The Five Pennies (1959) is a heartfelt musical drama inspired by the life of jazz cornetist Red Nichols. Starring Danny Kaye, the film follows a talented musician whose pursuit of success is tested by personal sacrifice, family challenges, and the changing rhythms of life.
Blending lively jazz performances with moments of humor and genuine emotion, The Five Pennies celebrates the power of music to bring people together even in difficult times. The film's memorable songs and moving family story remind audiences that true success is measured not only by achievement, but by love, resilience, and the relationships we cherish.
This little penny is to wish on, and make your wishes come true.
This little penny is to dream on, and dream of all you can do.
This little penny is a dancing penny, see how it glitters and it glows.
As bright as a whistle, light as a thistle, quick, quick as a wink upon its twinkling toes.
Oh, this little penny is to laugh on, to see that tears never fall.
This little penny is the last little penny, and most important of all.
For this penny is to love on, and when love is, heaven is there.
So with just five pennies, if they're these five pennies, you'll be a millionaire.
Mother?
Yes, Dorothy?
I was just going through this old scrapbook of yours.
Did Daddy really work with all these great musicians?
Jimmy Dorsey, Glenn Miller, Gene Krupa?
Certainly. Don't you remember?
Jimmy Dorsey used to bring you candy and peanuts.
Was that the same Jimmy Dorsey?
Of course.
I suppose that's how he got so famous.
How?
He stopped working for Peanuts.
Their names are all on the labels. I'll go find some records and show them to you.
Are you kidding, Mother? Did they really work with him?
Work with him? What? They were all working for him.
There wasn't a band in the country that could beat Red Nickels and the Five Pennies.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
No matter how accurate or inaccurate they are,
I always love classic biopics because of how much of a tribute they are to that person's life and art.
I absolutely agree.
Especially musicians' and composers' biopics are always just such a love letter,
not only to the men, but to their music.
As a matter of fact, oftentimes the story will take a backseat to musical numbers.
Few films strike that perfect balance between telling enough of the story and including enough of the music.
One such perfectly balanced film is The Five Pennies from 1959.
This movie follows the life of real-life jazz musician Loring Nichols, nicknamed Red,
and his climb to fame from a simple homespun cornet player from Utah
to the bandleader of one of the top bands in the country, the Five Pennies.
Along the way, we see him meet, fall in love with, and marry showgirl Bobby,
whose real name is Willa, and the beautiful love that they share.
As he and his friends, who are future music stars like Jimmy Dorsey, Glenn Miller, Gene Krupa, and many more,
travel around the country, meanwhile, he and Bobby have a young daughter.
However, tragedy forces Red to take a step back from his music to focus on his family life.
But will he ever be able to find that love for music again?
This film was made by Paramount Pictures.
It was produced by Jack Rose and directed by Melville Shavelson.
It stars Danny Kaye and Barbara Bel Geddes.
This movie is really interesting because Red Nichols himself was involved with the production.
That isn't often the case, because very often the person has died,
or the person is too old to actively participate in any way besides maybe historic consultant.
Yeah, and I think that serves as sort of a stamp of approval on the movie.
Since he was involved with it, he must have liked it.
Many people do not like how Hollywood does a take on their lives,
but the amazing thing is that Red Nichols himself played all the cornet parts of Red Nichols.
Danny Kaye spent months learning how to accurately fake playing the cornet.
It shows.
And it's very impressive, but it's so amazing to think that this is a middle-aged Red Nichols
actually playing his own music.
He's still got it.
He's still got it. He sounds amazing.
And that's just part of how this movie is such a tribute to the great Dixieland jazz and big band music
of the 20s and early 30s, moving into the 40s and 50s.
And so many great names in the music industry are dropped,
like they mention the Dorseys all the time, Gene Krupa, Glenn Miller,
and all those people are played by actors.
One interesting thing is that Ray Anthony, who was a very notable 1950s band leader, plays Jimmy Dorsey.
Yeah, and he's playing the wrong instrument for himself.
Right. Jimmy Dorsey was a noted saxophonist, and Ray Anthony was very famous as a trumpet player.
There's really no information about how that happened, but it's an interesting thing to know.
And apparently Benny Goodman was supposed to play himself, but he wanted too much money.
So that fell through.
But one person who does play himself is Louis Armstrong.
Right.
He is an important player throughout the film.
