LIVE: Royal Commission on Anti-Semitism, Social Cohesion Holds First Hearing on Bondi Beach Case

Live News Network
1.4K followers
6 Video Views·Feb 23, 2026
Australia's Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion holds its first public hearing at 6:30 p.m. ET on Feb. 23.
At the opening hearing, Commissioner Virginia Bell will make a short opening statement explaining how she will approach the terms of reference for the inquiry.
Senior Counsel Assisting Richard Lancaster SC will also make a short opening statement.
No testimony will be heard, and no evidence will be given.
We will commence today's proceeding by calling on Uncle Alan Murray to give us a welcome
to country. Uncle Alan is a Wiradjuri and a Kamilaroi man. His father comes from the
Kamundja village on the Murray and was a member, or is a member, of the Stolen Generation.
His mother is a Kamilaroi woman from north-western New South Wales. Uncle Alan is currently the
chairperson of the Metropolitan Local Aboriginal Land Council. So I now call on Uncle Alan
to give us a welcome to country.
Many thanks. In the corresponding welcome to country, I want to acknowledge that we're
on Gadigal land, and given the circumstances of what occurred in December, it means that
sorrow and business is part of the way of life, as we see in Australia. But also I want
to acknowledge our greatest warriors, Pemoy, Bangaroo, Mosquito and Windanite. These are
our legendary warriors who fought for this country. And a welcome to country is about
talking about their relationship to the land. In particular, when the patrol ships came
through Sydney Harbour in 1770. We're still fighting for our land rights. We're still
fighting for our sovereignty, because we never signed a piece of paper to say we're giving
up this land. But a welcome to country is about sharing our beliefs and understanding
our customs and our way of life. Because truly, we have faced many diversities over
the past, since 1770. And we know that atrocities have been committed against us. And we still
wanting a reckoning. Like yourselves, you're finding a reckoning and a solution to the
problems we faced every day since 1770. About Australians respecting us, and Australians
respecting all of us. And because we had a failed referendum, like yourselves, we feel
your pain, we feel your sorrow, and we feel that. But a welcome to country is about understanding
why you come to these lands, because this is a land of opportunity. But also, it means
that First Nations people, from here, from Bondi to Sydney, there are something in the
order of like 54 clans that make up all the Aboriginal clans here in New South Wales.
But here in Sydney, we've got 29 clans. And the only two surviving clans that live today
are the Gadigal people and the Bidjigal people of La Perouse. Myself, like the Commissioner
said in the brief, is that my parents come from far wider places. But because of the
past policies, it means that Aboriginal people have been flown into Sydney since 1770, pushing
Aboriginal people off land. And we do understand that. But the goodwill of us, in terms of
our sorrow and our business, we still have a reckoning. But a welcome to country is about
exploring all this. And I wish the Commissioner well. And I hope that one day you would feel
fit and proper to conduct the proceedings on land, so we can mix the dirt, smoke the
bush and have a proper smoking ceremony. So with that, good morning to you.
Thank you for that warm, inclusive and empathetic welcome to country, Uncle Alan.
This is the initial sitting of the Royal Commission on Anti-Semitism and Social Cohesion.
The Commission was established by letters patent signed by the Governor-General on 9 January
2026. Since that date, letters patent in identical terms have been issued by the Governors of each
of the states. Under each of the letters patent, the Commission is required to examine and report
on the matters that are identified in four terms of reference. I don't propose to refer to all of
them in full. They can be accessed on the Commission's website. We will commence today's
proceedings by calling on the three principal terms, and I'm going to do that in reverse order.
Uncle Alan is a Wurundjeri and a Kamilaroi man. His father comes from the Kamundja village on
the Midi Beach, and was and is a member of the Stolen Generation. His mother is a Kamilaroi
woman from north-western New South Wales. Uncle Alan is currently the Chairperson of the Metropolitan
Local Aboriginal Land Council. So I now call on Uncle Alan to give us a welcome to country.
In the corresponding world and the country, we want to acknowledge that we're going away, and given the
circumstances of what occurred in December, it means that sorrow and business is part of the way of life,
as we see in Australia. But also I want to acknowledge our greatest warriors, our family,
the trial of that individual will be the occasion to lead evidence of the attack.
