This documentary is the result of a full year of research and hard work to try to show the impact of climate change on the world of wine and the opportunities that it creates in unlikely places. Through the interview of 3 experts of English wine and climate change, this documentary is showing how people create vineyards from scratch, the challenges they face and the innovation they bring.
Chapters:
Intro: 00:00 General information on UK wine: 03:21 History of English Wine: 04:10 Impact of Climate change on English wine: 09:16 Challenges when growing vines in the UK: 11:56 Story of Denbies Vineyard: 15:05 How the UK vineyards created their own wine tradition (choice of grape varieties, techniques used, styles of wine, etc.): 18:20 Creating a good reputation for English Wine (branding/ rebranding): 25:01 Development of a market for English wine: 27:45 Climate forecast and influence on UK wine in the future: 29:38 Conclusion: 32:07
The history of wine is in many cases the history of our world and the reflection of the people
who inhabit it. It has accompanied us for more than 8 000 years since its humble beginnings
in the Georgian Caucasus. It has survived the ravages of time and seduced many civilizations
adapting, evolving, renewing itself in different lands and climates. However, many parts of the
world are unsuitable to grow vines. Some places are simply too cold or too hot to grow grapes
successfully. Vines require a specific amount of water, nutrients, sunlight and warmth to flourish
and yield desirable grape quality. If conditions are too cold, grapes won't ripen. If they are too
warm, they can over ripen and result in wines with unpleasant flavors and little freshness.
Optimal conditions to do wine are usually found between 30 and 50 degrees latitude on both sides
of the equator. However, with climate change we are observing a global shift in the areas that are
deemed suitable to grow vines all over the world. With some traditional wine regions going under
stress, while some places that were thought too inhospitable for vines in the past are now
developing their own vineyards. So we are seeing a significant polar shift in terms of potential.
We're seeing vineyards moving further north already. We're seeing a significant increase of
vineyards or viticulture in the UK. We're seeing an increase in Belgium. We're seeing an increase
in Poland. We're seeing an increase in Denmark. We're seeing an increase in Sweden and even into
Norway. There is increasing potential for them to grow and ripen grapes to make their own wines with
which were not there 20, 30, 40 years ago. Out of all the new vineyards that are emerging in the
northern hemisphere due to this global climate shift, there is one which is particularly
interesting as it has come a long way in terms of development and maturation. Going in a few decades
from being a backward cottage industry to competing on equal footing with prestigious champagne houses
in international contests, this wicked child of climate change is the United Kingdom. Within the
UK at the moment, there's around 700 vineyards. It's fair to say a large proportion of those are
relatively small, but there's some much larger vineyards of sort of 50, 100 hectares plus that
have been planted within the last 15 years or so. They're predominantly producing really high-end,
high-quality sparkling wine. The production volume at the moment is around 8 to 10 million
bottles annually, but we're seeing that number increase year on year as more vineyards are
established. The reputation is high, particularly around English sparkling wine, but we are also
starting to see more producers looking at still wines, whites, rosés. In some really good years
like 2018, we're seeing some really impressive still red Pinot Noir being produced in certain
parts of the UK. If winemaking in the UK seems like a modern thing, this opinion is actually
widely contradicted by historians and archaeologists' findings. Climate has changed a lot in the past
2,000 years, and the UK at times used to be a great place to grow vines and had a strong
winemaking tradition. So there's no evidence of Iron Age cultivation of the wine here,
and I discovered that in fact the Iron Age Celts of this country were importing wine
and drinking it in vast quantities before the Roman invasion. Tacitus, the Roman historian,
described how the English Celts were real barbarians when it came to drinking. They
didn't water their wine as the Romans did, and they used to do what we now call binge drinking,
so nothing has changed very much culturally there. And it's not until we get into the
Roman period where we have really good authenticated vineyards, and as I say, not
just isolated examples, just a few rows of vines at the end of a retired centurion's villa. There
is very good evidence of about half a dozen vineyards across the country. There's one recently
excavated quite close to where we are now, Denbys. In the Midlands, in the river valley of the Nene,
they've excavated many hectares of Roman vineyards and worked out that were tens of thousands of
litres of wine being produced, and this was agri-business. This was for industrial quantities
of winemaking, probably for the legionnaires in York and Hadrian's Wall. Then in the Dark Ages,
viticulture collapsed almost completely in this country, but didn't commence again until the
Norman conquest. And then in medieval England, medieval times, vineyards were developed all
across the country to a great extent. Of course, almost every monastery would have needed a vineyard
for Holy Communion and for dressing wounds and things like that, and would you believe at one
time we were producing so much wine that you remember every now and again we've had
misunderstandings with the French, and sometimes the peace treaty would specify
and no English wine is to be imported into France. Then, after the Black Death, viticulture collapsed
across most of England, and didn't begin again until the end of the 19th century, when one or two
eccentric gentlemen began to plant vineyards. This really began to take off in the 1960s,
1970s, with some quite well-established vineyards, and has now accelerated very dramatically over the
last 20 or 30 years, with very extensive areas being planted mainly across southern England.
