Sometimes, the real object that Lionel Trains based its O gauge model on is a dud, but the model version is popular and successful. This situation is the focus of today’s episode - the models that didn’t do it in real life, but are popular and ubiquitous in the world of Lionel and other O gauge trains.
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
Everyone wants to be first. People line up to be the first to see a new movie,
the first to buy a hot new book, the first to ride the newest, scariest roller coaster.
And model makers often rush to be the first to come out with a model of the
latest railroad technology. Sometimes both the model and the prototype are hits,
like the Lionel F3 for example. Sometimes the prototype is a solid performer, but
something about it just doesn't appeal to the model crowd. And sometimes the real thing is a
dud, but the model version is popular and successful. The latter situation is the
focus of today's episode. The models that didn't quite do it in real life,
but are popular and even ubiquitous in the world of Lionel and other O'Gates trains.
Our first example is the Pennsylvania Railroad Model S2 steam turbine locomotive.
Developed during the Second World War as a collaboration between Baldwin Locomotive
Works and Westinghouse, the S2 was a direct-drive steam turbine featuring technology that was tried
and true in marine applications, so it seemed a natural transition to attempt a railroad locomotive
version. After numerous delays caused by wartime materials shortages, the Pennsylvania Railroad
locomotive number 6200 finally emerged from Baldwin's Eddystone, Pennsylvania plant in
September 1944, and it was impressive. The turbine was capable of generating 6,900 horsepower at 9,000
RPMs, enough power to propel a 17-car passenger train at speeds of up to 110 miles per hour,
and at these speeds the locomotive was remarkably efficient. While the S2 is making headlines for
its futuristic design and high-speed heroics, Lionel Trains was eager to capitalize on the
publicity with their own model. In addition, the model was owned by the Pennsylvania Railroad,
the largest railroad at that time in the most populous region of the United States,
a perfect marketing target. Lionel's model debuted in 1946 in the form of the number 2020,
marketed for 027 sets, and the number 671, which while identical to the 2020 except for the number,
was marketed for 0-gauge track sets. The turbine was also featured in Lionel's new
electronic control set as the number 671R. Lionel's model was much smaller than scale size,
but it looked good with smaller 0 and 027 freight and passenger cars, it was a smooth runner,
and an excellent puller. Minor changes to the design over the years led to number changes,
to number 681 and then later number 682, and the model was still featured in the Lionel catalog
in 1955, after the real locomotive had been scrapped. A remarkable run. Meanwhile,
gremlins were appearing in the design of the real S2 turbine. While very efficient at high speeds,
below 35 miles per hour, where locomotives generally operate the majority of the time,
the S2 was a fuel guzzler and produced enormous amounts of smoke. As a one-of-a-kind locomotive,
repair and maintenance costs were mounting. In August 1949, the locomotive suffered severe
turbine damage and was withdrawn from service after just five years of operation. While the
debated the future of the S2, more and more new diesel locomotives arrived on the Penzey,
and their economy and efficiency spelled doom for the S2. The number 6200 was officially retired in
1952 and scrapped the following year. While the one-of-a-kind real-life S2 was a short-lived
experiment, Lionel's S2 remains a highly prized model for its dependability and smooth running,
and it has been reissued multiple times over the years in both traditional and scale-sized versions
by multiple manufacturers. In 1954, seeking a way to speed up the process of loading and
unloading automobiles from railcars, the Evans Company, in conjunction with the New York Central
Railroad, constructed an experimental bi-level autoloader capable of transporting six standard
automobiles. Union Pacific and Santa Fe also experimented with similar cars, although without
the Evans mechanism. Evans was already the market leader in producing autoloading systems that fit
inside special boxcars, which was the standard method of auto transport until the late 1950s.
The company was eager to gain a foothold in the new flat-car loading concept as well.
Again jumping on the publicity bandwagon of this new modern design, Lionel introduced their own
number 6414 Evans autoloader, although with four autos instead of six, in 1956. The Evans name
appeared prominently on the decoration, and perhaps Evans might have covered some of Lionel's
tooling costs for the car in exchange for the publicity that was a common practice at the time.
Lionel's version, with several variations, remained in production through 1966,
and the car has become a standard feature of post-war inspired layouts ever since. In reality,
however, the New York Central was not sold on the Evans design. Likely it was due to the added cost
and weight of having an Evans ramp mechanism on each railcar, rather than having permanent ramps
at the rail facility. But in any case, the New York Central car was the only Evans autoloader
flat car ever produced in the real world, and both Union Pacific and Santa Fe's attempts were also
one-off experiments. A sad reality compared to the popular Lionel model.
Our last example is the result of a mistake. In 1948, Lionel trains introduced its first
model of a diesel locomotive, the number 2333 EMD F3. The model was initially produced in two
color schemes, the New York Central Lightning Stripe and the classic Santa Fe Red and Silver
Warbonnet scheme. The models were designed and painted not only with the authorization of the
railroads and EMD, but the firms also split the cost of the model and paid tooling for the diesels.
So they were decorated very accurately. However, there was a mistake in the 1948 Lionel catalog.
There's been much debate over the years whether it was the artist, the printer, or Lionel itself
that goofed up. But for whatever reason, the Santa Fe models were shown wearing red and black, not red
and silver. Many Lionel collectors wondered whether the original prototype models from which the
artist was working were actually painted this way. Was there a real Lionel black bonnet, as these
colors were often called? Some modelers painted their own versions, but no O-gauge manufacturer
cataloged an F3 in this theme until the 21st century, when K-Line broke the ice and produced
the K25303TC set in 2005, a premium ABA set that looked just like the models in Lionel's 1948
catalog. But surely no one would actually buy models in an imaginary paint scheme that never
existed, right? Wrong. The models were a hit. Soon, K-Line, Lionel, MTH, Atlas O, and even Menards were producing
not just F3s, but many different locomotives and rolling stock models in the black bonnet colors.
Most of these offerings were limited editions produced for collector's clubs, conventions, or
specialty retailers, but some have actually appeared in regular production, such as this
set from Lionel in 2014. Even steam locomotives are not immune from the black bonnet treatment.
It seems that these days that Lionel's mistake from 1948 is almost as popular in the model world
as the real red and silver Santa Fe scheme. Before we wrap up, some honorable mentions
for this concept include Lionel's Quad Hopper, modeled after a relatively rare and specific
Norfolk & Western prototype made for hauling concrete, which has been made in dozens of
versions in both covered and open types by Lionel, Williams, Menards, and others over the years.
Another honorable mention is the U-36B locomotive, a rather unpopular diesel originally
owned by only three railroads, but which has appeared in numerous other schemes in the Lionel
catalog since. And what about steam locomotives in 242 or 264 wheel arrangements, which did exist,
but were exceptionally rare except for tank locomotives, and except in Lionel-land.
What about those funky Symington-Wayne trucks made by Lionel, MPC, and K-Line?
Yes, some things are more popular in our model world than in reality,
but just have fun and run what you love. We wouldn't want it any other way.
I hope you enjoyed this video as much as I enjoyed making it, and if so, please like it,
share it, subscribe, and tell your friends and neighbors. Keep the trains running,
regardless of prototype, and we'll catch you next time on Toy Train Tips and Tricks.