Introduction to International Law Part-I

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
1 Video View·Sep 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAhmad Sarwar introduces a lecture series on International Law, focusing on its definition and the debate over its legal status. He explains that while International Law lacks the centralized enforcement of national law, it remains a valid legal system recognized by states to regulate the conduct of states, international organizations, and individuals.
Hello, my name is Ahmad Sarwar.
I teach Law at UCL Tims.
And today we are going to start a lecture series on International Law from SCOPE CSS Club's YouTube channel.
In this lecture series, we will discuss all the major chapters of International Law.
And we will also discuss the problematic issues in each chapter,
which are frequently asked in exams.
Today's lecture is an introduction.
This introduction will be divided into three parts.
In the first part, we will discuss two things.
The first thing is what is International Law?
What is its definition?
And along with this, there is a very old debate in International Law.
Is International Law truly law or not?
We will discuss that as well.
As far as the question is concerned, what is international law?
If you examine all the definitions of International Law,
They basically say the same thing.
International law comprises the laws and rules
which are designed to regulate the behavior of the states.
In this definition, there has been a slight change over time.
And that change has occurred because
now, in the current situation,
There are not only state actors at the international level.
There are also international organizations.
In addition to this, there are also NGOs.
Individuals also have rights under international law.
Thus, the contemporary definition of International Law
basically states that states, international organizations
or any other actor operating at the international level,
The laws made to regulate their conduct are international law.
International law covers almost all issues at the international level.
Law of the Sea, Law of War and Peace
International Trade and Commercial Law
There is a law governing all international transactions.
Now, there are two debates in international law.
One debate is whether International Law is truly law or not.
And the second debate concerns the enforcement of international law.
That its enforcement is very weak.
That is why its enforcement is heavily criticized.
It is sometimes referred to as the weak law.
With regard to the first question,
Whether International Law is really law or not.
This question is raised because
Our understanding of the law has been developed through national laws.
We see that there is a parliament at the national level.
which makes laws.
In addition, we have an executive body.
which implements and enforces laws.
Then we have courts.
If any dispute arises, you shall go to those courts.
And the decisions of those courts are also binding.
They are also enforced by the executive authority.
But at the international level,
We do not see such developed institutions or systematic procedures.
There is no parliament at the international level.
Apart from this, there is no international police force or executive body at the international level.
which enforces international laws.
And the jurisdiction of the international courts and tribunals
and their rules and procedures are very different from those of national courts.
That is why people believe international law is not real law.
And because the enforcement of international law is very weak,
Its enforcement is heavily criticized.
We have seen that even in the last century,
especially during the Cold War
and even since the beginning of this century,
There have been numerous violations of international law.
The answer to this question in this debate is essentially that
The first point is that
if you want to determine whether International Law is law or not,
Then why are you setting National Law as a benchmark?
Why are we judging international law based on national law?
We raise this question because
The rationale of national law differs from that of international law.
National law is applied to individuals.
We see that individuals and communities hold a higher authority,
Which is the Parliament?
It makes laws, and then those laws are enforced upon individuals.
Thus, we observe a hierarchy at the national level.
There is no such hierarchy at the international level.
At the international level, we see that states are legally equal.
The laws that are made there,
or the manner in which the laws are enforced,
are based on the coordination and cooperation of the states.
They are not subject to any higher authority.
And at the international level,
Neither is it desirable nor is it possible.
that you can establish such a higher authority
Or you can establish a hierarchy at the international level.
So national law is operating in a different domain.
and international law is functioning in a different domain.
So making National Law a benchmark
to determine whether International Law is a law or not,
It is wrong.
The second point in this is that
International law exists.
The reason for this is that
all the states that are the primary subjects of international law
Accept that international law exists.
No state claims that international law does not exist.
Whenever a state violates international law,
Its breach is criticized.
And it is not criticized on moral or ethical grounds.
For example, in 2003, the United States invaded Iraq.
All the states that misunderstood the invasion
Did not say that the invasion is immoral.
Everyone said that the invasion was unlawful.
If you are calling something unlawful,
Then you will say it is based on a law.
That law is international law concerning war and peace.
In addition, the states that violate international law
Do not claim that they reject international law.
They also attempt to justify their actions according to international law.
Finally, we see that
all the foreign offices in the states
have international legal experts.
All the states on a daily basis
Judge their actions in accordance with international law.
Then there is the implementation of international law.
in their domestic courts.
So this is a strong proof that international law exists.
The third point is that
if there are breaches of international law,
then in the majority of cases,
There is an obligation under international law.
But publicity is given to those incidents
where there is a breach of international law.
That is why we feel that
if there is a breach of international law,
Then it is enforced heavily.
The fourth point is in the context of enforcement.
We just discussed that.
The enforcement of international law is very weak.
For this reason, International Law is criticized.
that there is no law at all.
The answer to this is that
if the enforcement of a law is not carried out properly
or enforcement is weak,
Does that mean there is no law at all?
The laws that we refer to as law at the national level
are referred to as law at the international level
because individuals regard those laws as law.
They are the subjects of that law.
They also believe that there is a higher body.
which is the parliament
and that higher body has the right to make laws
and enforce those laws.
That is why the laws that the parliament makes
are considered to be law.
The second point in the context of enforcement
is that if the enforcement of a law is weak,
It does not mean that it is not a law.
It means that there is a problem with its obedience.
The enforcement of law is related
to the obedience to the law.
If a law is not being properly implemented
at the national level
Then we do not say that it is not a law.
We say that there is a problem in the enforcement of this law.
and it should be improved.
Similarly, if there is a problem in the enforcement of international law,
Then it is a matter of enforcement.
We cannot say that it is not a law.
Yes, we can say that it is a weak law.
and its enforcement should be criticized.
But if more institutions are developed at the international level
and its enforcement should be strengthened,
Then it will be better.
The fifth point pertains to lawmaking.
It is true that there is no parliament or higher body in international law.
We have discussed that.
But it does not mean that there is no international law-making.
Following this introduction,
We will study the sources of international law.
We will see how international laws are made.
There is a platform called the United Nations General Assembly.
It provides a platform for the states.
where they can enact laws through coordination and cooperation.
They can sign treaties.
But it is true that there is no parliament at the international level.
This is the layout of this debate.
We can conclude this debate.
by stating that international law exists
but it is not the same as national law.
The principles and rationales of national law differ.
from those of international law.
But it is true that international law
exists as a legal system.
This was today's lecture.
The first part of the introduction.
In the next part, we will discuss
How international law is enforced
and its problems.
We will meet again in the next lecture.
Thank you.