From the very beginning to the very end, he pops up in a few poignant scenes,
just being himself, playing his music, singing in that characteristic Satchmo style.
And he was a friend and frequent collaborator of Red Nichols.
So it's such a great tribute to that era, the way they can recreate those amazing numbers
with not only his great trumpet playing and singing, the fabulous cornet playing of Red Nichols,
but then the hilarious antics of Danny Kaye on screen.
Right.
His singing and his imitating Louis.
It's a humorous side that I doubt the real Red would have contributed.
He probably would have just been more focused on playing the cornet.
So that adds another level of entertainment to the film.
Very similar to Louis Armstrong's frequent collaborations with Bing Crosby.
It's really great to see him with another performer and the way they play off of each other.
And his chemistry with Danny Kaye is really unique.
I guess Satchmo was very... He was really funny.
His way of singing and playing.
He's one of those performers you kind of get the impression he probably wasn't scripted very much.
That's probably true.
And that certainly was the way he did his music. He didn't read music.
And in the first scene with him, he kind of is teasing the young and rather hapless Red Nichols
as he's at the Speakeasy and he's never been to one before, so he's gotten drunk for the first time.
And he's saying, I know how to play the cornet and why don't you write out all your parts?
And Louis is like, you can't write out, that's not jazz, that's not Dixie.
He's handing out all the parts to the orchestra.
But that was what Red did.
He blended great jazz style which he learned from people like Bixby and Louis Armstrong
with amazing classical style technique that he'd had as a child prodigy as a cornet player back in Ogden, Utah
as his father helped train him to become an excellent musician.
And the first band leader for whom he works is played by Bob Crosby.
Yes, that's another cameo.
But he's not playing himself and I believe that is a mythical band leader, right?
Yeah, that's a fictional character.
Because he's very mean, so I don't think they would want to portray a real person quite that negatively.
But it's possible he was based on someone and they just chose to keep his identity a secret.
The movie goes over quite a long period of time. It starts in 1924.
And it's supposed to end during the 1940s.
The early war years?
Yes, because it's definitely still during World War II.
And the character is 19 when the movie begins.
Danny Kaye was 48 at the time.
So he definitely looks more like the age of later in the film.
But they do a lot to age him with graying his hair.
And the infectious energy of Danny Kaye makes him ageless.
He's perfectly believable as this innocent, wide-eyed young man who, while naive in some aspects, is also really confident.
He's saying, pretty soon you're all going to be working for me.
When he first starts playing in that band, because he knows that he's good.
He doesn't have that much experience, but he knows he's good.
And that confidence combined with sort of a playful, silly nature is what makes us love that character.
Any time a film covers this much time, there's always going to be at some point the actor isn't going to be exactly the right age for the part.
So I think you kind of take that into account when going into it.
And that's never been something that has bothered me at all.
Besides the real music of Red Nickels, which is featured throughout the movie,
there also are several original songs written for this, making it kind of a double musical.
Both the in-context music and then just... most of the music is in context.
But some of them are more personalized songs, which were written, both words and music, by Sylvia Fine, who was Danny Kaye's real-life wife.
I had no idea she wrote music. I knew she usually wrote his lyrics.
She also was a producer on a lot of his films.
They had a very long and very happy marriage, like the Nickels did in real life, which is nice.
And they had a great partnership, too, because she helped him find and then would write for him the material that really made him shine.
So she helped insert that Danny Kaye charm into all those numbers, giving him time to do his funny shtick.
So you could see how he would shine as a performer, as well as putting a spotlight on how Red Nickels would shine as a performer.
And it paid off in this film because it got four Oscar nominations, too, which were for best musical scoring and best original song.
For the title song, right?
Other noteworthy actors in the film, most notably, are Barbara Bel Geddes as his wife.
As well as being a successful film actress, she was also very successful on the stage,
most notably originating the role of Maggie in Tennessee Williams' Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, in the original Broadway run.
Interesting.
And later in her career, she's probably most remembered for being on Dallas.
Yes.
And she played that role for almost the whole run of the show, except a brief time when she had to have surgery.
And Donna Reed replaced her, quite controversially.
And they ended up giving the role back to her.
As a result, Donna Reed sued them for breach of contract.
But that was the only time in television up to that point that someone had lost a role and then gotten it back.
So she's probably most remembered for that.
Yeah.
