Many newcomers to the O and O27 gauge 3-rail hobby ask about those metal or plastic switches on the tops or bottoms of older Lionel Trains locomotives, and many experienced hobbyists know what they are, but they really don’t understand how they work. Well, never fear, because today we are diving into these ingenious devices, how they work, and some basic repair and maintenance tips, AND we’re going to troubleshoot and repair a couple of example models. If your unit seems to stick in one direction, or hums without the locomotive moving, or just works intermittently, we’ll show how you can usually fix your problem.
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
Exploring the magic, the mystery, and the mechanics of Lionel's classic E-units
on this episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
Hello again, this is Mike with another episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
And one comment that I see a lot online from newcomers to the hobby...
Especially those who are transplanted from H0 and N scales is...
What does this little lever at the top of the Lionel locomotive do?
And well, many experienced hobbyists know what this is, but they really don't know how it works.
So, never fear! In this episode, we are going to take a deep dive into Lionel's E-units.
How they work, how to maintain them, and how to do some
minor repairs to keep them running for a very long time.
Now, I'm going to save you some time because if we are looking for a video
where we do a complete overhaul...
A complete rebuild of an E-unit, say with a burned out coil or busted fingers...
This is not that video.
Now, complete overhauls can be done if you have the proper tools, the time, and the patience.
And currently, I'm 0 for 3 on those counts.
Also, if you're looking for maintenance and repair tips on the
scout type reverse mechanisms with the plastic frame motors...
I'm not really going to cover that in this video,
although I will point you in the right direction where you can find some guidance on that.
So, let's go ahead and dive in, starting with what exactly is an E-unit and what does it do?
Universal motors, such as those used by Lionel and most other toy train manufacturers
from the beginning of the 20th century until well past World War II,
can only change direction by physically changing the orientation of the motor brushes
in relation to the electromagnetic motor field.
This is true whether the motors are receiving AC or DC power.
Early motor reversing mechanisms relied on a physical switch,
either operated manually by the user or sometimes activated by a trackside lever.
In the early 1920s, a Mr. Harry Sparks, an appropriate name for an electrical engineer,
patented an electromechanical device by which a rotating metal drum
could change the orientation of the brushes through the motor field.
Think of it like a music box, but instead of the nodes on the drum
plucking metal fingers to make music, they instead complete various electrical connections to a motor.
A small solenoid held a ratchet mechanism,
that's that distinctive E-unit hum or buzz that you hear,
and when the power was interrupted, the ratchet would drop down and grab the drum
so that when power was reapplied, it would rotate the drum to the next position.
Thus, a repeating forward-reverse-forward or forward-neutral-reverse-neutral-forward
pattern could be created.
Ives Trains adopted this device, calling it an R-unit,
and began adding it to their toy train locomotives in 1924.
While this new ability to change locomotive direction
anywhere on the track by remote control was a popular innovation,
it was not enough to turn around the financial fortunes of the struggling company,
and by 1928, Ives Manufacturing came under the joint control of competitors Lionel and American Flyer.
With Flyer eventually bowing out to Lionel's full control and eventual absorption of the firm,
giving us, among other things, the Lionel Jr. line of 027 trains.
Lionel wasted no time studying, copying, and improving upon the Ives R-unit design,
and added their own distance control system to locomotives in 1929
with the use of what they called an E-unit,
a smaller and somewhat more reliable version of the Ives design.
This design remained virtually unchanged until it was fully replaced by
all-electronic reverse circuit boards in the 1990s.
Lionel used three basic reverse mechanism designs over the years.
The three-position unit, which operated much in the same way as the Ives design,
with the drum changing the orientation of the brushes through a forward-neutral reverse cycle,
and later a cheaper two-position system was introduced,
whereby the E-unit selected which of two separate motor fields were used,
each in opposition to the other.
There was also a reverse mechanism developed specifically for Lionel's
scout-type plastic-framed motors.
This design does not use a rotating drum, but instead actually rotates half of the motor housing
and the motor brushes to change the motor field.
In each design, a lockout switch can lock the motor into a single position
and bypass the reverse mechanism.
Regular E-units usually use a metal lever mounted perpendicular to the direction of travel
that can be accessed either from the top or bottom of the locomotive.
The scout lockout levers are usually plastic and are mounted parallel to the direction of travel.
Since their design is radically different from regular E-units,
I will not be discussing these here, but more information can be found by watching
this video, which is also linked in the description.
A three-position E-unit is so-called because of the three power positions,
forward, reverse, and neutral.
But actually, there are four different power positions on the E-unit drum.
In position 1 on the diagram,
power travels from the center rail pickups to contact number 1 on the E-unit,
then through contacts number 3 to the left-hand motor brush,
through the motor winding to the right-hand brush,
then back to the E-unit through contacts number 4,
to the field winding, and then to the common rails.
Position 3 is the opposite.
Center rail power enters the E-unit through contact 1,
but exits through contacts 4 to the right-hand brush,
through the armature winding in the opposite direction to the left-hand brush,
back to the E-unit through contacts number 3,
to the field winding, and finally to the common rails.
In positions 2 and 4, the E-unit receives power and hums,
but no power makes it to the motor brushes, and the locomotive remains in neutral.
Let's take a look at a Lionel Postwar No. 2026 as an example.
This model belongs to my father, and he purchased it on eBay,
only to find that the previous owner had completely removed the E-unit,
rewiring it for forward-only operation.
We ordered a replacement E-unit from the train tender,
and that's not a paid endorsement.
