2025 Porsche 911 GTS T-Hybrid vs. Aston Martin Vantage- Has Aston Escaped the 911’s Shadow?

Automobile Identity
371 followers
#automobile #autos #cars #4wheels #luxurycar #sportcar #highspeedcar #testdrive #toyota #tesla #porsche #hyundai #rollsroyce #royall #suvs
Can the Aston Martin Vantage ever be more than just a Grand Tourer?
If it's going to, it's got to take down the king of the everyday sports car,
the Porsche 911 GTS. To find out if the new Vantage has what it takes,
we're going to set both cars loose on one of America's best driving roads,
and then hit up a popular meeting spot to see what other car enthusiasts think.
Between an Aston Martin and a Porsche, which appeals to you guys more?
So yeah, my take, just for the look, will be on a Vantage.
I would rather own the Porsche.
Probably the 911.
Personally, I'll actually take the Aston.
Okay.
I think it's the 911. It's a classic look for me.
Forget everything you think you know about Aston Martin. It doesn't want to be a GT maker
anymore. It wants to compete with supercar companies. The 2025 Aston Martin Vantage is
proof positive of that. More powerful, more technologically advanced, and just
rawer than the version before it. It wants to compete directly with McLaren and Ferraris
of the world. But there's one problem with that.
I don't know if it's a problem, Christian, but it's certainly a challenge.
The 2025 911 Carrera GTS T Hybrid takes the 911, you know, that's the standard bearer
for six-figure super performance sports cars, and it ups the ante yet again.
Aston Martin hasn't stood still with the Vantage, but neither has Porsche with the Carrera.
And now this GTS has more horsepower than ever before,
tons of other performance upgrades, and it's the quickest 911 Carrera we've ever seen.
So Aston's got to at least match, if not topple,
this stalwart before it really talks about the Ferraris and the McLarens of the world.
Yeah. Well, let's go find out if it can do it.
All right, Mac, as a Porsche aficionado, what makes a 911 so special?
Everybody probably has their own answer to that question, but one thing that's a common theme,
I think, with 911 enthusiasts in particular, certainly over years and years and years,
if there's one word that you would use to describe the 911, it's probably pure,
right, or purity of the experience.
That's pretty relevant to the car we're driving today because
this is the first electrified 911 ever.
Yeah, 53 horsepower, 110 pound-foot motor,
that's basically wedged into the bellhousing of the eight-speed PDK.
I'm sure there's been plenty of people,
Porsche fans, who've talked amongst themselves about, is that right for the 911?
And I understand that discussion and debate and all that, but
all you have to do is drive this new GTS T-Hybrid, as Porsche calls it,
and you realize all it does is up the experience by that much more by giving you a boatload of power.
It's pushed this car to 532 horsepower, which you normally would not have
in anything short of the big boy 911 turbo, right, or a GT...
Three.
Yeah, GT3, GT2, GT division car.
Here's the thing, it's completely seamless.
I have no idea what's going on other than what the screen tells me.
It recharges itself, by the way, really quickly.
Yeah, and it's a small battery of only 1.9 kilowatts
in the front where the 12-volt would be, so you're not messing with the weight distribution.
Not that that's something that Porsche is ever really worried about, considering where the engine is.
Yeah, but from the work that's gone in over the years,
taming the behavior of this platform with the rear engine, and now with big power,
all it does is make it a little more lively.
You know, the back end is willing to play around a little bit,
but it certainly isn't intimidating.
It's so seamlessly easy to drive, it's intuitive to drive,
and it just inspires huge, huge confidence,
no matter what kind of situation you find yourself in.
But I think it's really important to note that if you didn't tell me,
and I'm willing to wager if you didn't tell anyone else,
maybe there's a pro race driver out there who races 911s,
who's so sensitive to the power delivery and the way everything feels more than I am,
they can say, oh, this must be a hybrid boosted car,
but I don't think anyone who buys one of these,
or is even thinking about buying one of these,
will ever know what's going on with all that stuff, unless you tell them.
Yeah, I totally agree with you.
I like to fool myself into thinking I can maybe notice it near red line when it shifts.
You kind of get, it feels to me like a late surge of power
when there shouldn't be power necessarily,
but honestly, it could be my mind playing tricks on me.
Let's find out.
I don't know, man.
I think it's just fast.
Yeah, I think that's what it is.
It's just fast.
I think they were smarter approaching the hybrid this way
versus maybe what Chevy did with the Corvette E-Ray.
That's also has its own benefits,
but that feels different to other Corvettes,
whereas, I mean, you got a great thing going with an i11.
