Top trade negotiators from the United States and China kicked off a new round of talks in Paris on March 15, a little more than two weeks ahead of an anticipated summit between their leaders in Beijing.
NTD discussed what’s at stake with Keith Naughton, cofounder and principal at Silent Majority Strategies. -- 📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
And top trade negotiators from the U.S. and China kicked off a new round of talks in Paris
yesterday, a little more than two weeks ahead of an anticipated summit between their leaders in
Beijing. Joining us now to discuss the upcoming summit with the Chinese Communist Party is Dr.
Keith Naughton. He's co-founder and principal with Silent Majority Strategies. Thanks for joining us.
In an interview with the Financial Times, President Trump said that he may now delay
the planned meeting with the Chinese Communist Party leader. He also suggested that China
should help secure the Strait of Hormuz, noting that it's China getting about 90%
of its oil through the Strait. What do you think he's signaling with these comments now?
Well, I think that's a smart move by the president. You know, when you're dealing with
Xi Jinping and the CCP, you want to do what you can to control the agenda. I think they want this
meeting. They want this meeting to be in Beijing. They want the president to come to China. I think
for that to not happen, it's an embarrassment to the country. So I think they very much want
this meeting to occur. They've got their own internal economic problems. So I think they
want to have continued trade. They need to have a deal. I think it's very curious that these
meetings are in Paris. You know, neither side wants to have the negotiations on the other's
territory. Yet things are so hostile in East Asia with the provocative actions of the CCP
that they don't want to meet in Tokyo. They don't want to meet in
Seoul or in South Korea. They're sort of stuck meeting in Europe, which I think is a very
interesting turnabout. I think it's a reflection of their poor diplomatic standing in East Asia.
That's quite interesting. And I hadn't really thought too much about that location. But yeah,
curious in all of even Europe, France chosen. Why do you think that is?
Well, I think the French have good espionage services. I think the French like having it
there. They'll probably know half of what's going on. But I think it might be a little
bit about courting Europe, courting the French. China will send its negotiators and try to
signal themselves as these sort of fair arbiters, this sort of fake front about how they're
everybody's friend. And so I think that's a chance for them to put on a little bit of a show
during these negotiations, especially in times of war. And it's sort of, in a way,
it's a logical logistical place to meet in Paris, Geneva, those sorts of places in Europe.
Now, Keith, trade is expected to, of course, be a major part of the discussion since Bessant is
leading these pre-discussions along with Jameson Greer, especially though after the Supreme Court's
late February ruling on global tariffs imposed under the emergency law.
How could the ruling shape the talks and the leverage on both sides?
Well, I think it hurts Trump's leverage. It hurts Bessant's leverage. They have some
workarounds, so I don't think these tariffs are going to really fall. Look, I think it's
been a mistake. The president had the votes early on to give himself more power from Congress to
levy some tariffs and to extend them, especially against China, which is a country that is not
popular in the United States or in Congress. I think he made a real mistake. He generally
hasn't really pushed enough legislation through Congress while he had the votes.
But I think they've got some workarounds so that they can still be in a strong enough negotiating
position. I think Bessant's one of the best treasury secretaries we've had in a long time.
He's very sharp. He's an excellent Wall Street operator, and that's meant in the kindest sense.
And I think, as your guests have pointed out on the previous segment,
Cargilland is completely defenseless. The United States could knock out that oil supply to China
at any moment. So having that leverage helps. And if you're negotiating with Xi,
if you're negotiating with the CCP, you have to have leverage or they'll disagree to anything
that they want to and simply ignore it later. And you bring up a really interesting point,
because the pendulum swung toward China with the Supreme Court decision, but maybe it swung to the
middle or even back to the U.S. with the actions taken in Iran, coupled with the Venezuela extraction
of Maduro. So how does all this come into play? And do you think it's in the president's best
interest to keep the meeting as scheduled or to delay it as he's now signaling?
I don't think President Trump can leave the country during this crisis with Iran. So I think
he's got to delay it. I don't think he should cancel it. I think it's worthwhile to say,
well, I've got to put it off 10 days and maybe more. But if China, if you want to help bring
a resolution, we can get this meeting done and try to settle things between our two countries.
Could depend on the progress made in Paris, whether the Chinese think that there's some
sort of deal or that they're headed towards a deal. But I think it's true negotiating. You
want to leave your opponent off balance and you can turn to what I think many in the mainstream
media are calling a problem in negotiating into an asset. Very interesting. And I want to now
pick your brain and turn into China in the interior. Xi, the longest serving leader since
Mao. He's rewritten the CCP's own doctrine, allowing himself a third, fifth, five year term.
He has himself purged many of his own top people in the military. And last year it was reported
that Xi was already on his way out after he suffered an alleged stroke.
And then the economy, of course, is having its challenges as well. It has been reported that
since the Iran war started, that their daily incursions into Taiwan airspace has either
slowed or stopped entirely. So how does this meeting affect the dynamic with Xi inside China?
Well, it's hard to figure. I mean, we really don't know what's going on in the
politburo on the Central Committee. It's not much different than dealing with Russia and the Soviet
Union in the Cold War. I think that purge blindsided most of the international community.
This limited incursion, it could be because of the stripping of so many leaders in the
politburo. It could be simply a decision to save on fuel during this crisis. You know,
China is deathly afraid of being caught short on fuel or on food. There's an enormous amount of
hoarding and storage for that. So they may just be decide, well, we're going to be prudent over
the next few months because we don't have an imminent attack. But we do know that there are
a lot of stresses there. I think Xi adding this third term in a rather unorthodox manner, and
everybody knows at this point, that really means unlimited terms for him. I think that hurts his
legitimacy with the wider population. I think that's very alienating when you make that sort
of change and when things aren't improving economically for most people in China. So I
think it's a weakening of the regime. But of course, the regime still remains very dangerous
and it's still a serious threat to Taiwan. Very interesting way to break that down,
what could be happening. As you point out, no one truly knows what's happening, but all we can do is
look at these signals. Now, as we finish up, I just want to get your view on, you know,
what are the most pressing goals for the U.S. to get out of this pre-negotiation and the actual
summit between President Trump and Xi? Well, I think the pre-negotiation, you know, ideally,
it's the actual deal. I mean, you don't really want the president and Xi trying to
make substantive changes to the deal because this is very complex issues at stake.
With all due respect to the president, I don't think we want a lot of freelancing.
We want the people who have been in that room in deep negotiations, have a deep understanding
of the matter, be able to present the president with a good final proposal. But I think what we
want is some stability. I think we want to end or cut back on espionage, on the intellectual
property theft. And I think we want to put some controls or restrictions on the number of
provocative incidents that are being perpetrated by the PLA around the Philippines and around
Taiwan and find ways to de-escalate. So I think that's really going to be the key thing. We'll
see if it happens. Maybe it will. Maybe it will happen temporarily. But I think those are the
key goals for the United States. Well, we appreciate your insights, Dr. Keith Naughton.
Thank you. Thank you.