Adversarial Foreign Investments - Hon Mario Mauro

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Mar 4, 2026
23rd Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 6-7, 2023
-Hon. Mario Mauro
Former Italian Minister of Defence
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good morning It is my
pleasure to be invited to such an important
autograph event I would like
to extend my congratulations
Honorable Al for the very clear
picture you provide
about the issue But
let me share some European insights
regarding the European
strategy agains
e hostile foreign investme
I return to discuss the
European Union since its
origins which has long
embraced the
free movement
of capital but now
believes that in certain cases foreign direct
investment can pose a risk
o security and public order
A risk that depends on
the sector in which
the foreign company seeks to invest
and the degree of control the company holds
A factor
that is frequently associated with
e political and economic
characteristics of the country where
the company is headquartered
For this reason most member
countries have regulations in
place to control investment and
acquisition in the strategic
sectors mentioned by Honorable Al
by foreign entities
As in the case of my country
of the golden power in Italy
However
in an integrated market
like the European one
the negative effects
of adversarial foreign investment
If not controlled or approved
in one country such issues
could spread to
others Consider
for example the disruption
of electricity supply on
transnational networks or
theft or sharing of know-how
arising from collaboration
several countries
So here
in March 2019
the regulation establishing a framework
for the control
of foreign investment
in the European Union
was approved
a regulation that takes
effect on October 11 2020
The European Union regulation
does not replace national
regulations but
introduces for
the first time
a mechanism for
cooperation between the
European Commission and member
countries If the investment is
screened at the national level
The country is obliged to
notify the
Commission and other
members who can provide an
opinion on the transaction
but the final decision on
whether to approve or block the
foreign investment still
rests with the target country
Only in cases where a
research program involves
an investment likely
to significantly
affect EU-funded projects such as the
Horizon 2020
research program or
the EU FOREALTH program
or critical EU
infrastructure for example
the Galileo Satellite
System or the TEN
The target country must
provide the Commission
with an explanation if it deviates from the
opinion provided by the
Commission regarding the
Trans-European Network
and Continental Networks
In 2020 and 2021 member states
reported to the
Commission that they had
reviewed a total of 3 356 investment
files linked to as many applications
for approval
In most cases
the dossier was not subject
to formal review
for example
because it was evident
that it would not affect security
or public order
This accounted for 79% of cases
in 2020 and 71% in 2021 While the
majority of files subject to formal
review were approved
without conditions
79% in 2020 and73% in 2021 In
2021 there was conditional
approval
In 23% of cases
the decision
was pending member countries
blocked only 1%
of transactionsin 2021
and 2% in 2020
as in the case of the
German government 's
failure to approve
the purchase of
semiconductor
manufacturer Siltronic by Taiwan's main
rival Global Wafers
Between 2017 and 2019 many developed
countries besides
Italy increased
their protectionist
measures with a
particular focus on
technology sectors
the United Kingdom
France Germany and Japan But
what had
happened in those
years A surge in foreign
investment from China had
reached economic
significance
The economic model and
political strategy
were such tha
at it could be seen
as a concern by the target countries
of the acquisitions
China's economy
had reached the GDP
level of the United
States by 2016
consideringpurchasing
power parity
without becoming a
market economy
15 years
after joining
the WTO
In addition the Made
in China 2025 plan
announced by Beijing
In 2015 the clear goal was
to invest in
foreign companies
to bring technology
and expertise back
home to boost
China's competitiveness and
government-
controlled firms
could receive subsidies in
foreign acquisition deals
and can sacrifice the
profitability of the
foreign asset on the altar
of home country goals
especially when its
government has a political
cycle that lags
behind market realities
A growing
distance between
political and economic
models exacerbated by
the COVID-19 pandemic and
the failure to condemn
Russia's February 2022
invasion of Ukraine has
made globalization
less fluid
All contributed to
the proposal launched
by Janet Yellen on
April 13 to strengthen
economic ties between
countries that can
be trusted
by referring
to friend-sharing
In response to the U S Treasury
Secretary's
proposal the European
Union and New Zealand
signed the Free Trade
Agreement on June 30
after just four years
of negotiations
despite
orny issues such as
agriculture politically
relevant for the EU and
economically relevant for New
Zealand At the press conference
Commission President
Ursula von der Leyen
states that
this new agreeme
comes at a pivotal
geopolitical moment when
democracies like ours
collaborate
to deliver
tangible results for
our citizens The most
recent example known
to those
most concerned
s the harbor of Hamburg
The German federal
executive led
by Olaf Scholz has given the green
light for
a stake by
Chinese giant Costco
to acquire shares
Tollerford the smallest
containerterminal
in Germany's port
of Hamburg
The deal
calls for a limited
stake of 25 % versus the
previously planned
35% The
signed agreeme
s a compromise
that in
addition to
limiting China 's
share of
entry ensures
Costco is
denied the contractual
ability to
grant itself
veto rights
over strategic
business or personal
decisions
In addition
the Beijing
-based company is
prohibited from appointing
members of
management
The ally that
had led the
adoption of the
EU regulation
to control
foreigninvestment
seems to
have fallen
silent as
investment from
China has
stabilized in
value shifting
focus toward
the most
sensitive sectors
sectorsacross
European
countriesnational
regulations where they
exist
have been
updated and many
countries still
without them
have already
begun
a consultative
or legislative
process that
should lead to
the adoption
of a
new control
mechanism
The European Unioneconomy
has reached
a level
of integration
that it
cannot afford weaknesseseasily
exploitedby
authoritarian
regimes
A
capital surplus
in the
immediate
could turn
into an economicdisaster
and
politicalfailure
in the long
run
Thank you
very much
for your
attention and I
hope to share in the
futurewith
you
the same Hvala
