A Planet that Survived Inside a Red Giant Star

Mysteries of the Universe
549 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
One of the topics I've been bringing up in some of my recent videos is the idea that planets can
survive inside red giant stars. This sounds hard to believe at first, but red giants are so large,
and their gas is so dispersed, that their surfaces are far thinner than Earth's atmosphere.
This means that a planet will survive inside a red giant star after being consumed for potentially
millions of years, with friction slowly stripping away its mass and causing its orbit to spiral
inward, increasing the mass loss until there's nothing left. But this is still a gradual process
that takes a long time, and the largest planets, like gas giants, will take the longest to
disintegrate. Red giant stars also don't exist for very long, so it could be a possibility that
a scenario occurs where a particularly massive planet enters a red giant star, but before it's
fully destroyed, the red giant itself contracts either due to the helium flash or becoming a white
dwarf, allowing the planet to exit the star alive. Which then obviously creates a planet that was
inside a star and then came out alive to tell the tale, which is pretty cool.
So far of the thousands of exoplanets we've found, there's been no confirmed example of a
planet doing this. Red giants are large and hard to find planets around in the first place,
and this should be rare to begin with. However, there's one planet that may have a decent chance
of this being the scenario it experienced, and its name is Hala. While there's still a lot
unconfirmed about it, all of the potential scenarios for its formation and history are
exciting. 8 Ursae Minoris b, officially named Hala in 2019, is a gas giant orbiting the red
clump star 8 Ursae Minoris, which was named Bakedu in the same year. Now calling Bakedu
specifically a red clump instead of just a red giant is important. A red clump is a specific
type of red giant star that has already undergone a helium flash, the moment when helium starts
fusing in a star's core. And helium flashes only occur for stars roughly 0.8 to 2 times the mass
of the sun, so it really only happens for roughly sun-like stars. Bakedu is estimated to be about
1.5 solar masses, so this makes sense. When a helium flash occurs, the red giant contracts,
sometimes becoming just 2% of its former size, before expanding once again later.
This will be important for this video, as this means that Bakedu used to be larger,
but has since contracted. Hala is a gas giant taking 93 days to orbit Bakedu at 0.46 AU,
slightly further away from its star than Mercury is from the sun.
Other than that, not much is known about it. Because it was discovered with radial velocity,
only its minimum mass is known. Hala is at least 1.6 times the mass of Jupiter,
but may be larger depending on its orbital inclination, which is unknown.
Its orbit is decently circular, with an eccentricity of 0.06. It's close enough to Bakedu
that when it stops being a red clump and gets onto the asymptotic giant branch and expands again,
it will certainly be consumed and likely destroyed. It's likely that Hala was a warm
Jupiter planet before the star began heating up and expanding, and it's now become a full hot
Jupiter. However, there's something weird with Hala's orbit. Bakedu is currently about 10 times
as wide as the sun. As previously mentioned, when a red giant experiences a helium flash,
it may contract to as much as 2% of its original size. It's estimated that when Bakedu was a red
giant, it was about 0.7 AU wide, which is far larger than Hala's 0.46 AU orbit. Not only would
Hala have been inside the star, it would have been extremely far inside it.
This poses a bit of a mystery, as the 8 Earths and Minoras system's properties aren't very well
constrained yet. The sun will take roughly 1.2 billion years to have a helium flash after it
becomes a red giant. The number will be different for Bakedu due to its larger mass, but either way,
we may be talking about Hala being inside this star for hundreds of millions of years,
which actually shouldn't be possible. Planets may last up to millions of years inside red giant
stars, but probably not hundreds of millions. Something's going on here.
One potential explanation was that Hala's true mass was nowhere near its 1.6 Jupiter mass minimum.
A brown dwarf, for example, may have no problem surviving for this long.
However, it's estimated that there's a 99.2% chance that Hala is less massive than a brown dwarf,
making this scenario unlikely. At first, there were several
potential explanations, the most likely one being that the mass of Bakedu was simply incorrect.
A 2024 study looked into the system again, and found that the star's true mass may actually be
1.7 solar masses, not 1.5 like I previously said. This higher mass would pull in its gas more,
contracting its maximum extent as a red giant. This would also mean that Hala would have to
orbit further away from the star to cause the same radial velocity signal.
These two factors combined make Hala's survival much less of a mystery. The lower radius of the
red giant and larger orbit may have been just enough to push Hala past the red giant's surface
and keep it from falling inside the star. However, this isn't known for certain,
and the paper finding this new mass acknowledges it's odd how their estimate was different from
previous ones, and don't try to resolve that discrepancy.