This Commission must do its work without risking any prejudice to that criminal proceeding.
Leading evidence at this Commission from people who may be witnesses in the criminal system,
through the New South Wales Police, the Jewish Board of Deputies, to the families of the deceased,
and to others directly affected by the attack, to meet me later this week in less formal
surroundings, so that I can explain more fully the limitations on the scope of the
agencies, on how they should respond, on how they should respond, on how they should respond,
formulating these recommendations. It follows that in investigating the nature and prevalence
of anti-Semitism in Australia, the Commission will apply the IHRA working definition.
The definition itself is uncontroversial. It provides anti-Semitism is a certain perception
of Jews, which may be expressed as a hatred towards Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of
anti-Semitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and or their property,
toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities. The definition is accompanied by 11
examples of conduct which could amount to anti-Semitism. At least two of the examples
are controversial and have led some critics to argue that the IHRA working definition
wrongly labels as anti-Semitic the expression of political views which do not reflect a hatred of
Jews. While I'm open to receiving submissions on the issue, my current view is that these concerns
pay insufficient regard to the terms of the definition itself, and they're apt to overlook
the requirement to take account of the overall context in which conduct occurs
before making any determination that the conduct is anti-Semitic. I should note that it is
uncontroversial that criticism of the policies that may be pursued by the government of Israel
from time to time is not of itself anti-Semitic. Examining the ways in which we might strengthen
social cohesion in Australia could well be the work of years, not months. I am required to deliver
my final report to the Governor-General and the Governors of the States not later than the first
anniversary of the Bondi massacre. Anniversaries are important. The first anniversary for those
directly affected by it and for the broader Jewish and Bondi communities is going to be
a difficult time. I acknowledge that for some it will never be right to speak of closure,
but one small part of coming to terms with the events of that evening will be the work
of this Commission. I regard the delivery of my report on or before the first anniversary
as a matter of critical importance. This imposes a tight time frame, and it's going to impose
limitations on how the Commission approaches its terms of reference. My focus will be a practical
one. I encourage members of the community who have an interest in any of the Commission's terms of
reference to visit the Commission's website. A submission can be made by any person using the
online form or by email. I'm interested in hearing from Jewish Australians who've experienced
anti-Semitism, whether at school or at university or in the workplace or elsewhere. Making a
submission does not commit a person to giving evidence in public, and no person will be
to do so. But I am confident that there will be members of the Jewish community who are willing
to give evidence in public about their experiences of anti-Semitism, and that their accounts may be
illustrative of wider patterns. In this way, the Commission will seek to assess the impact of
anti-Semitism on the daily life of Jewish Australians, and this is an important aspect
of the first term of reference. I'm mindful that while anti-Semitism may be the oldest religious
and ethnic prejudice, other religions and ethnicities are also subject to prejudice in
Australia. I expect that social cohesion will be advanced by measures that address discrimination
against religious faiths, ethnicities and cultures generally. Nonetheless, against the background of
the massacre of innocent people who appear to have been targeted simply because they were Jewish,
I trust everyone will appreciate why the focus of this Commission will be on tackling anti-Semitism
as a starting point in strengthening our bonds of social cohesion. I will now call on senior
counsel assisting to outline the practices and procedures that he proposes the Commission adopt,
and to give a broad indication of the nature of the evidence that he anticipates leading before
the Commission. Mr Lancaster. Thank you, Commissioner. I'm pleased to announce formally
my appearance as senior counsel assisting the Royal Commission. Appearing with me as senior
counsel assisting is Ms Ellie Hager SC, and with us are Ms Tamara Phillips, Ms Eleanor Jones,
and Mr Joe Petri seated at the bar table today. The central task of the counsel assisting team
is to assist you, Commissioner, to enquire into the issues set out in the terms of reference,
and report upon them by the dates set out in the letters patent. The Council will work
closely with the solicitors assisting the Commission. There will be a team of solicitors,
ably led by Ms Louise Amundson and Mr Tony Jooney. The Commission has the ongoing benefit
of the vast experience of Mr Dennis Richardson AC, and those who are assisting him at the time
of the commencement of this Commission. The staff of the Commission includes analysts, researchers,
support officers and other corporate staff. The administration of the Royal Commission
is undertaken by the Office of the Official Secretary, Ms Anne Sheehan.
