Mental Health | Essentials of Global Health with Richard Skolnik

Smart Insurance Choices
22 followers
7 Video Views·Mar 5, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome. Today we're going to speak about mental health. By the time you finish
this session you should be able to speak comfortably about the burden of mental
disorders, who is affected by that burden, the key risk factors for mental
disorders, the health social and economic consequences of them, and selected
measures that can be taken to address mental disorders. Let's start with two
vignettes to illustrate the significance of these problems. Rachel is
a 17 year old girl in Ethiopia. Rachel is in her last year of secondary school.
Lately Rachel's been feeling very sad and having difficulty overcoming that
feeling. Some days Rachel doesn't want to get out of bed, leave her room, or go to
school. She also cries a lot. Rachel is one of millions of people in the world
who suffer from depression. Sam is a 35 year old man in England. Sam worries a
lot. From time to time Sam worries so much that his heart beats fast, he gets
sweated up, and he feels like he can't breathe. Sam is one of many millions of
people in the world who suffer from an anxiety disorder. With these comments in
mind, let's explore further some of the specific disorders we'll discuss today.
One of the major categories of non-communicable diseases in the global
burden of disease studies is mental and substance use disorders. This category
includes a number of mental disorders, such as unipolar depressive disorders,
anxiety disorders, bipolar affective disorder, and schizophrenia. The category
also includes substance use disorders, such as alcohol use disorders, and drug
use disorders. In addition, it includes some behavioral disorders, such as
conduct and eating disorders. Together these disorders are very important to
the burden of disease, causing about 7% of all DALYs in low- and
middle-income countries in 2013. Covering a wide range of such disorders,
however, is beyond this session, so we are only going to cover here selected
mental disorders. Now four of them contribute the largest share to the
burden of mental disorders. These are unipolar depressive disorders, which
we'll refer to here as depression, schizophrenia, anxiety disorders, and
bipolar disorder. Let's look at a graphic that briefly defines these disorders.
Bipolar disorder is a serious mood disorder characterized by swings of
mania and depression. Depression is a mental state characterized by feelings
of sadness, loneliness, despair, low self-esteem, and self-reproach. Panic
disorder is an anxiety disorder characterized by attacks of acute
intense anxiety, and schizophrenia is a mental illness, the main symptoms of
which are hallucinations, delusions, and changes in outlook and personality.
Let's now talk further about the burden of disease. The first thing I want to
highlight is that the burden of mental health disorders is large, it's
underestimated, and in most countries it's also very much underappreciated.
Let's look first at the burden of these disorders globally for 2013 for both men
and women and all ages. And let's, if we might put the cursor over here, and we'll
see that for both sexes all ages in 2013 looking at disability-adjusted life
years for the world as a whole, depressive disorders constituted about
two and a half percent of all those DALYs. Anxiety about 1%, schizophrenia
about 0.64%, and bipolar disorder is about 0.4%. And now let's look at how
these figures would look if we shift to examining only the low and middle-income
countries. And here what we see is depression
constitutes about 2.4% of all DALYs, anxiety about 0.9%, schizophrenia about
0.4%, and bipolar disorders about 0.4% as well. Now it's important to
understand that this burden of these four mental disorders in low and
middle-income countries in 2013 was greater than the burden associated with
diarrhea, HIV, tuberculosis, or malaria. Let's now look at how the burden of
these disorders varies between men and women. Let's start with a global look and
let's start with females, if we might. And here we see when we're looking for 2013
for females of all ages at disability-adjusted life years or DALYs,
depressive disorders constituted almost 3.4% of all DALYs, anxiety disorders
about 1.4%, schizophrenia about 0.7%, and bipolar disorder about 0.5%. Now let's
take a look at men globally. And here we see in fact
quite obviously that globally the burden of these disorders is higher for women
than it is for men. For men that year was about 1.8% for depressive disorders, 0.6%
for anxiety disorders, 0.6% for schizophrenia, and 0.3% for bipolar disorders. Now let's
take a look at the same graphic but examine men in low and middle-income
countries. And here we see that for men in low and middle-income countries in
2013, about 1.7% of the disability-adjusted life years could be
attributed to depressive disorders, about 0.6% to anxiety disorders, about 0.6% to
schizophrenia, and about 0.3% to bipolar disorder. Now when we look at women,
females in low and middle-income countries, we'll see the boxes expand
because the burden of disease and disability-adjusted life years for them
is greater than it is for men. In fact what we see is for women, depressive
disorders were about 3.2% of total DALYs, anxiety about 1.3%,
schizophrenia about 0.7%, and bipolar disorder about 0.5%. Now one reason for
the large burden of these conditions is the substantial number of people who
suffer from mental disorders. Another is that mental disorders often start
at relatively young ages, they can go on for a very long time, they are sometimes
not cured, and they therefore produce large amounts of disability. There is
some mortality associated with these conditions, usually associated with
suicide, but it's exceptionally important to think of them not just in terms of
deaths that might be attributed to them, but really to disability and to the
disability-adjusted life years associated with them. The World Health
Organization carried out projections in 2008 and looked at how the burden of
disease might move between then and 2030, and these projections suggested that
these mental disorders would become increasingly important in all country
income groups, in all regions of the world, and also suggested in fact that
they would become the second leading cause of the burden of disease in low
income countries, the third highest cost in lower-middle income countries, and the
highest cause in upper-middle income countries. The projections also suggested
in fact that unipolar depressive disorders alone by 2030 could
constitute over 8% of the burden of disease in the high-income countries.
