Before the American Revolution… before the Enlightenment reshaped political thought… one book defined early New England.
In this episode of American Legends, Tiffany Brannan explores the life and legacy of Michael Wigglesworth — Puritan minister, Harvard scholar, physician, and author of The Day of Doom, the best-selling book in colonial America.
Published in 1662, The Day of Doom became the most widely read work in the New World for over a century. Memorized by children, recited in homes, and quoted in churches, it shaped the theology and worldview of generations of early Americans.
Born in Yorkshire, England, Wigglesworth immigrated to Massachusetts as a child. He later studied and taught at Harvard, served as a pastor, and ministered to his community both spiritually and physically. Though deeply admired for his kindness and humility, his writings reveal a man wrestling with doubt, sin, repentance, and the fear of judgment.
His dramatic depiction of the Last Judgment reflects the strict Calvinist theology of the Puritans — a worldview built on accountability, divine providence, and spiritual discipline. Yet beneath the powerful language of judgment lies a profound message of grace: “Get apart in Christ, and make the Judge thy friend.”
Understanding Michael Wigglesworth helps us better understand:
Puritan theology and culture
Early American printing and literature
The spiritual foundations of New England
The moral worldview that preceded the Revolution
Harvard in the 17th century
The influence of Calvinism in colonial America
To understand a people, we must read their words. Wigglesworth’s poetry offers a powerful window into the spiritual intensity that shaped early American civilization.
Join us as we discover the man behind the most influential book of early colonial America.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
When we hear the word Puritan, what comes to mind? A stodgy, prudish person who
is a religious fanatic and doesn't want anyone to have fun? Well, what should come to the mind
of any American is the strong people who are actually the founders of our nation.
In learning more about American history, it's very interesting to learn more about the Puritan
culture and how it was a time not only of hardship and struggle in creating a civilization out of
the wilderness, but also a time of great spiritual enrichment, faith, community,
and even great literature. As printing began in the New World, today we're going to talk about
the author of the best-selling book in the New World. At the time of the American Revolution,
the 1770s, ideas about all men being equal and such were a new fad coming from oftentimes the
French school of enlightenment, this new humanistic or deistic thinking. However,
the beliefs and philosophies which had built the nation during the hundred years or so before that,
that American civilization was really getting started in the New England area,
was very different. The best-selling book in the colonies in those early days was actually a long
poem called The Day of Doom, written by Michael Wigglesworth. Wigglesworth was a very important
man in the early colonies in Massachusetts. He was a pastor, a physician, and he was born
in Yorkshire, England to very devout parents who, being staunch Puritans, soon found that they had
no place in England, so they joined the other Puritans in immigrating to New England. He was
the only son, which was a rare occurrence in most families of that time. As a young boy in the
colonies, arriving when he was about the age of eight, he began his studies and he was becoming
very well-learned, learning Latin and showing great improvement in his mind. But when he was
10, his father became lame and he was stricken with an illness, so Michael had to stop his schooling
to help his father on their farm. After about four years of this, though, Michael's father
deemed that it was God's will for his son to continue his education, and Michael also later
reasoned perhaps he felt that he wasn't too well-suited to husbandry. So he sent Michael
to continue his education, and before long he had relearned everything he'd forgotten during his
years away from his school books, and he soon was becoming most learned. He eventually studied at
Harvard University. Yes, Harvard was there then. And later he would teach at Harvard. He studied
first medicine, which is why he later would act as a physician to his congregation as well as a
spiritual leader, but later he turned to divinity studies and he became a Puritan minister in the
colonies. He was very well regarded by his congregation. People admired him greatly and
were very impressed by not only his piety and his fervor, but his humility and his kindness
of spirit. These terms to describe him might be a bit of surprise if you've read The Day of Doom
because it's very strong in its descriptive language. This poem is 224 stanzas long,
and each stanza has eight lines. In this very long, very intense poem, Wigglesworth described
what would happen on the last day, the Christian day of judgment. He drew not only inspiration,
but actually quoted passages from scripture in describing what would happen to all the various
sinners who would face the wrath of God at that last day. The subject matter is similar to that
of a later very powerful preacher in America, Jonathan Edwards, with his famous speech,
Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God. Such language was very common in the Puritan church,
and the poem exemplifies the strict Calvinist theology to which these colonists subscribed.
