Federal prosecutor Jim Trusty discussed the legal implications of the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling and President Donald Trump's basis for using the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to impose tariffs, and the Court's focus on balance of powers in its ruling.
Trusty said the Trump administration should build limits on products and fuse length into tariffs, as in picking the top 20 imports from China to impose a tariff on them that relates to unfair trade practices to survive scrutiny.
Trusty also discussed the dissenting opinions calling out the practical consequence of refunding tariffs to foreign nations, and how Trump could work with Congress to get more authority, while imposing Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 to combat foreign unfair trade practices. -- 📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
So how can President Trump proceed after the Supreme Court striking down his use of emergency
powers to impose tariffs?
Joining me now to break it all down is former federal prosecutor Jim Trustee.
Jim, great to have you back on the program.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessin, Jim, saying today's ruling doesn't impact tariffs at all.
Here's what he said.
Let's be clear about what today's ruling was.
The court did not rule against President Trump's tariffs.
Six justices simply ruled that IEPA authorities cannot be used to raise even $1 of revenue.
This administration will invoke alternative legal authorities to replace the IEPA tariffs.
Jim, if you could start off just by laying out in simple terms for us what the court
ruled about IEPA and what it does and does not ultimately mean for the president's tariffs.
Sure.
So, you know, the power of the purse is something we always correctly associate with Congress.
That's from Article One of the Constitution.
It says Congress can levy taxes and tariffs and can do the spending.
But in certain circumstances in our history, including IEPA in the 1970s, Congress delegates
some limited authority to the president, to the executive branch, to impose regulation over trade.
And that becomes kind of a key phrase here.
This regulation idea has to be in the context of a declared national emergency.
So clearly it's kind of an emergency economic power where they're delegating for nimbleness,
for speed to the president.
And so in this case, President Trump announced two national emergencies.
One was fentanyl and the other was a large trade deficit.
And remember, this started off with the fentanyl component where he was levying tariffs on
China, Canada and Mexico, all logically connected to something you could probably legitimately
call a crisis, an emergency.
And that was kind of the easy part of this equation, I think, for using IEPA or at least
hoping to use IEPA.
When it began to expand to the trade deficit, it sounds less like an emergency.
And it became something where every country in the world was in play.
And what the Supreme Court focused on was a couple of things.
Number one, regulation does not mean tariffs.
And you could argue, well, isn't that less than a prohibition of trade?
Shouldn't it be on kind of a spectrum?
And the Supreme Court in the 6-3 opinion basically says, no, it's not a spectrum.
It's an entirely different concept.
Tariffs are kind of completely different than blocking trade in one direction or another.
And they pointed to the fact that Congress repeatedly has passed laws that referred to
regulation and imposing tariffs, and they didn't do it here.
So for statutory intent, they look at it and say, this means Congress did not mean to give
them the power to use tariffs.
And so that really is what it comes down to, is a combination of some bad facts, like not
believing the trade deficit is the type of emergency that IEPA contemplated, and then
just kind of the never-ending width and breadth of these tariffs.
In other words, they're not limited by time.
They're not limited to particular goods.
They are nation to nation and very different numbers depending on the negotiations.
All of that, I think, for most of us that are kind of free traders, works surprisingly
well. Our prices, our inflation and our prices of goods have not gone up like a lot of
doomsayers thought they would.
But now we're left with this new world where they have to find an alternative basis to
try to reimpose these tariffs, or they're stuck with some real practical devils in the
detail. But again, 6-3 Supreme Court conservatives.
And by the way, one last thing on that, Steve, in oral argument, I think it was Gorsuch
that said, what if we had a different regime, a different presidency, and they wanted to
use IEPA to say global warming was a crisis and we need to have 60 percent tariffs on
every country in the world?
The government said that would probably be OK under IEPA.
And I think that was the end of having any chance of Gorsuch joining the more
conservative part of the court.
Really fascinating stuff, a lot at play here.
The president, Jim, defiant, like his Treasury secretary that we just heard from
saying this ruling has confirmed he does have certain authorities which he will now use
even more forcefully than before.
Here's the president on that.
The good news is that there are methods, practices, statutes and authorities as
recognized by the entire court in this terrible decision and also is recognized by
Congress, which they refer to, that are even stronger than the IEPA tariffs available
to me as president of the United States.
So, Jim, let's take a look at some of the remaining tariff authorities.
There's three that he's highlighting today.
