Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/ivqmri • 🏘️ Find a Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Agent - https://ramsey.solutions/uzkxqr • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Connect with our Sponsors: - Learn more about Christian Healthcare Ministries ⮕ https://www.chministries.org/budget - Get 20% off when you join DeleteMe ⮕ https://www.joindeleteme.com/Ramsey - Call 844-2-RAMSEY to get started with YRefy ⮕ https://www.Yrefy.com/Ramsey - Visit Zander Insurance for your free instant quote today ⮕ https://www.zander.com/ - If you want your car to keep going and going, trust Christian Brothers Automotive. Find a local shop and get an exclusive Ramsey discount of 10% off.
If your private student loans are in default, you're not out of options. Go to whyrefi.com
slash Ramsey. My mom helped me take out some parent plus loans. They are all under her name.
I went to college, about $36,000 worth, with a verbal agreement from me that I would help her
pay them back. But now that it is time for me to pay them back, because I am out of college
and they are coming due, she is requesting the $36,000 payment in full. But when I look back on
my tuition bills, she received $17,000 in refunds that she never put back towards the loans. So I'm
trying to figure out how to start that conversation of I am not paying you $36,000. I am only going to
the amount that I used. It's been interesting and I don't know how to start that conversation.
Okay. Can we cut right to the chase here? I hate to say this. This one hurts to say.
Your mom is deceiving you. She's lying to you.
Yeah.
I just have a personal rule that if I'm dealing with somebody who lacks integrity,
A, I'm going to make sure I don't lose my character in the process. And B,
I'm going to be very clear about what I will and will not do. And I will see that through.
Because trying to preserve the relationship, she's already burned it to the ground.
She's trying to extort you for $17,000 more.
Wild.
Yeah.
Right? That's madness. A parent of integrity. If I did this with my kid, I would say,
hey, dude, I actually spent $17,000 on my own. You owe me this much money.
It's a lot. It's not a number that you forgot. Like, oh, I forgot I did that.
A lot of money.
Honestly, I would print the bill out and go sit with her and say, this is what was paid for my
bill. I don't know how much you ended up taking out or how much you had deposited into your
accounts. Where's the other $17,000?
Yeah. Yeah. She did let me log into her like parent plus loan portal so I can see how much
she really did take out for me and all of my sisters. But I had a feeling because then that
would have made my schooling a total of $64,000 for three years. And I only went to a state school.
So that price didn't really make sense. Plus I was like in state. So I did some research and
now I have to figure out how to have this conversation.
You got math on your side. You have bills and math on your side. I think it's a pretty
straightforward conversation when it comes to the what you owe. I think it's a harder
conversation about what her choice to lie to you has done to your relationship.
I'm trying to find any reason this might be different. Is there any way that like
did she buy you a car during that time?
She paid your car insurance and your food and rent?
So I lived at home. There was one year I did move out and lived off campus with some roommates,
but I paid my rent. I also paid my cell phone bill to her. She did buy a plan for me.
You're breaking up on us, Claire.
Yeah, you're cutting out on us.
Okay.
Oh, there you go. Now you're back.
You lived at home, you paid rent, but there was one time when what?
She bought a meal plan for me.
A meal plan?
Yeah.
Okay.
It was like $2,000 and I figured if it became a super big issue, I would offer to pay that back
too.
Listen, if meal plan is part of school, I might add that back in and say that. Say,
hey, I looked it up. Here's what I found. Slider the paper like they do when you make a negotiation
and say, now I do know that there was the one semester where you paid for my meal plan. I know
that that was $2,000. I don't know if that's part of this. I don't see it. Try to have some goodwill
there, I think, but I agree with what John said, man. This is dirty.
I hate this for you.
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, I'm sorry.
I would commit walking in the door to what your boundaries are going to be on this one
and play it as straight as possible. And the best you can,
this is going to be hard because it's your freaking mom.
It's your mother.
But keep your wits about you and keep your integrity and keep your character and
don't yell, don't scream, don't make accusations. Just be very clear.
And luckily for you, this is all tracked, right? You can see what she took out.
