Episode 134: The Lionel #460 Truck Transport Set, commonly called the "piggyback" platform, was a neat action accessory made between 1955 and 1957. The action was supplied manually, avoiding the complication and cost of motors and wiring. The accessory is simple to operate, and it's fun to use.
But how realistic is it? Does it actually represent real railroad operations of the mid-1950s, or is it a fantasy, like many of Lionel's Postwar accessories?
Let's explore these ideas in this episode!
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
Keep the trains running!
***As an Amazon Associate and a member of the eBay Partner Program, I may receive commissions from qualifying sales generated from the links on this video.***
Post-war Lionel, intermodal railroading, and the story of this often overlooked accessory
on this episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks. Hello again, this is Mike with Toy Train Tips
and Tricks, and today we're taking a look at what I believe is one of the unsung accessories of the
post-war era, the Lionel number 460 piggyback transportation set. Now for an accessory that
was cataloged for three years, in this case from 1955 to 57, there's not a lot of literature about
this accessory, and it seems to have been forgotten by many collectors and operators.
But as you see, it is a rather neat accessory operation. It couldn't be simpler, and there's
a lot of potential here. And this is an accessory that was really forward-looking. It was state-of-
operations at the time that the accessory was cataloged. The accessory was available two ways.
There was the number 460P that contained just the platform and the forklift, and there was the
regular 460 set, which included, of course, the platform, the forklift, two of these original
green trailers, and your number 460 piggyback flat car. Operation is very simple. It's manually
controlled with a lever and a wheel. You would rotate the wheel to get the forklift in your
particular position, and Lionel helped you out here. On the trailer casting are two little tabs,
which on the originals should be painted red, and that shows you where to line up your fork.
And so we're lined up. I'm going to lift my lever, take the trailer off of the flat car, and
you can see here there are two metal tabs that the track goes into to make sure you are the
proper distance away from the platform. Geometry is very important in the operation of this
accessory. So I've lifted my trailer up, and I'm going to rotate it around and drop it in its spot
on the landing pad here, where the molded dimples go, and rotate it around. And I can do the same
thing with the other car. I'm not going to on this car because, actually, I need to make a little
repair to this car, this trailer. So this set is not in perfect condition. I have a few
minor repairs, replacements, but the operation is great. So things that are missing,
there's a screw that's supposed to go here that holds the forklift onto our mechanism.
There is a little blue man who goes here on the forklift, and there are reproductions available
for under five dollars. They're all over, but he's really undersized. He's practically just
slightly over HO scale. As you see, this is undersized, and I'm missing one wheel,
which, again, reproductions are available. I'm probably just going to take this wheel
and use it as a pattern and 3D print a match to the other side. The wheels don't actually
need to rotate. As a matter of fact, they do not touch the platform. They are raised up
and out of the way. They're just for decoration. The flat car is intact, the 3460 flat car,
with the metal racking that holds the piggybacks in place and the piggyback trailers themselves.
These are the originals. The original green come with the 460 set, should have the Lionel Trains
placards on either side, as well as Royhoff, I think is pronounced, Duravan, an actual product,
and originals will also have a sticker right down here. This one has fallen off. You can
see part of the original sticker on this one, where it also said Royhoff. Now, this one,
there is a metal clip here that is missing, and so this comes off. That's why I'm not going to
show the operation of this trailer until I make this little minor repair.
So, because this one was not in perfect box condition, I got it for a surprisingly low
price. Matter of fact, I paid more for shipping than I paid for the actual product. My 14-year-old
spent hours playing with this when it came, even before I got it even close to putting it on the
layout, just putting the trailer on, putting the trailer off. You know, so in the age of video
games, this simple mechanism works. Now, as I mentioned, there's not a lot of documentation
on these. As a matter of fact, for the mechanism itself, I've never seen an exploded diagram,
just an instruction sheet, and so I've only seen one of these taken apart, and even that was not
in person, it's in a video. So, I'm going to take this apart so we can see what's going on inside,
and I think what we're going to find is that this one has been modified somewhat from the
original factory version. So, to take it apart, I've removed the trailers, I've removed the track.
Normally, we would have to unscrew the screw that's here, but in this case, we're just going
to pick it up, move it away, and then we have two screws right here, and you see this one,
again, it's not in perfect condition, there's a crack there, but that doesn't affect my operation
any at all. I'm going to remove these two screws, and that's going to give us access to the inside.