The anti-Semitic attack on Jewish Australians in Bondi on 14 December 2025 was a truly
horrifying event. Like in so many other parts of Sydney and Australia, members of our community
were enjoying a summer Sunday evening gathering at a public park near the beach. At a Jewish
celebration for Hanukkah, a festival of light, 15 people were killed, many others were seriously
wounded, and their lives will never be the same. There are many people who have been left with
psychological scars from that day. The Council assisting team acknowledge with great sadness
the immense trauma this has caused Jewish Australians. Members of the community living
in Bondi, those visiting for a meal or a swim that evening, those who bravely rushed to help,
and many others throughout Sydney and Australia have been deeply affected by the attack.
Commissioner, you have summarised the terms of reference and they are available to be read
on the Royal Commission website, asc.royalcommission.gov.au. As you have mentioned,
all six state jurisdictions have also issued terms of reference in similar form. One benefit
of that occurring is that it demonstrates a truly national imperative to tackle anti-Semitism.
Another is the practical benefit that you have and may exercise the powers of a Royal Commissioner
under both Commonwealth legislation and state legislation.
The Royal Commission website is the official hub for public information about the activities of
the inquiry. In your remarks today, you invited public submissions. If any individuals or
organisations wish to make a submission, please visit the website for details about how to do so.
People can also subscribe to the Royal Commission email mailing list through the website to remain
up to date with its activities. The terms of reference stipulate that the interim report is
to focus on issues requiring urgent or immediate action. If members of the public who wish to make
a submission intend to draw attention to matters that they consider require urgent or immediate
action, the Commission should receive those submissions by 13 March. Otherwise, the Commission
will continue to receive submissions in April and May.
I will now address some important aspects of the procedures of the Royal Commission for the
information of the public and for the particular attention of those who may become more closely
involved in the work of the Commission as witnesses or interested persons or organisations.
The Royal Commission has recently prepared a number of practice notes to guide its procedures.
You, Commissioner, will review these as necessary to ensure they are promoting the efficiency
and effectiveness of Commission procedures. These practice guidelines are, by way of brief summary,
firstly, a general practice guideline explaining the Commission and how it operates,
how to communicate with the Royal Commission and make submissions,
and expectations as to how evidence before the Commission will be published.
This also explains how confidentiality applications might be made.
The second is a guideline covering hearings, which explains the way in which hearings are
expected to run, the process of obtaining leave to appear before the Commission,
and the process for examining and cross-examining any witnesses called.
The third practice note is a document production guideline,
which explains the mechanics for producing material to the Commission,
including how to make claims of confidentiality over documentary material that is produced.
This guideline contains a detailed document production protocol, which explains how
documents should be saved and coded for upload via the Commission's electronic systems.
The work of the Commission will certainly proceed more efficiently if the procedures
in this guideline are followed. Finally, there is a guideline addressing
how claims for legal professional privilege will be dealt with by the Commission.
Can I add that in relation to leave to appear before the Royal Commission,
in due course the solicitors assisting the Commission will fix a time for the
submission of applications for leave to appear. This will be notified in the usual course such
applications will be dealt with by the Commissioner on the papers in advance of a relevant hearing.
As you have indicated, Commissioner, the terms of reference require questions to be asked and
answered about anti-Semitism in Australia leading up to the attack, and about the
steps taken by law enforcement and security agencies to protect the community. There is
one important issue that must be addressed immediately and publicly. You have done so,
but I do wish to repeat it. It is also an issue that is relevant to the scope
and content of the interim report due on 30 April. The letters patent refer to
the necessity for the inquiry to be conducted in a manner that does not occasion prejudice
to current or future criminal proceedings, or national security, or undermine social cohesion.
As you have mentioned, and as is widely known, the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions is
currently prosecuting criminal proceedings against an accused person who is charged with committing
a terrorist act, 15 counts of murder, 40 counts of attempted murder, and other offences.
