How To Repair And Operate Lionel (MPC) 6-2151 Operating Semaphore

Toy Train Tips And Tricks
93 followers
Episode 89: This is my childhood Lionel #6-2151 Operating Semaphore. Discover how this accessory works, how I repaired it, and two easy wiring methods. Also, discover a little about its predecessor, the Lionel #151 Operating Semaphore (1947-1969)
O Gauge 3D Printed Ties: https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:3332520
When I was nine years old I bought this Lionel 6-2151 semaphore with my own money. Today we'll
show you how I repaired it, two ways to wire it, and two ways to wire its post-war cousin,
the number 151 semaphore. Stick around and let's take a look.
Hello again this is Mike with Toy Train Tips and Tricks and today we're going to take a close look
at this number 6-2151 Lionel MPC era semaphore. This particular semaphore is very meaningful to
me. I remember when I was nine years old buying this at a train show with my own money. My father
was helping out a local hobby shop and working their table and so I was wandering around. I was
very precocious young lad from my exposure to the hobby shop and to our own home layout. I was well
versed in things both HO and O and prototype as well and so I looked for my own bargains and I
remember I found this. I got what I thought was a good deal on it. It was used but it was still in
mostly in the original box kind of mangled and I was very happy with the purchase to have a
semaphore. I already had two block signals but I liked the semaphore because I liked the motion.
So since many of you have never seen a semaphore in the wild, what they are is a railroad traffic
maintaining device. A signal that provides both a physical representation and the light
to give an indication of what the train should do. These were very common in North American
railroads starting about 1880 or so all the way up into the 1970s when they started disappearing
quickly. Some stragglers survived on CSX and BNSF until the early 2000s. Today you generally find
them at museums. You can find a few special use ones on some short lines. They came in different
sizes and different shapes, different functions. Sometimes they were an up what we call an upper
quadrant like these are. Some were lower quadrant like this Southern Pacific example and some do
still survive in special situations and on short lines such as this one from Lipsick, Ohio. This
was taken in 2017 or this one in Washington Courthouse, Ohio from 2006. Both of those on the
Indiana and Ohio Railroad. So there are a few of them still straggling around, but for the
most part these are pretty well extinct in the wild. So for Lionel, their first operating semaphore,
there were some that you would manually change in the pre-war era, but the first operating
automatically operating semaphore was the number 151 came out in the post-war era and ran from
1947 all the way up through 1969. Then MPC comes along in 1970 and for some reason decides to
completely change the design of the semaphore and coming up with this the 2151. So what are the
differences? Well for one, it's about an inch shorter. Two, the design of the semaphore arm
and the lenses is much more realistically proportioned. It's still way too large, I mean
this is what 12 feet, which would be absolutely ridiculous for a semaphore flag, but the overall
shape looks more realistic than the number 151 version and so I think a little more appealing.
But there was another internal difference that we're going to see in that the operation of the
signals is quite different from one another. To wire up either the original post-war 151
or the MPC 2151, there are three binding posts. On the post-war version, they are
exposed on the back side. On the MPC version, we have one, two, three, and the order for each
is the same. As you're looking at the semaphore this direction, the binding post to the far left
provides power to the light bulb. The post in the middle, in this case this one,
is common between the light bulb and the solenoid and the one on the far right goes to power the
solenoid. So here's how we do it with a 153C contactor. Here again with my temporary setup
here, I'm using track power from a lock-on. If this were a permanent setup, I would be using
accessory power. 10 to 12 volts is usually enough. You want it bright enough that the
light is a pleasant brightness and of course enough that the solenoid will make the arm move,
but not so much that the bulb gets too hot and melts everything or that you melt the solenoid.
So 10 to 12 volts on accessory power is usually sufficient for this accessory. A little bit more
for the post-war version, the arm is a little heavier and it's having to do more work because
it's working the opposite direction. So again looking at the MPC version, so the post underneath
on this side again provides our power to our light and I have it running over here to the center rail
of my lock-on. The middle post is providing the common for both. I have it running off of the
outside rails on my lock-on post number two and the far right post here provides the power for the
solenoid and I have it running to this post of the 153C contactor which when the train comes
and presses down on the contactor feeds in power which I have right now jumped over here to track
power again. And again I would do this normally with accessory power. So with the 2151 the action
is you have a normal stop indication, the train approaches, the indication goes to green to clear
until the train is out of the detection circuit. Starts red, goes to green. For the post-war 151
it works the opposite way. On the 151 you have a green indication most of the time
and when the train approaches it goes to red to show that that block is occupied.
So which is more appropriate as far as prototype operation? Probably the post-war 151 you're going
to have more opportunities for. As a single mass semaphore, a single head semaphore, you will run
into more of what we call block signals or occupancy signals where it stays green until there
is something in the block such as the 151 is more common. However there are some signals that are
as home signals and these are found at major interlockings or at diamonds, places where the
normal situation is they do not want a train proceeding without permission of the operator
or the dispatcher. So the block will remain red until a dispatcher or operator gives them the
signal to go. The semaphore or the block signal either one would then turn to green and then the
train approaches. So two things with this. One, in order to make this really prototypical you need
your approach section to be much longer than one or two pieces of track. Secondly, you would really
need a second contactor with a relay of some sort so that once the train passed the signal it would
turn back to red indication to be truly prototypical. But here we are in Lionel land so
does it really matter? You decide. So this is one way to wire up the signal using the 153c indicator.
