,
it will cause national scale disaster or chaos.
For example, Philippine is affected by many typhoons
in a year.
The typhoons impact, the disaster typhoons impact
will be limited regionally.
But if the undersea cable connecting Philippine
to the outside world is damaged,
then the implication, the damage will be nationwide
in such a short time.
And also the undersea cable has some military
and conflict situation implications as well.
There are well known cases in Europe in recent months,
last year in November, December and January,
some undersea cable connecting like Germany,
Finland, Sweden were damaged.
And people suspect Russian ship is involved in this case.
And also in December, Chinese flagged ship was suspected
damaging Baltic Sea cable.
And a few days, a few weeks ago in January 2025,
Swedish authorities seized a vessel trying to damage
undersea cable that connects Latvia and Sweden.
So there are these kind of cases in Europe.
And by cutting undersea cable,
the perpetrator intends to damage C4ISR,
which is Command, Control, Communication,
Computers, Intelligence, Surveillance
and Reconnaissance activities by the military.
The intention is quite clear.
And try to cripple opponent's potential retaliation
or counter-attack capability at the early stage
of war or battle.
So military aspect and civilian aspects
will be severely impacted when the undersea cable is damaged.
But in most of the countries, big countries,
this undersea cable damage is not a serious problem
because many countries have multiple lines,
multiple cables that connecting this one country
to another or outside the world.
So if there is a damage on one line of cable,
the backup lines can still function.
And there could be some congestion in data flows
and a bit of a slowdown, but it still functions.
So it should be okay.
But the serious problem is some small countries,
for example, the countries in the South Pacific Islands,
they are dependent on single line.
So this single line of undersea cable is damaged,
then the whole country will go back to pre-electronic era.
For example, in 2022,
there was undersea volcano activities near Tonga
and the single line connecting outside the world
and Tonga was severely damaged.
And it put the whole country almost entirely disconnected
from the outside world.
And it took five weeks to repair the undersea cable.
So it was a serious problem for Tonga.
And this region, Southeast Asia or Indo-Pacific
is not an exception of this potential undersea cable damage.
For example, in 2024, there was undersea cable damage
which were connecting Taiwan and Matsu Island
for multiple times.
And Chinese fishing boats were blamed at that time.
And also in April, 2024, a cable in Malacca was damaged
and it caused some internet disruption
across Southeast Asia.
When it comes to the undersea cable threat,
there are three different types of threat.
Intended, unintended or espionage or tapping.
So not all undersea cable damage
is with hostile or bad intention.
For example, out of all these total cases so far,
they reported undersea cable damage, 95% is unintended.
Only 5% was done with some hostile or bad intention.
For example, the fishing boats can drag nets
and it cause damage on the undersea cable
or seismic activities under the sea
can cause serious damage on the underwater cable.
So these kind of cases, unintended damage
accounts for 95% of the whole issue.
Intended damage is something about sabotaging
with the strategic and military purpose.
And these kind of activity is usually done
utilizing submarine and the submarines
deep in the sea.
They operate to damage undersea cable
and only small number of countries
with advanced military capability can do this.
So major powers have very specialized forces
for these kind of activities.
The good news though is the attack with strategic
and military purpose is not that common.
It is very costly to make this kind of activities
in the deep in the sea.
The operation is so difficult.
So it is much easy to sabotage or damage cable
once it is landed.
So this undersea cable damage with some bad intention
is not that common.
But another interesting type of threat
is tapping the wire for spying or data steal.
In this case, there's no serious damage on the cable itself
but the safety and security of the cable
and data that flows through the cable
will be compromised.
And this kind of tapping has some strategic
and military implication
as well as commercial implication too.
For example, some countries to develop their AI,
they need massive amount of data.
So the tapping the undersea cable
will be one of the way to collecting data for AI learning.
So there's this kind of dangers.
But the difficulties then we understand
that we have to protect
and we have to put those person or country,
the hold those country and person in responsibility.
But that's not easy.
The thing is, most of the regional countries,
they don't have high awareness
on the danger of this undersea cable threat
to the undersea cable.
Even if there is awareness,
there is a lack of effective MDA,
maritime domain awareness,
or surveillance capability of individual regional countries.
And there's also institutional loopholes.
Maybe you can imagine that to protect undersea cable,
there's some institutions and agencies can be mobilized.
For example, police, Navy, post guard,
intelligence agencies, some ministries,
and private sector that construct and operate this cable.
So there's a big question,
who's really in charge of protecting this undersea cable?
For Korean case, the police, military, Navy,
post guard, intelligence, and the ministry,
all aware that the undersea cable protection
is very important.
But the first responsibility goes to the private company
that construct and operate this undersea cable.
So if there's a damage and this private company
that operates this undersea cable report it to police
or maritime police, post guard, Navy,
then the government comes in to investigate
or take action.
So there is this kind of loophole.
And another problem is identifying the perpetrator
and holding this person or country responsible
or bringing the perpetrator to the justice
is extremely difficult.
Identifying these activity is extremely difficult.
It is done very quietly, deep in the sea,
and it is really hard and difficult
to detect this kind of activities,
especially when the affected country lacks MDA capability.
Thank you, Dr. Jehan.
Thank you, sir.
Thank you, sir, for your comments.
We're running out of time.
Oh, sorry.
Do you have a final word?
Let me finish in a couple of minutes then.
Okay, so the issue is the resilience.
Quickly, we have to recover from the damage.
There are only a few countries have this capability.
What we need is regional arrangement to protect
and to fix this undersea cable.
And it is time for the government to pay more attention
to protect and to repair this cable.
So we need a more effective
multilateral regional arrangement.
Individual countries do not have enough capability,
so we have to put our hands together.
Let me finish it.
I'm sorry for the time control.
Thank you, sir.
Really very much appreciate your contribution
to this dialogue.
