ADVERSARIAL FOREIGN INVESTMENTS - Dr- Sohan Dasgupta

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Mar 2, 2026
25th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
London🏴🇬🇧- August 31, September 1, 2023
-Dr. Sohan Dasgupta
Partner, Taft, Stettinius & Hollister LLP - Former Deputy General Counsel, U.S. Department of Homeland Security
Good morning.
Is it still morning?
Mr. Chairman, it's a great honor for me
to be here today with all of you.
Faced with attacks on the free world's security
and prosperity, we have an opportunity today
to deepen our international alliances.
Indeed, global leadership itself is
a fragile and ethereal trust.
Even a powerhouse counts as a leader
in the community of nations only when
it's an ally to other nations which
share its fundamental commitment to freedom.
In our era, our alliances in preserving the free world's
prowess will determine whether the free world itself
will endure.
Those who violate the most profound among humankind's laws
and rules, including its desire to preserve peace
through strength and cooperation,
injure us all most virulently.
And it's not just the use cogent's violations
of the most obvious peremptory norms in international law,
the law of nations, that denote such conduct and transgressions.
Through adversarial investments, hostile powers
and their agents and instrumentalities
sometimes endeavor to assail the intelligence
barriers of this country and my country
in acquiring assets that affect the core of our security.
All this is in service of promoting a particular vision
of the world.
I come from a nation brutalized but resilient
in the face of September 11.
But even in the face of the more subtle incursions
on our security and sovereignty, international cooperation,
tactical exchanges, and intelligence sharing
will very much be key.
In that vein, I briefly shall explain
certain facets of adversarial foreign investments
in our modern day and the solutions to addressing them.
Because we, as the free world, will
need to trust one another and fortify, indeed efflorescent,
that lasting firewall.
First, on the issue of sanctions,
sanctions on purveyors of technology harmful to us
has been regarded as a paramount imperative,
administration after administration in the United
States, for example.
The government has imposed crushing sanctions
on certain providers of spy technology,
surveillance technology.
Just a few weeks ago, even Germany removed one of them
from its networks.
Several such firms effectively are the instrumentalities
of hostile states.
Intellectual property theft, espionage,
supplying of telecommunications equipment
to other rogue states, vowing to obliterate,
or at least destabilize, the free world,
and artificial undercutting of prices
are just some of the conduct.
Others are the failure to adhere to appropriate standards
and to engender a detrimental dependency.
Next is export controls.
Russia has found itself on the US government's
international traffic and arms regulations
list of countries, to which export or import
of defense articles and services is now forbidden.
The US Department of Commerce has
been implementing a comprehensive 42-nation
and European Union-involving agreement
to manage weapons technology.
And last year, the president issued an executive order
preventing US persons from buying and selling
securities in 59 military industrial complex companies
in China.
Moreover, the Federal Communications Commission
has prohibited the approvals of risky telecommunications
equipment as they present an unacceptable national security
risk.
Still, the reality is our problems
will continue until we develop an industrial base
for manufacturing through a whole free world approach.
For that vision to be actuated, we
will need four-quadrant partnerships
across the hemispheres.
Then there's the issue of the Committee on Foreign Investments
in the United States, which is a potent interagency
mechanism of the US government to regulate
investment inflow into the nation.
CFIUS, as it's called, determines
whether a wide variety of proposed transactions
involving foreign entities wishing to acquire US assets
poses sufficient national security risk
to be stopped or mitigated.
Over the last five years, CFIUS' expansion has been dramatic.
In addition to critical technology, infrastructure,
data, and real estate, Congress currently
is debating whether another major category, farmland,
should enter that constellation.
US farmland, it is feared on a bipartisan basis in the US,
in the United States, is being acquired
by foreign adversaries.
And that may imperil our food security
and therefore our national security.
The overall purpose of CFIUS and such inbound investment
review mechanisms is to protect the free world's
agrarian, technology, technological,
and commercial prowess, because they're
viewed as the predicates of national security.
Piercing the corporate veil of the foreign acquirer
often reveals that its actual nationality,
for all intents and purposes, is a hostile one.
When the hostile power's surveillance or hegemony
would harm national security agencies'
access to high-quality, affordable, vital commodities,
spy on the nation, misappropriate or sabotage
vital data, or drastically raise the likelihood
of proprietary technologies' usurpation,
the committee has swiftly acted.
