Fraudulent Misrepresentation Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
7 Video Views·Mar 9, 2026
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
So over the last few lessons what we have been doing is talking about the concept of
misrepresentation. We noted in the previous lessons that in order for there to be a successful claim
of actionable misrepresentation what is required is for there to be a statement or a statement of
fact and for that statement to have been false or at least misrepresented or at least misleading
and for there to have been the inducement by the other parties into the contract on the basis of
that kind of statement. Now in terms of contractual inducement it requires that at least
it makes a material contribution to the decision of whether or not that individual should enter
into the contract. It doesn't necessarily mean that the individual in question only entered into
the contract because of the misrepresentation. It just has to make a material implication into
that. This lesson is going to talk about fraudulent misrepresentation and fraudulent misrepresentation
is the next major type of misrepresentation. There are two major other types of misrepresentation
that we're going to look at. The first of them being in this lesson being fraudulent, the second
in the next lesson being negligent. So let's just do a basic overview of some basic concepts
and we're going to begin firstly with the idea of innocent misrepresentation. As the name suggests
innocent misrepresentation will take place where all of the elements of misrepresentation are
satisfied but it is done with a reasonable belief in the truth of the statement. So if an individual
makes a statement of material fact and that statement of material fact is false or misrepresented
and as a result of that that induces a contract to take place but it is reasonably believed on
the part of the person who made the statement that in fact they believed that it was true that it was
at least true that the statement that they made then this is considered to be something known as
innocent misrepresentation i.e. all of the elements of actual misrepresentation are there
but it was done with a reasonable belief in truth. Now generally the remedy in a case for
innocent misrepresentation is either recession or damages. So it basically levies
lighter remedies than the idea of it being potentially void or voidable as a contract
just an innocent mistake fundamentally. On the other hand however we have the idea of fraudulent
misrepresentation and we can look at fraudulent misrepresentation by reference to one of the most
important cases in this area. The case that we're going to be referring to is the case of Derry and
Notice by the way that a lot of the cases in contract law are very very old a lot of the basic
principles of contract law are settled law and have been settled law for many many years
and just bear that in mind. So the case of Derry and Peak was a case where it did not show that
the claimant had a good claim for actionable misrepresentation at the time this was referred
to as the tort of deceit but it did outline the process that is required in order to show
a situation of fraudulent misrepresentation. So this is an interesting case where we have
a potential claim that doesn't actually materialise but the courts do make an effort
to discuss the process by which a fraudulent misrepresentation can in fact take place.
The company in question had issued a prospectus which stated that its tramways were able to use
steam power. This was not true since this was something which would require support
from the board of trade. The claimant in this case would see this prospectus and then as a
result of seeing this prospectus make a decision on the purchase of those shares. On the basis of
this prospectus even though within this we have the fact that it was not true since it would
require support from the board of trade. It was held that the defendant in the issuance of the
prospectus did not rise to the level of an actionable misrepresentation because essentially
the claimant actually believed the statements in the prospectus was true and so the courts will
then go about the process of outlining instead the process of showing an idea of fraudulent
misrepresentation. How is a fraudulent actionable misrepresentation shown or just
easily it's easy to understand fraudulent misrepresentation shown? Well the false representation
must be made knowingly. It must be made without belief in its truth of the statement or with an
amount of recklessness pertaining to the truth of the claim. So you make a false representation
but you do so with the belief that you know it is true. Okay I know it's false I say without
it's without belief it's true in relation to the statement or alternatively with a certain
amount of recklessness pertaining to the truth of the claim. So you might not know definitively
and categorically if the claim happens to be false but you are so reckless in your lack of
understanding as to the epistemic truth of the claim that it can still amount to a fraudulent
misrepresentation. According to Lord Herschel we get this passage and they say quote fraud is
proved when it is shown that a false representation has been made one knowingly or two without
belief in its truth or three recklessly carelessly whether it be true or false. So Lord Herschel
makes something of a hair-splitting delineation between a false representation being made
knowingly or without belief in its truth. So essentially what these two things represent are
essentially the same thing. If you say I know this is false versus I do not believe that it is true
you're there is a slight difference as you can probably understand but they both derive
basically at the same conclusion. But then the third point is that you can do so recklessly
carelessly as to whether or not it is true or false and this is how we prove
fraud can be shown in a case of fraudulent misrepresentation.
