BANK RUNS HIT PRIVATE CREDIT Morgan Stanley Blocks Exits

Loan Hub
4 followers
#finance
#financement
In this video we break down:
• Why the Cliffwater redemption surge is drawing attention
• Why Morgan Stanley blocking exits is a major liquidity signal
• How bank runs begin inside financial structures
• The role margin calls play in accelerating market stress
• Why liquidity pressure inside a $1.8 trillion private credit market matters
AI Generated·May contain errors
Here's an actual quote from a Zero Hedge article
that hit last night entitled,
"'Private Credit's Margin Call Moment Arrives.'"
We need to hear this.
Quote, we think a run on the bank is inevitable
and would recommend that all investors
get out of levered private credit while they still can.
End quote.
Okay, understand bank runs don't start
just with withdrawals, okay?
They start with withdrawal demand
exceeds the system's design limits.
That's exactly what just happened
inside the private credit market.
Investors just tried to pull 14% of their money
out of a $33 billion private credit fund
managed by Cliffwater LLC.
The fund allowed 7% to be withdrawn.
Think about that for a second.
The investors asked for twice the liquidity amount
that the system was designed to allow.
At the same time, yesterday we heard
that a private credit fund connected to Morgan Stanley
limited withdrawals to 5%.
And just hours ago, before I hit record on this video,
this bombshell hit the newswire.
Deutsche Bank disclosed roughly $30 billion in exposure
to private credit in its annual report
and flagged underwriting risks
and potential fraud concerns tied to the sector.
The stock is down about 8% right now on the news.
That's its biggest decline in nearly a year.
Let me read you a quote from that report.
It says, failures of a select number
of subprime lenders in the U.S.
increased investor focus on risks
associated with private credit
and raised wider concerns around underwriting standards
and fraud risk.
Okay, again, bank runs never start with the panic.
They start when demand for cash begins moving faster
than the structure can handle.
And we've seen this pattern before.
For the collapse of mortgage hedge funds
run by Bear Stearns, remember that in 2007,
investors began requesting withdrawals
faster than those funds could sell
the underlying mortgage securities.
Before Lehman Brothers failed in 2008,
short-term lenders stopped rolling financing.
And before the Silicon Valley Bank collapse in 2023,
deposit withdrawals accelerated
beyond what the bank could generate in liquidity.
Okay, different assets, different institutions,
but the same mechanism each and every time.
Too many investors want cash at the same moment.
The system slowed the exits,
and everyone suddenly starts looking for the door.
All right, that's exactly what just happened here.
Cliff Water Fund allows five to 7% quarterly withdrawals.
Investors tried to pull 14%.
Morgan Stanley, similarly, capped withdrawals at 5%.
So you could say, well, the structure
did what it was assigned to do.
It slowed the exits.
But here's the point.
Once the exit's slow,
investor psychology changes immediately.
Because in illiquid markets,
everyone begins asking the same question.
How many people are ahead of me in line?
This is the kind of risk
that the Risk Map newsletter will get deeper into
when it launches on April the 1st.
So make sure you guys are subscribed to the channel
so you don't miss the rollout, okay?
So while pressure is building
on the investor side of private credit,
something else just entered the system.
Banks are also, at the same time, tightening financing.
According to the same report,
in a matter we covered yesterday,
JPMorgan Chase has begun restricting certain lending
to private credit funds after marking down
the value of some of the loans tied to certain companies.
This introduces something that this market
has not really had to deal with yet,
and that's margin pressure.
Private credit funds, understand,
often borrow against their loan portfolios
to expand how much they can lend.
And banks provide the financing lines.
Those lines increase the size of the loans
that the funds can originate, okay?
But when the banks start marking down collateral values,
they reduce how much they're willing
to lend against those portfolios.
When that happens,
funds suddenly have less leverage available,
and there is your private credit version, okay,
of a margin call.
Margins also have a long history of turning slow problems
into very fast problems.
In 1998, Hedge Fund Long-Term Capital Management,
remember that name?
Nearly collapsed the global financial system
when lenders demanded massive collateral
after the fund's trades moved against it, okay?
The fund had, at that time, enormous leverage.
And once lenders issued the margin calls,
the fund was forced to rapidly unwind positions.
So what happened?
Well, markets around the world seized up on that, all right?
How about in 2007,
when two hedge funds run again by Bear Stearns collapsed
when lenders demanded additional collateral
against mortgage securities that were losing value?
And those margin calls forced asset sales.
Those sales pushed the prices lower,
and that triggered more margin calls.
And of course, that cascade was underway.
And more recently, just in 2021,
the collapse of Archegos Capital Management
wiped out more than 10 billion, okay?
And losses for major global banks
after margin calls forced massive liquidations
of stock positions.
Again, folks, same sequence, okay?
Lenders demanded collateral.
The fund could not provide it.
Assets had to be liquidated, and prices collapsed, okay?
So margin calls, understand,
do one thing in financial markets.
They slow, or they turn, right,
slow stress into accelerated pressure.
And now margin pressure's appearing exact time
in private credit that investors are testing the exit doors,
okay, trying to withdraw money faster,
and banks are tightening the financing, okay?
J.P. Morgan is leading the way.
So those two forces together put liquidity problems
right back at the center of the system.
So Morgan Stanley is blocking exits.
BlackRock is limiting withdrawals.
And now Deutsche Bank is flagging billions in exposure.
So when these three different signals appear
at the same time, liquidity limits,
underwriting concerns, and falling bank stocks,
that's confirmation that the credit cycle has turned, okay?
Think about the structure just for a quick minute.
These funds are making loans
that often run out five to seven years,
but the investors are allowed
to request their money back every quarter.
Once withdrawals start exceeding the design of the system,
okay, everything inside the structure shifts.
Funds stop thinking about originating new loans,
and they start thinking about liquidity.
They slow the exits, and they conserve cash.
And banks start looking much more closely, right,
like what's happening in Deutsche Bank today,
at the collateral behind the financing lines.
And that's where the margin pressure
comes back into the story.
Because once lenders start marking down loans
and tightening lines of credit,
funds suddenly have much less flexibility.
They can't extend as many loans.
They can't allow as many withdrawals.
And everything collapses.
So here's where, from my perspective,
the pressure moves next.
When funds shift from expanding to defending liquidity,
the stress moves somewhere else.
Well, it moves to the borrowers.
The companies that borrow money from private credit funds
now face lenders, right,
that are suddenly being more cautious.
And loans get extended much less easily.
Refinancing becomes much more difficult.
And leverage becomes a whole lot more expensive.
And that's how stress will spread
through the credit markets.
It doesn't begin necessarily with a full collapse.
It begins with the lenders tightening.
And remember the signal that triggered the entire story.
Okay, investors just attempted to withdraw 14%
from a fund designed to handle 7%.
That's not routine investor behavior, folks.
That's a stress signal, right?
On top of that, Morgan Stanley limiting withdrawals.
Cliffwater limiting withdrawals.
Okay, banks started also started tightening financing
like JP Morgan.
And now Deutsche Bank is flagging massive risk.
This is unfolding in real time, okay?
I will stay on this.
If you enjoyed today's content, leave me a like.
If you're not subscribed to the channel,
please subscribe so we can keep growing.
Leave me your thoughts and comments.
And with that being said, I'll talk to y'all soon.
