NEW! Was There a Second Great Sphinx at Giza - Ancient Architects

Ancient World
292 followers
Hello everybody and welcome to Ancient Architects. Please subscribe to the channel for regular
content on ancient architecture as well as all the latest news from the world of archaeology.
For decades now the hypothesis there was once a second Sphinx as a counterpart to the Great
Sphinx has been popular amongst alternative researchers, but the evidence has always been
lacking. Many have looked for it and many believe they know where it is, or at least
where it once was, so now I've taken a closer look at all of the claims as I independently
evaluate their credibility.
And so far there are three main contenders for its location. The first one is right here,
just north of the Great Sphinx and facing east. The second is right here and facing
west. And the third is on the other side of the Nile facing the Giza Plateau. And of
course there's a fourth option as well, that no second Sphinx ever existed.
But if the evidence is lacking, why do we even consider the possibility? Well of course
proponents think there is enough evidence worthy of investigation, and they often point
to the famous Dreamstealer between the paws of the Great Monument, because it shows not
one but two Sphinx statues back to back, thinking it could well be a representation
of what once existed on the Giza Plateau. But I have to say that this as evidence is
pretty unconvincing, because the Dreamstealer is not the only Stealer found at Giza that
shows the Sphinx. Many dozens more have been discovered, and the vast majority only show
one Sphinx statue. The two Sphinxes we see on the Dreamstealer are not meant to be taken
as a literal representation of what was once on the Giza Plateau. They're both portraying
the same god, Horemakhet, who was known as the Sphinx God in the New Kingdom. Also, every
Sphinx Stealer from Giza placed the god on a raised plinth, and of course this isn't
an accurate portrayal of the Great Sphinx, because it's cut from the bedrock below
ground level. It's the opposite to being placed on a plinth or pedestal. It's sunken
in the ground. The Dreamstealer was created in the 18th Dynasty for Pharaoh Thutmose IV,
but it wasn't an accurate picture of Giza. It's showing Thutmose IV making offerings
to Horemakhet, both in the East and the West. And that's because Horemakhet means Horus
of the Horizon, and there are two horizons, one for the rising sun and one for the setting.
The god is also known as Horakti, meaning Horus of the Two Horizons, aka the sunrise
and the sunset. The Sphinxes on the Stele both represent the one god and not two, in
the same way that the people on the Stele are both Thutmose IV.
Nobody looks at the Dreamstealer and goes hunting for two pharaohs called Thutmose IV.
They accept that what we're looking at are two representations of the one king, yet can't
accept we're looking at two representations of one Sphinx.
If you use the Dreamstealer as evidence for two Sphinxes, I can only assume we have to
use it as evidence for two Thutmose IV pharaohs as well.
But anyway, without going into too much detail, the hieroglyphs on the Dreamstealer do not
say or even imply there were two Great Sphinx statues. And so, what other evidence do people
have? Why do we even bother looking for a second Sphinx in the first place?
Well, people look at the Avenue of Sphinxes at Karnak as evidence that Sphinxes come in
pairs, one facing another. And apparently this is to emphasise the belief in duality,
a fundamental worldview balancing opposing forces to maintain cosmic order against chaos.
Duality was apparently important to the ancient Egyptians. Geographically speaking, there
was an Upper Egypt and a Lower Egypt. There were also two crowns in one for the king.
The pharaoh was the lord of the two lands. The soul had a car and a bar. There was divine
order in Mart and chaos in Isfet. Gods were often paired, for example Horus and Set.
In Egyptian mythology, it's said that Artem created his son Shu and his daughter Tefnut,
shaping them as a lion and lioness, and placing each one at the extreme tips of the universe.
And in Egyptian art, we also see Acre Lions or Acre Sphinxes back to back in pairs, with
the rising sun between them. Heracti was Horus of the two horizons. The rising sun and the
setting sun were both significant to the ancient Egyptians. And so, if the Great Sphinx looks
out to the rising sun, maybe there was once another looking out to the setting sun.
That is a lot of random mixed up evidence, but people often use it to justify the possibility
of a second Sphinx. But does it really all mean we should be looking for one?
Well, in truth, the idea of a second Sphinx is just theoretical. There's really nothing
tangible to imply there were ever two Great Sphinx statues at Giza. No text or archaeological
discovery at Giza suggests there were ever two Great Sphinx monuments, and so it's
really just hypothesis, and it has no real substance. There's no real reason to even
start looking. When the vast majority of Sphinx stele only show one monument, and when the
famous inventory stele only speaks of one monument, and when we know both of these figures
on the dream stele are Thutmose IV, well, it seems pretty clear to me there was only
ever one Great Sphinx. There's no real evidence there were two. But of course, the archaeological
record is not complete. Of course, I could be wrong. But right now, there's no evidence
to say I am. But Jerry Cannon and Malcolm Hutton would certainly disagree.
