The Ayatollah Khameini is dead in a missile strike. The U.S. and Israel are effectively at war with Iran. Trump and his administration, hawkish on Iran, pursue peace through force with Operation Epic Fury. This week, the guys sit down to hash out the military and trade implications in the Mideast region, and the quagmire of political considerations back home—including presidential powers and an impotent Congress at the forefront. Europe’s response, meanwhile, betrays its continued decline and unreliability. #claremontinstitute#iranisraelwar#iranattack#iranisraelconflict#middleeast#warinmiddleeast
------
Chapters 00:00 Introductions 00:24 US-Israel Missile Strike on Iran: Perspectives 16:38 Political Considerations of Iran War 30:12 The US's Reality as Global Hegemon 41:52 Closing Remarks
Hello and welcome once again to The Roundtable, your weekly publisher's and editor's podcast
here at the American Mind. I'm your host, Spencer Clavin, Associate Editor of the Claremont Review
of Books, a special editor of the American Mind, and now that the Ayatollah Khomeini is dead,
the last living human being who enjoys the work of Umberto Eco. So that may have me on a watchlist,
who's to say? In any case, we usually kick off with a little bit of banter these days,
a little chit-chat, but I think we're just going to jump right into it because what's the point
in ignoring what's on everybody's mind? We are at war with Iran. Operation Epic Fury has commenced.
I woke up on Saturday morning. I was running a conference and I kind of rolled up to the table
at about 9 a.m. Central Time and thought, okay, time to have a lovely conversation about
religious liberty and turn to my co-panelist and she's like, well, we're bombing Iran. I said,
okay, that seems like a significant event. This follows on from previous strikes,
sort of one-off strikes that were not part of a sustained operation. This is something much
broader. The New York Times calls it a vast military bombardment in conjunction with Israel.
That's a fairly accurate description. The Ayatollah Khomeini, as I mentioned, has been
killed. There have been US deaths, six as of the last counting, but I don't know if that's gone up
and a number of Iranian civilians as well. This has triggered knock-on conflicts. Israel is
currently fighting Hezbollah. There are obviously any number of cascading effects of this and we'll
probably be living with them, if not with this operation for some time to come. We have a number
of different angles that we want to approach this from. I think the first one I'm going to put on
the table is the much discussed Don Roe doctrine. We've done a fair bit of commentary on this
podcast and I would say interesting commentary, interesting discussion on this podcast about
what exactly Donald Trump's foreign policy is. A lot of his supporters associate Trump and their
support for Trump with the phrase, no new wars. This in some sense has troubled or led to questions
about that. On the other hand, there are those who point out that Trump himself is not specifically
the no new wars president so much as the prudence president. I think we have done a bit of
discussion about what that looks like and what it looks like to have a significant isolationist
support for a non-isolationist president. Matthew Schmitz at Compact wrote a little piece that was
quite effective laying out that Trump's hawkishness on Iran is longstanding, as is his
bullishness, his friendliness toward Israel. Put those two things in combination and this starts
to look quite predictable in some ways. It's also, of course, the Netanyahu administration is I think
really pushing for this, has been gunning to convince Trump and his closest advisors to
act on the Iranian threat. We shouldn't forget, of course, the history of nuclear development that
is behind all of this, especially the Obama deal and Trump's longstanding distaste for it.
With that, I'd like to get your guys' first thoughts just starting off here on how this
fits. Do you think this fits into Trump's overall picture? Is this a betrayal of all that has gone
before? Is it something in between, a little bit haphazard, a little bit planned? What do you guys
think? Well, something was planned. It didn't happen by accident. You're right about that.
We'd had the largest naval fleet presence in the Persian Gulf and in the eastern
Mediterranean in a long time. Obviously, Trump was prepping for something.
I just want to start by saying I want to urge everyone to resist the temptation to live
with their feelings about this conflict exclusively on X or on the ecosystem that is on X.
