Before it became one of America’s most beloved patriotic songs, “America the Beautiful” began as a poem inspired by a breathtaking view from Pikes Peak.
In this episode of American Legends, we explore the life of Katharine Lee Bates, the poet and professor whose words captured the spirit, landscape, and ideals of the United States.
From her early life in a household of strong women to her groundbreaking work defining American literature as its own field of study, Bates devoted her life to education, writing, and the love of her country.
Her poem, first published in 1895, eventually joined with Samuel A. Ward’s hymn melody to become “America the Beautiful,” a song that many Americans believe could have been the nation’s anthem.
But Bates was more than the author of a patriotic hymn. She was a teacher, reformer, war correspondent, and one of the early scholars to champion American literature as a distinct national voice.
Discover the story behind the woman whose poetry helped define the beauty and ideals of America.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
Oh, say, can you hear the strained voices and mumbled words of every random pop artist who
tries to sing our national anthem? While Francis Scott Key's beautiful words may stir up patriotic
feelings in your heart, you might have to stick some cotton in your ears, as many people struggle
to render this deceptively difficult song. Thus, it's no surprise that over the years,
many people have suggested alternatives to The Star-Spangled Banner to be our national anthem.
One of the most commonly suggested alternatives is America the Beautiful, which has often been
called America's hymn. Like The Star-Spangled Banner, this song wasn't written with the words
and music together to be the song that it is. The music was originally written by a church organist,
Samuel Ward, after an inspiring day at Coney Island, and it was many years later before it was
put together with a beautiful poem about nature by an English professor. Today, we're going to
talk about this English professor, a very educated woman, and how her poetry, her other writing,
and her lifelong dedication shows that she was a true devotee to her beloved country, America.
In the summer of 1893, Katherine Leigh Bates enjoyed a working holiday. She taught at Wellesley
College in Massachusetts, but she was eager to spend her summer holiday industriously engaged
while seeing more of the nation. She'd spent most of her life up to that point
on the east coast in the New England area, so she decided to take a job teaching at Colorado
College in Colorado Springs during the summer. While making the train trip out west,
she took her time making many stops. She visited Niagara Falls. She stopped in Chicago to see
the magnificent World's Fair, which included the White City, which was constructed for that World
Fair, and she saw the beautiful plains and all the agriculture, the wheat, the grass growing
in the middle of the country. Eventually, she made her way to Colorado. Always an adventurous spirit,
one day she went on an adventure to climb the nearby Pikes Peak, and it was there that she
received the inspiration for what would become the lyrics to America the Beautiful. She recounted
the adventure as follows. One day, some of the other teachers and I decided to go on a trip
to 14,000 foot Pikes Peak. We hired a prairie wagon. Near the top, we had to leave the wagon
and go the rest of the way on mules. I was very tired, but when I saw the view, I felt great joy.
All the wonder of America seemed displayed there with a sea-like expanse. Using the trusty pen and
pad that she always kept with her, she jotted down a few words, a few lines that came to her at that
moment. Her main intention was just to capture that vivid memory so she could tell her friends
about it. But later, when she looked at those lines, she decided to put them together into a poem,
which she named Pikes Peak. Today, there's a commemorative plaque on the site of Pikes Peak
with the words to that poem. In July of 1895, two years later, this poem was first published in a
weekly journal called The Congregationalist. It was simply entitled America, a poem on July 4th.
This poem was instantly received with great excitement by the public, and the journal was
quickly flooded with hundreds of letters. Now, these readers weren't content merely to say
that they loved the poem. They felt that it should be sung, and many of them began sending
in some music they'd written as suggested melodies for the song. By the year 1900,
it's estimated that over 75 different songs had been written to go along with the words,
but none of them quite struck the right chord. It wasn't until 1904 that someone decided that
something needed to be done about it. A good song needed to be chosen for this purpose.
That someone was Reverend Barbour, a Baptist minister in Boston. He felt that the words to
poem were divinely inspired, so he believed that the melody needed to be divinely inspired as well.
