Dr Sohan Dasgupta

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 5, 2026
23rd Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 6-7, 2022
-Dr. Sohan Dasgupta
Partner, Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP; Former Deputy General Counsel, U.S. Department of Homeland Security
AI Generated·May contain errors
Your Excellencies, Your Lordships, Ladyship, Friends,
I thank Congressman Bittinger for his graciousness
and generosity and for the US Congress
for hosting us for the last few days.
Through the lens of fifth generation wireless technology
or 5G, I would like to address the protection
and preservation of the free world's promise.
I'm truly honored to be here with you all today.
5G engendered faster data speeds,
increased device density, increased reliability,
ultra low latency will enable countless industries
such as IT, manufacturing, healthcare and agriculture
to flourish and innovate on an unprecedented level and scale
and it'll be forced and 5G will be forced to engage
with equally daunting risks that we are all going to face.
5G truly is unique from 3G, 4G and the rest of it.
Since 5G will let data travel at the speed of light,
compromising that data would wreak havoc.
It's therefore pretty easy to envision
why the globally competitive technological revolution
brought on by 5G is a matter of national security.
The race among nations and the private sector
is not just for superpower dominance,
it's about protecting the social
and economic prosperity of nations,
organizations and individuals
because economic security is national security
and technological control is economic control
which in turn seriously implicates national security.
Nothing short of the technological
and economic leadership of the free world is at stake.
Since we are in the capital of the free world
near the great dome of the capital of the United States,
it behooves those of us who are dedicated
to the preservation of national security
to stand together in defense
of the liberty of that free world.
If there was ever a time for people
to step up to the mark, this is that time.
Concomitantly, 5G can help spur unprecedented innovation
which may help enable us to protect and enhance
the free world's economic security and prosperity
or it could also destroy civilization worth having.
5G's rollout will elicit 3.8 to 4.6 additional jobs
and a GDP growth of 1.4 to 1.7 trillion dollars
over the next decade.
The largest immediate 5G gains will go
into IT, construction and manufacturing.
Use case for the internet of things
such as connected vehicles, smart cities
and industry 4.0 could fundamentally transform industries
and drive competitive advantage into the next decade
as a recent consultancy report has observed.
5G's collateral impact through the cottage industry
will be even more significant.
Those effects are expected to add 1.1 trillion dollars
to 1.2 trillion dollars just to the US GDP
and generate 3 million to 3.6 million additional jobs
over the next decade or so.
And 5G's higher sensor density will improve
production plans, decrease maintenance costs
and upgrade the supply chain maintenance process.
I shall discuss the implications of 5G
in pertinent US government policies.
Law denotes the priority of societies
and carries its imprimatur and our law
and those tasked with its enforcement
are therefore obligated to be rigorous
about scrutinizing 5G's dramatic potential
to undermine the freedom of thought,
economic potency and security of the free world.
First is the issue of sanctions.
The US government has imposed powerful sanctions
on Huawei and other providers
containing questionable 5G technology.
Those sanctions arguably have crushed Huawei's potency
in the worldwide smartphone market
and are now imperiling its domestic phone business too.
Huawei's smartphone revenue precipitously
has decreased from the 103 billion dollars
that it was in 2020.
Due to the sanctions, Huawei is involved
in something of an existential struggle.
Huawei, along with the surveillance equipment
manufacturer Dawa, the video surveillance firm
Hangzhou Hikvision and the telecoms firm Hytra
are thought to be not so much private industry actors
but rather the Chinese state's instrumentalities.
It's believed by many that Huawei
and some of the other alleged culprits
stole intellectual property from the West,
conducted economic and technological espionage
on Beijing's behalf,
provided critical telecommunications equipment
to rogue states and eviscerated
the Western telecommunications industry
by, according to some observers,
undercutting prices by as much as a third.
And the Chinese government subsidizes Huawei significantly.
That's not all.
5G's impact on artificial intelligence
and machine learning will also be profound.