When we think about who's affected, it's important to understand that people
throughout the world are affected by the four mental disorders we're
discussing. Often such disorders begin, as I mentioned, in adolescence or during the
young adult years, but they can become later, they can begin later in adulthood
as well. It's also exceptionally important to
understand that many people throughout the world suffer from a mental disorder
that has not been diagnosed. This may be due to a lack of knowledge, it may be due
to a lack of services, and it might also be due to a lack of stigma associated
with such disorders. It's also true, of course, that in many places people lack
the economic means to pay for health services, and this can also prevent them
from seeking such services. Generally we should expect people who are better
educated and of higher socioeconomic standing to be able to seek and navigate
mental health services better than people who have less education and less
income. We should also note that in many settings people seek care for these
disorders from a range of traditional healers, partly because they understand
them, perhaps they're also more accessible, but in some places they seek
them because they also believe that these disorders are spiritual in their
origin. There appear to be both genetic and
non-genetic risk factors for mental disorders. It's clear that women suffer,
as we said, from depression more than men. Early childhood abuse, violence, and
poverty may be important environmental risk factors for depression. However,
there's still very little definitive evidence on the risk factors for
schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or panic disorders. We do know, however, that
there's an important relationship between a range of social determinants
and mental disorders. Poverty, low socioeconomic status, low levels of
education, and low levels of social support increase the risks of these
disorders. If people succumb to them, in fact, they face additional risks of
falling into lower productivity, losing some of their income, and continuing a
downward vicious cycle where they get sick, they can't work, they get work, they
get poor, and they feel less well. There are relatively few data on the cost of
these disorders. In addition, the studies that have been done have been done
largely on high-income countries. Nonetheless, these studies are indicative
of the large direct and indirect costs that all countries face from the very
large burden of these disorders. A study done in the United States, for example,
suggested that mental health disorders cost the U.S. about 2.5% of its national
income every year. Similar studies done in Europe have suggested that these
disorders cost these European countries between 3 and 4 percent of their
national income every year. In addition, when we look at the cost to individuals
and to the groups with which they work, for example, studies done both in the U.S.
and in the United Kingdom have shown that workers suffering from depression
lose 40 to 45 days of work in a year as a result of their illness. Now, some
mental health disorders can be prevented, and some can also be treated
effectively. But unfortunately, despite the enormous importance of mental
disorders, there's often an inadequate understanding of the
importance of mental health, a lack of funds for mental health, a shortage of
personnel who understand mental health, and as I mentioned, an enormous amount of
stigma surrounding mental health disorders. As a result, there's been very
little progress in most low-income countries, and in some middle-income
countries as well, in addressing these problems. Even many high-income countries
fail to pay sufficient attention to or engage in best practice diagnosis and
treatment for people suffering from such disorders. Given the important burden of
disease associated with mental disorders and the low level of development of
mental health services in many countries, the World Health Organization recommends
that countries take a number of at least fundamental steps to lay a
foundation for addressing mental health issues, and these include having a mental
health policy, ensuring there's a unit of government responsible for mental health,
budgeting for mental health programs, including program development, training,
drug procurement, and program monitoring, training primary health care
workers in mental health, and integrating mental health into primary health care
programs. In addition, the World Health Organization has recommended, as a part
of its Mental Health Gap Action Program, that a package of mental health
interventions should be available in each country, tailored to the burden of
disease, tailored to the mental health resources available, the financing
available, and the local context. And we'll see this in the next graphic, where
they've recommended that countries address childhood mental disorders by
preventing such disorders as far as possible, partly through better maternal
nutrition and care, treating children pharmacologically with drugs as
appropriate, and also offering them psychosocial support, addressing
depression by treating with antidepressant medicines and providing
psychosocial support, and addressing schizophrenia and other psychotic
disorders by treating with antipsychotic medicines, and enabling families, family
and community-based psychosocial support as well. Very recently, the Disease