But even here, engaging in superior screening
through intelligence-sharing partnerships
with trusted allies would serve us all well.
And so would augmenting the free world's own supply chains
by adhering to the defense industrial-based sector.
In addition, almost a month ago, the president
issued an investment outflow order
restricting American semiconductor quantum
IT and some artificial intelligence investments
in certain foreign entities.
Focused on private equity and venture capital,
this order is designed to stop US capital, as well as subject
matter expertise, from helping Chinese entities develop
military intelligence, surveillance,
or cyber technology that could undermine
our national security.
Finally, Team Telecom, too, is a US interagency consortium
that is engaged with reviewing foreign investments
from a national security standpoint.
It consists of several governmental agencies
and it reviews telecommunications license applications
for foreign-owned companies trying to operate in the US
or connect us to foreign networks.
Team Telecom has honed in on rogue states, hostile states,
threats in the cyberspace, and this has shot through
with sweeping implications for high-value
and widely available spectrum options and license terms.
Why is Team Telecom important?
It is consequential because the FCC tends to defer
to Team Telecom and the FCC's remit allows it
to block common carriers in the interest
of national security.
And some of these concerns have consisted of hacking,
law enforcement disruption, surveillance, espionage,
and some entities repeated acts of assistance
to rogue states in gaining access to our governmental
and private data.
In 2019, Team Telecom denied China Mobile's FCC application
to provide international telecommunication services
because it was deemed to be vulnerable
to China's exploitation, influence, and control,
and that it would likely comply with espionage
and intelligence requests made by the Chinese state.
That theme tends to repeat itself in the way
that the FCC, as well as many other US government agencies
and consortiums, have been reviewing such applications
or sua sponte, deciding whether or not to revoke
or reassess those authorizations.
A year later, Team Telecom deemed China Telecom
to have been an untrustworthy and unwilling partner
that had run afoul of its longstanding mitigation agreement
and thus had counseled the FCC to terminate
its submarine cable landing license.
And that same theme repeated itself with China Unicom,
Pacific Networks, ComNet, and so on and so forth.
But we come to the thrust of it all, the crux.
Fundamentally, the free world must engage
in greater cooperation, exchange of ideas,
and intelligence sharing.
Our governments, organizations, and peoples
have an immense amount to impart to one another,
thereby sharing ideas and intelligence
and devising effective reforms.
Ordinarily, the best relationship among nations
is that which exists among its peoples,
among their peoples, and such exchanges
also reinforce trust in each other
and confidence and faith in our institutions.
There's a greater purpose here
and it deserves to be elucidated.
By preserving the free world, we safeguard freedom,
we safeguard the rule of law, we safeguard civilization,
and we safeguard truth itself.
It's the perennial quest for truth
that sets the free world apart and elevates us
to more than just the sum of our parts.
And that quest for the truth through success in industry,
commerce, or other enterprises cannot have its day
without the rule of law and security.
That's why international cooperation
to preserve the free world is so crucial.
It is no exaggeration that technological sabotage
and the concomitant economic espionage
of hostile powers and rogue nations
can demolish a free society to the point
that it may never recover.
Their first victim will always, or almost always,
be freedom of thought, because free thought
exemplifies ordered liberty in its most exalted state.
It has always been anathema to tyrants everywhere.
And an essential predicate of the rule of law, of democracy,
is that there be the free
and polychromatic exchange of ideas.
And that's the case both of ideas
that have already been benighted, discredited,
and of ideas whose time has not yet come.
Wholehearted repudiation of forced conformity
is an emblem and an article of faith
to our commitment to the rule of law.
So today, in this august gathering,
we might consider pledging ourselves
to protecting the free world's security
and thus its commitment to the rule of law.
What happens to one nation in one part of the world
will inevitably affect the rest of the world
and the rest of the free world in particular.
And whenever the free world is beset with doubt
about its ability to remain united,
we should remember, as the French like to say,
nous étons plus, we are more than even we think is possible.
We have greater ability to find common ground
than might initially meet the eye.
And it behooves those of us who are dedicated
to the preservation of national security
and the rule of law to stand united
in defense of the liberty of the free world.
So I thank you very much for your attention today.
Thank you.