Large AI models reposed in the cloud
could process data from electronic devices
and through what's called edge clouds,
5G devices directly and immediately
could connect with one another.
Some pioneers are deploying AI and machine learning
linked to 5G for their computing power.
The prevailing view, in the words of one commentator,
is that AI systems often can exceed
human performance wildly.
For some of our most advanced biological capabilities,
such as vision, hearing, language translation,
driving, and complex decision making.
Tesla, Amazon, various news organizations,
financial institutions, and large tech companies,
what's often called big tech,
produce AI services used by hundreds of millions
of users globally and daily.
And some estimate that by the year 2030,
AI is going to deliver global economic gains
in the neighborhood of 13 to 16 trillion dollars.
The global power dynamic among nations
and between corporations and their governments
could shift veritably.
And almost all of these will use 5G.
Two additional US government impositions
might be illuminating.
First, the Department of Commerce's
Bureau of Industry and Security
has been implementing a sweeping 42 nation
and European Union involving multilateral agreement.
Its main goal, principal objective,
is to coordinate a 5G skeptical export controls
on a list of equipment, software, and technology
that could be used in chemical
or biological weapon programs.
Second, the President issued Executive Order 14032,
preventing US persons from purchasing and selling
publicly traded securities in 59 Chinese military
industrial complex companies, CMICs.
This Executive Order covers Huawei, China Mobile,
Nanjing Panda, and other tech providers.
The economic, technological, and geopolitical implications
for 5G through these veins are unmistakable.
Next, we delve into another policy.
It's called the Secure Equipment Act of 2021,
which enlists the Federal Communications Commission,
a federal agency in this country, or FCC,
its assistance in precluding Chinese telecommunications
and security camera companies
from gaining even more of a foothold.
This law, the SCA, requires the FCC to clarify
that it will no longer review or approve
any authorization for equipment on the FCC's covered list.
That list includes Chinese telecommunications
and security camera companies that the US government
believes are national security risks.
What are they?
Huawei, ZTE, Hytra, Hangzhou, Dahua,
and these are just some of the companies
on that covered list.
The FCC may also revoke authorizations previously granted
and do it retroactively, therefore,
to equipment on the covered list.
Huawei's longtime status as the company
with the largest global market share of telecoms equipment
and thus its worldwide dominance,
and the lack of a viable and feasible alternative
in the free world generated some of these concerns.
Recently, the FCC has prohibited the approvals
of new Huawei and ZTE equipment on the ground
that they present an unacceptable risk
to the national security of this country.
Further, the FCC has also precluded the sale
or import of new equipment created by Hytra,
Dahua, and Hangzhou Hikvision.
Undoubtedly, the common refrain is that we need
a domestic industrial base for manufacturing
in the free world, be that in the form
of domestic production or nearshoring.
This is really, as has been alluded to,
about ramping up the supply chain
through a whole free world approach.
In the middle of 2020, the FCC issued orders
designating Huawei and ZTE as national security threats
and thus prohibited the use of universal service funds
to purchase telecommunications equipment
from those companies and from other high-risk suppliers.
Now, we come to what's called CFIA's Committee
on Foreign Investment in the United States,
which is a potent mechanism of the U.S. government
to regulate investment inflow into the nation.
And CFIA's is an interagency working group
of the U.S. government that decides on a wide variety
of proposed transactions involving foreign entities
that wish to acquire parts of U.S. businesses
and the level of national security risks that they pose.
Following the U.S. government's 5G Clean Path
or Clean Network Initiative, Japan, Australia,
New Zealand, Taiwan also prohibited Huawei equipment
in their respective mobile networks.
And Huawei-driven transactions have been blocked
by CFIA's in 2008 and 2010, respectively.
And CFIA's retains the ability to reopen
and preclude erstwhile clear transactions as well.
CFIA's bailiwick has expanded dramatically
in the last five years or so.
In fact, prior to the enactment
of the Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act,
of 2018, FIRMA, its jurisdiction had been limited
to transactions that could result
in foreign control of any U.S. business.
