So you are about to dive into your first permanent 3-rail O gauge layout, and you have decided to use O or O27 tubular track. Great! These are tried-and-true track systems that are durable, available, and that have served O gauge operators for a century.
But, what turnouts should you use? After all, in O27 track alone you have the choice of Lionel, Marx, K-Line - and others. They all work with O27 track, but which is best? Well, the honest answer is - it depends.
On my permanent layout, I use turnouts from a variety of manufacturers. Each brand has its own strengths and weaknesses and so I use different types of turnouts for different purposes. Let’s break down the turnouts that you are likely to find on the market today for O27 and O gauge tubular track so you can choose what works best for your layout.
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
So you are about to dive into your first permanent 3 rail layout,
and you've decided to use O or 027 tubular track. Great! These are tried and true track systems
that are durable, available, and that have served O gauge operators for a century.
But what turnout should you use? After all, in 027 track alone you have the choice of
Lydell, Marks, K-9, and others. They all work with 027 track, but which is the best?
Well, the honest answer is, it depends.
Hello again, this is Mike with another episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
This video topic was suggested by a viewer.
On my permanent layout, I use turnouts from a variety of manufacturers.
Each brand has its own strengths and weaknesses, and so
I use different types of turnouts for different purposes.
Let's break down the turnouts that you are likely to find on the market today for 027
and O gauge tubular track, so you can choose what works best for your layout.
Let's start with 027 track. Remember that both 027 and O gauge share the same track gauge or
distance between the outside rails. The main difference between the two are that 027 rails
are not as tall, and that 027 track has a tighter minimum curve 27-inch diameter circle
compared to the regular O gauge track. If you wish, you can use regular O turnouts with 027 track
if you shim the 027 rails to match the higher O gauge rails.
Also, no one is currently manufacturing turnouts for O or 027 tubular track systems,
but many are still available on the secondary market as they've been manufactured for 70 years
and longer, and unless abused, they will last for very many more years.
The most common 027 remote turnout found today is the Myanell 1122 and its descendants.
Manufactured from 1952 through the late 1990s, these turnouts are durable, reliable, and common.
Post-war versions feature a lighted lantern to indicate the direction of throw,
while modern era versions feature a red and green colored plastic shield to indicate
turnout direction. Modern versions also feature a lever to change direction manual.
Otherwise, the turnouts are identical and use most of the same electrical and mechanical parts.
The turnouts operate well with all Myanell post-war products and most other brands of
locomotives and cars, those that can operate on 027 curves. The exceptions are many Marx locomotives
and some pre-war Myanell locomotives that use large gears that make it impossible for these
locomotives to pass through the guardrails of the turnouts. All of these turnouts feature
automatic routing, or the so-called non-derail feature, whereby the middle wheels of engines
and cars cause the turnout to switch in the direction of a trailing point train,
meaning one coming from the diverging route. To accomplish this, special insulated track pins
must be placed on the inside rail of each of the two diverging routes.
One variation to watch for is the original 1952 version of this turnout. This switch does not
require insulating pins, but it has a larger switch motor housing that will not permit F3s and
some cars to pass through. All of these turnouts are internally wired to run on track power.
Because of this, any time any part of the train is on the diverging parts of the switch,
power is sent to the switch motor. This may cause the train to slow down and, in some cases,
may burn out the switch motor if a train is parked on the turnout for long periods.
Later in the modern era, Lionel added a turnout with 027 profile rails and an 042 curve to the
lineout. This turnout utilizes the same basic design as the 027 version, what allows for the
operation of larger engines and rolling stock. These turnouts were not made in large quantities
and so are more difficult to find. These Lionel turnouts are an all-around good choice for most
027 operators. The next most common 027 turnouts were made by Marx. The most common Marx turnouts
feature an all-metal construction and were offered with 027 curves. Marx also made plastic turnouts
that utilized 027 or larger 034 curves. The metal Marx 027 turnouts were first offered in the 1930s.
Over the years, they were produced in a variety of colors. Some versions feature a lighted position
indicator, but most do not. These metal turnouts feature what is known as a frogless design. This
means they have no need for guardrails, so wheels of all types can pass over them without trouble.
