The Mystery of the Missing Medieval Sea

Relic Archives
18 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 9, 2026
There's been a lot of rain here in the UK recently. So much so, that land that has been drained and
reclaimed for centuries is, all of a sudden, under the risk of turning back into the sea.
For example, a sea level rise of only a few metres reveals the now-drained marshlands of
the Fens in eastern England, and the extinct sea at Pevensea in southern England can,
as of right now, be seen on flood warning maps. According to the historian Michael Hislop,
the natural harbour first conquered by William of Normandy has turned into fields,
and the castle that once guarded an important coast is just in the middle of a bunch of lands now.
But these aren't what this video is about. Instead, all of this had me thinking about
something very peculiar I'd seen a little while ago. This is a hill in the valley of Glaslyn in
Wales. Most hills here follow a pretty normal naming scheme, usually containing one of the
and so on. Except for this one. This one is called Ynys Here, Long Island. No mention of a hill at
all. But alright, surely it's just a metaphor. Does it stick out like an island in the middle
of a field? Well, yes, but nowhere else in Wales is named like that at all, and the place is filled
with hills. In fact, with very, very few exceptions, the word Ynys in Welsh exclusively
applies to what you'd expect. Islands. Actual islands. In the sea. But what's interesting about
Ynys Here is that it's not alone. In fact, the majority of those very few exceptions occur right
here, in the middle of the valley of Glaslyn, where nearly every single prominent hill is called
an island. It is unlike, literally, anywhere else in the entire country.
You don't have to remember any of these names, but from Ynys Here we have the nearby Ynys
Ceredigion and Ynys Galch. We also have Ynys Ceoliog, Ynys Ygweli, Ynys Here and Ynys Yfan.
Finally, these names also occur quite a bit inland, as north of here we can find Ynys Fearlas,
Ynys Fach and finally, the largest of these islands, Ynys Fawr. Alongside the last hill,
Bwch Glas, who just has to be different. As I said, apart from this collection of hills,
some of the only islands I can find that aren't actually islands seem to be a peninsula in
south-west Wales, a village named Llanynas in north Wales and another called Ynys Ybul in
south Wales. So what's going on? Why in this obscure rural valley in north-west Wales do
we have an archipelago surrounded by a sea of grass instead of water? The first thought that
came to mind was, well, how long has this been grass? Were these once proper islands?
Looking on the website Floodmap.net, I decided to see what would happen if you raised the sea
level by a few metres, as those floods had revealed the old sea at Pevensey earlier,
and while most of Wales wasn't affected by an otherwise Netherlands-destroying 5-metre rise,
one area in particular looked very different. The Glaslyn Valley, with its collection of
islands, suddenly became completely submerged. What had happened here?
Looking at an old map from 1839, I couldn't spot anything different. The Glaslyn River still just
ran through solid ground, the nearby town of Porthmadog was still there, and these islands
were still just hills. But by looking at a map made only four decades prior, a very different
picture emerged. Because all of a sudden, two towns in the area, Porthmadog and Tremadog,
aren't there. In fact, the entire valley isn't there, instead being replaced by nearly four
miles of a brand new gulf or inlet, labelled Trythmawr. I had never seen this before,
and 13 miles of coastline disappearing is a pretty conspicuous thing, so I wasn't all surprised to
learn that this had actually been staring at me in the face for years. On any map I could find
produced prior to the 1800s, this sea, Trythmawr, was right there. Some authors made it pretty
prominent too. On the Cambria Typus, the earliest known map of just Wales, the author shows this
lost stretch of coast extending about halfway towards the other side of the ocean. A painting
from 1834 of Trythmawr, one that I'd used in my video several times, seemed to show a load of
sand. But another painting from 1818 of the same location, which is also a picture I've shown
several times, seemed to instead depict quite a bit of water extending deep into the mountains.
Water that was deep enough to allow boats on it, and some pretty sizeable ones too.
But again, nothing is left of this. Well, almost nothing, but we'll come to that in a second.
Miles of water were present in this medieval map, and indeed in maps all the way up to 1795.
Dozens of them, many of which I'd been looking at for years. So what had happened to this missing sea?
The answer lies, as it often does, with man. Well, with one man to be exact. William Maddox.