Now, FIRMA and these regulations have conferred
additional authority on CFIA's to review
and participate in blocking, if need be,
two new categories of transactions.
Certain non-controlling investments in U.S. businesses
involved with critical technology,
critical infrastructure, sensitive data,
and certain real estate transactions.
From 2016 to 2018, all three transactions
that the president blocked were Chinese investments
in the semiconductor sector.
And in 2018, President Trump famously blocked
the U.S. semiconductor manufacturing leader Qualcomm's
hostile takeover by Broadcom,
which was a Singapore-based company.
It was not a Chinese company.
A Chinese company was not the acquirer here,
yet CFIA's articulated that this Qualcomm takeover
could well perpetuate Huawei's 5G-related dominance
in the global telecommunications market.
And that hegemony, it was feared,
would harm the U.S. government's national security agency's
access to high-quality and affordable semiconductors.
CFIA, in recent years, has been absolutely vigilant
about transactions potentially enabling Chinese companies
to access and exploit individual data,
the breaches concerning data privacy,
and increased likelihood of the continuing breaches
have been a profound issue.
And CFIA, which has the power to impose mitigation measures
as conditions for approval,
it imposed the mitigation measure on Genworth
that the latter would use a U.S.-based third-party service
provider to manage and protect the personal data
of the U.S. policyholders of that company.
And it's finally very important to end with
the issue of Team Telecom.
Team Telecom, rather like CFIA's,
is a U.S. interagency committee reviewing
foreign investments from a national security standpoint.
It zooms in, very critically, on Chinese threats
in the cyber, consisting of the Department of Defense,
Pentagon, Department of Homeland Security,
and the Department of Justice.
Team Telecom reviews telecommunications
license applications for foreign-owned companies
trying to operate in the U.S.
or connect the U.S. to foreign communications networks.
Its modus operandi was to consult
with certain national security agencies
about telecommunications license applications.
And broadly speaking,
the Federal Communications Commission's remit
allows it to block common carriers from building new
or extending pre-existing telecommunications networks
unless public convenience and necessity so require.
Another legal provision entitles the FCC
to maintain the rights and interests of the United States.
Over time, much like CFIA's, Team Telecom's role,
and Team Telecom is, of course,
composed of other national security agencies,
but the FCC, in granting or denying licenses,
has the right and often the tendency
to defer to Team Telecom's recommendations.
Team Telecom has been very unwaveringly focused on China.
It has been increasingly aggressive
in its retroactive targeting of previously-granted licenses,
as an observer has noted, when China is concerned,
and on a bipartisan basis, the FCC has been part-dependent
on this Team Telecom course of action.
Team Telecom's concerns have consisted of hacking,
law enforcement disruptions,
surveillance, economic espionage,
and perhaps most keenly, China's access to Americans'
sensitive and critical financial health and other data.
Now, we have, in closing, I should mention
that we have addressed many specific themes today,
but the universal ones are deeply enduring.
And what are they?
They are that the human spirit's quest
to discover the higher purpose and meaning
will not be satisfied by engineering
and modern conveniences alone.
There's a deontological meaning
driving this engine of change,
and that meaning sets the free world apart
from the world that does not look at law and opportunity
as opening doors, but rather as closing them.
Putting a finer point on it,
the rapid and massive technological changes we face
and the governmental responses to them
concern the freedom of thought and economic potency.
We will not retain freedom if the means of our communication
or the ideas they carry are suppressed,
and the same will be true if the range of acceptable ideas
is skewed or distorted in any way.
We will lose the freedom of thought
if the price of communication is orthodoxy
and coerced uniformity and conformity.
Suppression or distortion of ideas
inflicts a double disadvantage.
Artificially stopping or minimizing the speaker
from expressing that speaker's ideas
and precluding the listener from being exposed
to those ideas and concepts.
Technological sabotage and economic espionage
can demolish a free society to the point
that it may never fully recover.
So I submit to you that these issues are profoundly important
and I thank you all for your extended attention
to this topic.
Thank you.