Whatever do you mean, right? Why would you say such a thing?
Maybe this has all happened before with similar events, but for whatever reason,
this one seemed to be, maybe because of its nature and its scale as opposed to Venezuela,
but it seems to me to be, it will be the new norm. It seems to be the most aggressive and
accelerated version of the age-old truth. I guess it's the digital age is analog to,
if it bleeds, it bleeds, which is if it's globally significant and America is involved
and added these days element and Trump is somehow wrapped up in it, it's the most awesome
opportunity for X engagement you've ever seen in your life. It encourages intemperate,
grandiose, sweeping, often unorthodox for the sake of unorthodox. My favorite version of the
unorthodox engagement for me was somebody saying, I'll tell you what this is really about.
You know what the IRGC has been doing? They've been mining Bitcoin for years. Trump loves Bitcoin.
His sons are invested in it. What do you do to make your sons rich? You bomb the grid in Iran
to stop their Bitcoin mining. That was, I think it's that one commentator on it said this. He
said amongst all the retarded takes I've seen, this is surely the most retarded. Yeah. I was
sort of writing notes. Did you mention Matthew Schmitz's piece on that in the opening? Yeah.
Forgive me. This is how much we prep for these folks. Sorry. Scratch that.
It's not whether Trump planned his operation in Iran. The question is whether we planned this
podcast before turning on the record button. Actually, I should correct myself. I am
monitoring the situation in real time and taking notes. He's on Twitter. While he's telling us
not to read it. Actually, my phone is in my office, which is across the way. Corrected.
It recalls to me, I won't give many details about it because the people involved were all doing it
not in secret, but just none of it was supposed to be public. We held a briefing during the
transition at our offices in Washington, DC. Mike Anton was presenting as well as some others.
Mike was involved in the transition and was possibly going to take a position
in national security or state department or whatever, which he ended up doing,
going to the state department. But Mike wanted to tell, especially the young MAGA folks,
look, you all should go into this with open eyes about what you're getting into.
And he was not admonishing Trump by implication. He just wanted to convey to them,
you must remember that some of you are much more restrictionist on foreign policy.
But remember, Trump has always been an Iran hawk. He hates the mullahs. They tried to kill him at
least once. He doesn't like their weird regime. They're a standing threat in the region. He has
said they can never have the bomb. And he's an ally and a friend of Israel. And that was his
policy in the first administration. And it will be in the second. Now, if you disagree with all
that, that's fine. You can still go in the administration, but you have to put a lid on
all that and do your job. So just remember that. Mike Anton, Nostradamus. Mike is prophetic. This
one was not that hard, but proven definitely ultimately correct. Now I will defend it as a
great act of statesmanship. I'll jump on the Iran hawk bandwagon. The youngsters, especially
maybe half the millennials, if not a majority of them, and especially the Zoomers, although the
Zoomers are complicated because they're pretty pro-Trump, especially men that table that,
have drawn this conclusion, which Spencer alluded to, that Trump was going to be the
war presidency. And so they're kind of confused now. Maduro raid, Iran, what's going on here?
Now the more brain virus ogled of them say, it's just the Jews controlling everything.
But they should recall that, I mean, long, sorry, I'm going on many tangents, but they're good. I
promise. Long ago, a great- The weave, Ryan, the weave.
