Unraveling the Indus Valley Script Yagna Devam s Groundbreaking Research The Breakfast Club Show

ancient literature
168 followers
Let's take you now to our top story, one we're delving deep into.
As Diwali continues to illuminate our homes, our hearts,
today we're inviting you to join us on a captivating journey
into one of India's most enduring enigmas.
It's the mysterious script of the Indus Valley Civilization.
Imagine a time, thousands of years ago,
when one of the world's first great civilizations flourished
right at the heart of South Asia.
Marked by breathtaking urban planning,
and a culture that historians again and again say is remarkable
because of just how peaceful it was.
Right within that lies a tantalizing puzzle.
The script of the Indus Valley,
which has eluded scholars for generations.
This research has been going on for a hundred years.
Why is the script so elusive?
We'll get into it in more depth, but in short, there are a few issues.
Number one, there isn't a Rosetta Stone of any kind.
Remember, a Rosetta Stone, when we say that,
we mean the existence of the undecipherable language,
along with a language that's already been deciphered,
or a script that's already been deciphered,
which would make it very, very easy for those who are trying to break into it.
The other issue, there are very, very small samples of it that exist.
Most of it, as we've said, comes on seals,
and that's very, very short samples.
That's largely been the issue
when it comes to trying to understand the script.
Now, the challenge is not just an academic one.
It's deeply intertwined with the rich tapestry of South Asian politics,
of its cultural history,
and today we are thrilled to welcome on to the show, Yagnadevam.
His interpretations have ignited curiosity, debate in the scholarly community.
Also, if I may say, Yagnadevam, beyond the scholarly community.
This is something that, you know, I was looking at this.
There's so much involvement with it online, on Reddit, for example,
people questioning, and, you know, you've been very, very open
and actually engaging with those who are questioning it,
and listing out, you know, why you agree,
where you disagree with their interpretations too.
So if we could first start just by asking you to give our audiences
a little bit of context here.
This script that we're talking about,
it's considered the last major undeciphered script in the ancient world.
How did you decide this is something I want to give, you know, a crack at?
I'm going to take a crack at it.
When did that decision happen?
Explain that for us.
Right. So this was sometime during the COVID lockdown.
There was no cinemas, no restaurants, nothing.
It was, you know, there was really nothing to do.
So I thought, and it looked like the lockdown is going to last for years.
So I thought I'll try to find a problem that is,
that will keep me busy for a while.
And I bumped into this, this problem,
and I tried falsifying existing decipherments.
And then I realized I could use something called a cryptogram method
to try to see if it works.
And that's how I got into it.
So can you tell our audiences a little bit of your interpretation
as to why you think previous decipherments were not working
and what you think you did differently?
So there were, there are more than a hundred decipherments to falsify.
Most of them are not decipherments and none of them are complete.
So there are 417 alleged signs in the script
and most decipherments only deal with like 20 or so.
And that is not a decipherment per se
because you cannot read most of the inscriptions.
You can read only inscriptions where these 20 or so,
the symbols are present.
So I wouldn't call them decipherments
and mathematically they are not decipherments
because, you know, when the scholars simply assign a value
and read the value, they are reading what is called the key.
They are reading their own assignments.
So it did not seem reasonable to me
and I needed a mathematically,
a model that I can mathematically prove is correct.
So I tried my own system.
Okay, before we go any further,
can I just ask you to explain to our audiences
this is a very important difference,
the difference between a language and a script
because we are talking about the script here.
The language also, we don't know much about it
but if you could first just tell us clearly what the difference is,
then we will ask you more.
Yes, so human beings, human brain is a symbol processing engine
and we can use auditory symbols,
essentially sequences of sounds to communicate concepts
and automatically processes them
and understands the information in that stream.
So a language essentially is just primarily auditory.
A script is a visual rendition of the same concepts
and you can render it in different ways.
So for example, a script like Chinese,
each symbol can represent a word
but other scripts could be sequences of sounds
and you can have the same thing written in multiple scripts.
So for example, you can write Hindi in Devanagari,
you can also write it in Brahmi,
you can also write it in Kannada also if you want.
So the script is what you see visually,
the language is what the actual sequences of sounds and grammar
and the concepts, the encoding of the concepts.
Can you tell us, there was seemingly before you dug deep into this,
there was seemingly some agreements, consensus around aspects.
One aspect for example was whether this is read left to right or right to left
and it seems as if the consensus was that it is right to left
largely because if you looked at a lot of seals,
there was cramping taking place towards the left.
Was that a consensus you agreed with in what you found
and also tell us what were the other pre-existing consensus
that you had as a base that you could take when you went ahead to understand this.
So the only real big consensus was the direction is right to left.
Almost nothing else is a consensus
because this is something you can mathematically measure.
So not only the crowding, those are called external signs,
but internal signs, internal means internal to the structure of the message.
External means their appearance, how they are carved and so on.
So when there are inscriptions that are identical
but they occur on one-lined and two-lined inscriptions,
you know that it can only be read right to left for example.
So this is the only real consensus.
Everything else is a suspicion.
There was a big suspicion that it would be some kind of Dravidian
and it is a guess, nobody knows.
There was a suspicion that this could be just not a script
but some kind of trademark or some kind of logo.
