LIVE: Utah Judge Rules on Disqualifying Prosecutors in Charlie Kirk Case

Live News Network
1.4K followers
31 Video Views·Feb 24, 2026
A Utah judge is scheduled to issue a ruling at 12:30 p.m. ET on Feb. 24 on whether to keep prosecutors on the murder case against Tyler Robinson, the man accused of killing conservative commentator Charlie Kirk on a Utah college campus. Robinson has not yet entered a plea. State District Judge Tony Graf has been weighing whether to disqualify the Utah County Attorney’s Office from continuing to prosecute the case.
All right.
Thank you, Mr. Ballad.
Mr. Novak.
All I would say is that if the court is going to open up a WebEx for some participants,
we will be there either in person or by WebEx or both because there are, as Your Honor knows,
a few of us.
Ms. Nestor will not be present because she's already engaged in trial in another county.
But we will, I guess what I would say today is that we will be appearing in person, present
in court with Mr. Robinson with us.
If there is some reason why one of us needs to appear remotely, then we'll address that
with the court.
All right.
Thank you, Mr. Novak.
So it sounds like we're going to go ahead and set this in person.
I realize that, you know, there are complications.
And Mr. Judd, it looks like there is no opposition to you appearing via WebEx.
And of course, as mentioned by defense, there are certain attorneys that may need to appear
by WebEx.
So we will accommodate that and we'll anticipate Mr. Robinson's appearance in person on March
13th.
Counsel, given the direction of the court dealing with closure and classification of
motions, how much time will you need to conduct your business in court?
I want to open that up and lock it down before that date gets cannibalized by other important
hearings as well.
Your Honor, this is Mr. Ballard.
I guess I would defer to the defense.
It's their motions to close and to classify.
But I think having a time limit regardless would be helpful.
I'm going to suggest, Your Honor, that it's going to be more than one hour and maybe less
than two hours.
And the reason why I say that is there are multiple motions to classify around the same
issues, which are the motion, the reply, and the evidentiary hearing itself.
And the court's going to obviously hear not only from the moving parties, which is Mr.
Robinson, but the state and counsel for the media.
And it would be hard for me to imagine that many attorneys in the court could do all that
in less than one hour.
Are you commenting on the amount of time attorneys talk?
Only myself.
I'm only referring to myself.
All right.
No worries.
I include myself in that comment.
All right.
So let's go ahead and set aside three hours just to be safe.
I don't want any party to feel pressured.
But as mentioned by Mr. Ballard, I believe that setting a timeline is appropriate.
So let's go ahead and start.
How does 10 a.m. on March 13th look?
10, 11, 12, concluding at the 1 o'clock hour?
That's fine for the defense, Your Honor.
That might actually allow me to get to my originally planned destination the same evening.
All right.
To Mr. Ballard?
10 a.m. is perfect, Your Honor.
Thank you.
All right.
And Mr. Judd?
Yes, Your Honor.
All right.
Let's turn to the second issue.
And we have that.
I believe it was April 17th date.
Does that allow sufficient time to address the evidentiary hearing being requested?
In terms of preparation for April 17th?
Yes.
That's when the court wants to do it.
We will be ready to go on that date.
All right.
And how much time, Mr. Novak, do you anticipate needing?
I certainly want to make sure that all parties have enough time to present what they need
to present.
Your Honor, I'm going to defer to Mr. Burt on that, if Mr. Burt is able to do so, looks
like technologically here.
Good morning, Your Honor.
Good morning, Mr. Burt.
Judge, I think on that, because it is going to involve the presentation of extensive exhibits
and also some expert evidence that we'd be looking at a full day accounting for cross-examination
by all the lawyers involved here.
All right.
And to the state, what's your input?
A is more than enough to be able to address those issues.
All right.
And to the state.
I'm sorry, I just...
To any other party.
I will defer to the party, Your Honor, on this.
As the court knows, we haven't seen the motion itself or the reply.
We've seen the state's opposition, but I think whatever the defense believes is necessary,
given that they are the party bringing evidence and the expert, if they believe that a day
is sufficient, we see no reason to push back on that.
All right.
I do note that we have other issues on that day.
I think we're just going to have to bump them.
And so we'll go ahead and set aside the full day on April 17th.
We'll start at 10 a.m. and conclude promptly at 5 p.m., if needs be.
But it is the intent that we fully address the issues and it's not carried over or continued
to another day.
The court anticipates, given what's presented, has been the practice of the court that it
would take it under advisement and schedule a WebEx hearing to issue its decision.
All right.
So April 17th, starting at 10 a.m.
I'm assuming in person, and Mr. Novak, I don't want to assume anything.
In person with Mr. Robinson in court?
Yes, Your Honor.
Exactly.
All right.
Thank you, counsel.
I really appreciate your working together.
And I know it's complicated.
You all have busy, busy schedules.
Is there anything else that the court needs to address at this time?
Thank you.
Nothing on behalf of Mr. Robinson at this time.
Thank you.
Ignore from the media, Your Honor.
All parties, I appreciate your hard work and your efforts.
And we will be in adjournment until March 13th.
Thank you.
Court is now in recess.
Good morning.
Calling case 2204-00027.
Grimmer and Associates P.C. and Matthew Grimmer versus Walker Patterson Inman III.
I have the parties enter their appearances, please.
This is Matthew Grimmer on behalf of the plaintiffs.
Good morning, sir.
And I'm trying to see if we have opposing party.
I don't see them.
All right.
Well, I'm glad that you're looking as well because I don't want to miss them.
Have you had any communications from opposing party in regards to today's hearing?
I have not.
The opposing counsel withdrew after the guardianship and conservatorship were set aside,
which was the basis for the motion.
So it really kind of mooted everything.
And I think they believed that that had been resolved last year.
But it was still hadn't been ruled on.
And so we just requested that the court proceed to kind of clean things up.
All right.
Well, good to know.
Well, so it is this hearing was set for 11 a.m.
My previous hearing spilled over a little bit.
But it is the date and time set.
I didn't see the other parties log on.
I'll admit that it was a few people who were attending the previous hearing.
But I didn't see him up here.
So being that it's 1123, the court typically waits 15 minutes from when
a hearing is called to allow all parties to log in.
There are sometimes technological issues, but I do not see them.
So, sir, what what is your motion, if any, for the court?
Yeah, our request is that the motion to intervene be denied as the basis for the motion
that Dacia Inman is a conservator of the defendant has now been set aside by the court.
So there's no longer a basis to intervene.
And it really is that succinct.
All right.
Given that this is time and place set for this hearing and the opposing party has not
appeared, I've checked online and in the courtroom as well.
There's nobody responding.
So I will grant the motion to not deny the motion to intervene.
And so that is granted.
If you wouldn't mind preparing an order consistent with this ruling,
submitting it to the other party to review just a form and then submit to the court for signature.
We will do.
Thank you very much.
Thank you.
Have a good rest of your day.
Court is in recess.