It might seem a bit harsh and a bit wrathful and like Helen Brimstone compared with modern-day
Christianity's emphasis on mercy, love, and tolerance. But if you look deeper into the
writings of Wigglesworth, both this poem and other works which were in this same volume,
I think you can see that although they had great respect and fear of God, the Puritans were not
unfamiliar with love of God and from God. The book, The Day of Doom, which was published in
1662 in The New World, begins with a brief autobiography by the writer, and then a foreword
called To the Christian Reader. In the later part of the book, there also are a few other poems
talking about the vanity of focusing on superficial elements and musings on how Wigglesworth imagines
he'll feel as he ends his life. In these, I think you see a very sensitive man who was well
acquainted with God's love and mercy. And indeed, although he would preach and wrote about the
necessity of fear and repentance, it actually is quite humbling to see how the Puritans believed
that everything was God's blessing when talking about that his father was stricken with an
illness. He said, the Lord in his mercy striking my father with an illness as part of his plan
because they truly believed that everything was God's plan, bad things as well as good things.
So as hard as it would be for the individual, they would always try to see the greater plan.
Reading about Michael Wigglesworth, I was struck by how much he reminded me of a character
from the most prominent work of fiction literature about the Puritan colonies, Nathaniel Hawthorne's
The Scarlet Letter. One of the main characters in that is the Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale, a very
sensitive minister who is beloved and almost idolized by his congregation, but who seems to
be afflicted by an unseen illness, perhaps of the soul rather than of the body, and who seems to
have great secret sins, which of course the reader eventually learns. And the congregation just can't
believe that he has such deep dark sins in his soul because he seems so pure. Similarly,
throughout his life, in his diaries and even in his poems, Michael Wigglesworth talked about how
he didn't feel that he was worthy even to believe in God. He was such a sinner. He struggled with
unwanted thoughts of lust throughout his life, and he firmly believed many times that he had
no hope of salvation because of this, although he remonstrated himself and doesn't appear to
have acted on any of these sinful desires. But he frequently would write in a code in his diary so
that no one would be able to understand it. Apparently someone figured out how to understand
it. But he didn't give himself any grace. He believed that he was very sinful, and people
would comment on how kind and good he was, and he certainly does seem to have been a very generous,
kind person who would really try to care for the spiritual as well as the physical health
of the people in his congregation, using his skill as a doctor as well. The reason that he
ended up writing The Day of Doom was that he abruptly stopped preaching. He was a very beloved
minister, giving powerful sermons, and then because of what's considered sort of a psychosomatic
illness, he declared himself unable to continue preaching and giving sermons. So he had to find
another way to share his thoughts and to continue ministering to people. So he turned to communicating
through his pen, and that's why he wrote The Day of Doom. And even in the opening to this work,
in his part called To the Christian Reader, he describes how people don't understand why he isn't
giving sermons, why he won't speak in the pulpit when he's so near to it.
And he basically says that if one could see inside his soul, one could understand why he
felt the way he did, and that it wasn't melancholy, as people declared. He wasn't just being moody.
That he almost was referring to that his voice didn't have the power to keep speaking,
so perhaps he had some ailment of the throat or of the lungs, because he declared how speaking
for even half an hour would continue to afflict him 10 days later. But I wonder if perhaps he
wasn't speaking more about a spiritual burden or affliction, again like Arthur Dimmesdale,
because he struggled with perhaps feelings of hypocrisy as he got up and spoke to the congregation.
