So, to recap, the Pros for the Menards Trains O Gauge Enclosed Auto Rack are:
They’re BIG and impressive! While they are too short for a scale car, the other dimensions are right, and the car looks good with scale equipment The car has excellent graphics and details And these big cars are priced right, retailing for $39.99 - about the same as a new-in-box Lionel enclosed auto rack that is much smaller and less detailed.
On the Con side,
These cars may be too big for many layouts. Check clearances on curves, tunnel portals, bridges, and especially turnouts. You might get away with traditional Lionel model O22 switches and Lionel FasTrack turnouts, but O27 and others with large motor housings are almost certainly out. To keep costs down, these cars have plastic trucks and couplers. Metal would be nicer, but they would certainly add to the price of the cars. Because of their near-scale size, these cars do not work well with other types of auto racks, especially Lionel’s earlier enclosed auto racks. And there are some prototype issues with the reporting marks and the brown flatcar platform
So, weigh the pros and cons for your layout before purchasing!
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
A big car at a moderate price. Menards enclosed auto rack on this episode of Toy Train Tips and
Tricks. Hello again this is Mike with another episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks and so today
I was innocently walking through an area of Menards. I was going to get some wire nuts and
electrical tape and on my way to the checkout of course I took a glance over to the toy and
pull supply aisle and there was a fresh flat cart stacked with brand new boxes and I knew
that meant they were restocking the train department. So a quick glance I saw a lot of
things that looked familiar from last year buildings and such and then there was this brand
new box that said auto carry. Now Menards first released the auto carrier right after Christmas
late January early February and I never actually seen one of these in the stores. They sold out
very quickly online so I think this is a new batch which makes sense as there's a brand new case of
them. So we're going to open it up take a look now one thing I noticed right off the bat I think this
is new too and right here we have a prop 65 warning for California. So does that mean that Menards can
sell these online in California now? Let's take our now familiar clamshell box and let's open it
up and see what we've got to work with here. This Menards auto carrier is an excellent representation
of contemporary cars but what about earlier auto carriers? From the Model T to the early 1950s the
most common way of transporting automobiles by rail was in special usually 50 foot double door
boxcars. These cars had internal racking system that would allow for the transport of up to six
standard size automobiles. Lionel's number 2758 and number 6468 cars are a good representation of
these. By the early 1950s railroads were looking for ways to move load and unload vehicles faster
and easier to help them keep up with America's automobile culture. One proposed solution was the
Evans autoloader as depicted by Lionel's number 6414 car. Unfortunately the Lionel version was far
more successful than the real car as only two prototype models were ever produced. By 1953
railroads began experimenting by attaching tringue in three tiers of racking to existing flat cars
and the modern auto rack was born. By the late 1950s railroads had settled on an 89 foot design
as the effective standard size for these open auto racks. Also it became standard railroad
practice for an equivalent leasing firm such as TTX to own the flat cars themselves with the
racks purchased and owned by the individual railroads. There are a number of accounting
reasons for this arrangement that are really too complex for us to discuss here but it works.
From the late 1950s to 1973 the open auto rack was king such as the Lionel MPC era open triangle
auto racks. As damages from weather themes and vandals piled up railroad searched for ways to
protect their automotive cargo and by 1973 the first fully enclosed auto rack was developed.
But it took another decade before these represented the majority of cars in the U.S.
railroad fleet and open auto racks could still be seen occasionally on U.S. railroads until the
mid 1980s. Lionel's enclosed auto rack is a good representation of these early enclosed racks.
All right so let's pop it open. Here we go. So here we have it and right away there are
some very good things and there are some okay things. Let's start with the good. This is a
good representation of a modern enclosed auto carrier. The graphics you see here all over the
place are great. This car has excess height, talks about deck ABC, we've got some other data here,
our car capacity, jack placement, all kinds of really cool finely detailed graphics, trust fund
marking, lift and jack here, again excess height here on the ends. I don't know if you can even
read that on the ends. Not only the excess height but talk about the doors and built by Menards up
2023. So this is a new batch. Can you if you can read that? Yes Menards 2023. So this is a new
batch as I thought. In case you're wondering the doors do not open on these. Okay now for something
on the bad side with the marking. First of all the number here. In order to keep some individual
number this is common with Menards cars. It's a separate sticker and it's usually slightly crooked
like this one is. The other downside is the reporting mark right here. Now TTX is trailer
train is a corporation that basically pulls rail cars. In this case with auto racks the racks are
owned by the individual railroads and are marked as such and the flat car itself is owned by TTX.