So, when I put together my database, I was interested in the geology, but something struck me.
I could actually correlate the advance and retreat of vineyards across the country,
correlative with temperature. It's often recognised that Roman Britain was slightly warmer than
England is today. Temperature then dropped in the Dark Ages, the Saxon sag, rose again in the medieval
warm period, and then dropped in a period that we call the Little Ice Age, when we had much colder
winters than we had before and at the present time. There are various factors which have
obviously impacted on winemaking. So, at the end of the medieval winemaking boom,
there were several factors, which included the Black Death, when, don't quote me on numbers,
but there was a total collapse in agriculture, a loss of labour, and a civil war almost at the
same time, the Wars of the Roses. But this did correlate with a drop in temperature from this
medieval warm period, when one writer at the time said you could walk from Gloucester to London
in summer, going underneath vines almost the whole journey, to the Little Ice Age, when
we have various, no accurate temperature measurements, but we have proxy thermometers.
And, for example, Gilbert White of Selborne, a very famous naturalist, used to record when his
tortoise went into hibernation in the autumn and when the tortoise came out in spring. So,
that's an indicator of temperature. And Parson Woodford of Norfolk, a clergyman,
kept a very detailed diary in which he recorded, tonight it did freeze under my bed,
which meant that his chamber potty was frozen in the morning. So, we have these paleothermometers
to work out temperature, as well as lacking accurate measurements like we have today.
And now temperature is rising, viticulture is becoming much easier, and we're having a real
renaissance of English viticulture across the country. Over the last 40 to 50 years, we've seen
in the most dominantly planted parts of the UK, so mainly in the southeast of England, we've seen a
shift during the growing season, which is roughly April through to October. We've seen a shift in
temperature of about one degree. And it's that temperature change that means that varieties that
are commercially desirable can be grown and they can be ripened to the levels they need to be
ripened to, to make the wines that we're now making. So, climate change has really underpinned
the sector. We've seen warming growing season conditions. We've seen a very, very slight
reduction in rainfall during the growing season. However, we still have weather in England, which
means we still get variability. If climate change nowadays feels like an evidence, a few years back
it wasn't exactly the case. And many people even doubted it. I started to publish my results of my
research on global warming, and the academics didn't believe that there was any impact of
climate change on viticulture over 2,000 years. Certainly the vineyard growers derided this idea,
but that was 20 years ago. And a while later, I was giving a seminar here at Denver's to
about 20 English vineyard owners. And at the end, we had a chat, a general discussion. And I said,
so how many of you are noticing that the bud burst is earlier than it used to be?
Almost everybody's hand went up. And the Vondage, the harvest, how much earlier is that?
And again, yes. I've been here 30 years on site, and religiously, we used to harvest at the beginning
of October, and we used to finish at the end of October. Sometimes it would creep into the first
week of November. Last year, we started harvest. We had a break after the first pick. We picked
at the end of August, which crazy really. That would have been unheard of a few, well,
10 years ago, that would have been absolutely, we were crazy thinking we'd be doing that.
So things have changed. The ability to grow varieties here that would have historically
been a real challenge is now possible. And some of the varieties we grow here now,
which were marginal, or the Pinot Noir, for example, which we only used to use for sparkling
wines, can now be used for producing a red wine or a rosé. So the flexibility of what we can now
do with those grapes has changed because of climate change. But all in all, we are noticing
that we have improved yields, and the quality of what we produce year on year seems to be going up
and improving as we go on. Even if the climate is warming up, it doesn't mean that the UK is yet
to the point where they can be considered similar to other normal wine regions. It is still a
marginal climate to grow vines as such. Vine growers really have to be careful regarding where
they actually establish their vineyards, and the need to take advantage of all the microclimates
that exist in the UK to protect as much as possible their harvest. There's a little bit
of a mixed message in the sense that climate change is very positive. That enables the commercial
potential to be realised. It enables the wine quality to be realised. But people should be aware
that we're still in a relatively marginal climate for viticulture. We're not Bordeaux, we're not
California, and we do have vintage variability. We still have rainfall at unsuitable or unfavourable
times of the year, such as happened in 2012, and we have years a bit like this past year
where we've seen generally cooler and damper conditions which have exacerbated problems
related to mildew. We still have challenges around early season frost events. A lot of places
around the world are affected by frosts, and it's a big problem for us. It's one thing which
has caused us a lot of issues over the years. We have employed various methods of frost protection.
