Nature of International law

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Feb 28, 2026
Hello my dear friends how are you all today In this
video we'll be discussing the
nature of international law
This is a highly debated topic and
also a very important
one: what is the
true nature of international law and
does it truly deserve to be called law
You can say something else
about this ever hum whether the
law says so or not—basically that's the whole nature of it
From the classical perspective
today's modern viewpoint whatever
we can write as answer to this I'
ve covered everything in this video
If this topic appears
in any of your exams
you can write this entire answer in it
whatever I'll show you in the slides ahead
here we have two
basically the point we're going to discuss
s this really a law
yes this is a law and
even more important is the question: what exactly is a law
so let's explore the different aspects of this
Let's move forward and discuss what the jurists said
about what seemed right to
them in their respective times
Yes if you like this
video you can subscribe to
the channel like the video and support us
we can also share this with our friends
then this raises a debatable question about whether international law
is truly law
as legal scholars hold differing views on whether
Everyone has their own opinion
—some say this isn't law at
all it's something else others insist no no this is the true law
so we'll find out everyone's opinions in this video
ranging from accepting it
as a fully functioning legal system
to questioning its effectiveness due to the
lack of enforcement
Most people consider this to be
a complete legal system in itself
and many believe that this is
precisely what international law is
It lacks enforcement for
instance if your law is Indian law
how is law made Law is made
first and foremost by the people
The government introduces a bill
which is approved in the Lok
Sabha then moves to the Rajya Sabha and finally goes to the President
When it reaches him he signs it and it
becomes law then
finally it is published
It applies in the gazette
This is how the law works
Now that we've made the law who made it
the Parliament if the state
My point is if the state
legislature isn't being enforced we
have courts—high court district
court supreme court—available
Police officials say these are
all proper elements of a fully
functioning international law
enforcement organization we have
That's why it's being said that
look there isn't even a parliament
at the international level and we
don't have a supreme court either
There's no international police
force capable of enforcing
all these things so nothing
like that exists so this law
No it's not yet plenty of people support this
view and many others hold their own opinion
We get to know about them
one by one as we keep writing
First of all the most important thing is John Austin—
what does Austin say Pay close
attention this is your note
You can do it too—just pause take video
notes and they’ll always come in handy
It will also be useful international
law and in jurisprudence
So what do you say Austin
Austin says
that law is a command from a sovereign
backed by sanction which will be the law
No it will always be under the command of a sovereign
which will be backed by sanctions
should you fail to comply
Meaning penalties will be imposed on you now what exactly
does "sanction" mean I've made
a separate video explaining this
I'll send you the link please definitely go check
what's included under sanctions
international law okay
what is Austin's law
it is a command of sovereignty backed by sanction
and what is sovereignty
sovereignty means authority
where no external
pressure or control exists
just like India is a
sovereign state right
I've written it myself so we are sovereign
because we are free to
make our own decisions
I
can't be bound by anyone internationally
right No external pressure will affect us
He says the law is whatever
the sovereign establishes
and if it's not obeyed sanctions will follow okay
according to him law properly so called is what
he considers law
properly so called and he
referred to such commands
as the command of the
sovereign backed by a
superior political authority
positive law which he
regarded as the proper subject
of jurisprudence is precisely
that law the command tha
sovereign is the law as far as I'm concerned
that's correct if the consent
rules were not issued by a sovereign authority
then they cannot be legal rules
If they do not establish
rules and sovereign authority
then according to Austin they are not legal rules
You can say something
else but you can't
say the legal rules okay so if we do the
If one applies the test of international law then international law does not qualify
as a rule of positive law so
international law does not qualify it as such
because international law lacks
a central authority there is
no sovereign or enforcement
mechanism either so that is why
Considered as Austin's view is that
international law is
not real law but merely
positive international law which is
nothing more than international morality
It's our morality and we'
re using it as a standard
or rather we're considering
it to be our moral values
Fine fine no it's not a law according to
Austin and this point
is open to criticism
It could happen and it does happen
but what are you talking about
I'm not an authority nor an organization
so how could I be If we look at it
from a modern perspective considering the period from Austin's time to now—