It's simply a great place to find Lionel Postwar parts.
This appears to be a more modern MPC-era unit, but it will fit just fine.
By the way, check a parts schematic to find out which E-unit will fit your model.
Lionel made these units in multiple configurations over the years,
and they are not interchangeable.
Anyway, we are going to get this thing back into proper operation
with the three-position reverse unit.
So, first, let's take a look at the wiring as we have it here.
So, you see that they have tied these together.
Now, if you look over here, our original wiring,
this is going to the headlight and to the smoke unit.
So, you know that this connection, this is the center rail.
This is the hot, and then these are grounded through the frame.
Grounded through the frame, grounded through the frame.
And the same thing with the E-unit.
The ground, which should be this black wire attaching to itself,
but be grounded to the frame through the attachment screw.
Okay, so here you can see what I will be doing.
The yellow wire here from the bottom is going to go to one of the brushes.
The blue wire is going to go to the other brush.
The green wire is going to come over here and attach with the motor field coil.
And then I'm going to have to run a jumper wire
from the center rail pickup and the hot for the headlight and smoke unit
to this tab here on the E-unit.
Normally, in original wiring, they would all be wired here to this tab.
But the way it has been rewired by the previous owner, they're not going to reach.
So, I'm going to need a new section of wire from here to here.
So, let's wire it up and see what happens.
Come on, melt the solder.
And so, if I did it properly, it should work even without the screw holding it in.
Because it's still grounded to the frame here.
So, let's take it over and apply some power and see what happens.
And does it work?
Neutral, forward, neutral, reverse, neutral, forward, beautiful.
The two-position E-unit is much simpler.
There are two contact positions on the drum
that send power alternately to one of the two separate field windings on the motor.
So, that's what happens when everything works well.
But sometimes things don't work well.
Or they work intermittently.
Or not at all.
How do we get a finicky old E-unit running again?
The most common solution is cleaning.
Sometimes these E-units can become oxidized or greasy or just plain gunky
after years of improper storage.
Grab a cotton swab and your favorite electrical contact cleaner
or denatured alcohol and gently clean all the contacts you can reach.
Be careful not to bend the tiny fingers.
And absolutely, under no circumstances, do not use WD-40.
It is a great product for many projects, but not this one.
Also, you may use some light grease such as Label
on the ends of the ratchet wheel shaft.
Do not get any oil on the fingers.
Next, check all the wiring connections to see if anything has come loose
or if any wires are broken.
These steps will usually get your E-unit functioning again.
But sometimes there's another issue.
For example, let's take a look at my father's N&W Bicentennial GP7 diesel.
Watch what happens here.
Let's take it apart and see what we can find.
I've untangled the wires and this one just goes to our light bulb.
That is a hot side, so that is not the problem because the headlight works.
So this one goes to one end of the motor field
and the two yellows go to either one of the brushes.
So again, it seems like...
And there's our connection to the other side of the motor field.
So that seems to be intact.
So it seems like our problem is somewhere on one of these two yellow wires
the connection to the E-unit is not functioning.
So either we have a broken wire somewhere in here
or it's not a good connection at one end or the other.
All right, so I decide to check all of the contacts.
Okay, so it should be in reverse right now.
And just taking a screwdriver and checking all the different contacts
what I find is right here we are now in reverse.
Neutral, forward, neutral, reverse.
So now I know this is my loose connection right here at the bottom of the E-unit.
So I'm going to take the E-unit apart.
I'm going to check this connection and we should be repaired.
I found that the loose connection is the yellow wire at the bottom of the E-unit.
This wire is located underneath the metal plate.
And the best way to access this wire to repair it would be to remove the metal plate.
But to do that I would have to take the E-unit casing completely apart.
Not wanting to get into that complicated a project
I instead figured that I could replicate the effect of putting the screwdriver on the contact
by using a short piece of wire to jam into the connection
making a shim and completing the electrical connection.
So I took a short piece of wire and removed the insulation from one end
left the insulation on the other end to use as a handle to properly position the wire.
All right, let's see if this worked.
Neutral, forward, neutral, reverse!
It does work!
Okay, and you see a little bit of smoke.
Don't worry about that.
That was my contact cleaner that's burning off as it cleans out there.
There's nothing wrong with the wiring on the E-unit.
So just having this little shim piece of wire here
see if you can see that a little bit better
this little piece of wire
the other end is bare
this is insulated apart so I could grab on and position it
but basically that's having the same effect as I was getting by putting my screwdriver in there.
It is bridging the electrical gap completing the circuit
so that we now have operation in both directions.
So sometimes thinking outside the box and a little bit of experimentation is all it takes.
Yes, obviously I need to replace that light bulb
but now we have bi-directional operation on the Bicentennial GP7.
By the late 1990s Lionel was using new electronic reverse units on most of their locomotives.
They are reliable, cheap, easy to maintain because there's no moving parts
and they're quiet.
There's no electromagnetic hum.
These solid-state replacements use microchips to detect the power changes
mimicking the old mechanical sequence
but with no moving parts to wear out or get dirty.
Instead of a lockout lever
there is usually an electronic slide switch to turn the unit on and off.
And there you have it folks!
From innovative Ives trains technology from a century ago
to modern solid-state components
The reverse unit is a basic part of O-gauge railroading
and will continue to be so for quite some time.
With a little bit of cleaning and preventative maintenance
these units can continue to function as designed for many many more years as well.
So, keep your trains running
and we'll catch you next time with more toy train tips and tricks.