It's the weave. That's right. Yeah. I'm the president of the country and the president
of our think tank. Yeah. Long ago in a presidential power class in grad school,
18 years ago or whenever it was, the great Mike Ullman, who worked for us for many years and
died a little too young, sadly, a few years back, was teaching a class on presidential power and
the institutional presidency. And he wanted to, as a man who is not only an academic, but had been,
had served in the Reagan administration and served on the George H.W. Bush transition,
he wanted to remind the class, which is a bunch of academics who, aspiring academics in their
mid-20s for the most part, that all presidents have these grand theories about how they ought
to conduct the office, failures of their predecessor, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
And then they take the oath of office and it's day one and they sit behind the resolute desk
and they get briefed about all sorts of scary shits. And that energy secrecy and dispatch
part of the presidency that the Federalist Papers described, and in defending it as being a unitary
presidency that is residing in one office and having these great powers in foreign policy,
they all are immediately impressed with that at that desk. Even more so, I mean, the founding was
one thing, but post-World War II, post-Cold War, in this kind of hyper-power status, the largest
military on the earth, the most global commitments from economic to security to anything else,
the weight of that bears down on anyone and it will sit on their shoulders. The weight of the
responsibility of that will impress anyone, even Donald Trump, as I'm sure it did in his first
term. And then even more so in his second term, as he learned all the pitfalls, domestic and foreign
that confront a presidency. So from Trump's perspective, I think it's pretty simple.
Yes, Israel wanted to do something as a follow-up to not only the B-2 bomber strikes of Isfahan and
the other nuclear installations, which Israel was very happy to have the US do because only the US
could do it. But very much in the front of Israel's mind was their security risks in the
region with a country that was, as I'm sure Israel knew because we coordinate quite closely with them
on intelligence matters, the Whitkoff, Kushner, and before them, others, negotiations with the
Iranians over the nuclear stuff, even after the bombings, which were intense and the negotiations
were intense, were not going well. It was clear Iran was saying, we have an absolute right to
enrich uranium. We've got 400 tons or whatever of it, don't quote me, at 60% enriched. Our
negotiations are going to start with, we got to keep that stuff. And from Israel's perspective,
a country that is saying that to the United States after just seeing fairly recently a
demonstration of their technical offensive capabilities and stealth capabilities in
bombing and nuclear sites, a place that was building up, and this was part of the briefing
delivered by the chairman of the Joint Chiefs, Kane, and then echoed by Marco Rubio in an
excellent Q&A with reporters last night, which was, you have to look at Iran's conventional force.
They've got 80,000 something of these unmanned drones. They have all sorts of ICBM capability
and less long range missile capability. Their conventional force is really the shield
behind which their nuclear deterrent would hide and behind which they could continue to
build up their nuclear deterrent. So that's all the backdrop for Trump and his calculation process.
Now, it appears from reporting that Israel and, or the US, or both working together,
got intel that the leadership would be, a good portion of leadership would be in one place.
Iran was rebuilding after the strikes and after Israel had taken out most of their anti-air
defenses in recent months in the lead up to the strikes on the nuclear sites.
But they were quickly trying to reconstitute their ability to, while stalling us all in
negotiations, reconstitute their ability to build a nuclear weapon. And they have said of Israel,
the good thing about Israel, it's small. It's a one bomb country, by which they mean a nuclear
bomb. So that's Israel's perspective. So Israel, I think, was keen on doing
something while they had the chance. And the US was positioned to support that,
but that's not the only reason we were there. We were there also to support
our strategic interests. And I think to, among other things, demonstrate to the Iranians that
these negotiations were important and high stakes with some carrier groups near and positioned to
defend our allies and also to maybe do something more, much more kinetic about Iran.
So Israel says, the timing's good. We should go now. And they may have even said, we're going to
go regardless. But Rubio has sort of hinted at that and sort of so has Heyseth. And Trump decided,
okay, well, this is our best opportunity. If we were to wait, and this was one of Rubio's
points last night, if we were to wait for Israel to do something, they were going to
retaliate against us anyway. We had a bunch of forces in the region. And so this was Trump's
energy, secrecy, and dispatch determination and calculation. And he went ahead.
Now, how is it a great act of statesmanship? Possibly, because the devil's always in the
details. Well, I would think that Trump, knowing all of these possible cascading follow-on effects,
which Spencer mentioned, I'll just mention a few. The Shia majority is rioting in Bahrain.