According to the historian David Thomas, Maddox was a wealthy man with family from Denbighshire
in North Wales. With his inheritance, he had bought an estate on what would have been the
shores of this inlet, and he set about a tremendous task. The Dictionary of Welsh Biography does not
call him an industrialist for nothing, and true to his surname, William Maddox envisioned turning
what was then the small port towns of Bortheghest and Aberglaslyn into a proper dock that could
serve the nearby slate mines. This new dock was called Porthmadog, humbly named after him. But how
he achieved this is what we're really interested in. According to D. Thomas, beginning from the age
of about 25, William Maddox began to enclose and drain thousands of acres of this missing medieval
sea, starting from around his estate where the town of Tremadog, also named after him, sits today,
aiming to eventually encompass the entire gulf.
By 1811, this process began to be truly underway, as with the permission of the British Parliament,
Maddox created a contraption across the mouth of the Glaslyn with a very disappointingly boring
name. A long ridge of rocks, road and eventually rail known as the Cob. This wall severely limited
how far the tide could travel in. The biologist P.M. Rhine notes that even in high tide, the
sea water is still mostly kept out today, and all of this allowed for Maddox to completely change
the landscape of this valley. According to G. Robinson, this sea, Trythmawr, likely looked a
lot like the estuary to its south, the Mawrach, and this can be seen here in that painting made
only a few years after construction of the Cob had started. But soon, this would not be the case.
I couldn't find a source for when the draining of the sea had been completed, so we can't know for
certain when these islands no longer became islands. But by 1821, the construction of
Horthmadog was underway, and in this map from 1833, the Glaslyn is shown carving its way through a
field, rather than emptying out into a sea nearly four miles to its north. Our missing medieval
water wasn't lost to a natural cause, it didn't vanish out of thin air, it was drained. These
islands became no longer islands, entirely due to man-made causes. When I first started to go
into this, I expected to find William Maddox as a sort of Loraxian bad guy, you know, draining an
entire gulf for a new shopping centre or a 24-lane motorway or a Thneed factory, but no, he doesn't
really fit that bill. In the words of David Thomas, Maddox was a pronounced radical and a supporter
of parliamentary reform. Not to mention, what was once the waters and sands of Trythmawr are
farms today. There's a salty marsh towards the north of the Cob, which is apparently a very
rare habitat in the UK, but the rest are just fields. Interestingly, this wasn't even Maddox's
original idea. He had read about the plans from another man, John Wynne, who had the same idea in
1625, but for whatever reason, never went through with it. This photo on Wikimedia Commons by
Christine Johnston calls the southwest of Tremadog a sea of grass, and that's an excellent pun.
Because not only was it an actual sea only 200 years ago, but even today it's still, in a way,
a sea, filled with almost a dozen islands that aren't actually islands anymore. What was once a
large outcropping in the middle of the water, large enough for its name to mean big or great island,
is now just a hill, and a small one, completely dwarfed by its surroundings.
But its name preserves the fact that this valley, these fields, are not natural.
There are several examples of islands that aren't properly islands here in Wales.
To the south by the River Dovey, we have places like Ynys Las, Ynys Tachwed, and Ynys Here,
all enclosed within these sandbanks. But according to the historian G. Robinson,
sediment deposits have changed the coastline of West Wales quite a bit,
and I imagine that this is how places like these lost their island status.
But Trythmawr sticks out, not only for its abundance of demoted islands, but for the
reasons it got that way. This sea was drained, ultimately, by an industrialist,
envisioning a port with a railway that he never got to see complete, all made for money of which
he died without, having left the country broke for Paris, where he passed in 1828.
Trythmawr didn't need to be drained, but it doesn't seem like Maddox did it out of a need
to crush wildlife in the name of progress. He looked up to figures like Alexander the Great,
but while he may have conquered Persia, Maddox sought to make his own mark on the map, literally.
So while yes, Trythmawr did not need to go, at least Maddox's dream wasn't to turn it into a
wasteland. At least this sea of grass with its islands that aren't islands is still there,
and it didn't get turned into a 4,000 acre car park. I don't know though,
I still wish I could have seen those hands. Thank you very much for watching, and thank you all for
100,000 subscribers. The next goal will be to reach 4.7 billion in the next 4 seconds.
Okay, okay, so we didn't quite reach that one, but it's okay, we can try again later.