Section 232, this is tariffs for national security like steel, aluminum in the auto
industry. Section 301, this is for unfair trade practices, for example, China.
And Section 122 for trade deficits, although this is a temporary power.
Which of these, Jim, might the president now lean into?
And are there any drawbacks to them?
I think my best guess is they're going to lean into 301 because that's really the most
expansive of the three.
It doesn't have built in fuse lengths and it allows for, I think, a pretty straight
faced argument that there's unfair practices coming in from a lot of places,
particularly China. So I think they'll lean into 301.
You know, I think there's a lesson to be learned, which is, number one, the Supreme
Court is looking at this as a balance of powers issue.
It's very clearly defined.
You're starting with Congress being in the driver's seat.
So you better have very specific language supporting you if you're going to try to do
tariffs as the chief executive.
And by the way, Congress should have been backing him up.
Like if you want to have a villain in this piece, it's not the Supreme Court, it's
Congress. They should have basically tried to find a way to back him up with statutory
help through this process.
But they didn't do that. But with 301, here's the word of wisdom I would give from
this opinion. Build some limits into it.
In other words, pick specific goods, maybe a whole bunch of goods from China.
Pick a fuse length.
Say this is a tariff that's going to be in place for the next six months or for the
next year. Then we'll revisit it.
The more you show a little bit of restriction and not try to make it an all
encompassing, all goods forever global thing, the better it's going to play when we
litigate it again, which is going to happen.
We're going to have people suing in the district courts and going up through the
courts of appeal. And the Supreme Court may not be done with this.
So I think you want to set it up to have the best facts supporting your limited use
of this power. And you can still get a lot done, but it's just not as easy as
announcing blanket numbers.
Certainly making it a little bit more difficult, the timetable and just the extra
procedural steps.
The president was using these tariffs, Jim, for foreign policy leverage in large part,
especially to counter the CCP's aggressive trade practices.
Could he now go country by country to determine if tariffs can be used as a tool for
national security? And what will that process ultimately look like?
Yeah, I mean, he's not undeclaring the emergency with fentanyl, so I think there's
some room there. And I think with China, unfair trade practices is always a fair
argument to make. I just think that, you know, pick the top 20 imports from China and
put a tariff on them that relates to unfair trade practices.
And it's going to survive scrutiny a little bit better than these kind of overarching
blanket unending numbers.
So we'll see because it's all going to go back to court.
This is like the Full Employment Act for lawyers, Steve.
But but predicting an actual outcome right now is not that easy with the Supreme Court
case because it doesn't really deal with the alternatives that apparently President
Trump and his treasury secretary are anticipating.
Well, to that point, Jim, another open ended issue that was left unanswered is the issue
of refunds making companies or countries or whoever whole that has been paying these
tariffs now that it's been overruled or set back.
The dissenting opinions today noted that the ruling didn't clearly lay out if, how,
when or how much the U.S.
would have to potentially pay back any tariff revenue.
How do you think the law might settle on this?
Yeah, I mean, this is literally the biggest devil in the details.
I think this is so hard to figure out because what your viewers need to remember is, you
know, tariffs are paid by the importing company.
And so in one sense, you could say, well, if they paid an extra 20 percent, that's what
they're entitled to. But the reality is they usually pass that on to the customer.
So their price goes up a little bit to cover that tariff.
And all of us that bought goods at Pier One Imports end up paying for the tariff.
So does that mean we get our dollar 46 back or do we get a hundred dollars or does the
company just take a blank raw number?
I think that is an insanely challenging component to this because we're talking about
billions of dollars and the dissent's right to kind of call out that there's a practical
consequence that none of us knows how it's going to play.
My assumption is, you know, the president probably had a pretty good sense that this may
well not go go his way today and that over the next few days we're going to see a flurry
of activity, including possibly working with Congress to get some authority, but imposing
under 301 the same numbers, the same tariffs, maybe trying to make stuff sound
retroactive. You know, bluffing might work pretty well with a good number of countries
who realize the only way to undo the bluff is to watch litigation that might take
another year to happen. So I think there's a lot of kind of arm twisting that can take
place to keep the regime largely in place as it is now.
But again, I think there's some fine tuning that's going to help protect them from
future litigation where the Supreme Court again takes offense at just the unlimited
scope of the current tariff scheme.
Former federal prosecutor Jim Trustee, greatly appreciate your insights on this.
Thank you.