The U.S. embassy in Riyadh yesterday or this morning told everyone in Dhahran to shelter
in place. Missiles might be incoming. The Dubai airport has closed. I mean,
the major international business hub in the region. Israel's airports are closed.
Ambassador Huckabee, U.S. Ambassador to Israel Huckabee, has told Americans trying to get out
of Israel and back to America on business or whatever that the Israeli Tel Aviv airport,
et cetera, it's going to be closed indefinitely. And so if they want to get out, the best thing
to do is take a shuttle to Egypt and try to fly out of Egypt. Insurers have told all the shipping
in the region to stay in port. So all of this has the potential to be quite damaging to Trump
going into the midterms. And you'd be a fool or just unacquainted with the workings and rhythms
of a presidential administration to think that Trump had not been told that all of this could
happen. So he's putting the midterms even more at risk in a way. I mean, this could go,
for a technical phrase, this could all go pretty up. The people who are critical of the possibility
of this being going badly are correct. Of course, war is hell and the unanticipated consequences of
war are unpredictable. Not infinitely unpredictable, but they can be wildly unpredictable.
So it's a huge risk. It's a huge gamble, the largest gamble of Trump's presidency.
But I don't think he would have taken it. He's not going to take it because Netanyahu and AIPAC
told him that he had to. It's just ridiculous. So he made the calculation that this was on balance,
the best thing to do for the United States. And I would encourage all of our, even our more sober
friends who are quick, everyone can't resist, our armchair critics immediately of this three days in
should take a beat and try to get the best reporting on what's going on. Be clear eyed
about the risks, but also clear eyed about what the president who's the commander in chief and
sworn to uphold the constitution and protect the United States decided was in the best interest
of the United States. Now we all, we, of course, as well, we'll reserve the right to criticize
the extent to which this was slapdash, which is the implication of a lot of our Trump's critics
on the left and the right and the John Bolton and others who are opining about this now daily.
But I'm not saying trust the plan because that's always been silly, a silly defense of anything
Trump does. But he made the high stakes calculated risk that this was worth doing now
for a variety of reasons. And I will end by just saying, few regimes in the world deserve this more
than the ruling class in Iran, which of course we should separate from a substantial portion
of their populace, which have stood opposed to that regime for some time. They have plenty of
American blood on their hands. They're a leading worldwide exporter of terrorism and mayhem.
They are, I don't know if they're an immediate threat to the United States. It doesn't
seem that their ICBM capability is, although they're, well, I will just tell everyone to
read this old document, now ancient document, which our former president, that is former
Brian Kennedy had a hand in the EMP commission's report on the threat of an EMP. And part of that
was the terrifying scenario of Iran having a new and launching it from a ship that they then scuttle
and detonating it over the middle of the United States at, I forget what the ideal altitude is
for an EMP that could wipe out a substantial portion of the electronics of the United States.
It might be 25 kilometers, but again, don't quote me. So I think people downplaying the threat of
Iran to the United States are incorrect or half informed or don't remember some of this stuff.
For Israel, it is and remains an existential question and we remain a close ally of Israel.
So it's a lot messier than people want to portray on Twitter. And finally, we should all pray for
the success of this mission and the safety of American troops and any other folks in the region
in harm's way who are the victims of decades of Iranian belligerence and international pariah
status and murderous terrorism. Amen. I have to say, I know we're contractually obligated to give
each other on this show and besides that we enjoy it. But Ryan, no joke. That was one of your finest
moments on this podcast, I have to say. Well said and co-signed. Mike, what do you think?
Yeah. I mean, obviously a lot going on, lots of thoughts. What Ryan said about X and the
instant kind of microwave kind of digital society that we've created, especially on the right.