Control Priorities Project for developing countries, generally known as
DCP3, the third edition of this work, has issued a very important volume on mental
health that I would encourage you to look at. And DCP3 has suggested, for
example, a number of platforms, including schools and health care
services, through which countries might seek to better, more
effectively, and efficiently address mental health. DCP3 has suggested, for
example, that in schools, that schools offer life skills training to build
social and emotional competencies for children. And along the lines of this,
DCP3 has also suggested that health care services should offer diagnosis and
management of depression and anxiety, and continuing care for schizophrenia
and bipolar disorder in primary care. Now, related to these efforts, a number of
public health measures can be taken to address some of the risk factors
associated with mental disorders. Addressing maternal depression can
reduce mental health disorders in children. Reducing abuse of women and
children can reduce the burden of mental illness among the abused. Curtailing
bullying of students in schools is also very important. Improving parenting
skills is helpful to the healthy development of children. Appropriate care
and counseling for children and adults affected by war, conflict, and other
complex emergencies can also reduce the risks of mental illness. A significant
amount of the mental health care, traditionally in many low- and
middle-income countries, has been offered in large psychiatric hospitals that have
consumed an overwhelming portion of the country's budget for mental health care
services. However, evidence is growing that for two to four dollars per person
per year, countries can provide effective and efficient services that are
community-based, and that would offer drug therapy combined with
psychosocial support for bipolar disorder, depression, and schizophrenia,
and drug therapy for panic disorder. The goal would be to integrate such support
into routine primary health care services as far as possible, and a very
recent study that has emerged has suggested that the benefit-cost ratio of
investing in these services is exceptionally high. In fact, the ratio for
the treatment of depression and anxiety was between 3.3 to 1 and 5.7 to 1. In
other words, every dollar invested in such services yielded, in some cases,
almost six dollars in return. Given the weak state of health systems in most
low-income and many middle-income countries, and their lack of attention to
mental health, accomplishing these aims will require much greater political
attention to mental disorders. In addition, it's going to require measures
to get additional funds for mental health, and wiser use of them as well by
taking some of the measures that we've discussed. There have been few mental
health success stories in low- and middle-income countries. However, there's
been some important progress in Uganda in creating a community-based approach
to mental health. More recently, there's been some very exciting evidence of
successful outcomes achieved in cost-effective ways through community-
based approaches to mental health in parts of India. In addition, although
Chile is now considered a high-income country, it will be important to follow
the progress that Chile is said to be making as well. It's also essential to
keep in mind, as one seeks to address mental health issues in low- and
middle-income countries, that these countries have scarce financial
resources and a very limited number of mental health professionals. Thus, they
are very unlikely to be able to take an approach based on psychiatrists and
psychiatric nurses, as might be the case, for example, in high-income countries.
Rather, approaches that are scalable, effective, and sustainable will almost
certainly, in low- and many middle-income countries, have to depend for some time
to come on community- and family-based approaches similar to those that are now
being used in India, as I mentioned. Now, putting such an approach in place will
require that countries take a number of steps. They'll need to shift financial
resources from the large mental hospitals to community-based approaches
to diagnosis and treatment. They'll need to train primary care physicians and
other staff working in primary care to treat the mentally ill. They'll need to
circulate to health workers protocols for brief behavioral and cognitive
therapies, so at the lower parts of the system, community health workers and
primary health workers can make effective and efficient efforts in
addressing mental health, and they need to increase the availability of modern
generic drugs. Mental health, as I mentioned, takes an enormous burden on
the health of people in all countries. The burden of mental health conditions
is generally underappreciated, underfinanced, and highly stigmatized, and
yet we know there are a number of measures that can be taken, and we're
learning more and more about them all the time, to address these disorders in
ways that appear to be doable, scalable, and cost-effective. It's almost certainly
time now for a larger range of countries, especially those that are low-income and
lower-middle-income countries, to pay increasing amounts of attention to mental
disorders, their exceptional burden, the toll they take on people, communities, and
society, and begin to take more and more of these measures to address them. In the
next session, we're going to speak about injuries.