You can actually probably go to the college and get the bill that was transferred,
the day bills were paid. I mean, you can do a little bit of forensic
accounting here and figure out exactly what she paid and exactly what she kept for herself.
Wow. Shouldn't have to be like that.
Jade, I've heard this over and over and over again, working with college students.
I feel like we are in the era of the parent plus loan.
I feel like we are getting so many calls about that.
I don't know if it just happened in that decade.
It's not the era, it's the bills are coming due for that era.
Oh my gosh. And I just, yeah. I mean, obviously if you sign a parent plus loan,
the parent is the one on the loan. And usually what's gone awry here is
there is some sort of verbal agreement, either you will pay or you won't pay.
And then the time passes and inevitably someone forgot.
Either someone forgot or- They change it.
If you're in a position where you need to borrow a ton of, so much money that you need to
get a full Stafford loan and get a parent plus loan, then you're in a financial situation that's
already challenging. And when they write you a blank check and they're like,
hey, we're going to send you 20 and the bill's only 15.
It takes another level of integrity, another level of discipline to not spend that five.
Oh yeah. Because it feels like it just got
free deposited. That's a problem for future us, we'll deal with it later.
Yeah. And my daughter's going to be rich one day,
she can cover it. And that's not the agreement we made.
It's not, it's not. Plus it's a fraudulent use of student loan
money to be honest with you, but- 100% it is, yes.
Jade, I cannot tell you how often I heard this story from college students.
Parents would take out loans in their children's name and use that money to pay for stuff around
the house or whatever. Yes.
And it just became an off book stimulus program in a way.
Yeah. Because you get the amount of money needed for, that's allotted to you for the semester.
The semester, so say you get, I don't know, I'm making this up. Say you get $7,000,
but you only needed $5,000. The quote refund, $2,000 just sitting there. It's like, well,
I may as well take it. It's real hard to not-
Man. And so-
Not send that money back. What's the moral of the story children,
to check your bill and make sure that your parents aren't jacking you?
I think anytime you go into an agreement with somebody you care about-
Yeah. And there is financial borrowing in between
you two, just expect that that relationship is going to get sideways at some point.
It's going to. And the best thing you can do, if you are listening and you're like, oh crap,
I think I have parent plus loans. And I think that this could end up being me.
Try to jump on, like, don't wait, don't wait. Talk to that person today and say,
what's the deal with this? If you're thinking about taking out those types of loans,
of course, I'm going to tell you don't do it. Please just stop in the name of love.
And I know it's a tough conversation because let's take a minute and talk about this. College
is expensive. It's filled with expectations on the student end and the parent end, right?
How many parents get so much pride over saying which school-
My kid goes to this school, yep.
Yes.
And then there's the student who is probably in one of the most emotional periods of their life
making this decision. And it's like, this is where all my friends are going. And don't you
want me to have this college experience?
College has tuned the sales cycle to a 17 or 18-year-old's feelings.
Yes.
Right? You hear college students say, this was the one.
Right, like they're choosing their-
And then parents are like, all right, well, I got to mortgage my soul because they found the one.
Yeah.
Right? It's madness. It's madness.
It's madness. And then there's the element of, I guess I'm going to call it some sort of shame
because what we're finding is a lot of parents are taking out parent plus loans and not telling
the student that they did it, not telling them that that's the way that this whole thing is being
funded. And then it comes back to bite in the butt later. So guys, our teaching on this is so solid
and so clear. If you can go to college, pay cash. Okay? And I know that that sounds, what Jade,
you've lost your mind. No, the way to do it is you have to start talking about it before you're 17.
You have to start talking about it very, very early, setting that expectation. Yes,
you're going to school if it suits you because maybe college life doesn't even suit you for
the career that you want. That's another conversation, but make sure it said, Hey,
you don't have a college fund. We may not have a five 29. We expect you to work part time,
or we expect that you'll go to a community college, whatever that is. Parents,
please have that conversation. There's no shame in that game. It is a privilege.
If you are able to pay for kids college, and it is a privilege for both the parent and the student.
Why refi refinances, defaulted private student loans for struggling borrowers.
Learn more at why refy.com slash Ramsey.