As well as before this, she started in films very young, back in 1947,
and got her first Oscar nomination for I Remember Mama, when she plays the oldest daughter.
That's right.
So she brings a lot of depth and warmth to the role of Bobby slash Willa.
And then a couple of different actresses play their daughter.
Right.
First, when she's like seven or eight.
And then when she's 14, in the last part of the film, she's played by Tuesday Weld,
who's a cute little blonde actress you'll see on many sitcoms of the era,
such as The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet.
And she also starred in the CBS television series The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis.
Oh, yeah.
And many years later, she was in a very famous film, Once Upon a Time in America.
For a while in the 60s, she was kind of noted for turning down roles in really successful films,
like Bonnie and Clyde and Rosemary's Baby,
specifically because she could tell they were going to be commercially successful.
I don't know why she didn't want to be in successful movies, but...
I guess she prized the art above the ones that would be really sensational.
And of course, one of the most notable things about her is that she has a very strange first name, Tuesday.
Her name was actually Susan, but as a child, her nickname was Tutu,
which she got from a young cousin who couldn't say Susan.
And eventually that became Tuesday, and she legally made her name Tuesday Weld.
The real star of this movie, of course, is Danny Kaye.
And first and foremost, he was a comedian and then kind of a vaudeville-style performer.
He was too young for vaudeville, but...
A real old-fashioned kind of song and dance man.
Yeah, because he also sang and danced, and that's how he met his wife.
And he performed on Broadway, and then that brought him into movies.
But he wasn't just a funny man, he wasn't just a jokester.
He could be a very intense, dramatic actor.
Yes.
And I think you see that in this movie probably more than any other.
Or at least as much as any other.
We watched this a lot when I was very young,
so I actually had very vague memories of it.
And watching it again, it was funny.
Some of the light-hearted moments were what I had forgotten,
but the really dramatic part right at the center of the film really stood out to me vividly.
And other scenes and songs and moments in it.
But it really is a very strong performance for him.
Probably, yes, one of his most challenging acting roles that he played.
I feel like a little part of me growing up thought that he played the cornet from seeing this movie,
because he's so convincing at it.
He is very convincing.
I feel like somewhere in the back of my mind I was thinking that was one of his cells.
He really sells it.
And it is such a great performance because he's not just dramatic, he's not just intense.
He's also funny, he's also tender and romantic and loving and fatherly.
Yes, he really has to cover the whole range.
And how much you see his character change, he becomes very bitter and depressed.
Depressed and sort of aged before his time,
because the character really isn't supposed to be that old by that point.
But he keeps calling himself a dinosaur.
And they had to age him a bit more in sort of great temples.
But it just highlights how his soul has aged, really,
and then how he kind of comes back to life at the end of the film.
For a biopic, this movie is actually very accurate.
That's impressive.
Maybe because he actually had a pretty nice life.
That's a good point. He did have a nice life.
All too often there'll be, oh, this composer had three wives, let's just make it one.
Red only had one wife.
Or this composer had a really dark spell, let's not focus on that.
Or let's really dramatize that.
But they basically stuck to the facts.
I'd say the biggest thing that they just kind of glossed over
was the fact that his meteoric rise to fame in the late 20s, early 30s,
did kind of fade as that style of jazz was becoming less popular in the big band era.
He tried to have a big band, it wasn't a huge success.
Now, he didn't lose all his money or anything.
Throughout the Great Depression, he continued working very successfully as a musician,
most notably being Bob Hope's band leader for many years.
And that's why there's a strange little cameo appearance by Bob Hope
in the scene in the Brown Derby later in the film.
And he also worked as a studio musician, you know, whatever he had to do.
And he was still playing that cornet and being very successful.
Not as much as he had been with his band, the Five Pennies,
or any of his other groups, because he had a few different groups with different names.
There was another interesting thing about him.
In those early days, he and his group of friends,
which did include all those huge name musicians,
made all these records, but not always with the same name.
They had all these different names of groups when they were touring,
when they were making records.
Several times, he would use the Five Pennies.
That was a recurring name.
But it wasn't as consistently branded as in the movie.
And it was not because there were five musicians in the group.
There usually were more.
It was just the play on his name, Nichols, which really was his name.
He was really Loring Nichols, and he had red hair.
So this was one of the few movies where Danny Kaye got to have his natural hair colour.