We used to use big burners out in the vineyard, but again it's very expensive, again with oil
prices, diesel prices going up. It used to cost us roughly about £7,000 a night, and it used to
take us a long time to get around there. Quite often if you have three or four nights in a row
of frost, it could mitigate the money you spend on it. You would have made that buy,
but not protect yourself in the first place, and just taken the hit on losing the grapes.
So we don't use that employing method. We don't think it's very environmentally
friendly either, burning lots of oil out every night. Global warming has had a very positive
impact on winemaking in the UK so far. However, if the UK wine industry is emerging as a new
exciting player in the global wine landscape, it is still in many ways a work in progress.
Local vineyards have come a long way to produce high-quality sparkling wine,
but are still facing quite a few challenges, both climate-wise and market-wise. To understand
better the situation, as well as the efforts needed to develop a new national vineyard
and put it on a map, we decided to go to a city called Dorking, south of London,
to visit the largest single estate vineyard in the UK, called Denbigh's Wine Estate.
Denbigh's was among the first large vineyards to be developed in the UK almost 40 years ago.
Its history is entangled with the renewal of the UK wine industry, and is a great case study for
climate change. In 1984, my father bought the Denbigh's estate, and at the time it was a pig
and cattle farm. It was losing a lot of money. We joined the common market and it became very
competitive, so my father started to look for another use for the estate. It was at this time
that a friend of my father's, Professor Sally, pointed out to my father the potential that was
My interest in Denbigh's began when my house that I lived in at that time,
from my study window, I could look out across what is now Denbigh's Vineyard, and I used to
think after all my travels, what a fantastic place for a vineyard. I knew Adrian White,
Sir Adrian as he is now, socially, and just for a joke, I wrote up a report for him,
like I might write a consultant report for an oil company, saying, look, you've got this
fantastic old pig farm, sunny south-facing slope, the same rock that Champagne has grown on,
global warming, why not have a vineyard? And the report mentioned the earlier vineyards of
England and the rocks and so on. And a little while later, several months, he said, Richard,
great idea, I'm going to have a vineyard. So my father looked at the land, he looked at the
English wine industry, which was pretty much non-existent, and English wine had a very
poor reputation at the time. It was very much a cottage industry. Yeah, when we first had the
idea of a vineyard here, people were concerned it was a bit of a white elephant, that people,
that it would be, it wouldn't work, and therefore they were very concerned about developing a big
business centre here. Their concern was that if people didn't come, what was this big building,
huge building, in a very highly sensitive area of the country, what was it going to be turned into?
So there were concerns about it, and you can understand for some people, it is a beautiful
area, and there were concerns about what this big development could be turned into. But we were
very, we had conviction, we knew what we were trying to achieve, and unfortunately there hasn't
been a lot of incentive from the government. It's been a lot of personal investment we've had to make
in this business. There are a couple of joint European schemes that we had help with
over the last five or six years. One was further assistance with our growth into wine tourism,
and some with the wine equipment. So we did have a few, a couple of grants for that.
But apart from that, we're on a level playing field with everybody else. I mean, again, I think
a lot of those grants were European-wide. Some other industries like microbreweries,
they do have a lower duty threshold to support smaller local beer producers, whereas with the
English wine industry, we've never had any preferential treatment in terms of duties
than anybody else. The initial vineyard project at Denbigh's was lacking support from the local
community, and was perceived by many as an eccentricity. This experience was shared by many
of the first professional vineyards, as they were trying to create a brand new industry. In addition
to the lack of public support, these early vineyards had to go through a painful process
of trial and errors to understand that there was the great varieties that would fit their climate
and soils, and come up with their own winemaking tradition. We had a lot of challenges in the early
days. We decided to plant many different varieties, because we weren't sure how good some
varieties would grow here, not just on site, but here in the UK. So we did a lot of spread betting,
because we didn't want to wait for three years and thought, well, that was absolutely rubbish,
and we had to put up the whole vineyard to start again. So we produced a lot of different varieties,
and then over time we have changed the varieties that we grow here on site. When Denbigh's was
first planted, they took advice from the German Wine Institute at Trier, who quite properly
recommended cool climate Germanic grape varieties, the varieties that many people would be familiar
with, Niersteiner, Schoenberger, Riesling, that sort of thing. Over the years, most of those Germanic
cool climate varieties have been grubbed up and replaced with warmer climate French varieties,
and in particular with what we often call the holy trinity that's used for making champagne,
Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier and Chardonnay. And this is being replicated across many
Englands in southern England. Older vineyards are grubbing up their cool climate Germanic
grape varieties and are being replanted with warmer climate varieties. Climate change has
really made possible the development of vineyards in the UK. However, just having
an appropriate climate doesn't make a wine industry. This requires a lot of investment,
knowledge, experiments and in the end just very passionate people who are committed to do the
best products possible with what they have. Currently English wine is on the rise,
but it came a very long way. If now some sparkling wine in the UK can compete with
champagnes, this is quite a recent development and is the result of decades of hard work of
pioneers like the White family, which really had a vision of what the future of the UK could be.
