🌍North Sea Continental Shelf Case 1969 - Explained

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
3 Video Views·Feb 25, 2026
Explore the historic ICJ judgment in the North Sea Continental Shelf Cases (Germany v. Denmark & Netherlands).
This case established key principles of customary international law, the equitable principle, and clarified how maritime boundaries should be drawn under UNCLOS. Ideal for law students and international law enthusiasts.
Hey today we're diving into another important case from our International Cases series
The case known as the North Sea Continental Shelf Case
Ninety-eight nine
Alright I've put together the entire playlist for international listeners
For this today we'll explain exactly what happened in this case using simple language
How did the continental shelf case come about and how has this case progressed
So let's begin with the torn fabric and move on to its first slide
First of all you'll understand the name
What's the name It's North C so we're talking about North C
There's always some dispute over the continental shelf which is why the case arose in the first place
Alright this is the 1969 case
Okay this is clear
You understand the background behind this image don't you
First understand the overview of this once
There are three countries in this basically
Germany Denmark and the Netherlands Alright
Germany Denmark and the Netherlands are on
the same side
Because both of them are accepting the same principle
In the entire case
and which side did the other party end up on
Germany became the
issue after that
Regarding my time boundaries
A complete topic has been created
UN Clause
During the lockdown season
Decide one way or the other sooner or later
You'll fully understand it then
What is the law of the sea
How we expand the boundaries
How we have agreed on what we've agreed upo
What is laughter and what is not
Everything is covered in it
I had already told him that
There are so many things
Meaning if a storm is beginning to brew
The boundary of Cargo India is
The international law on looting will no longer apply right from that point onward
We are given a certain buffer zone
Every country that has
an ocean that's right
Treat your own area up to twenty nautical miles as such
Just as you treat your lending area
Alright after that
Next twelve nautical miles have separate rules
Up to 200 nautical miles
There are separate rules for it we
call it an EEZ—Exclusive Economic Zone
After that the high season begins
You can go and watch that video yourself
Now let's discuss this case
So here are three countries
Now they're at odds over his continental shelf
The issue is now why this issue exists
See an issue arises only
when there's barren land
Fights always happen only when necessary
When the fight is over something
It has some value
The area here now
Oil and gas reserves are present
Therefore these three countries have arrived
Because we need it
First understand this:
at these three parties are
They are signatories to
the 1958 Geneva Convention
And at that convention
What is written there we'll understand further ahead
But understand here that not all three are
It has been signed
All three have accepted the treaty
What is a catch
Germany did not confirm it
Now if you're signing up and verifying your account
I don't know what it means so I've
A large number of international lock-in videos
If you understand the meaning of both of these then you're Saroo
Let us know in the comment section so the rebels among everyone can see it
Help is welcome that's fine
For now from this slide we've understood that there are three countries
He's the brother and he's got their back
What's the fuss about now
They all get along well together
Regarding the continental shelf
See what happens
if there are two countries between
The ocean is vast incredibly so
Then there's no issue at all
But the issue arises then
When the central area of the ocean is involved
It's a limited one
if both of you are 200
Want to go up to nautical miles
Imagine the ocean between them
It's just three hundred nautical miles
You both need to file claims of 200 each
That won't work out at all
They will overflow the ocean as they come face to face
That's where the pangas will begin
If that area is a
very end and rich area
There are oil and natural gas reserves there so
So now you understand don't you
There's also a story unfolding between these three
We'll go through each item one by one to make sure nothing is missed
Please take note of this
Highlight the Equi-distance Method
We will adopt the Equi Distance Method
Between them was a multilateral treaty
Now the Equi Distance Method means this
Assume there are countries
Land areas of bo
Where there is absolutely a spring-like land area
They are both leaving
From there we will head toward the sea
Assume he exited from there
The open sea lay 200 NM ahead
Now what will they do
Both countries are equidistant using the method
One day you will cross the vast ocean between us
Distribute it
But where will the ocean's cutting take place
Both of their external ones
The land area will be from there
Assume it's someone's identified line
Meaning if there's a line from Jik Jakk
Is it really worth the trouble
Denmark and the Netherlands are on the same side
Germany is on a separate path
So the gangster duo's story is
Denmark and the Netherlands
Among these the one that is Denmark is
His boundary is quite
tight and strict
Measure from behind please
Where your land boundary begins
Just take a little bit of buffer
But start measuring from there
So that we can get our fair share too
Measure us too
So that harmony may flourish between them
It's not as though they're caught in the whirlwind of Identity
Denmark is receiving a larger share of the disputed area
And Jamni is losing Los Angeles
Their statement was this:
Now Jamni had this treaty here
It's finally starting to make sense
Now let's look ahead to what has happened here
They say "Look you
didn't sign the treaty "