Because when he began acting, Sam Goldwyn convinced him
that his red hair didn't look as good in Technicolour as blonde would.
So he bleached his hair for most of his movies.
Now, in the later films, I think they let it get a little more red.
But here, it is very red.
Sort of red and quite Christmas, right?
I think of him as having red hair.
I think it began to be more red in the 50s.
But here, it is definitely red.
That's his character, and it's part of it.
But I think Danny Kaye could relate to this character,
although they didn't have quite the same background
because Red Nichols was a Mormon, actually, coming from Utah.
And Danny Kaye was Jewish.
But they both had a sense of being a little different than the average person.
And a sense of individualism.
Danny Kaye wouldn't get a nose job when he went to Hollywood.
He was like, you need to change your name, get a nose job, dye your hair.
And so he agreed to dye his hair.
But he's like, nope, this is who I am.
And he became famous and beloved for who he was.
Was that his real name?
No, but he changed it a couple of times earlier.
It was much longer than that.
And too hard to pronounce.
It started with a K.
So in this character, he got to express his depth as a person
as well as his depth as an actor.
And then in real life, Red Nichols did leave his career
because his daughter had polio.
And so he began working at a war plant
and just moving from traveling around San Francisco
and then moving to Los Angeles, just like in the movie,
just to take care of their daughter.
But it wasn't quite so much if he was on top of the world
and he gave it up, his career was technically waning.
So they tweaked that a little bit for dramatic effect.
He was still very much in the throes of his career,
but you're right.
The Five Pennies wasn't touring as the huge success.
He was still a very active musician
and he would have continued being so
and probably continued reinventing himself
if he hadn't made that sacrifice for his family.
And also the dramatic subplot of their daughter being in boarding school,
as far as I can tell, that's not really based on fact.
Yeah, it's hard to find details about exactly where their daughter was.
At first they thought she had spinal meningitis
and then they realized it was polio.
But she was paralyzed as a result of that.
And of course the dramatic turning point is
can Red get back into music?
As his wife hopes he will.
In the movie that seems to happen when his daughter is about 14
in the World War II era.
The style of the clothing looks like the 50s by that point.
And in a way that's a nod to really what was more realistic
because it was in the late 40s going into the 50s
that he restarted his career.
So they shifted the dates a little bit there.
It was definitely after World War II.
He made a few film appearances in the 50s.
He restarted his band.
He was touring around and being a very successful musician.
Again, very popular.
He regained that fame showing he was just a lucky penny.
And it's funny that now amongst these jazz greats
whose names are still quite well known
his is kind of not a name you hear that often.
Yeah, largely because he did give it up for a while.
And then during that heyday of the big band era
that was when he was completely out of music.
That's true.
And then he mainly regained his fame around Los Angeles.
He began appearing at different places around Los Angeles.
He did start touring again because he was playing
in San Francisco at the time of his death
which was in the early 60s.
He was still very active in performing.
And one night he was having some chest pains
so he called for some medical help
but he died before they got there.
And that night the band still played
but they had a single spotlight on his chair.
That sounds like the conclusion of the movie.
But the movie ends when he's just like
at the beginning of his second cover score
because he was still alive and very active.
That would be a very dramatic ending for a biopic.
That sounds like a Hollywood ending.
And as a result of that nod to the 50s
it's very much the 50s fashion
by that latter last act of the movie.
My outfit is based on one which Bobby wears
at their daughter's birthday party.
It's a green full swing skirt, 1950s style
with a simple white tailored blouse
and a red belt with black shoes.
She only wears one hat in the whole film
and that's a little rain cap.
But in this era of the 30s, 40s and 50s
a woman would have been wearing a hat
so I paired her with a little red hat.
My outfit is inspired by Dorothy
their daughter's dress at her 14th birthday party.
It is a pink full skirted dress
with puffy sleeves.
She has little pink bows in her hair
and very simple flat shoes
due to her partial paralysis.
Some of the things that remain with you
after watching this movie years later
are the beautiful original songs
that just complement it so well.
The most memorable is of course
the title song, Five Pennies.
Just such a touching, beautiful song
that I've always loved singing and hearing.
It's performed in a three-way
sort of musical round.
Not quite a medley because all three songs
like a canon are being performed at the same time.
Five Pennies, Lullaby and Ragtime
and Goodnight.
All these melodies are laid over each other
so charmingly.