Now different classes of flat car have different sets of reporting marks and DTTX that reporting
marks would be used for a double stack container car. Obviously that's not what this is. For the
proper reporting marks for auto rack cars would be either ETTX that would be a tri-level auto rack
a TGTX would be a bi-level and then there's also CTTX which is a convertible where the racks can be
converted from double high to triple high. And as you can see here there is a spot here where the
individual railroad that would own the rack could be marked but there's no markings there. So you
can add your own sticker make one or decal or whatever. The other issue and this is a minor
nitpick is with the TTX the flat cars even if the top is this oxide red or they call it a burgundy
color the flat car itself the bottom is almost always in TTX yellow with the black markings.
How many people are going to know that? Just you know railfan nerds like me. This is not a scale
car by any means. Real auto racks are going to be 89 feet so we're measuring out 16 inches across
the body which comes out to 64 feet significantly short of 89. However the height on these is pretty
close with the O scale so it just has a good O scale look to it. We also have some good underbody
detail. Now the trucks these are the plastic version of the Menards truck still with metal wheels
but this is all plastic trucks and couplers. So what if you want to combine these with Lionel
cars that were made earlier? So here is one of Lionel's MPC era tri-level auto racks and you can
see Lionel's version is much much smaller. The height as you can see is about right if you put
a roof on top of this the height is about the same. Despite the size of the car there's not
as much weight as you would expect. It's not as light as the Lionel car because there is
this heavier underframe although that feels like a thick plastic rather than a metal.
Still there's a little more heft than the Lionel cars but you're not going to want to put this
up front with a bunch of post-war cars behind it especially on tight curves.
Speaking of tight curves Menards does say that this will navigate 027 curves although I would
not attempt 027 turnouts just from common sense. The Lionel version just barely clears 027 turnouts
and you see how much shorter it is. And we have a coupler issue. A common problem with Menards
couplers particularly the plastic ones this is also true of Lionel plastic couplers of the 80s
there's just not enough mass here for this pin to hold back resistance on the knuckle and so
occasionally you get one that wants to pop itself open. So what we're going to do is I'm going to
grab a small o-ring and I'm going to wrap right around here around this armature. It's going to
hold the armature and the pin in place without gluing the coupler shut or anything crazy like
that. The coupler will still work but it shouldn't pop as freely. That is a 5 16th
rubber o-ring from an assortment from Harbor Freight and it holds things securely. Honestly
this is the first Menards coupler I've ever had trouble with. I have had this experience with
lots of Lionel couplers through the years so that's how I knew how to handle it. Speaking of
couplers as I was working on this I noticed that the thumbtack portion on the bottom of the coupler
is all plastic so there's nothing metallic here for a magnetic uncoupler to catch on to. Also
while we have it parked here on this 042 curve you can see even on this 042 how much overhang
there is and in fact this comes dangerously close to striking the motor housings on my Keyline
042 turnouts. I definitely would not try these on 027 031 remote turnouts on the curves. You're
probably going to run into some problems with that so 042 I'm going to say is the absolute
minimum radius on these large cars. Now let's talk about height. So here we have the top of our car.
This is your highest standard Lionel trestle piece. So you see that if you're using a regular
Lionel trestles and tunnel portals and such you may have some clearance issues as from the bottom
of the track to the top of the car is just shy of five and a half inches. The car is tracking
reasonably well considering there are six cars in a caboose behind it. Now granted these are not
heavy cars you know there's a bit of weight there and I was expecting there to be a bit more of a
but there's enough weight that you could put you know a train load of four of these back to back
to back to back without having any any trouble as long as you're using I'd say 042 and larger track.
Looking at the undercarriage I would say that if one were so inclined you could unscrew the
underframe and probably get inside to add some additional weight if you wanted to. And here you
can see how the height of this car just dominates over a an MPC era Haikyuu box car by Lionel.
Even though the Haikyuu car is taller than your typical Lionel box car this AutoRack is
significantly taller so you would definitely want to mix this in with more of your scale like.
So to recap the pros for the AutoRack are first they're big and impressive,
second while they're too short for a scale car the other dimensions are right and the car looks
good with scale equipment, third the car has excellent graphics and details and these cars
are priced right retailing for only $39.99 about the same as a new in box Lionel enclosed AutoRack
that is much smaller and less detailed. On the con side these cars may be too big for many layouts
check your clearances on curves, tunnel portals, bridges and especially turnouts. You might get
away with traditional Lionel model 022 switches and fast track turnouts but 027 and others with
large motor housings are almost certainly out. Also to keep cost downs these cars have plastic
trucks and couplers. Metal would be much nicer but they would certainly add to the price of the cars.
Also because the cars are near scale they don't work well with other brands of AutoRacks especially
Lionel's earlier enclosed AutoRacks and there are also some prototype issues with the reporting
marks the DTTX and the brown flat car platform which should be yellow. So we the pros and cons
for your layout before you purchase. As always I hope you enjoyed this video as much as I enjoyed
making it and if so please give it a like, share, subscribe and leave your comments. What do you
think of these Benards cars? And whatever the size of your layout keep the trains running
and we'll catch you next time on Toy Train Tips and Tricks.