Unmissable US EUROPE Fight At Munich Mike Waltz CLASHES With Kallas Over Trump Onslaught WATCH
So I don't really buy this argument that we are not doing anything.
You know, in the beginning you said also that,
is it that actually the rules of jungle and the might makes right
actually has always been there.
And one might say that it's true,
that those who have the power have had different rules.
But even in jungle, you know, animals cooperate.
We're asking the rest of the world
to be there with us in a fair way financially.
Because there is a cost of the status quo
and the status quo was not sustainable anymore.
And that's, I think, on behalf of our constituents,
a fair question to ask.
Okay, how do you respond to that?
It's a reasonable point, surely.
No, of course it is.
But if you look at also to the United Nations
and all the contributions,
then when it comes to the development aid,
Europe is doing the biggest share.
So I don't really buy this argument that we are not doing.
The questions that we are all asking ourselves
is the old system at a big picture system
of multilateral rules, engagement, alliances is changing.
And we are wondering what the United States,
where it wants to go and what it wants to do.
And is it a world of might is right,
great power politics unconstrained?
Because, and this is the question to you,
does the president believe in a multilateral system
where there are rules that would constrain
the United States or not?
NATO is stronger because of our leadership
and push for the reforms that were badly needed,
namely the contributions.
The UN will be stronger at the end of this process.
The status quo was unsustainable
and not working in places like Gaza or Azerbaijan, Armenia.
You have to ask yourself, why were we 18 months ago
in so many active wars around the world?
And I think it's a fair question for the president to say,
why hasn't the UN been able to resolve issues
like a border dispute between Cambodia and Thailand
or Azerbaijan or media,
or we could walk around the world
or Kashmir and India and Pakistan,
where we faced a very serious nuclear escalation.
So what I'm hearing outside of forums like this privately
is thank you for American leadership.
America has to lead.
If we have to have more focus plurilateral
or focus multilateral organizations to do so,
I think that should be perfectly acceptable
if we're getting the results that results
in peace and security.
Yeah, okay, thank you.
I think that was actually very clear.
Questions?
Lady here in the fourth row.
If you could identify yourself and keep it very brief.
Thank you.
My name is Amal Modallali.
I'm a researcher at Princeton University.
I have two quick questions.
Mr. Walts, it's good to see you.
Thank you.
And thanks to your efforts,
Resolution 2803 was passed
and the Board of Peace was as established.
But the problem that people are having
is that the charter of the Board of Peace
that came out from the White House later on,
it does not mention Gaza
and it talks about solving global problems.
Doesn't this go beyond the mandate
that you got from the United Nations?
Can I have a second question?
Why don't we just stick with that one
because there were a lot of hands went up
and it's a very focused question.
Look, the Board of Peace is absolutely focused on Gaza.
I think you will see that in the meeting next week.
But in the formation and in its founding documents,
the team wanted to leave flexibility
to be able to tackle other problems if asked.
Again, this was an outcropping
of what I think history will look back on,
which was an absolutely historic meeting
where the president convened the countries of the region
and the Muslim majority nations,
namely Pakistan, Turkey, and Indonesia.
Just a few weeks prior,
we had the strike on downtown Doha from the Israelis.
There was a lot of concern
would this diplomatic momentum continue?
And just a few months later,
we had Sharm el-Sheikh with Abu Mazen from the Palestinians
shaking the president hand
in the historic speech at the Knesset.
The hostages released, the ceasefire in place,
the humanitarian aid flowing,
and now an international security force moving.
So again, let's focus on the results in Gaza
that we're seeing as a result of this action.
Thank you.
Gentleman there in the second row.
I'm Mustafa Barghouti from Palestine.
I have this question.
We are held accountable as Palestinians three times a day.
Israel is violating the ceasefire already 1,500 times.
Who's going to hold Israel accountable?
And the second question,
how can we call this a board of peace
if it has the prime minister of Israel in it,
but not a single Palestinian in it?
Thank you.
Kaya, would you like to answer that?
And then maybe Prince Faisal would like to add something.
But this is exactly the point of accountability
that I'm saying, that nobody should be above the law.
I mean, if we have agreed international rules,
then if you are breaching those rules,
then you should also be held accountable, whoever you are.
Prince Faisal.
Certainly, I completely agree.
And obviously, it's not a ceasefire
if the guns haven't ceased.
I think where I'm most concerned
is even if the killing has stopped, the dying hasn't.
So aid access is still an issue.
And I know that the US team is working on that every day.
So one of the reasons we are remaining engaged
is just because of that, is we do see,
it doesn't always translate, unfortunately,
into what's happening on the ground,
but we do see a consistent engagement
on trying to get these things addressed,
whether it's the ceasefire violations,
whether it's the issue of opening up aid access.
And of course, when the resolution was adopted,
it was very clear it included language
that addressed the right of the Palestinians
for self-determination.
So certainly, I know from the Kingdom's perspective,
many of those countries that signed onto the resolution,
many of those countries that have agreed to join the board,
we see this very much as one step on the road
to Palestinian self-determination.
Obviously, the priority needs to be
to stop the dying in Gaza, stabilize that situation,
to start the rebuilding, to build the reassurance
that there is no more longer a threat
from Gaza to its neighbors, and then move that
to addressing the issue of Palestinian rights.
And with that, we believe very strongly
that if we don't address holistically
the rights of the Palestinians,
including the Palestinians of the West Bank,
and here, this is very critical,
the unity of Gaza and the West Bank needs to be maintained.
And that can only happen if we stabilize
the situation in Gaza, because there's no linkage
with a space that is currently in chaos.
So we have a lot more to do.
We have a meeting coming up,
and I'm sure we'll hear more about what's being done.
It's a daily effort to stabilize the situation.