Turn it over, and with this side loose now, there are two tabs over here, and we can just reach in
and pull this bottom plate off, and now we have access. So, on this side,
this is basically our lever that controls the height of the fork. So, on this, yes,
there's some gunk there that needs to be cleaned off, it's making that sticky,
so you want to make sure that that's clean. You might put a little bit of oil right here on this
pivot point, but other than that, that's all that goes with this part. So, here you see,
we have our wheel, and a long rod that goes to this metal stopper here, and to this metal plate.
Now, the only other version of this I've ever seen, this metal plate was smooth, and
try to zoom in here, if you look here, these striations, also the other version I've seen
did not have these two washers, which help keep the rod in the proper position.
Hello, this is Mike of the future, butting in. Since shooting this part of the video,
I've continued to be curious about the mechanism used in my No. 460. I still have been unable to
locate either an exploded diagram, or another example of a No. 460 mechanism to examine to
compare with mine. But I did find the exploded parts diagram for the No. 462
derrick platform that shares many of the same parts with the No. 460. And what I have found
is that, clearly, my mechanism has been modified. First of all, the rubber tip at the end of the
drive shaft should be a No. 460-25 rubber sleeve. That was the same part that was used in the No.
462, and it is clearly not the part that is in mine. My rubber piece is some unidentified,
almost tire-looking piece, and that is the reason for the two washers as spacers,
because my rubber piece is smaller, is not as wide, as the regular part, the No. 460-25.
Secondly, as we look at the No. 462, and we zoom in, we look at the metal platter, and clearly,
in this version, we can see the striations on the 462 that are present on my No. 460.
That leads me to believe that either the part was modified somewhere in production
as an improvement of the mechanism from the completely smooth version to the striated
version, or someone, when they modified the other rubber piece, also modified this by taking the
platter off of a No. 462 derrick platform and putting it on my No. 460. So, if anyone has
any additional information about this particular part and the striations on the metal platter,
please leave a comment and enlighten us on this detail so that we can all learn together.
And now, back to your regular video. There is clearly too much grease here,
so I'm going to clean some of this off. Just slide that, and let's get rid of some of this
excess. The whole thing comes off, that's okay. Yeah, it looks a whole lot better. Actually,
we'll put our washers back on here. Our two washers for spacers, our little rubber, this
looks like a wheel, and we're just going to pop that on there. It doesn't have, it's not on there
tight, just enough to make some contact. Flip this spring back up, slide that under, and boom.
You might find for your particular application that you might need to bend the angle of this
slightly, depending on, you know, if the fork is too high at rest, it's not going to fit
underneath the trailers. If it's too low, it won't fit over onto the flat car, so you need to get it
in that proper range. And your track height is probably going to make some difference with that,
so you might make some adjustments to that angle depending on your particular setup. But this,
you know, just being, you know, a little sheet metal here, that's pretty easy to bend into
whatever configuration you need. All right, I'm going to put it back together. Okay, we're
reassembled, and just to show you operation here without anything in the way, with the wheel,
that turns our little plate under here, so this makes a complete 360-degree circle.
So again, geometry is very important for the operation of the accessory, in that in order to
pick up the trailers, you have to get it aligned just right so that our two tabs here line up
diagonally, the four holes either on this side or this side, depending on which side you have put
the trailer on. This accessory will work with trailers other than the original green ones,
but of all of the different designs, it has to have all four holes. This is a later trailer with
only two holes in the mold. You can see where the other two holes used to be. This one really
won't work. This will fall off as you try to move the trailer around. So again, when you put the
trailer in the divots right here on the platform, as you go around, I see I might be a little bit
too high here, might have to adjust that, but when my fork is right here between the two red marks on
the trailer, it's lined up. We're pretty close. There, nailed it that time. So we can rotate this
around a full 360 degree circle and drop it on the trailer, which would be back here. So as I said,
as this was made in 1955 through 57, this was pretty much state-of-the-art railroad technology.
Now the idea of carrying trailers on flat cars really goes back to the end of the 19th century,
but it was of limited use. Things like circus trailers, sometimes horse-drawn carts, but
as a regular service, putting trailers on flat cars really didn't begin until about 1936. The
Chicago Great Western Railroad started using some service to some of the smaller towns along its
route. This practice was deemed successful and it was picked up by several other railroads, including
the New Haven, which by the outbreak of World War II, the New Haven had the largest piggyback fleet
of any North American railroad. Still at this time, most of our piggyback service was just
an individual trailer or two mixed in with a regular freight. There was not dedicated trailer
trains to this point, not until 1953 when Southern Pacific began service of dedicated trains of
nothing but piggyback service for less-than-carload service. So by 1955, when this accessory was made,
not only Southern Pacific, but Pennsylvania, Norfolk, and Western, other railroads were
catching on to the efficiencies of using this piggyback trailer service for less-than-carload
service, and it was taking off by leaps and bounds. Also, most piggyback service at this time
did use shorter trailers such as this. This one measures out to just under 20 feet. 20-foot to
about 28-foot trailers were typical in piggyback service up until the late 1950s, and even after,
you often found the shorter trailers in piggyback service. As a matter of fact, even today,
28-foot trailers are the preferred method for parcel services like FedEx, UPS, etc.