Thus, he turned to his hymnal, and there he found that 1883 hymn written by Samuel A. Ward.
The hymn was called Materna, and it was reasonably popular, but not particularly
well-received or famous. It was just a nice song written for an existing
hymn lyric. As soon as he tried putting them together, Reverend Barbour knew that it was
perfect, so he introduced that song at his church that year. It was he who first published it in 1910
as part of his best-selling hymnal, Fellowship Hymns. It was he who gave it the title,
America the Beautiful, as he put the lyrics and music together. Thus, the song finally had its name,
and it could become America's hymn. Not only have average citizens suggested its replacement of
the Star-Spangled Banner, but it's even been a bill in Congress many times, particularly during
the Kennedy administration. Many people feel that it's a better choice to be the national anthem,
not only because it's more singable, but because it has a less militaristic feel. It's not about war,
as many patriotic American songs are. Instead, it's celebrating the beauty of America itself,
the land, the landscape, but also the people who inhabit it. Although America the Beautiful is
Katharine Lee Bate's most recognizable work, it's not the only thing she wrote. She spent most of
her life dedicated to Wellesley College, and it's no surprise that she was most comfortable in this
environment that was a women's school, surrounded by other ladies, because she also grew up in a
largely female world. Her father died a month before she was born, and her mother worked very
hard to raise her and her three older siblings, two of whom were sisters. Later, they all went to
live with her aunt. Both her mother and her aunt were very well-educated women, so it's no surprise
that Katharine would be well-educated as well. Her interest in literature was apparent from a very
young age. She began keeping a journal at age six, and in these earliest entries, you can see her
clever mind and her eager spirit, even as her spelling was a little bit faulty. Later, she began
crafting poems and thoughts on how girls should be given opportunities as well as boys, and they
should be allowed to do work outside as well as inside. Thus, it's no surprise that, as a grown woman,
Katharine would be a very adventurous spirit, not being afraid to travel alone, with her pants as
neatly poised on the bridge of her nose, and despite her short, stout, somewhat ungainly frame,
she was unafraid to hike up Pike's Peak and go on adventures. She went to Wesley High School
and Newton High School before entering the learning institute that would be a very important
part of the rest of her life, Wellesley College. She entered this newly formed female college
in 1876 as part of its second full class, which included only 43 women. She graduated in 1880
with a Bachelor of Arts degree, and at that point, she began teaching. She taught at various high
schools and girls schools for the next 10 years. In 1890, she was able to continue her education
with higher studies in England at Oxford University. She was afforded this great experience
through the prize money that she won for a young adult novel she wrote, The Rose and the Thorn.
After spending 1890 and 1891 studying abroad, she returned to her alma mater, Wellesley College,
where she got her master's degree. She was first an associate professor there and eventually became
a full English professor. She would remain that, at that college, for the next few decades.
Shaping that growing institute of learning. She was, of course, in English literature,
and at that point, English literature mainly studied literature from England, and any writing
which had been done in America would be sloppily lumped into that group. Katherine Neibates was
one of the first people to explore and define American literature as its own distinct art form,
separate from that of other English-speaking countries, particularly our mother country
of England. She taught extensively about American literature, Wellesley, and she even wrote a book
entitled American Literature. This was a college textbook, and it's considered one of the first
college textbooks on American literature. This book is divided into six lengthy chapters,
dividing the history of the United States into three different time periods, and then analyzing
the life and the resulting literature of each period. She focused the most time, including
four chapters, on the national period, the time when America was a nation, which, at that point,
was really just over a hundred years. She explored the poetry and the prose, talking about
writers from the earliest Puritans to contemporary writers of her day, and she explored their lives,
as well as what life was like in America at the time. It's a very engaging book, which you can
find for free on the Internet Archive, and if you're interested in American literature or
Catherine Lee Bates, you definitely will find it very enlightening to see
how people of the late 19th century viewed literature up to that point. In the introduction
to that book, she wrote, in this outline of our literary progress, it is especially designed
to show how essentially American literature has been an outgrowth of American life.
