I recently purchased two of Lionel’s O gauge Alco RS-3 models. Interestingly, it was two different purchases of two very different models, but for roughly the same purchase price of around $25. For one model, I think the price was right. For the other, I got an incredible bargain!
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
A Tale of Two Alcos on this episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
Hello again, this is Mike with another episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
I recently purchased two of Lionel's RS3 models. Interestingly, it was two different purchases
of two very different models, but for roughly the same purchase price of around $25.
For one model, I think the price was right. For the other, I got a pretty good bargain.
I've always had a soft spot for Alco's RS3 and similar looking RS2 road switchers.
The rounded edges give the model a less industrial appearance than the earlier RS1 models,
and the rounded cab and the long hood are more reminiscent of a trusty hound dog than a
locomotive. And locomotive crews generally appreciated the Alco's lugging power and
robust GE electrical system. Around 1,800 total RS2s and RS3s were built between 1950 and 1956,
and many were still serving on class 1 railroads some 20 years later,
significantly outliving their cab unit staple mates, the FA line. Some RS2s and RS3s survive
on short line and tourist operations even today. Lionel did not introduce a model of the RS3 until
1988, likely because the traditional open frame motor was too wide to fit into the model's narrow
hood. Instead, most Lionel RS3s sport two can motors, each self-contained within the locomotive
trucks, leaving a great deal of empty real estate above the frame for the electronic components,
if required. Each power truck features two rubber traction tires on one side and twin
roller pickups, for a total of four pickups and four traction tires per model. The first Lionel
RS3s were the 18803 Santa Fe and 18804 Sioux line models in 1988. These were quickly followed by the
18805 Union Pacific, the 18809 Susquehanna in 1989, the 18807 Lehigh Valley in 1990,
and the 18814 Delaware and Hudson in 1991. Most RS3s ride on a sheet metal frame with
sheet metal handrails, much like a traditional Lionel GP7 model, and most feature an electronic
three-position reverse unit. Most models come with three factory-installed light bulbs, one on each
of the ends and another in the cab. The cab bulb is prone to overheating and causing damage to the
roof. At just over two pounds, these models are a bit on the light side, but they are smooth runners.
And then there are my models. The first RS3 I purchased was this number 1802 Heavy Duty
Construction RS3 from the uncataloged number 721902 Heavy Duty Construction set from 1999.
This uncataloged set was targeted at the bottom-end beginner market for mass merchandisers.
The set included three basic yellow gondolas, signs, construction loads, a crane, two vehicles,
a book of blueprints to build your own layout details, and a cheapened RS3 model. How cheap?
Well, how about a single motor? How about forward-only operation? How about a plastic frame
and handrails? How about a single light bulb and an unpainted shell so thin that the entire
short hood glows from the illumination of a single grain of wheat bulb? I knew this model was basic,
but I didn't know how basic it truly was. But for only $25, I was willing to take a chance and add
an RS3 to my fleet. Putting the diesel on the layout, it experienced power outages at every
turnout, requiring me to run at Mach 2 in order to pass through these turnouts without stalling.
Looking at the trucks, I saw center rail pickups on both trucks, so I figured the electrical
issue was the lack of a ground pickup on the unpowered truck, especially since the plastic frame
prevents the usual use of the frame as a common ground. Cosmetically, the model was okay, except
for a broken handrail at one end. This did not bother me too much, as I figured I could come up
with some solution in time. So, I disassembled the model to check out the innards. Remove four
screws that hold the shell in place. The first obvious item is the simple bridge rectifier that
converts the AC input power to DC for the single motor. For now, I'm leaving the model with forward
only operation. The easy way to add reverse would be just to remove the rectifier and run the diesel
on DC power only, reversing the model just like a traditional HO or N scale model. Or, I could add an
aftermarket reverse unit later, which would cost $40 to $60 for a model that cost me $25.