The currency of the prosecution and the nature of the charges brought against the accused
are such that it is not possible for this Commission to inquire into and report on a
number of the elements of term of reference C, which, as you have summarised, is the third
term of reference concerning the circumstances of the Bondi attack. This Commission and the
important work of gathering evidence will not interfere with the administration of justice or
otherwise prejudice that prosecution. Receipt of evidence from those who may be witnesses in
the criminal proceedings would carry that risk, and as you have indicated, Commissioner, that
will not be done. For the same reason, we do not propose to conduct public hearings on the
matters with which those pending charges are concerned, and judgment will need to be exercised
about where that line is to be drawn. This will inevitably reduce the scope of the Commission's
public hearings and the Commission's public reports on some issues, but it is necessary to preserve
the proper administration of criminal justice. Turning now to evidence gathering to support
the report and recommendations of the Royal Commission, the Council Assisting Team will
lead evidence relevant to the terms of reference. A great deal of the evidence will be documentary.
This Commission has already issued dozens of notices to produce to Commonwealth and State
agencies and various other organisations of interest. Some documents have been produced
and continue to be produced in answer to those notices to produce. There are also further notices
to produce that are yet to be issued. It is also proposed to lead evidence from relevant persons
by way of witness statements. The Commission will also hear oral evidence from witnesses
in person, including expert evidence. The process of document production by
some recipients of notices is not presently where we would like it to be.
Commissioner, in light of the very tight timeline within which you are required to inquire and
report, it is appropriate for you in my submission not to countenance any delay at all in the
production of documents or witness statements that are required to be produced. The Royal
Commission's Act 1902 of the Commonwealth and relevant State equivalent legislation
contain ample powers to require the attendance of witnesses to explain any delay.
Council Assisting proposed to lead evidence on at least the following four broad topics.
The first is to identify anti-Semitic conduct in its various forms in Australian society,
including by hearing from Jewish Australians about their own lived and living experiences
of anti-Semitism. This will examine the large number and increasing prominence
of anti-Semitic incidents in Australia in recent years and indeed in recent days.
The second broad topic is to inquire into the drivers of anti-Semitism,
including ideologically and religiously motivated extremism, radicalisation pathways and vectors
for extremist content online and in institutions. This will include considering the actions of
individuals or groups professing racist or far-right ideology or extreme cultural or
religious prejudice. The Commission will explore ways to counter the spread of extremism in
Australia. The fourth broad topic is to identify what law enforcement and security agencies have
been doing to tackle anti-Semitic conduct and how the response could be improved for
the protection of the community. The fourth broad topic is an inquiry into the circumstances
leading up to and surrounding the attack on 14 December. Subject to what I have said earlier
about being careful not to prejudice the criminal proceeding, this will include an inquiry into
threat assessments and information sharing by agencies. The steps taken by agencies in response
to the planned event at Bondi and to secure it, and steps taken in response to the attack itself.
The Royal Commission has already commenced informing itself about many of these topics,
including by informal meetings and roundtables with numerous individuals and organisations.
Council assisting look forward to continuing that process and to working closely with
interested community organisations to advance the work of the Commission.
The Letters Patent refer to social cohesion as the national consensus in support of democracy,
freedom and the rule of law. The consensus to which the Letters Patent refer is not a
uniformity of opinion, nor does it require or involve the suppression of fair criticism and
debate. It is quite the opposite in my submission. It is a consensus that a diverse multicultural
society can subsist and thrive only by mutual acceptance of our respective democratic freedoms
exercised according to law. Social cohesion begins with empathy. A large part of the work
of this Commission will be to present evidence to allow a broader understanding of the scourge
of anti-Semitism, its nature and prevalence throughout Australian society and its impact
on the lives of fellow Australians. Through that understanding, there may be opportunities to
improve. The schedule of hearing days on which the Royal Commission will sit in public to hear
evidence has not yet been fixed. Hearing days will be notified on the Royal Commission website.
That process will begin as soon as practicable, having regard to the production of relevant
documents and witness statements and the requirements of procedural fairness.
The terms of reference require an inquiry into very substantial issues in a short space of time.
Commissioner, the final product of the Royal Commission will be your report and the
recommendations you make to the Commonwealth and State Governments. The consideration and
implementation of those recommendations will be a matter for those Governments.
In my submission, the Commission will now be adjourned to a date to be fixed.
Thank you, Mr Lancaster. The Commission will now adjourn to a date to be fixed.