A people originally of English stock and increasingly open to European influences,
we have nevertheless a national character modified by local conditions and a national
point of view. Hence, our literature is rightly viewed as the individual expression of an
independent nation. Bates wrote a lot of poetry throughout her life, publishing several collections
of assorted poems. She also wrote short stories, a few novels, editorials, and articles. She was a
during that time, fought to combat the negative stereotypes that were being perpetuated about the
Spanish. Yes, they were our enemies, but she didn't want our fighting them to be based on
bigotry or prejudice. After the war, she wrote a travelogue called Spanish Highways and Byways,
in which she described the landscape and the people of the country as they were recovering
from the war. She was always a great champion for social reform of all kinds, whether it was
racial tolerance, equality for the recently freed slaves, equal rights for women, or religious
tolerance. One rather amusing credit of hers is that she popularized the character of Mrs. Claus,
Santa Claus's wife, an interesting note for a woman who never married herself. In her 1889
poetry collection Sunshine and Other Verses for Children, she featured the Yuletide poem
Goody Santa Claus on a Sleigh Ride. She gave Mrs. Claus the first name Goody, and in it she describes
how Santa Claus really doesn't do anything but just sit around and get fat all year, whereas his
wife is the one who does all the real work. She tends most notably to their grove of trees, which
is where they grow not only the Christmas trees, but the magical trees that grow all the presents,
all the toys that are given to the good little girls and boys. She tends to them so that they
can grow all the sugar plums and the tops and the dollies, and apparently Santa Claus is also in
business with the Easter Bunny and some other whimsical figures, because she referred to how
she has to tend to the eggs that are the magical Easter eggs. But all Goody wants in return is to
ride with her husband on his sleigh one night, so she gets her wish. It's a really charming poem,
you can easily find that if you look it up online, and although the first name Goody and a lot of that
lore she made up isn't popular nowadays, apparently that popularized the idea of Santa Claus not being
a celibate bishop as Saint Nicholas was, but a jolly lovable husband with a very devoted wife.
The first work which Catherine Lee Bates had published was an 1887 collection of poems.
It was called The College Beautiful and Other Poems. It featured 36 freestanding poems of
various lengths, most of them were pretty short, and they weren't particularly connected. The themes
range from tributes to beloved poets, both living and dead, who had inspired her, to pastoral
descriptions of nature, to rousing poems about college life and her alma mater, which sort of
sound like college songs if you set them to music, and most notably a couple of beautiful patriotic
poems. One of them is called Memorial Day, but the one which really stood out to me is My Known Country.
Had this poem been put to some beautiful hymn, it easily could have been national hymn, a national
anthem as well. It's a very beautiful and emotional tribute to the United States. It begins with the
lines, many the lands that the true-hearted honor, many the banners that blow on the sea,
ah, but one country, God's blessing upon her, ah, but one only is precious to me, dear for her
mountains, rock-based, cloudy-crested, hooded with snow mid the ardors of June, haunts where the
bald-headed eagle has nested, staring full hard on his neighbor the moon. This poem is incredibly
poignant today because in it, Catherine doesn't whitewash some of America's darker chapters of
history, particularly because she was so reform-minded. She poetically bemoaned, quote,
the blots that bestain her beautiful vestments, that's solely the white, saying that she would
give her own blood if by it she could, quote, purge her forever from shame of the Indian, shame of the
slave. These lines really struck me because today so many people who care about equality and the
idea that all men are created equal look back on American history and see, well, this person was a
slave owner or American Indians weren't treated well during this time, so we should just throw
it all out. America was founded on hatred and bigotry. It's no good. None of these people were
good. But Catherine really had great insight when she wrote about these ideas in this poem.
She speaks about America as a beautiful idea, a great ideal, and like a person. No human being
is perfect, yet we still love other people. No institution is perfect, but we still can love
such institutions. And similarly, she loved America and the idea behind it while acknowledging that
there had been some tragic hypocrisies, periods of time when not all men were viewed as equal
or treated as equal. But she doesn't remain in bitterness or acrimony. She moves on to
a beautiful, uplifting ending for her poem. Conquer thy foes by forbearance and truth,
still by the need of thy sires storm-driven, glad in strange waters their vessels to moor.