English wines have changed dramatically over the years. When we first started,
the rest of the industry wasn't really an industry. It was a cottage industry
and the quality was known to be poor. They had a very small acreage per vineyard only had,
I think the average acre was a half an acre to an acre. The quality was up and down every year
based on the weather conditions. There was no ability to blend different varieties together.
It was purely based on what we produced in that vineyard in that year using very primitive
equipment. But also there was very little access to the state-of-the-art equipment because the
vineyards just weren't big enough to justify that sort of investment. Also with a winemaker,
they want to be inspired producing top quality wines, but if you have nothing to play with,
poor equipment and very low yielding varieties or not very exciting varieties, you can't attract
the best winemakers from around because it's not in their interest to do that.
English wine was also very expensive because we produced very small amounts of it. That's
changed dramatically over the years. There's been a huge amount of investment. The economies
of scale have gone up. We've brought in some very high profile winemakers from around the world
because of the scale of what we're now producing. We're buying in state-of-the-art equipment to
ensure that we are producing the best possible wine that we can produce here in the UK. We can't
As the UK wine industry is relatively recent, it doesn't have a legacy of techniques,
local grape varieties or wine tradition comparable to other wine regions in Europe.
If some may see that as a weakness, it may prove itself to be an asset in the long run.
Free of any tradition, the UK vineyards are freer to innovate and pick from the old world
and the new world what works best for them. This leaves the door wider open
for new products and unseen before wines. In addition to that, as the climate is warming up,
having flexibility regarding what grape variety to plant in order to adapt to higher temperature
is definitely an advantage that is not shared by the older vineyards of Europe
that are limited by their appellations. We were starting off, we didn't have traditional
ways of doing things in here in the UK for producing wines, but we did want to look at
traditional methods and we want to look at new world methods. Traditional methods, we use oak
barrels for example, very traditional methods. We also use stainless steel tanks as well.
We also have experimenting with concrete as well, concrete eggs for example.
So we took a broad approach of our wine growing the vines and also our wine producing methods.
But I think the most important thing for us is to produce a high quality wine
and it doesn't necessarily mean just because we've always done it one way, we have to do it that way
because we might also be missing out on something very exciting that we might be able to grow here
that we just haven't thought of before. And this is why I think we have been successful over the
years because we haven't sat on our hands and done it just one way. We've looked at what other
people are doing as well. So whether that means adopting new world methods or sticking to
traditional, at the end of the day, it's producing a quality product. So it's what's in the bottle
that counts. But again, we're always looking at introducing new wines. Some of it is consumer led
and some it's because the climate is changing. If we hadn't done that, we wouldn't be producing
the amount of rosé we produce. Some supermarkets we supply just ask for our English rosé.
Again, when we first started here, it was not really conceivable that we were producing a rosé
and when we did start producing it, it was a very limited amount. But I think that's equally
as important because even we, what we've had a lot of success with here in the past,
it may get too hot for producing some of those aromatic fruity wines that we're known for
producing. We might have to start looking at other varieties and changing our styles of wines
to keep up with what's happening with the climate. The volume of wine produced in the UK
really skyrocketed in the last two decades. Early 2000, only around 15,000 hectolitres
were produced in the UK. Right now, we are close to 100,000 hectolitres. This growth in volume is
also visible in terms of the number of hectares which are dedicated to wine making. The hectarage
under vine has grown by 160% over the last 10 years and tripled since 2000. There are currently
some 3,000 hectares of vines in the UK, with a further 2 million vines expected to be planted
this year alone. But not just this, the actual branding around English wine has changed
tremendously. Part of it is due to ditching the label British wine, which for decades has been
associated with low quality wine made from grape juice imported to the UK but not actually produced
in the UK. And the other reason is due to the adoption of several quality standards,
as well as winning a lot of different prizes in international competitions.
