"In this video Byzantine Art History Professors Evan Freeman and Anne McClanan discuss two medieval Byzantine ivory and bone boxes now housed in the Metropolitan Museum in New York : 1. Byzantine Ivory Casket with Warriors and Dancers, 11th century, Gift of J. Pierpont Morgan, 17.190.239 and 2. Byzantine Bone Casket with Warriors and Mythological Figures, 10th–11th century, Gift of J. Pierpont Morgan, 17.190.237 Video Editor: Anna Weltner This video is available CC BY 4.0
Object descriptions from Met website: for #1 ""If perchance you wish to exempt certain pagans from punishment, my Christ,/ May you spare for my sake Plato and Plutarch,/ For both were very close to your laws in both teaching and way of life./ Even if they were unaware that you as God reign over all,/ In this matter only your charity is needed,/ Through which you are willing to save all me while asking nothing in return."" —John Mauropous (ca. 1000–1081) Classical literature and classical images were preserved throughout the Byzantine period. The erotes who dance and wage mock battles on the sides of this casket and tame a female panther on the lid recall imagery associated with the ancient pagan cult of the god Dionysos. AND
for Object #2 Bone caskets, used by the Byzantines in their homes, were often decorated with themes from classical antiquity. In the Middle Ages many such caskets reached western Europe, where despite their non-Christian decoration they were used in churches as containers for relics." #Antique
We're here in the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York and we are looking at two boxes
or caskets from the Middle Byzantine period that are made of bone and ivory.
One of the most striking features to me when I look at these is I'm noticing that each
one is composed of separate plaques that were attached to the wooden frame on the interior.
All of the plaques show us this playful and wonderful world of mythological figures, though
I'm not quite identifying a specific myth.
These boxes were made of wood at their core, but then they were decorated with these different
plaques of ivory and bone.
One of them is completely made of bone plaques, the other a combination of ivory figural plaques
and bone strips decorated with rosettes.
Because these boxes often then ended up, the ones that survived anyway, in western medieval
cathedral treasuries where they housed relics which were enshrouded by textiles, some of
which were Byzantine textiles, that might have even had some of the same playful imagery
such as griffins, eagles, animals that also appear on some of these ivory boxes.
These kinds of decorative and mythological elements were actually common on secular objects
throughout the Mediterranean, not just in Byzantium, but in Islamic lands during this
time as well.
In addition to thinking about these connections across the Mediterranean, it's interesting
to think how these images stretch into the past, so we might be wanting to look at it
and kind of identify each figure with a specific myth.
But they probably enjoyed rather a more freely associated set of connotations, including
the one that Virgil made where gates of ivory led to false dreams.
Ivory both was alluring but also deceptive and maybe lent itself therefore to these depictions
that were playful but not instructive.
These plaques don't seem to be telling a coherent story that one would read from one
to another.
We see isolated figures, a warrior figure on a throne, figures with weapons engaging
in battle or kind of mock combat.
We see playful erotists frolicking with scarves, musical instruments, many of them are semi-nude.
Some are hunting a lion and others appear with a tamed panther.
It's tempting to see carved ivory from the Middle Ages and like the ancient statues of
Greece and Rome, think that they were white as they often appear in museum collections
today.
But just like those ancient statues, carved ivory in Byzantium was almost always gilded
with gold leaf and painted with many different colors.
Another way our aesthetic preconceptions might differ from the Byzantine audiences, I'm noticing
those little rosette strips that run along the side of the figures are often cut off
even in the middle of the rosette.
The way the rosettes are cut off is a very clear indication that those were being carved
as big long strips and then cut to fit in these various shapes and sizes to cover the
wooden box with these decorative elements.
Of course we wonder why they were made, for whom they were made and earlier scholarly
works on these tended to be grounded in contemporary gender assumptions, gender stereotypes.
So they would say, oh women must have owned these, maybe they put perfumes in them.
But there really is no evidence for that whatsoever.
All we really know is the people who had these had some sense of the classical past or at
least enjoyed having other people assume they did and they were wealthy because these were
very expensive materials and they've been carved at a very high standard of craftsmanship.
The quality of the carving indicates that these are luxury objects.
The non-sacred decoration suggests that these kinds of boxes had a non-sacred function.
They were probably used in domestic or courtly context but really we don't know.
They probably were used by a range of people to contain a range of different objects.
And it's interesting because since these were made after iconoclasm, so they're squarely
in the middle Byzantine period, we might think of them as an aberration, right, after this
big conflict about the nature of religious images.
But we have to think that these secular images in a way are the least problematized body
of images in Byzantine art history.
It's the religious images that were called into question during iconoclasm and so maybe
they didn't have the frisson of the forbidden.
And we know that these decorative motifs were not only popular in Byzantium at this time
but were found throughout the Mediterranean and in Islamic lands as well.
And so it seems likely that these kinds of boxes may have been used as diplomatic gifts
and objects of trade beyond the borders of Byzantium as well.
So as they changed hands, no doubt changing meaning as well to their new audience.