Why ruin it, you know?
For sure, and it certainly hasn't ruined it.
I was very curious to drive this car after reading about it,
our previous reporting about it.
I wanted to know as well, you know,
does this somehow alter the question you asked me in the beginning?
What is a 911?
What's the experience all about?
What defines a 911?
What defines it is exactly what we've got here.
We've got great handling,
I think probably the best steering on the market still today.
Yeah, it's really good.
And it almost feels like it steers itself at times,
which it can, you know,
with the lane departure safety system and all that,
but it does really feel like it just knows
where you want to put it at all times,
and it just sort of follows your hands.
What I like about this car a little bit more
than I like about the Vantage is the,
I wouldn't say the steering is remotely delicate,
but it certainly is lighter.
And with the lighter front end,
physically, by virtue of having the engine in the back,
it just feels like it's a little more eager to turn into corners
than the Aston Martin does.
Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
I liken it to your ice skating,
and you do a crossover to make a turn,
and you just dig into the ice and rip out the next bend.
And the tires grip so quick, so much,
and that front end is so quick.
It's, you know, really, really engaging.
So what would the Vantage have to do
in order to match this level of engagement
and, you know, cohesion of performance?
I think the Vantage has to immediately feel like a driver's car,
not a GT car, as it mostly has in the past.
It needs to communicate what it's doing at all times.
It needs to tell you what the front tires are doing,
and it needs to be able to go around corners
in a way that doesn't feel remotely lazy, right?
So there's no way it's going to feel like this car
because it's, in a lot of senses, it's the opposite.
Right.
Here you've got a relatively small Boxer 6 engine
all the way behind you.
There you've got a big V8 all the way in front of you.
You know, they've moved the engine as far back
behind the front axle as they can in the Aston,
so that helps the balance, I'm sure.
But there's no way around the fact
that it's just not going to feel exactly the same.
But if it can use a platform with that layout
and get anywhere close to the overall performance and experience,
I think that makes it a legitimate contender
and option for people who, as much as I love Porsches
and 911s, and I know you do too,
sometimes you've had enough of it.
Definitely feels like a bigger car.
Yeah, I was going to say, it's the first thing you notice, right?
From behind the wheel, with that steering wheel in particular,
it's a lot thicker than the wheel on the Porsche,
and the steering itself is notably heavier.
Yeah, I wouldn't say it's better or worse,
it's just different in its character.
Imagine British cars have that really light,
delicate, tactile feeling, and this is not that.
This is neither light nor delicate in any way.
No, it is not.
It sounds really good.
Yeah, this AMG-sourced turbo V8 is a monster.
With 600 horsepower, it punches hard, to put it mildly.
On a road like this, this wasn't necessarily
an Aston Martin's forte in the past,
or it's certainly maybe not where it wanted to live all the time,
but this Vantage, it's kind of made for this.
Yeah, it feels at home.
I mean, I'm quite easily into a rhythm now.
I'm used to the size.
Yeah, it's easy to place.
It's engaging.
I'm having fun.
I don't know if you are.
But that's the thing, is the capability of this car is so high,
I have no concerns about flying off the road.
Not that you should in any modern car, but much like the 911 GTS,
this car takes everything you throw at it, no problem.
I think the combination of the heavier steering setup
and front weight bias versus the rear engine 911,
it gives it a completely different character.
And it's kind of funny because it's similar in the sense that
it goes like heck in a straight line.
It stops really well.
It handles corners really well.
But it feels different in the way that it's doing it, as you would expect.
But at the same time, is it a huge difference to you?
I don't know that it's affecting the fun much.
I think the 911 feels a little more, to use the word we used a minute ago,
delicate maybe.
It is a little bit lighter, maybe 200 pounds-ish.
It's not nothing, but it's not super substantial,
especially in a car making this much horsepower and torque.
So it's just more the balance of the two chassis.
The 911 front end seems a little more eager.
But again, that's to be expected because you're pushing around
everything in the front of this car.
Yeah, it's just the way it handles, it's just slightly different.
There's a slightly different character to it, but it's quite enjoyable.
It's a much stiffer platform than it was in the past.
And I think we mentioned earlier, you might call it a facelift.
But it's, to me, a facelift.
It's like a new front fascia, literally, and maybe a new infotainment system
and some tail light treatments and things like that.
Maybe a slight horsepower bump.
Which, oh, by the way, this has all those things too.
Oh yeah, right, it does.
But on top of that, it's a huge power upgrade.
It's a huge chassis upgrade.
It's a software upgrade on the way that the differential
and all the stability control and traction control system works.