Keeping in mind that, first of all, piggyback service itself was brand new to the scene,
but also that the interstate highway system was yet to be constructed,
most trailers were built pretty light duty for just around-town service. We didn't have the
long-haul roadworthy trailers that we have today in 1955. Most trailers were loaded not using
forklifts but using ramps where a truck would pick up the trailer and back it onto a long
string of trailers one at a time. Then these lightweight trailers had to have jack stands
applied and had to be strapped down to the flat car in order to make it because the suspensions
were not sufficient to hold the trailers on the flat cars themselves without damaging the trailers.
It wasn't until later in the 1950s and into the 1960s when dedicated trailer-on-flat car,
or TOFC, equipment was being made with built-in fifth wheels, and by then the trailers were
getting longer, 35, 40, 45, 48, up to today's 53-foot, and they were made for more long-haul,
heavy-duty service with stiffer underframes, and so it was just a matter of getting the
trailer onto the flat car. So while the idea of putting trailers on and off the flat cars using
a forklift probably existed, as a matter of fact, it most certainly existed in some form,
ramp service in the 1950s was by far the most common. Now today, special forklifts,
either from side loaders, straddle loaders, or overhead cranes, are the most common way to load
and unload trailers and containers onto flat cars. But as we look at the markings here on the
forklift, the Ross Trail Loader, by the way, early versions had the sticker like this, later versions
were heat stamped. This Ross Trail Loader, why is there a sticker here? Lionel would be very unlikely
to go to the added cost of marking these with an actual brand name, Ross. Ross was a Michigan firm
that built forklifts, tractors, and such. Apparently many of their products went to
England during World War II for the war effort. Ross was bought by Clark Equipment in 1953,
but the Ross name survived for a while. Obviously Trail Loader for trailer loader would be a model
name for a particular type of forklift for loading piggyback equipment. I was unable to find really
any specific information about a Ross Trail Loader, save for one short little comment made on
a message board for those who collect tractors. Someone mentioned that they had once owned a
Ross Trail Loader, but I could find no other information, no photos, or anything about it.
However, other photos that I found of Ross products show many forklifts in this same general
shape with the tricycle gear, so this was most likely an actual product. Otherwise Lionel again
would not have gone to the expense of adding this. As a matter of fact, Ross probably paid
Lionel a fee to have this put on their product. The Ross Trail Loader most certainly existed.
How successful it was in the 1950s, it's hard to say. Since even as trailers became longer and
for piggyback service and highway service through the 60s, 70s, 80s, and up to today,
it's still not unreasonable to use these shorter trailers on your layout because many of these
short trailers are still popular with partial services like UPS, FedEx, even the U.S. Mail.
So even having these short trailers mixed in with the longer 40, 45, and 48 feet is not out of the
question today. One problem with the Lionel version of piggyback service though is having the
trailers back-to-back as such. Although I have seen a photo showing that this did sometimes happen
when trailers were loaded from the side onto flat cars, since most loading was done by ramps and then
by the late 1950s, early 1960s, dedicated flat cars with built-in fifth wheels were common and
those were always set the same direction, this is the actual configuration that your trailers should
be in. However, not only with the loader but with the mechanism that holds the trailers onto the
flat car, this won't work very well. So if you can ignore that one little problem with their operation,
otherwise Lionel's piggyback operations are pretty close to prototype. So here again we have the
Lionel number 460 piggyback platform, a neat little accessory that has been largely ignored over the
past several decades. It's an inexpensive accessory as long as you're not getting the complete boxed
version with all inserts. When you get a version that needs a little bit of work like this one,
you can get it for quite a discount. But it is still fun and it still reflects regular realistic
railroad operations. So I hope you've enjoyed this video as much as I've enjoyed making it,
and again, if so, please like it, share it, subscribe, and tell your friends, tell your
neighbors. Meanwhile, keep those trains and trailers running, and we'll catch you next time
on Toy Train Tips and Tricks!