So those are not consensus, only this one is the consensus.
Can you just tell us and you have already touched on this a bit.
When we were introducing this topic to our audiences,
we told them that right at the heart of this is a lot of South Asian politics
and this is a very evocative issue for people.
I know as you were approaching it, you had to be very objective
in the way you were approaching it, very scientific.
But it is a very emotional issue for people.
Right at the heart of the disagreement is this question
of what language family or script family does this come from.
Are we looking at Indo-Aryan, so are we looking at for example Sanskrit
or are we looking at the other options, Dravidian languages.
And I just want to ask you, you seemingly have solved that in your interpretation.
What was your process? Walk us through it.
Because we haven't actually gotten into how you did this yet.
Right, the how I did it is a different thing and how I can explain it is better.
So essentially Dravidian is what is called an agglutinative language.
So in language, when you have a word, the root has affixes.
So for example, if you talk about Kannada,
ava is that person, avaru is plural.
And if you add ali, that's locative, it's in that person.
So avarali means in them.
These affixes you add in agglutinative languages are regular.
And the affixes by themselves are not words.
In fusional languages like Sanskrit and Indo-Aryan,
the affixes are kind of irregular.
You can have different things for different concepts.
So when you look at the inscriptions, it is pretty clear,
it is not just not Dravidian, but it is not any agglutinative language.
So it is not Elamite, it's not Japanese,
about 90% of the world's languages are agglutinative.
So it's none of those.
And the inscriptions depict multi-stem compounds.
Like in Tathpurusha, I don't know how much people know about this,
but you can join two or three stems and make a compound.
So you can say raj, shura, vira, and all of them can be one.
And that is possible only in Sanskrit.
So you see signs of those, that structure,
which indicates that the language is Sanskrit.
Not even Hindi, it's just Sanskrit.
Okay, and now can you tell us, I just want to lay this out for our audiences,
what are some of the aspects that your research has unveiled beyond that question?
Beyond the language?
Yes, beyond the language family, yeah.
So in the context, in the content of the inscriptions themselves,
what I saw is a lot of names of Rudra.
And mostly short names, because there is no space to write long names.
And they have names like Rava, Tana, and so on.
And the root of these words, these names, for example, the root of Rava is Ru.
And Ru means both roar and kill.
And Shiva is both roarer and killer.
And I believe that a lot of the Sanskrit language,
the reason all these roots have these dual meanings,
they have all the meanings of the characteristics of Rudra
is because it actually evolved from this kind of theology.
I saw many, I've seen names of Rig Vedic poets like Vamra.
Vamra actually means ant.
But it's also the name of a Rig Vedic poet.
And, you know, many of such names.
I've seen names of various deities, which are very rare.
They are only attested in Rig Veda.
Like Nrahan for, I think it's Indra.
And Dhanvachara, which means someone who roams in a desert, that's also Indra.
So there are all these rare names, which I, you know,
I have a little bit of Sanskrit background,
but these things I had to look up to figure out what they are.
So it appears that they have, you know,
the inscriptions agree with the iconography of, you know, essentially sacrifice.
And you may have seen the Pashupati seal and the sacrifice seal and so on.
So it agrees with that iconography.
And, you know, so I'm still reading, you know, many of the seals.
I've read only about 37 percent.
And as I learn more, you know, we'll present more of them.
OK, I want to ask you one last question before we let you go.
The manner in which you've conducted your research and shared it with the world,
you know, the review, the paper that you've written,
you're constantly updating that paper itself.
You're engaging again and again with some of the criticism that's coming in.
I want to ask you a big part of this field is the peer reviewed process.
Since you've put this out, you've shared this with the public.
What have responses been like? I don't want to know from the public itself,
but other researchers who, you know, so far had believed they deciphered aspects of it.
Right. So there is no actual, I would say, critical feedback.
There is essentially this. I found some good feedback, which I've incorporated into my versions.
I have improved them. One was to try to see if you can reconstruct it with grammar.
So I used Paninian grammar and the readings got a lot better.
And thanks to the people who suggested that.
Another is the elimination of what's called L words.
L words are words that were invented in the medieval times for Slasher poetry.
So after eliminating that, I could get much more meaningful readings.
Some people suggested that, you know, you have to figure out how this script emerged as Abugida out of nothing.
And then I did some research. I found that the script actually originates in 4000 BCE.
So these are some of the good criticisms I've got and that's helped me improve the paper.
But there's plenty of, you know, fallacious arguments such as, you know, I cannot believe this or, you know, things of that nature.
Mostly I cannot believe it or why would somebody write this? I would have written it differently and so on.
Those things, there's not much to do because when someone uses a fallacious argument, I just understand that they have admitted defeat.
And there is no input for me from that argument to improve the paper. So I go to other people.
Yagnadev, thank you for taking out the time and joining us here on Diwali morning.
The work you're doing is such a crucial puzzle piece for all of South Asia to understand the way in which our history has played out.
There are so many more secrets this could potentially unlock.
So thank you for doing the work you're doing. This is an ongoing conversation.
We're going to take you, our audiences of The Breakfast Club, into a quick break.
We hope you found that deeply interesting. It's a complex story.
We're going to head into a break. On the other side, more of The Breakfast Club.
We're taking you to a musical journey on the other side.