So it really has, to me, changed the character from the Gen 1 version
of this AM6 Vantage platform.
Yeah, the one thing that really stands out to me is how thoughtful
all the upgrades were.
They didn't just make it stiffer and it's like, that's better.
It's stiffer while not having any drawbacks.
There's payoff for it.
It's quite a good ride.
Software going on, it lets you get that little bit of slip on a tight corner,
which makes it honestly way more engaging and way more fun.
So you can turn it quickly.
It feels bigger initially, but it doesn't drive bigger.
So it doesn't feel like a bigger car.
Yeah, you make a great point.
And that goes back to what we were saying about substantial and delicate.
It's absolutely substantial, especially when you look at it by itself,
say on the side of the road or in a parking lot or even in your garage.
It looks like it's a big car, but then you put it next to the Porsche
and they're pretty much a similar footprint.
I don't have all the dimensions here in front of me as we're driving,
but this isn't like something that is in a different size class
than the 911 at all, like not at whatsoever.
So just the long hood gives that illusion
and it makes you feel like right now we're in a bigger car.
It might be a little wide.
I think it's a little wider.
It's a little wider.
You've certainly got more shoulder space,
but it's not too much car for a road like this.
And this is a tight, twisty, but quick road at the same time.
I don't feel like this car is overkill for it whatsoever.
No, and this is like the natural stomping grounds of a 911.
You come up here on a Friday morning or any weekend,
it's 911 city.
They're everywhere.
You can't throw a rock without getting one.
Oh, absolutely.
And this is just completely at home.
I think it'll be really interesting to see
what the average enthusiast thinks when we pull up to newcomers.
So let's look at car from two perspectives,
from purely just for the look, the shape wise.
Vintage is so much sexier than the 911.
Well, of course, 911, they have to stick to the original shape, right?
Because it's 911, right?
But the newer vintage are just so much more prettier to look at or even to drive.
So yeah, my take just for the look will be on a vintage.
And also for me, I collect a lot of cars,
the classic proportions of a sports car,
you know, the longer hood.
The wide head.
Yeah, and this just does it for me.
I'm gonna have to go with the Porsche.
Visually, I think it just looks sick.
I think it's a, it's kind of like a tighter looking car.
I feel like this, I mean, I know it's a hell of a lot of fun,
but still, but it looks like a bit of a boat.
I think this is gonna rip through some canyons.
I'm a Porsche guy, but I will say,
I think Aston's making the best looking cars in the game right now.
The facelift is a nice touch.
Everything, the roar, just all sick looking cars.
Different price point,
but I would definitely take that over my 911.
I never claimed to be a car expert.
I am an enthusiast, but I always feel
every sports car wants to grow up and be the Porsche.
So what do you think the Aston would need to do
to grow up to be like the Porsche?
No, the Aston's in a class all its own,
but I would call this like,
they used to call my RS5 Grand Touring.
Just a little heavy, very comfortable, lots of power.
I put more power into it,
but I think it's in a separate class myself
and it'll never be this, but it doesn't have to be.
It's in its own class.
It is probably at the top of its own class.
So it's a wonderful thought.
All right, so we just had a day of hard driving the mountains
and talked to some enthusiasts about these cars.
What did we learn, Mac?
I think we learned a hell of a lot,
especially about the Aston Martin Vantage.
It's absolutely now a world-class driver's car, sports car.
To me, the Porsche, it's a little lighter.
It's a little more nimble.
The steering's a little lighter, more direct.
The gearbox is a little sharper.
A little more responsive all around.
All around.
So from a pure driving standpoint,
the 911 Carrera GTS T Hybrid still takes it,
but this is not far behind.
It's a world-class driver's car.
And look at this body.
Oh yeah, it's stunning.
And I would agree with everything you said.
This is the car I'd rather drive.
I don't know if it's the car I'd rather own,
for all the things you said.
Sure.
It's beautiful.
It's comfortable.
It does almost everything as well as the 911 up here,
but it's got its own unique thing going on.
And I thought we learned a little bit about that too
when we talked to all those enthusiasts today.
Yeah, I think that was really informative.
And it really does speak to how important the entire package is.
So if you're not hellbent on just the absolute
finest grain performance driving experience,
but you can get almost all of that,
plus everything that comes with the Vantage,
it's a hard choice.
Yeah, it really is.
But if you are hellbent, to steal Max's words,
on the most absolute finest driving experience,
then you'll agree with the two of us
that the Porsche 911 GTS is the winner of this comparison.
For more on these two cars, the test data,
all the details, head to MotorTrend.com.