I think in instances like this where we're talking about nuclear countries, huge population centers,
devastation, this is really some serious stuff. And I think some of the indicators and some of
just the tendencies on X and other social forms of media can tend to downplay that,
can tend to play up hot takes and so forth. So I think kind of some sitting back, some sober
analysis, not always being the one to have the right take, the quickest take off the line,
I think is really, really valuable, especially in war. And I just want to reiterate too,
and just read a little bit of that Schmitz piece that you both referenced that was that compact,
just talking about Trump and what he's kind of historically, his stance has been on Iran.
Because I think you have, there is something to this. I think you do have some of the,
I mean, I went back and looked in 2016, 2020, 2024 on foreign policy. And there is a reason why
I think people say, oh, Trump said no war. Well, he did say that a lot. I mean, J.D. Vance wrote
an op-ed, I think in the Wall Street Journal in 2023, that talked about no war. If you read that,
it wasn't quite the Thomas Massey libertarian line though on that. I mean, it was a little
bit more nuanced. I mean, there was certainly, I think he left open the door at a crack for
some prudential calculations on that. But in any event, so I think you see political rhetoric on
one side, campaign rhetoric. And then too, I think a larger horizon of what Trump has been
saying for decades and decades and decades on Iran. In 1987, there was a speech in New Hampshire,
he suggested, in the words of New York Times, the United States should attack Iran and see some of
its oil fields in retaliation for Iran's bullying of America, 1987. In 1988, Trump told The Guardian,
I'd be harsh on Iran. They've been beating us psychologically, making us look like a bunch of
fools. One bullet shot, one of our men are ships, and I do a number on Karg Island,
that's an Iranian oil hub. 2011, Trump told Bill O'Reilly, I wouldn't have let them have a nuke,
referring to Iran. He then dismissed Barack Obama as a weak president, kisses everybody's ass.
So this is something that he's obviously held onto for a very, very long time.
The idea that the people somehow elected some absolute isolationist, that's not at all what
they were electing. This is just pretty obvious. We'll probably touch on this later. The question
of J.D. Vance going forward, I think is a very interesting one. The New York Times has reported
that he talked about, hey, if we're going to go in there, we go big. We got to win.
Losing is something he absolutely hates. People talk about what kind of foreign policy does he
have, neocon or isolationist or whatever. I think it's winning, whatever that means.
You look at what he's done already, even in this term, which is an interesting contrast to his
first term in a way. I think the New York Times reported that I think he's gotten basically
involved in seven different military incursions. You look at Venezuela, you look at bombing the
Houthis, that campaign that I think lasted over a month. So this is not a president who is unwilling
to use any kind of military power at all. I think one thing that does hurt us, and especially the
younger crowd, especially millennials who lived through 9-11, is that we see every military
incursion through that lens. Oh, my gosh, Mike. You just made me realize
you're so right. We're just like the boomers. For years, we've been saying, boomers, you're so stuck
in that one moment of the end of the Cold War. It's us. We're stuck in 9-11. You're completely
right. Wow. Moment of just personal clarity. Not to turn this into a therapy session for me,
but go on. Yeah. No. I think that's really important to recognize.
Every generation has lenses through which they view everything. We understand what the boomers
went through and what they lived through. Of course, they're going to view everything through
kind of a more Cold War, post-World War II lens. That makes perfect sense. But I think we need to
be fully understanding of how we tend to view everything either. When you look back at American
history, this kind of almost implicit idea that any use of military force whatsoever should be
immediately suspect is obviously unconstitutional, and the president needs to be impeached. You just
don't quite see that. Civil War, anybody? I know they're still obviously fighting about Lincoln and
Thomas D. Lorenzo writing a ton of books and that kind of thing. But this has just been
part of presidential power. We were just talking about the tariff case and the power that the
president has for Article II. The executive power is vested in the president. You compare that to
Article I, legislative powers. That by itself should tell you something about what that means.
I think just going back to Trump, this is just like Iraq. I think in Afghanistan,
really defined George W. Bush. This is going to be the defining thing for Trump.
