Medieval Europe's Ultimate Catfish Story

Medieval Legends
5 followers
Modern scholars cast serious doubt on the tale, pointing to its late appearance in written records and its use as anti-Catholic propaganda during the Reformation. Still, the story shaped centuries of tradition and rumor—from a strange “toilet chair” in Vatican rituals to whispered tales of erased histories. In this episode, we trace the myth, the evidence, and the enduring power of one of history’s most outrageous ecclesiastical scandals.
#History #WeirdHistory #PopeJoan
In the shadowy margins of medieval Europe, a legend emerged of a woman who defied the
rules, deceived the most powerful institution in the Christian world, and sat, undiscovered,
on the throne of St. Peter.
Her name was Pope Joan, or so the story goes.
The tale begins in the mid-ninth century, around the year 855.
According to later accounts, a brilliant young woman, disguised as a man, rose through the
ranks of the church under the name John.
She became a scholar, a priest, a cardinal, and eventually, Pope.
For over two years, she allegedly ruled Christendom as Pope John VIII, dispensing papal authority
and presiding over holy matters with none the wiser.
But then came the moment that unraveled everything.
While leading a solemn procession through the streets of Rome, the Pope went into labor.
The crowd watched in shock as the Holy Father gave birth, exposing what no one had suspected.
Some say she died on the spot, others claim she was executed by an enraged mob.
Either way, the deception ended in blood and scandal.
But did any of it really happen?
That's where history gets murky and fascinating.
The earliest written version of Pope Joan's story doesn't appear until nearly 400 years
later in a 13th century chronicle by Jean de Mailly.
His version was brief, but sensational.
Later writers like Martin of Opava expanded it, adding dates, locations, and theological
drama.
The story was repeated, reprinted, and embroidered across Europe.
But there's a problem.
No contemporary documents mention a female pope.
The Liber Pontificalis, Rome's official papal register, lists no gap in the succession.
And Pope John VIII is a real historical bigot who reigned from 872 to 882, well after the
time frame claimed for Joan.
Despite these gaps, the legend spread.
In the Middle Ages, it was treated with a strange blend of belief and suspicion.
Some saw it as a cautionary tale about pride, others as divine punishment for deception.
But it was the Protestant Reformation that gave the legend new life.
Reformers like John Hus and Martin Luther seized on the Pope Joan narrative as evidence
of papal corruption.
Here, they said, was the ultimate proof that the church was fallible.
So corrupt and self-absorbed, it failed to notice a woman sitting at its highest seat.
The myth began to affect ritual.
One enduring rumor claimed that papal enthronement ceremonies now included a physical verification
of gender.
A pierced chair, known as the sedia stercorare, was allegedly used to allow cardinals to verify
the new pope's masculinity.
A man would sit, a cleric would check, he has two, the cardinal would declare, and the
ceremony would proceed.
Modern scholars, however, believe the chair's purpose was symbolic.
Its name, roughly translated as dung chair, suggests humility, not inspection.
Still, the myth persists, and the chairs remain displayed in the Vatican museums, sparking
centuries of speculation.
There are even stranger clues.
Some researchers have examined coins attributed to Pope John VIII and found irregularities,
two distinct monogrammed types, possibly hinting at a now-erased papal figure.
Others argue this is coincidence or confusion.
There's no hard evidence, but the idea lingers.
By the 17th century, the Catholic Church began to explicitly deny Pope John's existence.
The legend was labeled a fable, a slander, a Protestant invention.
And yet, it wouldn't die.
The story entered art and literature.
Pope John became the subject of plays, poems, and feminist reimaginings.
She was painted as a martyr, a genius, a trickster, and a victim.
In the 20th century, she became a symbol of suppressed female agency.
Even today, novels and films revisit her tale, asking what if.
Whether real or invented, the legend of Pope John endures because it touches something
primal, our fascination with power, gender, and forbidden truth.
In a world where women were barred from leadership, Pope John offered a radical possibility that
intellect could outwit hierarchy, and that for a brief moment, the unthinkable had happened.
Was she real?
Most scholars say no, but the story of Pope John continues to live because history, like
faith, often turns on what we choose to believe.
If you liked what you watched, please like and subscribe.
We post interesting and crazy stories from throughout history every Wednesday and Saturday.
Yesterday's craziness, because yesterday was crazy too!
