2026 Regular Session - Day 40 - HB 534 Comments | Rep. TJ Roberts

Kentucky House GOP
24 followers
Mar 5, 2026
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Like a recurring bad dream, Kentucky's judicial canons keep getting
struck down. First, Kentucky tried to limit judicial candidates from responding to questionnaires in
Family Trust Foundation of Kentucky v. Wolnicek. Then, Kentucky tried to prohibit judicial candidates
from identifying their political party in Kerry v. Wolnicek. Now, Kentucky wants to
prevent judicial candidates from campaigning as a member of a political party or identifying
their political party affiliation. When Kentucky writes these judicial canons,
it must forget Thomas Jefferson's warning that, quote, a democracy cannot be both ignorant and
free. More importantly, the canons violate the First Amendment. Those are not my words.
That is the word of federal judge Amulthapar on the Sixth Circuit in the case of Winter v.
Wolnicek. The federal courts have consistently held since 2002 a very basic principle that
judicial candidates have free speech. And yet, right here in Kentucky, seemingly every election
cycle, judicial candidates engage in speech that is clearly protected under our precedent.
And it gets struck down in federal court every single time. Mr. Speaker, I want to respond to
the point about nonpartisan elections because this statute is clear. Judicial elections remain
nonpartisan. There is no R or D or I or L or G next to the name of any candidate for judicial office.
This section of this act simply allows judicial candidates to do what the First Amendment,
the United States Supreme Court, and the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals that is binding on
Kentucky has repeatedly stated they are allowed to do. It puts an end to this persistent practice
to ensure that candidates are able to inform the voters of where they stand on these crucial
issues so we can have further transparency. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