He's obviously thinking about midterms, but if he thinks that this is just of such importance to the
United States, it's national security going forward, okay, I understand. He makes a calculation
in the moment saying, I wish I could focus much more on domestic policies and affordability.
But the world doesn't give you that kind of room to be able to pick and choose what you want to do.
It throws things at you and you have to react. I think it's a mistake to link at the hip domestic
and foreign activity. Part of the other criticism, one of the many criticisms on the right is,
Matt Walsh was voicing this yesterday on X, is, look, I was promised mass deportations and we
haven't gotten those and yet we're going on a regime change war. The implication is that
we're doing all this over there and spending money over there and thus, we wanted to do the
stuff at home first. If you do one, you can't really do the other, or you're getting distracted
from the other. They're separate things and we have separate cabinet agencies to oversee
these sorts of activities, so it's a little too facile. Then finally, well, finally,
just my little quick rip, Trump running wild on foreign policy is also because of the structure
of the constitution, there's a lot more room to do it. We've seen this with presidencies going
very, very far back, really even to the beginning, but particularly in the post-war era
and especially in the post-Cold War era. Congress, for a variety of reasons,
has not declared war since World War II. This has also come up in the conversation,
Congress hasn't authorized this. If I listed all the foreign kinetic actions,
much lower stakes, I might add, and some of them just humanitarian, allegedly humanitarian,
going back through the last seven presidencies, we'd be here a long time. Congress, for whatever
reason, now, especially on foreign policy, perpetually reserves the right to critique
Africa back. They will occasionally summon after a real attack on the homeland, of course, 9-11,
they summoned the ability and the will to do something like declaration of war or the modern
equivalent, the authorization to use military force. But Trump is running wild in foreign
policy because there are great threats in the world and also he has a lot freer open field to
run in. Meanwhile, at home, the frustration of a lot about the home front has to do with these
themes we've been talking about for a while. Neither of these parties has won a commanding
majority or a legislative agenda at home in decades. There's a tiny majority in the house.
The GOP is encumbered with all sorts of pathological institutional,
to drag an analogy out of a couple of podcasts ago, clown car tendencies.
The domestic scene with a very powerful presidency that the administration has done a lot,
Congress has been able to do some, but the quagmire at home domestically has to do with
the large behemoth of the administrative state, the way we do modern government,
the collapse of congressional institutional prerogative and ability to function.
And so this is just a long way of saying we shouldn't be surprised that the active and
swift and consequential actions have occurred to Trump in his first 18 months, mostly in foreign
policy. As you say, Ryan, it's the most significant risky act of his presidency. I mean, I would say
both of his presidencies, both terms, I think by a pretty clear distance. And as Mike adds,
probably this will be the most one. There's probably not going to be a more significant one
down the pike. Just as a personal reflection, I will say that there's this thing going on
on Instagram with Francis Fukuyama, who, if you are basically all our listeners know,
author of the end of history and the last man, a much misunderstood book, but also therefore a
much mocked one. And he's known for posting little, he's like an old man now. He's posting
little shots of himself, selfies on Instagram, and people will go on and comment and say,
please help Mr. Fukuyama. History started again. Can you end it? I think, I mean, actually some
of what he says at the end of that book is actually pretty apposite to what's going on
right now. But my major point is just that I mentioned I was at this conference over the
And I had one of those surreal moments where you sort of step outside of yourself and
view what's going on, like out of body. And I thought, boy, here I am, like in the imperial
capital, sort of discussing among various elites, you know, how to keep the polity together while
the legions roll out the gates of war. I just thought, oh, look, it's history only. It's also
now. So I hope we win this thing. I really do. I mean, it seems like we are embarking or let's
say we are acknowledging the fact that we've embarked upon history. I think it's a new phase
in our history. I'm now kind of obsessed with this new paradigm that I have where we've been
focusing on the wrong era of Roman history because we've been thinking so much about the fall of the
republic and the beginning of the empire, which is this kind of longstanding comparison that
Americans have always been very haunted by. But actually, since we're 250 years in,
we're really only halfway through the length that Rome's republic lasted. And what happened about
halfway through Rome's republic is that the conditions under which the empire would eventually
emerge started to take shape. This was Rome's big expansionist phase. Now, I'm not therefore
calling for us to take territory in the Middle East or something. I'm just saying this may be
the phase of republic's history that we've entered in on, the phase when we remain a republic,
but also become increasingly... I mean, we've been a world power for a while, and now we're,
I think, kind of facing up to some of what that means. And it's, as Ryan points out,
the fact that people who are saying it's very uncertain and many bad things could happen
are 100% correct, but that is kind of how history works. So that element of it is very, very
alarming. And as you say, Ryan, the kind of right reaction to it is prayer, not to say,
how can Trump possibly do this? I think a lot of this is really kind of just acknowledging
certain realities that we've been aware of, and we've talked about a lot of this podcast.