They say that in reality, Bakedu's mass is probably between 1.5 and 2 solar masses.
This large range of masses would result in many different scenarios for Hala,
some where it enters the star, and some where it doesn't. Either way, there is another potential
scenario that resolved these problems entirely, but it's now disfavored.
In 2023, it was suggested that maybe Hala was never inside the star at all,
and migrated to its current orbit. However, there's not really a way for a planet to migrate
that quickly in a system like this, so a complicated explanation for how this may
have happened was needed. And they suggested that Bakedu used to have a binary star companion that
was destroyed. In this scenario, 8 Ursae Minoris was originally a system containing a star 23%
more massive than the sun, with the companion star 86% the mass of the sun in orbit around it.
In this scenario, Bakedu is actually the smaller star. When the larger star became a red giant,
extra mass began falling onto the companion star, and it became a white dwarf. 8.6 billion years
later, the second, smaller star, Bakedu, consumed the white dwarf. This caused essentially a
premature helium flash, causing Bakedu to start burning helium before it was ready.
Basically, Bakedu's expansion was halted, leaving Hala, which is orbiting both stars, unaffected.
However, this scenario is unlikely for one major reason. For it to work, it requires the 8 Ursae
Minoris system to be at least 9 billion years old or older. However, age estimates of the system
suggest it's only 1.9 to 3.5 billion years old. It hasn't existed long enough to have this scenario
occur. So, while the scenario of Bakedu eating a white dwarf does explain the data, it's unfortunately
unlikely because there hasn't been enough time for it to happen. This leaves Hala's existence
still kind of confusing, though there are specific scenarios where it makes sense.
Again, the answer to this mystery mages me that Bakedu's mass was different than we previously
thought. But either way, I think Hala is still a super interesting planet. It doesn't have much
time left, and we know for a fact it's going to get consumed and fully destroyed by Bakedu fairly
soon. Unfortunately though, it doesn't seem like this happened to another star in the system.
And unfortunately, again, we don't know much about Hala's current or past environments.
It is likely a gas giant with a low chance of being anything larger like a brown dwarf,
but it's exact size will make it's history, present, and future very different.
Larger planets carry more internal heat, and the largest masses could easily raise Hala's
temperature by hundreds of degrees. It's exact size also determines how long it will survive
inside Bakedu, and maybe how much mass it lost if it ever was actually inside it previously.
It could also allow us to speculate on what type of moons it may have had.
If it's about 0.5 or so AU away from Bakedu and didn't migrate to where it is,
that close distance may inhibit the formation of large moon systems, but then again,
bigger planets usually have bigger moons. So if Hala had any, they could be pretty interesting.
Maybe there's a scenario where Hala was consumed by Bakedu and lost all of its moons coming out
alone. However, I should emphasize again that this is all speculation, and right now we really
have no idea what happened to Hala. There are many scenarios that could explain a strange orbit today,
not all of which involve it ever being inside Bakedu.
Being 532 light years away and around a bright star makes this a difficult planet to study,
especially because it doesn't transit from our perspective, meaning for now there's really no
way to get more data about it other than what we already have, that being its orbit and minimum
mass. Though I will also mention there's some evidence of a second planet in the system at
least 5 AU away from the star, which could correspond to a planet fairly similar to
Jupiter if the mass is right, though I can't find any information about it other than its orbit,
as it only has a roughly 67% chance of actually being at 5 AU, and its orbit is largely unconstrained.
Continuing with the system being named after mountains on the Korean peninsula,
this additional planet candidate could probably be called something like Giri, but whatever.
This planet will definitely survive the future expansion of Bakedu, assuming it exists of course.
From the best I can tell, it's very likely that the data is being created by a planetary signal,
we just don't know what its exact orbit would be to fit the data. But either way, it's probably
a gas giant, and maybe one of several planets in the 8 Earths A Minoris system we haven't detected
yet. Who knows, maybe there are other inner planets that actually did enter the star if Hala didn't.
But unfortunately this is all the information we have about this mysterious system.
A red giant that has potentially swallowed a planet that survived to tell the tale,
and has a much lower, pretty much disproven chance of having eaten a star in the past as well.
That scenario is not considered to be likely at all anymore, but it does show that there
are systems where it may be possible. And Hala, assuming it actually did enter Bakedu and the
star's true mass didn't allow it to just barely scrape by, is a very interesting planet with a
history we're only just beginning to figure out. Hopefully we can find out more information about
it soon. Thank you for watching, if you enjoyed check out my other videos about exoplanets and
space exploration.
