Quit social media | Dr. Cal Newport | TEDxTyson

Science Stops
9 followers
All right, so you probably don't realize
that right now you're actually looking
at something quite rare,
because I am a millennial computer scientist book author,
standing on a TED stage,
and yet I've never had a social media account.
How this happened was actually somewhat random.
Social media first came onto my radar
when I was at college, my sophomore year of college.
This is when Facebook arrived at our campus.
And at the time, which was right after the first dot com bus,
I had had a dorm room business,
I had had to shut it down in the bus.
And then suddenly this other kid from Harvard named Mark
had this product called Facebook,
and people were getting excited about it.
So it's sort of a fit of somewhat immature
professional jealousy, I said, I'm not gonna use this thing.
So as I go along my life, I look up not long later,
and I see that everyone I know
is really hooked on this thing.
And from the clarity you can get
when you have some objectivity, some perspective on it,
I realized this seems a little bit dangerous,
so I never signed up.
Never had a social media account.
So I'm here for two reasons.
I wanna deliver two messages.
The first message I wanna deliver
is that even though I've never had a social media account,
I'm okay, you don't have to worry.
It turns out I still have friends,
I still know what's going on in the world.
As a computer scientist, I still collaborate
with people all around the world,
I'm still regularly exposed serendipitously
to interesting ideas, and I rarely describe myself
as lacking in entertainment opportunities.
I've been okay, but I'd go even farther,
and say not only am I okay without social media,
but I think I'm actually better off.
I think I'm happier, I think I find more sustainability
in my life, and I think I've been more successful
professionally because I don't use social media.
So my second goal here on stage
is to try to convince more of you to believe the same thing.
To see if I could actually convince more of you
that you too would be better off if you quit social media.
So if the theme of this TEDx event is future tense,
in other words, this would be my vision of the future,
would be one in which fewer people actually use social media.
Okay, so that's a big claim.
I think I need to back it up some.
I thought what I would do is take
the three most common objections I hear
when I suggest to people that they quit social media.
And then for each of these objections,
I'll try to defuse the hype and see
if I can actually push in some more reality.
This is the first most common objection I hear.
That's not a hermit, that's actually a hipster web developer
down from 8th Street, I'm not sure.
Hipster or hermit, sometimes it's hard to tell.
So this first objection goes as follows.
Cal, social media is one of the fundamental technologies
of the 21st century.
To reject social media would be an act of extreme bloodism.
It would be like riding to work in a horse
or using a rotary phone.
I can't take such a big stance in my life.
So my reaction to that objection is,
I think that is nonsense.
Social media is not a fundamental technology.
It leverages some fundamental technologies,
but it's better understood as this,
which is to say it's a source of entertainment,
entertainment product.
The way the technologist Jaron Lanier puts it
is that these companies offer you shiny treats
in exchange for minutes of your attention
and bytes of your personal data,
which can then be packaged up and sold.
So to say that you don't use social media
should not be a large social stance.
It's just rejecting one form of entertainment for others.
It should be no more controversial than saying,
I don't like newspapers, I like to get my news from magazines
or I prefer to watch cable series
as opposed to network television series.
It's not a major political or social stance
to say you don't use this product.
My use of the slot machine image up here
also is not accidental
because if you look a little bit closer
at these technologies,
it's not just that they're a source of entertainment,
but they're actually a somewhat unsavory source.
We now know that many of the major social media companies
hire individuals called attention engineers
who borrow principles from Las Vegas Casino Gambling
among other places
to try to make these products as addictive as possible.
That is the desired use case of these products
is that you use it in an addictive fashion
because that maximizes the profit that can be extracted
from your attention and data.
So it's not a fundamental technology,
it's just a source of entertainment,
one among many and it's somewhat unsavory
if you look a little bit closer.
So here's the second common objection I hear
when I suggest that people quit social media.
The objection goes as follows.
Cal, I can't quit social media
because it is vital to my success
in the 21st century economy.
If I do not have a well-cultivated social media brand,
people won't know who I am,
people won't be able to find me,
opportunities won't come my way,
and I will effectively disappear from the economy.
So again, my reaction is once again,
this objection also is nonsense.
So I recently published this book
that draws on multiple different strands of evidence
to make the point that in a competitive 21st century economy
what the market values is the ability to produce things
that are rare and are valuable.
To produce something that's rare and is valuable,
the market will value that.
What the market dismisses for the most part
are activities that are easy to replicate
and produce a small amount of value.
Well, social media use is the epitome
of an easy-to-replicate activity
that does not directly produce a lot of value.
It's something that any 16-year-old with a smartphone can do.
By definition, the market is not gonna give a lot of value
to those behaviors.
It's instead gonna reward
the deep, concentrated work required
to build real skills and to apply those skills
to produce things like a craftsman
that are rare and that are valuable.
To put it another way,
if you can write an elegant algorithm,
if you can write a legal brief that can change a case,
if you can write 1,000 words of prose
that's gonna fixate a reader right to the end.
If you can look at a sea of ambiguous data
and apply statistics and pull out insights
that could transform a whole business strategy,
if you can do these type of activities
that require deep work to produce outcomes
that are rare and valuable, people will find you.
You will be able to write your own ticket.
You will be able to build the foundation
of a very meaningful and successful professional life
regardless of how many Instagram followers you have.
So this is the third common objection I hear
when I suggest to people that they quit social media.
In some sense, I think it might be one of the most important.
This objection goes as follows.
Cal, maybe I agree with you.
Maybe you're right.
It's not a fundamental technology.
Maybe using social media is not at the core
of my professional success, but you know what?
It's harmless.