And something like this was probably bound to occur. I'm glad it's happening under Trump,
actually. I think Trump is a good person to be at the helm during this time.
We have a few other angles that we wanted to talk about, and no doubt this will not
be our last podcast on America's war in Iran. I think we wanted to cover, just when the week
finished, the European side of this, which was interesting. I mean, Keir Starmer had this weird
statement, I think maybe it was Sunday, it might have even been Saturday, where he basically said,
I didn't know this was going to happen. I kind of don't like it. The UK, blah, blah, blah. I mean,
it was a weird, weird video. Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission,
has inserted herself in order to try to be relevant, saying all the normal platitudes
about war and avoiding unnecessary violence. I mean, she basically went on to say,
I too am monitoring the situation, and I'm still important, please pay attention to me.
I thought it was kind of pathetic. I think most interestingly, Macron said today,
I believe that is Tuesday, March 3rd, that he would be working with China to help de-escalate
the situation. So let that sink in for a minute. The president of France is saying that he's going
to work with the United States's major geopolitical rival, one of the two biggest
client states of which is Iran, on de-escalating the situation. Teddy Roosevelt negotiating the
end of the Russo-Japanese War, this is not from Macron's perspective. So this just demonstrates,
the sorry state of European defense capabilities and foreign affairs, even from a member of
Five Eyes, that is the UK. So I think Europe's response has been interesting and does not,
in the immediate near term, portend well for the lessons they may have drawn from
Marco Rubio's admonishment, gentle admonishment of them at Munich that they
needed to reassert themselves and stand up as capable allies.
And that's something I was going to immediately link to, is looking back at Marco Rubio's speech
and kind of in, you know, an open hand saying, look, we're really in this all together. We're
derived from the same kind of civilizational sources. We need to stand together. And yeah,
I mean, you look at, you know, some of the people you named certainly, you know, some of the,
you know, I mean, very reminiscent in some ways of, you know, 2000, what, two or three,
you know, when the Iraq and Afghanistan wars and all that started from Europe. I mean,
it was much more actually, much more heavily against. This is a little bit mixed in some ways.
We actually ran a great piece yesterday by one of our fellows, Kristen Ziccarelli,
that just showed, you know, look, I mean, this kind of points back to, you know,
Europe needs to kind of rediscover its history and needs to discover, you know,
by most again, like, you know, where is this kind of idea of, you know, strength and power
and military force and that it needs to be sometimes like militaries do need to be used.
And that you're, it has this throughout all its history. And you look at the crusades alone
and look at what it's gotten to. It's gotten to, you know, Europe, where you have certainly some
nations, Hungary comes to mind, where they're actually fighting for something. They're fighting
for renewal, but so many have just outsourced their entire sovereignty, you know, to these
bodies. And what's been the result of that? Just absolute decline. You look that everywhere.