The frogless design also eliminates gaps, so cars that are backing up on these turnouts are
less likely to derail on the tight 027 curves than on a regular Lionel turnout. As a result,
I like to use these Marx turnouts in yard and industrial tracks where I intend to do a lot of
switching. The downside of these turnouts is a gap in the center rail that can sometimes trap
Lionel and other brands of center pickup rollers. However, these turnouts can easily be modified to
problem, as in the video link at the top right of the screen. Marx turnouts are not internally
wired to the track and so must receive power directly from the transformer. As a result,
they do not have the non-derailing feature built in, but they can easily be modified for this
feature if desired. These Marx metal turnouts are very durable and are usually less expensive
than their Lionel counterparts. On the other hand, I do not recommend the Marx plastic turnouts.
While they do include a special sprung frog design that accommodates both regular and
fat-wheeled locomotives, they lack guardrails, so heavier locomotives and cars tend to derail
on them, especially when approaching from the facing point or the non-diverging route.
Perhaps the best of the common 027 turnouts are those that were made by Caneline. Caneline's 027
turnouts were available with either 027 or wider 042 curves. Early versions feature twin-bulb
position indicators on a large motor housing, while later versions are low-profile with LED
indicators. Like Lionel's 027 turnouts, Caneline's come internally wired with the non-derailing
feature, and like Lionel's, they require insulated track pins on the inside rails of the diverging
routes. Unlike Lionel's turnouts, Caneline's feature power limiting switches so that trains
occupying the turnout do not send power to the switch motor after it's been thrown. With no
additional power going to the switch motor, more power is available to the train, and switch motor
burnout is highly unlikely. Caneline's turnouts also come with additional wiring posts so the
operator can choose between track power or transformer power for the turnouts. And like
Lionel's 0 gauge turnouts, these turnouts feature internal contacts so that block signals can be
added to them to indicate turnout positions. If there are any drawbacks to these Caneline products,
it's that the switch motor housing on the early versions is a bit unsightly, and there is a tall
ramp around the switch frogs that makes them a little rough for passing rolling stock. Like
Lionel's turnouts, Caneline's will not accept the fat wheel locomotives. Because of these extra
features, Caneline's turnouts tend to be priced a little higher than their Lionel counterparts.
Caneline made far more 042 turnouts than did Lionel, so in this case the Caneline versions
are both easier to find and less expensive than the Lionel versions. Some other 027 turnouts you
may run across include Lionel number 1121 turnouts. These were made from the 1930s until 1951.
They look a bit like smaller versions of Lionel's regular 0 gauge turnouts.
They lack the automatic non-derail feature, but they will accommodate fat wheeled locomotives.
As with Mark's turnouts, these early Lionel turnouts require some additional track pins
in the center rails to accommodate modern pickup rollers. And of course, all of these 027 turnouts
were also offered in manual control versions as well. The most common turnouts for larger
0 gauge rails is the Lionel number 022 turnout. These were made from 1938 into the early 2000s
and utilize 031 diameter curbs. They are pre-wired for the non-derail feature
and are set for track power, but they can easily be modified for transformer power.
Like the Caneline turnouts, Lionel 022 turnouts have an internal contact
that allows them to be wired with block signals to show the direction of the switch.
Also, users can swap the switch motor housing from one side of the turnout to the other. Lionel also
made number 711 and number 731 turnouts with 072 wide radius curbs for standard 0 gauge track.
These work well but can be very difficult to find. Lionel's 0 gauge turnouts will not accommodate
fat wheel locomotives. Overall, Lionel's number 022 series turnouts are common,
reliable, and durable. Less common than their 027 brethren, Caneline also made a line of 0 and 042
turnouts. These models have the same features as their 027 counterparts, but with the taller
0 gauge rails. Caneline also made some of these in their Super Snap Track series,
featuring a black center rail and more realistic track ties. While not specifically made for
tubular rails, many operators consider the products of Ross Custom Switches to be the
best turnouts that are in current production. They are available in a wide variety of curve
radii and configurations, they're reliable, and they look great. However, they do come with a
premium price tag and they may require some rail shimming or special track connectors to work with
tubular rails. In summary, if you're using standard 0 gauge rails, Caneline turnouts offer some
premium features, but Lionel's number 022 turnouts work well and they're easy to find. For 027,
Canelines are again fully featured but a little harder to find. Lionel's 1122 series are the
standard 027 and they're very easy to find. If you want a fraudless design or if you need to
accommodate Marx or pre-war fat wheel locomotives, Marx's metal turnouts are cheap and abundant,
but early Lionel number 1121 turnouts will also work for this. So which is best? Well,
it depends on your equipment, your budget, and on your operating needs. I hope this video has
decided which turnouts are best for your layout and if so, please like the video, subscribe to
the channel, and leave a comment about your favorite turnouts. Whichever you choose,
keep the trains running and we'll catch you next time on Toy Train Tips and Tricks.