I have some fun on it.
Weird Twitter is funny.
I don't even really use it that much.
I'm a first adopter.
It's just kind of interesting to try it out.
And maybe I might miss out on something if I don't use it.
What's the harm?
So again, I look back and I say,
this objection also is nonsense.
In this case, what it misses
is what I think is a very important reality
that we need to talk about more frankly,
which is that social media brings with it
multiple well-documented significant harms.
And we actually have to confront these harms head on
when trying to make decisions
about whether or not we embrace this technology
and let it into our lives.
So one of these harms that we know this technology brings
has to do with your professional success.
So I just argued before
that the ability to focus intensely
to produce things that are rare and valuable,
to hone skills that the marketplace values,
that this is what's gonna matter in our economy.
But right before that,
I argued that social media tools
are designed to be addictive.
The actual design desired use case of these tools
is that you fragment your attention
as much as possible throughout your waking hours.
That's how these tools are designed to use.
Well, we have a growing amount of research
which tells us that if you spend large portions of your day
in a state of fragmented attention,
the large portions of your day
where you're constantly breaking up your attention,
take a quick glance, do a just check
and just quickly look at Instagram,
that this can permanently reduce
your capacity for concentration.
In other words, you could permanently
reduce your capacity to do exactly
the type of deep effort that we're finding
to be more and more necessary
in an increasingly competitive economy.
So social media use is not harmless.
It can actually have a significant negative impact
on your ability to thrive in the economy.
I am especially worried about this
when we look at the younger generation coming up,
which is the most saturated in this technology.
If you lose your ability to sustain concentration,
you're gonna become less and less relevant to this economy.
There's also psychological harms
that are well-documented that social media brings
that we do need to address.
So we know from the research literature
that the more you use social media,
the more likely you are to feel lonely or isolated.
We know that the constant exposure
to your friends' carefully curated
positive portrayals of their life
can leave you to feel inadequate
and can increase rates of depression.
And something I think we're gonna be hearing more about
in the near future is that there's a fundamental mismatch
between the way our brains are wired
and this behavior of exposing yourself to stimuli
with intermittent rewards
throughout all of your waking hours.
But it's one thing to spend a couple hours
at the slot machine in Las Vegas,
but if you bring a slot machine with you
and you pull that handle all day long
from when you wake up to when you go to bed,
we're not wired from it.
It short circuits the brain
and we're starting to find
that it has actual cognitive consequences,
one of them being the sort of pervasive background
hum of anxiety.
Now the canary in the coal mine for this issue
is actually college campuses.
If you talk to mental health experts on college campuses,
they'll tell you, along with the rise
of ubiquitous smartphone use and social media use
among the students on the campus
came an explosion of anxiety-related disorders
on those campuses.
So that's the canary in the coal mine.
This type of behavior is a mismatch for our brain wiring
to make you feel miserable.
So there's real cost to social media use,
which means when you're trying to decide
should I use this or not,
saying it's harmless is not enough.
You actually have to identify
a significantly positive clear benefit
that can outweigh these potential
completely non-trivial harms.
So people often ask, okay,
but what is life like without social media?
That can actually be a little bit scary to think about.
What I found from people I know
who've gone through this process,
there can be a few weeks that are difficult.
It actually is like a true detox process.
The first two weeks can be uncomfortable.
You feel a little bit anxious,
you feel like you're missing a limb.
But after that, things settle down
and actually life after social media can be quite positive.
There's two things I can report back to you
from the world of no social media use.
First, it can be quite productive, quite productive.
So I'm a professor at a research institution.
I've written five books.
I rarely work past 5 p.m. on the weekends.
Part of the way I'm able to pull that off
is because it turns out
if you treat your attention with respect,
you don't fragment it.
You allow it to stay whole.
You preserve your ability to concentrate.
When it comes time to work,
you can actually do one thing after another
and do it with intensity.
And intensity can be traded for time.
It's surprising how much you can get done in an eight-hour day
if you're able to give each thing
intense concentration after another.
Something else I can report back
from life without social media
is that outside of work, things can be quite peaceful.
So I often joke I'd be very comfortable
being a 1930s farmer
because if you look at my leisure time,
I read newspaper while the sun comes up.
I listen to baseball on the radio.
I, honest to God, sit in a leather chair
and read hardcover books at night
after my kids go to bed.
It sounds old-fashioned,
but I'll tell you, they were onto something back then.
It's actually a restorative, very peaceful way
to actually spend your time out of work.
You don't have the constant hum of stimuli
and the background hum of anxiety
that comes along with that.
The life without social media is really not so bad.
So I pulled together these threads
and you see my full argument
for why I think not everyone,
but certainly much more people than right now,
use social media.
Much more people should not be using social media.
And that's because we can first, to summarize,
discard with the main concerns
that somehow it's a fundamental technology
you have to use, nonsense.
It's a slot machine in your phone.
We can discard with this notion
that you're not gonna get a job
if you don't use social media, nonsense.
Anything a 16-year-old with a smartphone can do
is not gonna be what the market rewards.
And then I emphasize the point
that there's real harms with it.
So it's not just harmless.
You really would have to have a significant benefit
before you would actually say this trade-off is worth it.
And finally, I noted that life without social media,
there's real positives associated with it.
So I'm hoping that when many of you
actually go through this same calculus,
you'll at least consider the perspective
I'm making right now,
which is many more people would be much better off
if they didn't use this technology.
Of course, some of you might disagree.
Some of you might have scathing,
but accurate critiques of me and my points.
And of course, I welcome all negative feedback.
I just ask that you direct your comments towards Twitter.
Thank you.
