Iranian drones: Cheap to produce, costly to defend against

Army Analysis
8 followers
#Iran #Drone #News
Trump administration officials told lawmakers during a closed-door briefing on Capitol Hill Tuesday that Iran’s Shahed attack drones represent a major challenge and US air defenses will not be able to intercept them all, according to a source in the briefing.
Tom, how significant is the concern that U.S. air defense may not be able to intercept many
of these Iranian drones?
It is significant and it is growing, Pam.
Wolf, let's take a look at what the U.S. is doing right now.
They're fielding a previously unused military asset.
I'm going to show you a life-size model that we bring into our virtual studio here.
This is the Lucas drone, low-cost, unmanned combat attack system.
It is, as you can see, about 10 feet long, about an 8-foot wingspan.
It weighs about 180 pounds.
It's powered by a propeller back there, which means very low heat signature, hard to track,
and up front it can carry about 40 pounds of high explosives.
It is also, interestingly, based upon a clone of an Iranian drone, the Shahed-136 Kamikaze.
The Iranians have been working on this for years.
The U.S. got a hold of one.
They had engineers take it apart and say, let's build a better version of it.
That's what they have done, and yet the Iranians continue to rely on this and many other types
of drones, but this one in particular they rely on for several reasons.
One, compared to a missile, which requires a great big launch platform that can be targeted
and taken out and then the missiles are no longer useful, this can be launched from the
back of a truck, from the middle of a field, from a boat, compared to a missile, which
requires a big production facility, which also can be targeted and destroyed, these
can be made in many covert locations all over that are hard to track down, and compared
to a missile, which will cost at least a million dollars, sometimes several million, this is
cheap, only about $20,000 per unit.
So when we look at these maps out here where you see places where drones have hit or missiles
have hit, every time a drone is hit, it doesn't necessarily mean just one drone was launched
there.
Instead, squadrons of things are launched.
They send many of them in precisely because of what you said at the top, Wolf, because
if you have a system out there that can't stop all of them, you only need 10% to get
through to do a tremendous amount of damage as we have been seeing in these videos in
various places.
One of the concerns here is also that the cost of the systems to stop these is higher
than the cost of the drones.
In many ways, military analysts say the Iranians have been preparing for many years for just
this type of conflict, so though they didn't want to have a war necessarily, now that the
war has come to it, their use of drones is forcing the U.S. to fight a type of battle
that the Iranians would prefer, even as the U.S. tries to turn that weapon back against
them.
What we're seeing play out here is essentially a war of attrition.
It's the ability of the Iranians to launch missiles and drones versus the supply of U.S.
and Israeli interceptors that can knock them out.
Now, President Trump said a couple of days ago, and rather absurdly, that there's an
unlimited supply of missiles and interceptors and munitions, and that's simply not the
case.
But there are some signs that the Iranians had a lot of capabilities, but it's definitely
being degraded.
I mean, on the first day, they launched 350 missiles.
On the second day, 175, and the third, it looks like about 125, and only 50 yesterday.
So there's still, there's definite signs that they're being degraded.
The other thing that they're working on is the launchers, the missile launchers.
They started the war with perhaps 450.
The IDF is claiming perhaps at least a half of them have been knocked out.
But they still have a lot of drones, a lot of missiles.
The drones can be very, very dangerous.
And we've seen play out in Ukraine, of course, the Iranians are providing a lot of drones
to the Russians.
So it's probably been involved into a war of attrition, the ability of the Iranians
to continue to mount attacks using their missiles, which left of them, and their drones, and
the United States racing against time to try to knock out their capabilities to deliver
those munitions.
Two sources have also told CNN that at least one of America's Gulf allies is already running
low on crucial interceptor munitions.
Let's bring in Hayley Britsky, joining us live again out of Washington.
So one of the issues, Hayley, with these Shaheed attack drones that Iran is using is that they're
designed to fly low and slow, which allows them essentially to evade air defences.
Walk us through it and walk us through what sort of options the U.S. has to be able to
counter that.
Yeah.
So, like you said, these can sometimes evade air defences a little bit easier than Iran's
ballistic missiles.
And we know that attack drones are frequently used by Iran and its proxies throughout the
region.
We've seen them target U.S. forces for quite a while now.
And Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth, Chairman of the Joint Staff General Kane, apparently
telling lawmakers, according to these sources, that, you know, kind of downplaying the concerns
about this, but at the same time saying that they likely would not be able to catch all
of them because Iran has so many of them.
And I really have to iterate here how big of a deal that is, how striking of an admission
that is.
Given the resources, the money that the U.S. has poured into the counter-drone problem,
since watching Ukraine's war against Russia, the U.S. military has been very aware of the
threat of drones.
They've been training on these cheaper drones, getting defence industry to build more of
them so that the U.S.'s arsenal had them as well.
So this was a really big issue that the U.S. military has seen coming, but essentially
telling lawmakers that it was more of a problem than they anticipated.
And we've seen the very real cost of this, right?
Just a few days ago, six U.S. service members killed in what was a suspected drone strike
on a facility they were working out of in a port in Kuwait.
So these have very real consequences.
And it certainly raises a lot of questions about how the U.S. military can better protect
their forces against these kinds of drones.
What systems would be better to shoot them down?
We saw for weeks leading up to this operation, air defence capabilities being flowed into
the Middle East.
More forces, more air defences certainly coming in in the next coming days.
So it raises a lot of questions that the military will have to answer about how to protect their
forces and why those steps had not been taken enough leading up to the beginning of this
operation.
A really important data point that they got out quite early was the idea that in terms
of the one-way attack drones, the Shahids, the cheap, effective, longer-range drones
that you can fire for not a lot, that often are taken down by highly expensive Gulf air
defence systems, that they've seen an 80-plus, sorry, a 70-plus percent drop in those since
the early days of this conflict.
I say the early days, we're four days in, but since the start.
And the missile attacks are now down 80-percent plus from that time as well.
Here's the siren, I'm afraid, Becky, we have to move in as a result.
And that, interestingly to me, shows that we're dealing with a potential here that the
Iranian inventory is reduced, or it's been hit on the ground by this persistent set of
airstrikes, or potentially that they're conserving what they do still have in order to be able
to protract this conflict over a number of days.
But it gives you a slight sense of the timeline, really, of what the limits on Iran might be,
how the US is perceiving that.
And then we had this other change they talked about as well.
Let me just guide my cameraman, Luis, through here.
That they, the United States, are moving from a focus on precision munitions to potentially
being in stand-in positions, where some military experts have said that's going to enable them
to use unguided munitions, dumb bombs.