Then, looking at the unpowered truck, I saw no wires whatsoever. Meaning that there was not only
no outside rail contact from this end, but the center rail pickups were simply along for the ride
and contributed nothing toward powering the model. Fortunately, this was an easy fix. I removed the
horseshoe clip that holds the unpowered truck in place, and this gave me easier access to the wheels and
the pickups. I cut a strip of sheet brass to fit on the side of the truck and to make contact with
the metal wheels. I grabbed a red and a black stranded wire. Stranded because it's more flexible
and less likely to disconnect with the motion of the truck. I chose red and black. I would have
preferred red and white at the time, but I was out of white wire. But even this was a mistake
altogether. You see, red and white, or red and black in this case, usually imply polarity in
the circuit. Red for the hot, or positive, and white, or black in this case, for negative. But
this part of the circuit is AC current with no polarity. And so Lionel's standard wiring scheme
in this case is yellow for the center rail and blue for the outer rails. The result of my mistake
is when the wires attach to the bridge rectifier, there's a mismatch with red to yellow and black to
blue, and red and white wires heading to the motor and light bulb. It does work, but it may cause
confusion later on if I need to do any repairs. In any case, I soldered the black wire to my brass
strip before I glued it in place on the truck. Then I added a red wire to the copper strip for
the center rail pickups. I actually removed the rollers because I thought it would be easier to
work with the copper strip with the rollers off. While this was true, I found the process of
replacing the rollers to be very frustrating, so I would not do it again unless I have no other
option. With these new wires soldered to the appropriate leads on the bridge rectifier,
the unpowered truck was now ready to add both hot and ground power to the motor and reduce or
hopefully completely eliminate power loss on the turnouts and crossings. I'd like to pause just a
moment and ask that if you're enjoying the video so far, please like it, subscribe to the channel,
and leave a comment about your experience with Lionel RS3s. And if you want to stay up-to-date
about new O-Gage products from Lionel, Atlas, MTH, Menards, and more, follow the link at the
end of this video and visit the new What's New in O-Gage channel. And don't forget to subscribe
and hit the notifications bell so you never miss an update. Now back to the video.
Then I took a look at the traction tires. They both seemed to be structurally sound, but
periods of slipping made the tires very smooth and likely not very good at providing traction.
I decided to freshen these tires up a bit by adding a coat of bullfrog snot to them.
I applied a coat all the way around each of the tired wheels and then applied power and let the
motor run in place for several hours until the product was even, set, and became clear. I also
took advantage of this inverted position to add a small amount of plastic-safe lithium grease to the
gears, allowing it to spread through the gear train as the motor continued to turn. After this was
finished, I ran the model frame-only around the layout. I experimented by adding different
amounts of weight, and I found that 8 ounces was kind of the sweet spot where it would improve
traction significantly but not be too much weight for that single motor. Then I sent the shell of
the model over to the paint booth for redecoration into my Freelance Railroad's colors and focused
my attention on the second model. While I paid about the same for this model, it would normally
be worth significantly more. This model was a victim of a very poor eBay listing. The loan
photograph was extremely dark and out of focus, and I think the item description was written by
an AI app because it described the model as a DC-powered HO scale model by Atlas. Still, I
thought I would take a chance, and it worked out well for me. Most RS3s sell in the $100 and up
range. While Lionel did make a Susquehanna RS3, this one is not it, as the color scheme and the
cab number are different than the Lionel version. This is a custom-decorated model, and a very
well-done model at that. There is only a small bit of decal sheen on the cab numbers that give
away that it's a non-factory finish. This is a standard conventional control RS3 with two motors
and an electronic three-position reverse unit. More recent editions of the RS3 have included
lion-chief control. To remove the shell, this model has a screw on each end attaching it to
the metal frame, whereas the cheaper model used four screws that were invisibly secured to the
shell underneath. Once the shell is removed, you will immediately notice the difference under the
hood. Twin motors, three light bulbs, and an electronic reverse unit. I purchased this unit
with the intent of repainting it, but the previous owner did such a nice job that I've decided to
keep it as is, at least for now. So, with just a little dusting and lubrication, this model was
ready for the layout. Meanwhile, I had completed the painting on the other RS3, and it was time
for decoration. The white letters and numbers on the black portions of the model are vinyl pieces
cut out with the family Cricut machine, as seen in previous videos. The black logos on the ends
are inkjet printed designs, also seen in previous videos. With the shell painted and lettered, I
could work on finding the necessary space for that eight ounces of weight I needed.
I used these one-quarter ounce wheel weights that I got from Amazon, reinforcing their own
adhesive material with hot glue when necessary. Similar weights are also available at a reasonable
price from Harbor Freight. And that just left the handrails on the cheaper model.
My first idea was to find and order a replacement part, but I was unable to find a diagram for this
particular design, nor could I find any such replacement part. My next idea was to fashion
my own replacements out of wire, but after several attempts, I was not at all satisfied with the look.
Then, I came up with the idea of 3D printing replacement handrails. I successfully found a
on Thingiverse that I was able to modify for the design, and it should work, but then my printer
went down. The extruder died, and so the handrails are on hold until my printer is back in operation.
And I didn't see the need to hold the video indefinitely just for this one missing part.
Now, except for the broken handrails, I have a pair of good-looking and great-running RS3s
for less than the usual price of a single model. With a few easy modifications, the cheap,
heavy-duty construction model makes a nice companion to its twin-motored mate,
and they operate very well together. This is just one example of how, with a little bit of work,
we can turn those bargain lemons into great models. So keep your eyes open for bargains,
and keep the trains running, and we'll catch you next time with more toy train tips and tricks.