Austin from 1790 to 1859 modern
international institutions
have emerged such as the
United Nations the International
Court of Justice ICC
numerous organizations have emerged at the international level
which
whose decisions you accept and which you reject
Yes sanctions are imposed on a country in various
ways now sanctions have
become extremely significant
International law as we understand it
means that if we do not accept India's laws
What will happen to me now brother I could still face FIR
Alright file another complaint then
It's slow but we know what
sanctions exist under municipal
law—now how will it play out at the international level
You'll need to watch the full
video I made about the sanctions
So just go to the button and check it out after this video
and that's how we've become our modern international
stitutions such as the UN and the
ICJ demonstrate that look there
are obligations—binding obligations
—and the UN does have the power
Hi the ICJ has the power
so this is a criticism
of Austin's theory
which many people accept
Just as Bentham Hobbes and Bufendorf
these three supporters also challenged the
legal nature of
international law dismissing
it as merely moral and ethical rules
It's fine if there are three that's okay
I hope this is also clear now let's move forward with this
Haaland a prominent
English jurist
from 1835 to
1926 was also a staunch
advocate of legal reform
positivism meaning even
that influences Austin 's
theory and Austin's theory itself is also
You'll soon see for yourself how
flawed her theory is they say it 's
as simple as this: the true law must originate from a sovereign
The authority that has the power to enforce its rules
brother should make rules
that it can actually enforce
What's the point of setting a rule if you can't even
enforce it as clearly
demonstrated by the example shown
I make my own schedule but brother I'm getting up
at six tomorrow morning and I'll be studying then
At this point I've created a proper timetable
last minute meaning I
stayed up until midnight
If you didn't even follow it yourself what good
did it do was there any
benefit to the rule for you
If you don't even follow the rules you create then there's no point
at all which is why they say: create
the rule but follow it yourself
If you don't follow the rules they
might even impose sanctions so you
must abide by them and remember
that's exactly what their term means
international law the
vanishing point of
jurisprudence is where legal principles seemingly dissolve into ambiguity
and questions about it arise directly
ey have come
many times before to describe the vanishing point of jurisprudence
by doing something like this
There have been quite a few
questions coming up both
in your LLB LLM and many other different exams right
No in the UPSC mains exam questions have
frequently appeared among
the options chosen for law
So what does this mean basically
It means vanishing point
which is the point where
two parallel lines meet
They appear to intersect
but never actually meet
It's not achievable because they're parallel lines so how
could they ever meet That's why it's called the vanishing point
—it just seems like it should disappear
International law is indeed
law but upon closer
inspection it becomes clear—no these are not laws in the true sense
at's exactly what was said
—that these parallel lines
which seemed like they should meet never actually do
So who is the vanishing point of
jurisprudence International law In
international law both parties are
judges of their own cause Both parties
Each person is their own judge in their own cause and this
is a legal principle by analogy so
these small words here you see—
I've prepared a table just for you—please
take a look at it it
includes all the jurists
and about them the lines I 've
written regarding what
they actually meant by international law in practice
ey proved quite helpful to you
international law
is not the subject matter of jurisprudence
you observe that the rules of international law are
We follow courtesy and we will follow it as long
as there is goodwill if there is no goodwill we won’t but if there is then we will
They're going simple
thing is it's fine with
Holland now onward now we come to J G Star
from the Inka period
until 1911 to 2006
okay they say that international law
Bro the true legal system is inherently its own justification — so
why is that To explain this we've been
given four points four basic arguments
The initial argument
is that international
law is a legal system because it
is claimed to consist of binding rules
and principles that govern state conduct
Today's international law provides
binding rules and principles
that every state recognizes and
conforms its domestic law accordingly
It also creates him doesn't it
Just like the UDHR the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights according to which we have
I believe our country should also have
laws for human rights just like this
Despite many countries witnessing it no
one pays attention to international law
There are binding rules brother
so create your own according
to them—no one’s watching just make internal rules bu
They are followed by established rules and
recognized under the ICJ
Statute which states in
Article 38 that these rules are enforced through
international courts via treaties and customs
The international court exists
to enforce treaties and customs
but that doesn't mean it operates in the way one might assume
There isn't a koi system at all—this is