Louis Armstrong is singing Lullaby and Ragtime
and Danny Kaye is singing Goodnight.
No, Louis Armstrong is singing Goodnight.
Danny Kaye is singing Lullaby and Ragtime
and Louis Armstrong is singing Goodnight
and then his little seven or six year old daughter
is singing Five Pennies just for a brief moment.
I always love it when two songs go together like that
and then this way it's three all together.
It's impressive that that many melodies
could go together.
And of course the first time is when he sings it
to his daughter, he's trying to get her to go to sleep.
He has five pennies in his hand
and then finally his wife sings it
in the last scene.
Now there's an interesting bit of trivia about
the pennies because in the opening credits
they cleverly use pictures of real pennies.
You see the front and the back of them
and you know they look like
this penny here,
what's called the wheat or the feather penny
where it says one cent
and it has the two pieces of wheat
or some people consider them feathers.
This penny is from 1957
so it's older than the movie.
But in
1958
they changed the style from
the wheat penny to
this back where it's the
Lincoln Memorial.
And this is what it was for the next
several decades until
recently in the 21st century
it was changed to the new one that
looks like the Warner Brothers logo
and says E Pluribus Unum.
The shield.
So by the time
that the movie was released
the pennies such as shown
in the opening credits were no longer
being minted.
What a strange coincidence because there only
have been in recent
memory three different designs of pennies
and that it would actually change during that
brief time between when they made the credits and when the movie came out.
But it added to the historic
nature of the film, the fact that it wasn't about current
times, it was about the past
and it's especially
noteworthy now that pennies aren't even being
minted anymore.
Recent development.
I firmly believe that these pennies
are not a dying race and that
since we still have ones from the 50s and older
there still will be plenty of pennies. If we never made any more
pennies we're not going to run out of pennies.
But as the song
charmingly points out
the pennies
in the song aren't just
one cent pieces, they're representing
different ideas
different things you need in life
different pennies are to wish on
to dream on
one dances, to laugh on and to love on
and if you just have
these five pennies
these things, you'll be a millionaire.
Highlighting the theme of this film that
Red gives it all up
for love of his family.
He loves his music, but he loves
his wife and daughter even more.
And ultimately he gets
to have both his way, but it's
he feels
bad for making maybe a few
selfish decisions for his career and so
then he gives everything up
to help his daughter. So it's such
a beautiful family story
and highlighted by the
family story of Danny Kaye and his wife
and they really had just one daughter so
another way he could relate to Red
Nichols and interestingly there is
a cameo of Red Nichols on
screen in the film.
There's a montage of
various odd jobs
that Red takes
and the joke is that
he's always playing some version
of my Indiana home.
In various different locales
it's a Hawaiian
punch hour, the Canadian
Mounties and
in one it's like
Eskimos and so he's
dressed up like an Eskimo and
he's with a few other horn players
and one of those Eskimo horn players
is Red Nichols himself.
That's amazing. Why do you think that this
movie could be
relatable or enjoyable to
younger viewers today?
I think a biopic
always is
kind of a good way to start with classic films
because you sort of take into account
a biopic is probably going to be about someone
at least a bit from the past
so you sort of go into it with
it's going to be set in an old time
so I think maybe that makes it less jarring that it was
made in an older time and since it is the later
fifties, it's in color
it's very crisp, even the style of the
cinematography, it's a bit more like modern
films so it's more approachable than
even older movies probably
and I think it's just
it would be a really great introduction to maybe a new
style of music if younger viewers have never heard
jazz or at least not this kind of jazz
I think it's just really
could open a lot of interesting
doors for them and like you said the themes of
family and self-sacrifice, those are timeless
never going to go away
so I think all those things together really
make it approachable but also
an introduction to
a lot of things. And of course if you
are a fan of any kind of jazz,
Dixieland, big band music, you will
definitely want to look up this film
it's available on
DVD which you can buy on Amazon
Prime or on Walmart
Barnes & Noble, it's also
available for streaming
on Amazon Prime Video, YouTube
and other streaming platforms
in clear, crisp copies
in colour which you can rent or buy
The Eternal Love Triangle
is a feature of many love stories
but rarely is it
handled with as much honour, respect
and honesty as in our next
topic, a 1930s
melodrama about a woman
who marries for companionship
after losing the love of her life
only to find out that
she can feel true love again
but not for her husband
Thank you for watching, goodbye!