Not corrected
This is the Aqui Distance Method right
This is not a conventional provision
It's so old we've
already customized it
The custom between us is what
separates us from all other nations
The ocean's equal
breath is our custom
That's why being
custom it is a law
If you've watched my video on the source of international law I explained that one of the most important sources of international law is custom
If it's a custom then it will be binding on Germany they argue since this is a custom therefore it is binding on Germany
Alright now let's see what Germany has to say
That's a very strong line—this entire paragraph is highly important and the whole slide is crucial really
It's true if you look at your side's wedding preparations you'll see that well our wedding will happen it has to happen just like how a garland must be worn and there are other elements too that simply must be there—yes that's settled Now it's not necessary that we
Since so many weddings take place in Manderi it will be arranged according to those schedules
But there are certain factors that will always remain present
Marriage ceremonies will take place and in them the sacred thread will definitely be tied
And some things simply must have sindoor applied
So what's present here is a psychological element which is why our customer is
But the ICJ found no such cyclical element here
Therefore they ruled in favor of Jamni that the principle of acquisitive prescription does not bind Germany
The next crucial step is achieving an equitable solution
And we came to the country seeking a viable solution
So that any dispute among you can be resolved
Sign the new treaty sign anything at all
But this is not a custom
There is no binding on the ground
Equity does not always mean equality
It means fairness
That's a great line—you'll definitely relate to it
So we chat about news like we used to
That reservation should not exist in the country
And why is that if there are two people
You need to
deliver the reservation to them
One without reservation is
So why is this reservation
But what exactly is a reservation
Reservation is not equitable in principle either
You're not seeing everyone equally
—no you'll see only that one
equity among equals means
fairness among those who are equal
Check whether equality exists or not—only
then can they be categorized based on caste
Look at the people in that income group as well
Is there any distinction or favoritism between them
If you look at people from different income groups
Then you finally saw it
That's precisely why reservations are made
Those with lower incomes
have reached the top
If you're looking at equity
That doesn't mean it will be equal among all of them
No that doesn't
always mean being fair
Even if there is favoritism toward someone else
But we're bringing them to the same
platform Later
After that we see
You'll take two points from here
customer international law
If any international law is to become
an international law for a customer
It means he has to become customized—
first and foremost that's what matters
Widespread and consistent state practice means
something that is common and uniformly observed
And consistently practicing
We will refer to this rule as
customer international law
And with that it's not
here anymore—it's over
A jurist's sense of legal obligation is also
something that must be present
You've been using him for so long now
That you've turned him into your own practice
The sense of legal obligation has arisen
That will simply have to be done otherwise
This task will remain
unfinished as we know
Jamala will have to be done
You'll have to do the rounds for this job
Without it the task will remain incomplete
Therefore both of these things should be present
To turn any law into a custom
then any matter related to custom
Any question regarding international law arises
Equitable principles
take precedence over
rigid methods when
fairness demands it
That's the one I mentioned regarding the reservation
It's related to this thing that's fine
Thus two things have been established here
Now let's understand the conclusion of this case
Let's first see the impact of this
What is its impact international law
This case becomes a cornerstone of
maritime boundary delimitation law
fluence UN clause
which I have fully produced in video
It influenced Article 83 how customs are
formed and affirm
that treaty rules do no
It automatically becomes customary law
If you have made a treaty
Don't assume that we've been around for fifty years
They're sitting there having settled the matter
Everything written in the treaty has been made custom
No brother no that's not how it is
Alright so these are the things in this case
It comes out of this case
so the conclusion is correct
Let's see the conclusion at the end the final conclusion
Just that the ICJ emphasized
fairness meaning equity they said
Emphasize understanding over mechanical
application of rules—you'll create your own rules
We who are seated in court
what shall we see as fairness
We will judge it based on the principle itself
Whether the rules for drawing maritime
boundaries are fair or not is debatable
Now there's a very good line in it that I've fully
bolded to emphasize that treating
unequal situations equally is not equity
The understanding I've had since then
regarding reservation is equal treatment
An unequal situation is not equity
now giving equal treatment to
people in unequal situations
You can't call it equity is that right
You must provide equal treatment among equals
It will happen so understand it
If you don't understand this line please read it again
Read it and you'll understand within a couple of readings
That's a very good conclusion the entire case is sound
Now I've got you
The entire case law has been explained now it's up to you
You like it share it
They comment they subscribe to the channel
Whatever you do it's now up to you
I've finished my work
See you in the next video
Till the end goodbye
