North Sea Continental Shelf Case

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
May 22, 2026
In this international law case, Germany v Denmark and the Netherlands, the court considered the circumstances under which treaty law can become customary international law (and therefore be binding on all countries, even those which did not sign the treaty)
AI Generated·May contain errors
Music
International law nowadays is commonly made by treaties between nations.
It can also arise from the established customs of nations in dealing with one another.
The distinction matters.
Treaties only bind the countries that sign them.
Customary international law binds every country.
West Germany, Denmark and the Netherlands all had North Sea coastlines.
They had agreed on coastal sea borders, but not borders on the continental shelf, which has oil and gas.
Denmark and the Netherlands had signed the Geneva Continental Shelf Convention,
a treaty about deciding disputed continental shelf boundaries.
West Germany had not signed.
The convention applied a principle called equidistance,
which basically meant drawing a line equally distant to the coastal boundaries of each country.
Due to the shape of the German coastline, equidistance would have given West Germany
a much smaller proportion of the North Sea compared to the other two countries.
Before the International Court of Justice, Denmark and the Netherlands argued that the
Geneva Continental Shelf Convention had been applied so broadly that it was now customary law,
binding on West Germany.
The Court considered how treaty law can become customary international law.
They said,
There is no doubt that this process is a perfectly possible one.
At the same time, this result is not likely to be regarded as having been attained.
They considered several factors.
First, whether the treaty created an equidistance rule at all.
This was doubtful because the treaty required countries to negotiate an outcome
and only applied equidistance if they could not.
The treaty also allowed divergence from equidistance in special circumstances,
so there was no clear rule.
Second, the Court considered that for a treaty provision to become a customary rule,
there would have to be broad acceptance of the rule, even by countries outside the treaty.
There was no evidence of that in this case.
Finally, even if equidistance had become the common method,
there would have to be evidence that the states were applying that method from a sense of legal obligation.
The Court said,
As a result, the treaty did not apply and there was no customary law,
so the three countries had to return to negotiations and sort it out amongst themselves.