In their book, The Giza Plateau Secrets and a Second Sphinx Revealed, they apparently
show exactly where they believe it is or was on the Giza Plateau. Like everyone who believes
the idea of two Sphinxes, they use the dream stele as evidence, which as I've said is
extremely questionable. And even though the stele shows two Sphinxes back to back, Hutton
and Cannon place their two Sphinxes on the Giza Plateau side by side, which in itself
is totally at odds with their so-called evidence. They present more evidence than just the dream
stele for there being two Sphinxes at Giza. But in truth, there's nothing concrete.
There are no specific finds, sources or texts and it just comes down to opinion. For example,
they note that pairs of lions are often seen in Egyptian art, but in truth, such depictions
have no bearing on the Giza Necropolis. But anyway, they believe the second Sphinx is
located right here, beneath an apparently unexplored mound on the Giza Plateau. And
on diagrams they show the Great Sphinx and the mound in relation to the Khafre Pyramid,
showing there is some kind of symmetry. And whilst this isn't the worst place to put
a second Great Sphinx, it doesn't quite work. As many of us know, in relation to their
architectural achievements, many often mention the Egyptians' mathematical precision. But
with that in mind, the second Sphinx would need to be a little further north for any
perfect symmetry. If we're looking at the relationship with
the Great Sphinx and the Khafre Pyramid, it should be exactly where we find some Old Kingdom
mastabas. Placing it here, under this mound, makes it asymmetrical in relation to the Khafre
Pyramid and the Great Sphinx, and it would just look, well, a bit off.
And then we have the biggest problem, the causeway. The causeway to the Khafre Pyramid
is the sacred walkway to the Pyramid from the Valley Temple, so surely any second Sphinx
monument, if we're aligning it with the Khafre Pyramid, should be right here, on the
opposite side of the causeway. This would look the best, and with regards to the Khafre
mortuary complex, it would make the most sense. Entering the causeway and having a Sphinx
on your left and right would look amazing, far better than having two Sphinxes on the
right, the second of which being over 150 metres away.
And just to add, this so-called mound looks to be just a standard piece of Giza bedrock,
just a part of the plateau that's covered with sand. There is no evidence there's
any kind of monument beneath. No historian, no document, no diagram and no myth or legend
has ever placed an enormous second Sphinx monument right here. In my opinion, this is
all just wishful thinking and guesswork, and so I think it's time to move on.
And so we go to the second possible location, the one that's most talked about on the
internet, an idea proposed by Dr Reeder Abdul Halim. This outcrop of limestone bedrock
is located adjacent to the tomb of Ken Kawas in Giza's central field. And yes, from this
angle, but only this angle, the mind is tricked enough to think this looks a bit like a Sphinx.
This right here is the head, this bit is the front paws and this is the monument's back.
Dr Halim notes that only one side of it is carved, and he says the other side is possibly
buried or unfinished. He says the head is badly damaged by time, but he can't help
but notice the similarities between what he calls the first and second Sphinx.
Of course, whenever anybody presents a new theory or hypothesis, they present the evidence
in the best light possible, to make their ideas sound as credible as possible.
Dr Halim explains how it's close to the tomb of Queen Ken Kawas, a queen who he wrongly
says is the wife of King Khafre, because in reality she is more likely the granddaughter
of Khafre, daughter of Menkaure and wife of Yusakath.
But anyway, the important thing is the second Sphinx is close to important royal tombs,
so it is in a good location for prominence. He says that at Giza, both Sphinxes are the
oldest known large sculptures carved out of the bedrock, both of them with a length of
about 73.5 metres from front paws to tails. But, sorry to say that this is not accurate,
and for two reasons. Firstly, the so-called second Sphinx is a
Secondly, it's clearly not a sculpture in any definition of the word. Just look at this
part of the bedrock on Google Earth. The northern side of this so-called Sphinx is still attached
to the bedrock. There are no paws in front of the so-called head, just natural beds of
limestone unevenly eroded by nature. Old Kingdom burial pit entrances are clearly seen in the
top of the outcrop. Again, this only looks like a Sphinx when you're stood right here,
when you're looking in a west-northwesterly direction. When looking from any other direction
it looks nothing like a Sphinx. It really is just smoke and mirrors. It's clickbait,
because nothing about this says Sphinx. And one more thing, to call this an eroded
head really is wishful thinking. In my opinion, nothing about it looks head-like at all. It's
just a natural wind-eroded ventifact. I was lucky enough to visit this outcrop known as GCF1 in 2023,
and I can honestly say, after looking at it from every possible angle, there is nothing
Sphinx-like about it. It really is just a bedrock outcrop. This channel was cut through the bedrock
to isolate the tomb of Ken Kawus, maybe when the site was just an active quarry in the
Old Kingdom, and the tomb of Ken Kawus was an original quarry block. When the quarrying
was all done, tombs were built into the outcrop with entrances cut into the southern face.