Yeah, English wines not only had a pretty poor reputation domestically when we first started,
but internationally, I don't think it was a necessarily poor reputation. I don't think
people think that you could grow wines or produce wines here in the UK. The English
wine, as it became more serious, we had to start adopting some European wine standards,
which was very good for the English wine industry, because it meant that you couldn't just sell
anything to anybody of any quality. It had to be quality approved first. So in terms of
chapitalisation, how much you chapitalised the wine during harvest, how ripe the fruit was. And
what was very important for us is to enter international awards, which meant that there
were blind tastings, no one knew what was necessarily in the bottle, or where it came
from. And therefore we were matched against our peers from around the world. And that was
important to us, it made sure that you know, if you won an English award, well, you would win that
because, but who you compete against, only other local producers. So we did enter a lot of
international awards. And now year on year, English wines are winning top awards in those
tastings, whether it be for sparkling, or for still wines. One of our rosés, for example,
voted the best in the world in 2012, for our 2011 rosé. Again, it created quite a storm at the time.
But it does show that if you're producing something you can honestly grow well here,
there's no reason why you can't win those international awards for it.
Now we're seeing the final piece of this industry sign to appear, which is the market for this UK
wine. And at this, the UK is actually very fortunate, because it is one of the countries in
Europe, where the number of bottles per person, bottles of wine per person is the highest. So
there is a very strong domestic market, which allows the country to not rely overly on overseas
markets, where competition with local winemakers, like in France can be quite fierce. Historically,
we don't export a lot of English wine, partially because the domestic market is so strong at the
moment. The demand for our wines is really very, very high. We couldn't sell it to supermarkets
in the early days, partially because English wines couldn't produce enough of it. And again,
the quality and the price was variant on how good the harvest was that year. But now we have
consistency, we have the quality that supermarkets are coming to us to buy the wine now. And every
supermarket now in the UK has English wine on their shelf, which was unheard of years ago.
We have been looking positively at a lot of international sales and exports. And we do export
some of our wines, but on a very limited niche basis. We sell our wines in China, Japan, and
we have done some in America as well. But the domestic demand is strong and growing so much
at the moment. And because we haven't got to worry about with all the logistics of selling our wine
internationally. And again, it's more profit or margin erosion when we're selling overseas.
But we do export and it's something we are looking at more out in the future,
because the demand is growing for English wines overseas as well.
With climate change, it is really hard to tell what the world of wine will look like
in 10, 20, 30 years from now. But one thing seems quite clear. The UK and all the northern
countries in Europe will really benefit from the situation. Some investors and French vineyard
owners in places like Champagne in France have well understood this and are starting to buy land
in the UK to prepare for this environmental change. Experts now are also trying to do forecasts
on what this future climate will look like and how it will impact vineyards in the UK
and all around the world. For the models and the scenarios we've looked at,
across nearly all of them, we see an increase in temperature over the next 20 years during
the growing season. We see years such as 2018, the highest yielding year in the UK,
becoming more commonplace. In some areas, we do see a slight reduction in rainfall.
Generally speaking, that is seen from a viticulture perspective as positive. It means that
yields should be increased, should be more consistently higher. It means that ripening
the varieties we grow now should become a little bit easier. It means we can branch out in terms
of wine styles. As I say, perversely is a positive for growers in the UK, but we have to remember
that other parts of the world, climate change is very negative for vine growing and wine production.
If we look, for example, at the wildfires in California, in Australia, in Provence this year,
they've devastated wine producing areas and they are increasing. Regardless of the fires,
a severe increase in temperatures, as we have seen, means that a lot of the styles of wines
that have been produced in the past can't be. The sugar levels are too high, the ripening
profiles are uneven, the alcohol levels are not commercially attractive. When you include other
problems such as water supply, etc., it means that there are areas in the world where viticulture is
under a lot of stress at the moment and there needs to be a significant amount of adaptation
taking place to enable them to cope with those conditions. As grapes are very temperature
sensitive plants, the winemaking landscape is guaranteed to be impacted in decades to come by
climate change. Real alchemy between the wild nature and human culture, wine is a poem that
talks about the passing seasons, the genius of men and women and the personality of the very earth.
Wine is an expression of the time we live in and a witness of changes our environment is going
through. It seems very likely that the wine center of the world will move further north and that the
picture that will be drawn of the wine landscape by then will look completely different from what
people have been used to for centuries. To paraphrase one of Professor Silly's jokes,
the future of English wine may well be Scottish rosé.