a proper legal system of its own isn't it
Second enforcement mechanisms do exist—through
diplomatic pressure
sanctions judicial
enforcement and
self-help measures among parties
They can retaliate they can take
countermeasures states can do so
whether it's the WTO ICC ICJ or
sanctions sanctions are in place
When it comes to international law these issues are
crucial and enforcement is what ultimately makes
the law effective he argued noting that domestic
law also faces significant enforcement challenges
Absolutely right if
you're going to enforce
the law then domestic law enforcement too
My struggle is this: there are so many laws
but they're never enforced
—just look at it now
Think about it at your level
like you ride a two-wheeler right
You've got all the rules set in place for your two-wheeler
When you're walking you
shouldn't be wearing
sleepers—proper protective gear is essential
gears should be worn including a helmet
which is yours if your
two-wheeler has one
Without side mirrors it's
also illegal—so all these rules
exist but how are they enforced Helmets for instance—
Shiva No because the helmet is visible from the
door and that means it's
important so he's on his way
Next have you ever seen someone wearing
slippers and still managing to do something
He's riding a two-wheeler so
it's unusual for it not to have
side mirrors extremely rare meaning it's not even comparable
It's a law but enforcement isn't really
happening so what's the point of following it
Domestic law also struggles
with enforcement so if you don't
keep it on that platform their
argument makes perfect sense
That's correct you should look ahead
Today international law regulates
far more than just states—
international law
now encompasses a
wide range of actors beyond states
governing is required and
it governs organizations
multinational corporations and individuals alike
They come within his range
and since he has such
a wide scope how can you possibly challenge him
You're only seeing it on states but
it's also happening to individuals
to organizations to multinational corporations—plenty of them
It seems to be focused on these three points: first they
presented your point second they highlighted
the difference between domestic and
They often say that
international law has no
legislature no parliament
and no centralized authority
No unlike in our national
legal systems we accept this
however he argued that this
does not negate its legal nature
This does not mean
it lacks legal nature
at all it simply functions differently
—far better than claiming international
law merely functions differently
municipal law serves a different
function yet it is still part of the same
system thus the conclusion drawn here
is that international law is indeed law
its true sense as compared to
municipal law it is undoubtedly wea
That's a great term to remember international law is
still law even if it's weak
— that's a separate issue
They’ve long been gone
Roscoe Pound—his tenure 70 and 64—what he’s done
look now it’s
all behind us
Pound viewed international law as an
evolving system that
gains legitimacy through
social acceptance
meaning that if society
accepts the law then it is indeed law
e argued that international law is a
law because states and global actors
follow it in practice anything that is
followed by people in practice is law
They've been insisting we haven't let go of our stance
so its legal value has expired
that's all it really means
You're absolutely right—when we say law as
a social control what do we really mean by international law Law
as a social control that's the essence
This is the complete chart starting from the beginning — you'll understand everything clearly Everything that might have been missed
is also fully covered here
Hi as Austin said positive morality
is not true law it is positive
morality because it lacks sanction
and enforcement as Holland pointed out
vanishing point of jurisprudence
Hart says is an imperfect
legal system because it has
primary rules and primary rules mea
It's an obligation but not a secondary
rule—secondary rules were not what
they said about enforcement enforcement
isn't the point here so that's settled
Hart says Kelsen claims that the true legal
system is international law which serves as
the supreme norm and it is this principle
that we look to when assessing today's states
Municipal laws are
banned so Kelson
said this Grotius stated it is
based on natural law principles
meaning it is universal and binding
It operates based on the
principle of natural law
international law independent of state consent
as George Zelenik states that international law
functions according to the will of the state
The state is saying it 's
voluntary but if you
don't comply it won't
work—simple Oppenheim
ey say this is a
functional legal system
that regulates relations between states
even without centralized enforcement so
how can they not consider it functional
The legal system maintains that
J G Stark asserts it is a genuine
legal system absolutely as we
have studied previously and indeed
Roscoe Pound a social
tool works because society
accepts it if it weren't
accepted it wouldn't function
at won't work that wasn 't
called law so I hope
this is also clear you've made the entire char
you can still take a screenshot
you've already taken it
so this is the end of this video and if you liked this video
If you liked it please like share
it with friends and subscribe
to the channel I'll be back soon—stay tuned bye thank you