Open thy gates, O thou favourite of heaven, open them wide to the homeless and poor.
So shall the peoples from ocean to ocean bring precious tribute of blessing to thee.
So shall thy children yield loyal devotion, all for the love of mine own country. Note that country
is spelled c-o-u-n-t-r-i-e, not y, in the title of this poem. I'm not sure why. I guess that was
an alternate spelling at the time. But you can find the full text of this poem if you just look
up the name of that collection, The College Beautiful and Other Poems. You can find the
full text in an old manuscript on the Internet Archive. Although Samuel A. Ward died the year
before his song was paired with the beautiful words of Pike's Peak, Catherine Lee Bates lived
certainly long enough to see the popularity of her poem and then the song as it was paired with
that beautiful melody. She published the poem three times, first in 1895, then 1900, and then in 1911.
And the words were changed slightly each time. The 1911 text is the poem that we know from the song,
but the original is the most different. The 1904 featured most of the changes which were in the
after that, mainly just making it more of a chorus. Some of the noted changes you might
notice are that instead of it being, oh beautiful for spacious skies, it begins, oh beautiful for
halcyon skies. And the fruited plain was originally the enameled plain. Interestingly, the famous
conclusion, from sea to shining sea, originated in the closing line of the 1904 version. That phrase
wasn't in the original version at all. We don't usually hear all the verses, so the lyrics to the
1911 version are worth reading. Oh beautiful for spacious skies, for amber waves of grain,
for purple mountain majesties above the fruited plain. America, America, God shed his grace on thee,
and crown thy good with brotherhood from sea to shining sea. Oh beautiful for pilgrim feet,
whose stern impassioned stress, a thoroughfare for freedom beat across the wilderness. America,
America, God mend thine every flaw, confirm thy soul in self-control, thy liberty in law.
Oh beautiful for heroes proved in liberating strife, who more than self their country loved,
and mercy more than life. America, America, may God thy gold refine, till all success be nobleness,
and every gain divine. Oh beautiful for patriot dream, that sees beyond the years,
thine alabaster cities gleam, undimmed by human tears. America, America, God shed his grace on thee,
and crown thy good with brotherhood from sea to shining sea. Some of the lyrics in that poem,
such as the reference to the alabaster cities, aren't as immediately understandable today.
But in that one line, for instance, she was talking about the white city of Chicago that
she'd just seen at the World Fair, because it looked like it was alabaster with all the
beautiful white buildings. In reading the text of all three versions of the poem, which you can
easily find on Wikipedia, you'll see how those same themes that she had earlier in My Known Country
are present in the text of this poem and song, talking about the beauty of nature,
the nobility of the idea of America, the fact that America isn't perfect, but that it's worth
the fight, that it's something worth defending and protecting. Catherine Lee Bates, never married,
some believe because she would have lost her tenure as a professor at Wellesley College had
she married. There were two men, notably, whom she was believed to have loved throughout her life,
and she had many close relationships with female friends, enjoying the spinsterhood companionship
of many other professors, female professors, at Wellesley College. In a way, I consider her
decision to not marry, because I would say it was a strong decision, not just the fact that she
didn't believe in marriage or home at heart, I don't think that's what it was with her.
I think that she saw her dedication to literature, writing, and education as not just a job, as many
women would be teachers if they needed to support themselves, no, for her it was a true vocation,
a true calling, and the reverence and almost worshipful way she writes about America makes
it seem almost like she was sort of a nun to American literature, with the sort of devotion
to the college and to her country that a nun might have to a church, particularly in the opening
lines to her poem Memorial Day, she refers to America as my country and my queen. Through her
writing, her study of American literature, her inspiration of countless students, and above all,
her penning of the beautiful words of this poem, Catherine Lee Bates was indeed an American legend.
Thank you for spending this time with me, and I hope you'll join me next time for more
American Legends.