Within the first year of the book's publication, all 1800 copies that had been printed had sold,
so more and more editions were printed. In fact, there were hardly any first editions left because
the books which were owned were thumbed through so vigorously. For at least 100 years after its
publication, that was the mainstay of every Puritan home. It was something that everyone read,
memorized, recited, children learned it alongside the scriptures in their catechism,
and it really became a mainstay of Puritan theology. It was said even in 1828 that many
older people could still recite the whole thing by memory because they had learned it. So I think
that this work is extremely important when studying American history, even the Revolution,
because surely those founding fathers, at least some of them, were not only familiar with this
work but had probably learned and memorized it in their childhood. It influenced and shaped
the culture which would have the determination and strength to then have the Revolution and
create a new nation based on freedom to create a new one nation under God. The opening stanza
to the foreword to a Christian leader is as follows. Reader, I am a fool and have adventured
to play the fool this once for Christ, the more his fame to spread. If this my foolishness,
help thee to be more wise, I have attained what I seek and what I only prize. He concluded this
opening with the following stanzas. The God of heaven grant these lines so well to speed,
that though the things of thine own peace, through them mayest better heed, and mayest be stirred up
to stand upon thy guard, that death and judgment may not come and find thee unprepared. O get apart
in Christ and make the judge thy friend, so shalt thou be assured of a happy glorious end.
Thus praise thy real friend and servant for Christ's sake, who had his strength would not
refuse more pains for thee to take. I especially like that line where he says, get apart in Christ
and make the judge thy friend. This shows that the reason that people like Mr. Wiggleworth and all
those other founders of the nation worked so hard wasn't that they thought they were going to find
gold or just escape persecution. They were working hard because they believed that was God's will,
and that's why they risked their lives to sail across the ocean and start this new nation, when
life wasn't that primitive back in England. It actually was pretty comfy.
So they were going from families like the Wigglesworths and other colonists knew a better
life before they came to America, so it wasn't really that they were trying to find a better life.
They had a much worse life in terms of material comforts. What they were trying to find was a
better spiritual life, and ultimately to start a community. A community that their children and
grandchildren would enjoy in a way that they never could back in England, and perhaps which they never
would see in their own lifetime. Michael Wigglesworth was married three times. His first and second wife
both died, as happened very often in those early days of the colonies. Many of the founding fathers,
but especially earlier than that, had sometimes two, three, four wives. Not because of divorce or
bigamy, but because childbirth would often lead to death of these women who were more sensitive in
the harsh climate, and then they would frequently remarry because they needed mothers for the
they already had. With his first wife, Michael had one child. He had six children with his second wife
and an eighth child with his third wife. He lived a long life to the age of 73, and many of his
children would go on to become ministers, officers in the Revolutionary War, and important members of
a growing New England society. To understand a people, I think we shouldn't just read about them.
We should read the works by them. By studying the art, whether it's in the form of visual art like
painting and sculpture, oral art like music, or literary art like poems and novels, we find out
more about the true nature of a people. And I think we can't find many better examples of the
true Puritan nature than the writings of Michael Wigglesworth, as he was a respected man in his
community, and an excellent writer of the beliefs which the Puritans had, which inspired not only
his generation, but the generations which would come more than a century afterwards. To find out
more about the style, I recommend you find one of the many free copies of the entire text of The Day
of Doom, including the foreword and the afterword yourself, and read it if you have some spare time
or just over several days. But to give you an example of the kind of dramatic language he uses,
here's just the first stanza of The Day of Doom. Still was the night, serene and bright, when all
men sleeping lay. Calm was the season, and carnal reason, thought so it would last for aye.
Soul, take thine ease, let sorrow cease, much good thou hast in store. This was their song,
their cups among, the evening before. I think that modern Americans need that message much more than
the Puritans needed it in that day. No matter what your religious faith is, it's a word of wisdom
that one shouldn't assume that the comfortable condition of the present day is going to last
forever. We all know that life is fleeting and we're all mortal, we are but dust, and we must
look for something higher, some greater purpose, some kind of faith, something that inspires us to
treat others and ourselves with dignity and respect. That's the message which the Puritans
have for us, as beautifully exemplified by writings such as those by Michael Wigglesworth.
Thank you for spending this time with me,
and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.