All the hostages are out now,
so now the focus needs to be getting
the lives of the Palestinians in Gaza
into a much, much better place,
and allowing that then to be the opening
towards a pathway towards the Palestinians
and the Israelis can live together side by side
in peace and in harmony.
And I just would add very quickly,
we've had over 4,000 trucks per week
moving now since the Sharm el-Sheikh.
Number one, it's not enough,
but it is exponentially more than it was.
And as the minister pointed out,
there was language in the peace plan
that is now in the Security Council resolution
post-reform towards Palestinian self-determination
and no occupation, no annexation of Gaza,
which again, I would argue forcefully
that only President Trump could bring all sides,
including the Israelis, to the table to get this far.
A long way to go, but we are far better
than where we were in September of last year.
Thank you.
There are a lot of hands going up.
Question here very briefly.
Very briefly.
Katarzyna Pisarska, I'm the chair
of the Warsaw Security Forum Poland.
My question to you, Ambassador Waltz,
just an honest reply, please.
Does America-
Think of it pretty straightforward
and honest so far.
Does America need a rules-based order?
And if so, what are you willing to also sacrifice?
Because you have been backing this world order
for years and years.
And thanks to the United States of America,
many of us, including Poland, has benefited immensely.
And what we're seeing now is a withdrawal
that's an honest, I think, assessment of many of us,
and we just ask ourselves,
are you willing to fight with us,
the Europeans and others, for this world order?
And the same question really to Kayak Halas.
Do you feel that the Europeans are willing
to really fight for this order?
Thank you.
And I would follow your question.
Are the Europeans willing and able
to take the tough financial steps necessary?
I'm a recovering politician myself.
I know how tough those votes are
when you have a social support system.
But look, to answer your question directly,
absolutely, the American people have underwritten
with their hard-earned dollar,
the global multilateral rules-based order
since World War II.
However, with 37 trillion in debt and counting,
the massive debt load that the Western world is facing,
I think it is fair on their behalf
to ask 450 million Europeans
with the same size economy as the United States
to be more self-sustaining in their own defense.
And it astounds me why that is so controversial.
Ambassador, I think it's not.
It's a fair question.
When I go to people in Indiana and Georgia
and North Florida that I represented,
and it is their money paying more than 180 countries
combined into the UN system,
it's fair to say, yes, I have to look at them honestly
and say it's being well spent, and it's not.
Absolutely.
And indeed, I think as Chancellor Mertz made very clear,
the Europeans have belatedly got the message,
and there is a recognition that defense spending has gone up
and is going to go up further.
Europe needs to get his act together,
and I'm going to come to Kaya Kalas again.
There's an absolute, that was very clear in Chancellor Mertz.
But it wasn't clear in 2014.
Why not?
It was, it took, I would, I mean, I'm not.
I mean, we're acting as though
things were coming unglued now.
It's been coming unglued for 10 years,
and no one was responding in an effective way.
Now we're asking more forcefully.
Yes.
And I think we're seeing a good result
as a result of the 5%.
Well, the question, I think,
that was being asked from the audience was,
if the Europeans are responding now,
do you still believe in multilateralism in this order?
Do you still believe in it?
Or as Chancellor Mertz said,
he said, and I just wrote it down,
even the US is reaching the limits of its own power
if it goes alone.
Do you agree with him that the US could not go alone?
I mean, I'm looking at the grouping I just discussed
of our Gulf-era allies.
I'm looking at the Abraham Accords.
I'm looking at the fact that the President
didn't need to take on Azerbaijan or Armenia, and he did.
He didn't need to take on Pakistan and India, and he did.
And we're asking the rest of the world
to be there with us in a fair way financially.
Because there is a cost to the status quo,
and the status quo was not sustainable anymore.
And that's, I think, on behalf of our constituents,
a fair question to ask.
That's, Kaya, how do you respond to that?
It's a reasonable point, surely.
No, of course it is, but if you-
I wrote that down.
If you look at also to the United Nations
and all the contributions,
then when it comes to the development aid,
Europe is doing the biggest share.
So I don't really buy this argument
that we are not doing anything.
In the beginning, you said also that,
is it that actually the rules of jungle
and the might makes right actually has always been there?
And one might say that is true,
that those who have the power have had different rules.
But even in jungle, animals cooperate.
And so you are better off when you work with others.
And if you think in the global,
if we take the superpowers,
what is actually the difference?
You know, when, for example, Russia goes to war,
they go alone because they don't have allies.
When America goes to wars,
then a lot of us go with you
and we lose our people on the way.
So that means that you also need us in your,
to be this superpower.
Because if we look at the bigger picture,
I mean, in terms of economic might,
I mean, China is a very, very powerful country
in terms of military might as well.
So what is the difference between you
and the other superpowers so far is the allies.
But I'm coming to this point that,
of course, we are willing to fight for the world
where there are some kind of rules.
Because majority, or actually all the European countries
are small countries, or those who haven't realized
that they are small countries yet.
But we are small countries.
So we need a rules-based order.
And it is clear that the current rules-based order,
you know, it has been put in place
after the Second World War,
considering all what was happening there,
what were the powers fighting then.
And it doesn't serve the world right now.
But what serves the world is the rules, really,
that are protecting everybody
so that nobody's above the law.
And I think that is the difference,
that we actually want partnerships
that are based on dignity,
where we actually listen to the other party
and we care also what the other countries
are thinking about.
So it's not like we make decisions
in this border peace charter, for example,
that you don't have to actually take into account
anybody who is on that organization,
because one person can make the decisions.
And that is, I think, the difference,
how we see the world.
Because if countries are treated equally,
I think there's also less chance for war and tyranny.
So I realize that I have completely failed
to instill a rules-based order here,
because this conversation has been wholly dominated
by the two biggest economic and political blocs.