And now, if we go back to Google Earth, let's look at the position of Dr Halim's second
Sphinx in relation to the wider Giza landscape. There is clearly no obvious alignment or relationship
with the Khafre or Menkaure pyramids. It's position is too random to be designated a
major monument. I can't see any reason for a second Sphinx facing west to be built right
here. Nothing about GCF1 screams Sphinx. Well, nothing apart from this one specific photograph
taken at this one specific angle, and even this is dubious. If I was going to have a second Sphinx
on the Giza plateau, to have some kind of relationship with the first, there are only
two places I would put it. Right here facing east next to the Great Sphinx on the southern side of
the causeway, in front of the Valley Temple. Or here, facing west at the opposite end of the
causeway. Any other location just really doesn't work. So, for me personally, the first two locations
for a second Sphinx can be completely dismissed. But there is one final location we do need to
consider, because it's mentioned in sources that often get overlooked. According to Akasha Eldali,
in Egyptology, The Missing Millennium, Ancient Egypt in Medieval Arabic Writings,
there was an old tradition of a second Sphinx on the eastern bank of the River Nile,
and this second Sphinx was facing west. Apparently, it was mentioned by 12th century scholar Aladrizi,
who said there was a second mudbrick Sphinx, a female, on the eastern bank of the River Nile
in a very bad state of repair. It was made of mudbrick but faced with stone, but most of this
stone had been removed, making it a ruin. Furthermore, in the 12th century AD, the Nile
was apparently lapping at its feet. Another writer said in 1224 AD that there was another
small Sphinx across the Nile from the large one, but it was in a ruined state of brick and stone.
Apparently, Naziri Khosrau visited Egypt in 1047 AD and heard rumours of a second Sphinx
but never saw it. Another Arab source apparently says there's a large statue of a female and a
young male and it faced the Great Sphinx, and they called this female the Sphinx's wife.
And so, whilst there are a few historical sources, it still isn't the best evidence to work from.
No details of any specific location were mentioned by the chroniclers, there were
no specific measurements of the second Sphinx, and with the eastern bank of the Nile being more
than 9km from Giza, well, even if there was a second Sphinx, it's hard to say there was any
kind of real tangible relationship. 1,000 years ago, the River Nile was further west than it is
today, but no more than a kilometre, meaning the opposite side of the Nile was still at least 8km
from Giza. But as we know from recent discoveries, when the Great Sphinx was standing proud in Old
Kingdom Egypt, it was looking out over a now defunct branch of the Nile, the western branch
of the Nile which is now known as the Khufu branch. This has now long since dried up,
silted over and built upon. The branch was also long gone in the days of Al-Idrisi,
and so with regards to the location of the second Sphinx, I don't think they're referring to the
east bank of the Khufu branch of the Nile, as they wouldn't have known it even existed.
In the 12th century, Al-Idrisi said the Nile was lapping at the feet of the second Sphinx,
and so with the continued migration of the river to the east over time, if Al-Idrisi was correct,
any second Sphinx is now long gone, eroded and erased by the River Nile.
When everything is investigated, all I can give is my opinion, and it's based on the level of
knowledge we currently have. Right now there is nothing on the Giza Plateau that could be
a second Sphinx. There's no good reason to think there is one right here and this patch of bedrock
only looks like a possible Sphinx when we're looking from one very obscure angle. From every
other orientation including from above, it has no semblance to a Sphinx whatsoever.
The only possible option is the Sphinx mentioned by the Arab chroniclers
that there was once a Sphinx-like monument on the other side of the River Nile.
But due to the distance between Giza and the eastern bank of the Nile in 11-1200 AD,
it is a bit of a stretch to say the monuments had any kind of real relationship,
although I guess it's not impossible. A lot of Arab chroniclers are known for often giving
somewhat inaccurate accounts of history. They're not the most reliable, and what is sometimes
written to sound like fact, could often be just hearsay folklore or legend. Either way,
with the migrating channel of the River Nile, the remains of any second Sphinx are now firmly lost
forever. I think unless a new ancient text is uncovered, or a compelling new archaeological
discovery comes to light, the hypothesis of a second Sphinx can now firmly be put to bed.
Maybe there was a monument on the other side of the Nile, or maybe not. But either way,
I'm afraid to say, now we'll never know. Thank you very much for watching this episode
of Ancient Architects. If you enjoyed the video, please subscribe to the channel,
please like the video, and please leave a comment below. Thank you very much.