So this is a huge problem. And I think it's kind of really a decision point kind of for Europe,
you know, which way are they going to go? Are they going to go to a place where it's just,
you know, the same thing just accelerated? Or are they going to look at, you know,
what Trump is trying to do? So that's kind of the real question. And that's,
that's the difficult thing is, you know, which path are they going to take?
Yeah. I don't know if this is quite correct as an analogy, but, you know, Rubio talked last night
about congressional notification. And he said, you know, I briefed the gang of eight ahead of
time. The gang of eight is not the old immigration, you know, amnesty crew for
shorthand stuff, but really the senior leadership of Congress that can be trusted not to leak this
sort of thing ahead of time. So Rubio said he briefed them ahead of the operation. And then
they have been briefed a couple of times after. It seems like, it looks to me like
this administration is treating Europe and even all of Five Eyes, a portion of Five Eyes,
maybe the UK portion of Five Eyes as not even as reliable as a part of a trusted member of Congress
on international activities that affect them much, much more, not quite in their backyard,
but in their, maybe in the, like the lot behind their backyard. I guess we'll get more details
about the extent to which Europe was read in on this ahead of time or which countries in Europe
were, but I thought it was pretty telling that Starmer basically said he didn't know this was
going to happen, that it's a testament to the internal political difficulties of the UK.
And we'll see how this all goes going forward. Again, it may be the case that Rubio's warnings
at Munich, as well as they were received at Munich, will prove for some time
unrealizable in terms of the partners that he wanted to further stand up in Western Europe.
But it's a big place. There's a lot of diverse constituencies and interests across
Western Europe. And so to talk of all of them as one is silly, even though they have, as you say,
ceded a significant portion of their individual and in a way kind of shared collective sovereignty
to bureaucrats with no real connection to the peoples of those different nations. So
it would be interesting to watch. And I'll just add one last thing. Some of the people who were
kind of voice support, NATO chief Mark Rudy, I think that's how you say his name. So he voices
support for the strikes on Iran. I know that he's... Ruta, yeah. So he is, I think...
German Chancellor Merz as well. Yeah.
Yep. He did too. There was Sunday's E3 statement. So that's Britain, France,
and Germany said they were ready to take steps to defend their interests in the region.
So those are just... So again, it's not all bad. I mean, there's some element of hope there. But I
think as you said, Ryan, I mean, really, I think you have to look at it too. We're in a generations
long project. I mean, you look at just the changes that I think need to take place. You look
at really the chaos that the office of prime minister has been in Britain recently. And then
you look at what's possibly in the future. I mean, you look at in France, I think the next presidential
elections, I think it's either 2027 or 2029, but Jordan Bardella could possibly win. I think he's
certainly. You look at what happens in Germany with AFD. So this is not only a grand political
realignment ongoing in the United States, it's that way in Europe too. And I think you're right
to see that Rubia really was setting a foundation for the future, even if right now it doesn't look
like I think what the Trump administration would want. They're really looking at administrations
certainly beyond the ground. Yeah. I mean, we'll handicap our own criticism or mine anyway.
You know, Munich was like two weeks ago, so it's near time still yet, but yeah.
This definitely won't be our last conversation on the subject and we'll be dropping a paid
episode as always on our sub stack Claremont digital plus. So please do join us for that.
One of the things I love about this podcast is that when big events happen
and I have all these thoughts swirling around in my head, I'm like, oh good. I'll at least get to
talk to my smart friends about it on Tuesday. So we hope you feel the same way. And thank you all
for listening to the round table. If you want to know more about everything we do, visit our
websites, the American mind, American mind.org Claremont review books, where you should definitely
take a look at Mike Anton's excoriation of Laura field Fury road at Claremont review books.com.
And you can donate to support us at Claremont.org slash donate. Thanks very much to our production
crew, which is really just at this point, the brother, G Ryan Gannon don't forget to rate,
review, share, subscribe, let people know about the podcast really helps us in the ratings.
And thanks all of you for listening. We will see you next time.