Cryptocurrency, Stablecoins, and CBDCs- Mr. Chris Land

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Mar 6, 2026
23rd Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 6-7, 2022
-Mr. Chris Land
General Counsel, U.S. Senator Cynthia M. Lummis
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thanks, JC, and thank you, everyone, for attending today.
It's a really important forum, and I'm really glad
to welcome you here today.
So the Responsible Financial Innovation Act
that Senator Lummis has co-sponsored
with Senator Gillibrand deals, there are kind of three buckets,
as I think you mentioned earlier.
There are commodities, there are ancillary assets,
and then there are pure securities
or pure investment contracts.
U.S. law treats investment contracts
and securities a little bit different than the rest
of the world, so what's necessarily an investment
contract or security in the U.S. wouldn't necessarily be
construed to be so in your home jurisdictions.
But so this whole concept of an ancillary asset is what we hope,
what Senator Lummis and what Senator Gillibrand hopes reflects
kind of the case law around the Howey Test.
There's this Supreme Court decision
from the 40s called the Howey Test,
and it interpreted what's an investment contract.
And you know, Senator Lummis and Senator Gillibrand have looked
at all of the case law that interpreted Howey
from the 40s on and determined that, you know,
if you're providing an asset with an investment contract,
it's not necessarily a security or it's not necessarily part
of that investment contract.
So Senator Lummis and Senator Gillibrand's bill would recognize
that, you know, fact that's based in the case law and say
that if you're providing a most digital assets aren't
necessarily decentralized enough
to be considered pure commodities
like Senator Lummis mentioned that Bitcoin clearly is today,
but they don't necessarily always check the boxes of,
you know, being an investment contract either
because they're not conferring a business interest in a, sorry,
a financial interest in a business entity.
But as Senator Lummis has rightly pointed out,
many of the digital assets today have security
like features that requires increased disclosure
in the digital asset markets.
Consumers need to be aware of what assets they're, you know,
they're placing their money with and, you know,
what financial decisions they're making.
And in the digital asset markets today, you know,
I think Senator Lummis rightly pointed out that, you know,
there isn't adequate, you know, there are a lot
of information asymmetries that occur and that consumers need
to have more information.
So that's one key part of the Lummis-Gillibrand bill.
What it does is requires disclosures
from most digital asset, most digital asset companies
and they have to provide some tailored information to the SEC
and that would help better inform people's market choices.
I'll just add a few brief comments.
America, you know, for better or for worse, has, you know,
kind of shifted its attitude towards innovation
and financial services since 2008.
You know, when Dodd-Frank was enacted in 2010,
there was a real, there's an appropriate focus on risk
and Congress imbued kind of a risk-focused approach
to everything in financial services
and it's still highly appropriate.
But that culture of risk mitigation
at all costs has been so imbued in some
of the financial regulators
that people are ignoring the potential for innovation
and that's going to have long-term consequences
for America's position in the world.
You know, our role is, you know, having the most liquid
and deep capital markets in the world.
You know, being able to, you know, be a force for democracy.
A lot of that's tied to our economic strength.
So, I mean, it's really important
that America really takes digital asset innovation
and financial technology and builds upon it and, you know,
doesn't, you know, dismiss it as, you know,
being just another risk that we should mitigate.
We're like, we need to have a balanced framework.
I think my boss feels pretty strongly
that provides appropriate consumer protection
but allows innovators the space they need to try things
in an appropriate and focused manner and, you know,
not shut out the innovators out of this country
because that would be extremely short-sighted.
You know, everyone's talking about the FTX implosion
and the FTX implosion, in my boss's view,
was not, you know, a failure of the technology.
It was a failure of regulation and it was a failure of people.
You know, if the Lummis-Jillibrand Bill had been
in place, you know, two months ago,
FTX wouldn't have been permitted to do many
of the business practices that they were clearly engaged in
and they probably wouldn't have imploded.
You know, if the Digital Commodities Consumer Protection
Act, the Stabenow-Boson Bill had been in place,
it probably wouldn't have occurred either.
So, you know, FTX, in my boss's opinion, was just a failure
of people and the law and not a failure of the technology
and doesn't have any, you know, it doesn't show
that crypto is more or less, you know,
doesn't have innovative potential.
It's just, it is what it is.
It's a failure of people and I just think we have
to be careful to have a balanced view of, you know, what crypto is
and what it isn't and, you know, what the state of the market is.
In fact, I was just going to turn to FTX, actually.
So I wonder, you know, from a legislative standpoint,
does that, and it's been a tumultuous time in crypto
in the last couple of months, for sure, does that failure
of FTX, do you think that accelerates consideration
of legislation or slows it down or does it make any difference?
Both. I think it makes legislation more certain
at some point down the line, but it's probably pushed
out the time frame a little bit.
You know, we have to wait on the SEC and the CFTC
to do some digging around and what happens and, you know,
that'll inform some of the legislative measures
that we put in place.
And, you know, I just think we've, I think it's appropriate
that Congress pushes pause for six months to a year to,
you know, find out what really happened
so that we can make appropriate legislation that isn't knee-jerk.
You know, we don't want to, you know, we don't want to pass,
you know, I don't think Congress should pass legislation now
because that would likely be a staggering overreaction
to what happened and, you know, at the same time,
we don't want to wait too long because we don't want
to allow, you know, other bad actors in the crypto space
to continue to operate.
Thanks. You know, one of the cool things, I've lived in London
for a long time and I get to work at Parliament and I get
to see like the foundations of the U.S. Constitution
and British law and that's what that was based on is, like,
when you go through the U.S. Constitution, you can find
like 20 things that we, you know, took from Great Britain.
So the parallels are insane.
But I just wanted to make a closing remark
that I really appreciate everyone being here.
You know, Senator Lummis and Senator Gillibrand really love
to talk to parliamentarians from around the world
about crypto regulation and what's going on
because you guys have been doing this, you know, for a long time
and we've had some really good ideas come out of meetings
with MPs from Australia and the U.K. and the European Union.
So, you know, please feel free to get in touch with our office
and we'd love to set up a conversation.
And thanks for everything you do
and really enjoyed the panel, Commissioner.
See you later.