Let's show you a second way. Okay so the second method of wiring we totally get rid of the 153c
connector and instead we just use two lock-ons. One here, well in this case you can't see it on
the camera, it's over here. Okay so two lock-ons. In this case I have two insulated track sections
and I showed how to make those in a previous episode, episode 65 or so I believe. So what I've
done here is I've removed the metal ties and insulators. You can either you know put down
electrical tape or paper or whatever. In this case I've completely removed the ties and I've
epoxied on these cool 3D printed ties and I'm going to include the link to these on Thingiverse
in the comments section and the description section of the video if you want to do these.
Kind of cool. Or you can use wood or whatever but in this case I want to insulate all of the rails
from one another instead of the normal metal tie setup where the two outside rails are tied
together. So I've insulated the rails and I've put an insulating pin here and at my opposite end
which is just outside of camera range here near my lock-on. So what happens is I have reversed
the wiring to the signal. This time instead of sending common to the middle to power to provide
common for both the solenoid and the light bulb I am now sending hot to both of them. In this case
again from my center rail thanks to this lock-on I could tie it into my power bus or auxiliary
power and only need one lock-on but in this case this temporary connection I'm using track power.
So from the center rail number one goes to the middle to provide the hot for both items. So then
my common for my light bulb is also going over here to position two on the lock-on so it's going
to the common rail. Again I could tie that into my bus wire hide it under the layout not use track
power but again this is a temporary setup just to show how it works. So hot goes to middle common
outside rail goes to this contactor underneath on the far left side and the one for the far
right side that I will get common to the solenoid complete the circuit is coming from my insulated
track section. So when the train crosses from here to here the metal wheels will send the circuit
from this rail to this rail through the wheels will complete the circuit and activate the signal
like this. And as long as there is a train in my section in this case these two pieces of track
the signal will remain activated and as soon as the train clears the signal deactivates.
This system also works exactly the same way for the 151 except like we said before the indication
is different. This would be green and it changes to red as the train approaches. So you can do it
either with the 153c or you can do it with insulated track power. There are other ways you
can do it using infrared detectors using magnetic read switches and other circuits but these are the
two simplest ways. And now as I mentioned in the previous video one of the reasons that people
will shy away from the 153c is that for block signal use when you have when it's choosing
between an either or it likes to get stuck in the middle. And again just like in my last video since
this is an on off switch it's either off or on off or on it makes it easier
to set the adjustment on the 153c. Also some post-war 151s original equipment instead of a
153c will be a 145c which was originally designed for the automatic gateman. The only difference is
instead of three contacts you have two and it's on or off so instead of having three contacts where
you don't use one you have a contact just one on each side and the train activates and completes
the circuit. But the concept is the same. My particular 6-2151 as I mentioned I bought this
when I was about nine years old with my own money and somewhere in the vicinity of 1983-84
I was between layouts I was moving layout from one room to another things got boxed up
and somehow in the move my semaphore flag broke right there. And from that point until last week
this semaphore was broken and every time I had gotten to a point on the layout where hey let's
get some parts and fix the semaphore something would happen and I'd be tearing up the layout
and starting from scratch. Ironically I'm about to redo the track plan on this one.
The whole layout isn't coming down but some major changes are happening so it seems to be like the
curse of the semaphore when it's time to fix it something goes wrong with the layout. But
finally got the parts and it was a much easier fix than I thought and if you check right over
here in the diagram you can see all these parts are readily available and so what I needed to do
to fix the flag was if you look carefully back here there is a pin you're going to need that pin
and once it's in it's in pretty good and so I ended up having to slice this one off the
original one in order to remove the old semaphore flag. So I had to cut that pin off pull it out
with pliers that freed up the broken semaphore flag. I salvaged the the lights from the old one
those popped out very easily and again those parts are available but just popped out easily
pop them back in with this and then as far as reassembly on the back side of the semaphore flag
you're not going to be able to see it here without me taking it apart and I'm not going to take it
apart again but you can kind of make out this little dot here is where this pin goes through
this little dot here there is a wire that is attached there's a solenoid there's a spring
there is a beam and at the end of that beam is a wire that comes up and sticks out and
through this little slot right here it goes back and forth and it attaches to the back of the flag
there so as the solenoid goes up and down it moves the mechanism including this wire and that wire
is what moves the solenoid back or moves the semaphore back and forth up and down it's
attached to this wire that's what provides my up and down movement with the solenoid and the spring
but the only other part that tends to go wrong with these is the light bulb which is accessible
by removing this screw you can take the ladder off remove this panel and the light bulb sits
right in here there's the cover so you pull this off that pulls off the plastic light bulb cover
and the bulb can be replaced there I suggest that if you are going through that process
go ahead and replace it with an led my bulb was fine also for easier access you'll notice
this side is a solid piece whereas this side has this removable panel which gives you easier access
to the spring the pole the wire and the light bulb if you need it so these two pieces can
come apart this side panel pops off and you can get in there also if I had to do it over again
I would probably in the process of replacing the semaphore flag also get a new spring this one
doesn't seem to be as quite as springy it's a little reluctant to push it all the way down
sometimes that can also be caused by pushing this pin in too far as I found the hard way if you push
this in too far it adds friction to the semaphore flag and it won't rotate freely but I pulled it
out put a little dab of some of some lube on there and it's working fine now so after 20 30
almost yes 30 plus years this semaphore now works and once my new track plan is in place it will
find itself a permanent position on the new layout so again this is the MPC era the 1970s early 80s
6-2151 or there's also the post-war number 151 semaphore add some light add some motion add some
activity to your layout pretty easily showed you two ways to wire it either with the 153c contactor
or you can do it with a 145c and using the insulated track section two easy ways to do it
and so there you go I hope you like the video if you do please subscribe share
tell your friends tell your neighbors and until then let's keep the trains running
you
