Considering its $200+ price and terrible specs, Johnnie Walker Blue Label may be the most overpriced scotch whisky on the market. To consider just how expensive this whisky is, I discuss a couple of alternate blended malts as honorable mentions, then share a list of TEN single malt whiskies I would choose for less than the price of the Johnnie Walker Blue Label.
Please remember to Subscribe for more videos like this one, and follow us on Instagram: @whiskyabouts to vote in polls and stay up to date with what's coming up on the channel.
If you're watching this video on my channel,
you're probably not here to comparison shop
Johnny Walker Blue label, right?
And even if you've ever had it though,
you're probably familiar with this whiskey
because it's kind of everywhere, at least here in the US,
for a whiskey that's sort of positioned
as a sort of luxury exclusive thing.
It's also very expensive and not very impressive.
So today we're gonna have a little fun on the channel
and I sort of made a list of the sort of 10 bottles
of really worthy whiskeys that you could buy
if you traded in a bottle of Johnny Walker Blue
at the whiskey shop.
That list starts right now.
My whiskey journey has taken me to Scotland and back.
I've explored whiskey education, tastings,
and distilleries from Islay to Speyside.
Now my journey continues here with you
on Whiskey Whereabouts.
As always, when we do these videos,
I have to point out that whiskey prices vary wildly,
not just from here in the US to other countries,
but within the states, from state to state, shop to shop.
But I've been sort of looking at a market price
of Johnny Walker Blue label at about $210.
And the price for the bottles I'm comparing
are from the sort of same market,
so it's all relative anyway.
You spring for the Johnny Walker Blue,
you will buy blended whiskey.
It's green whiskey in the batting.
40% ABV, it has color added.
It is chill filtered.
It does not have an age statement.
So none of that's very good.
It has a reputation, sort of word around on the street,
sort of gossipy, that the whiskey in the batting
is very old, and old whiskey is expensive to age.
And it is believed to be sometimes 23 years, 25 years,
28 years, you know, the youngest whiskey
in the Johnny Walker Blue.
It's very, very drinkable,
but it sort of vanishes sort of in your mouth
as soon as you have a sip of it on the palate,
let alone the finish.
It is a whiskey for people who wanna flex,
who don't drink a lot of scotch whiskey.
So I'm gonna start with a couple,
as we normally do, honorable mentions.
And my first honorable mention
is going to be the Johnny Walker Green label.
If you want Johnny Walker, the Green label
is the one most whiskey people will tell you
is the worthwhile.
And the thing about the Green label
is that A, it has a 15-year age statement,
and B, it's a blended malt.
So it is a blend of four Diageo single malts,
Talisker, Kragenmoor, Kalila, Linkwood.
It's a 43% whiskey, and it is decently priced
for a 15-year age statement when it's based
on those sort of caliber of single malts.
Another honorable mention, though,
if we want a really premium blended malt,
I will point you over to Compass Box,
the gold standard for blended malts,
blended scotches in the sort of whiskey world right now.
And I would say you can get your hands
on No Name No. 3.
If you can find it, that's a $190 bottle.
It actually is limited in its quantities.
They only made 11,000 bottles.
It's 48.9%.
It is blended malt, and it has Laphroaig,
Beaumont, and several other whiskeys
that go into this batting.
Mortlock, Kleinlich, obviously, Compass Box,
and one of their other sort of less-identified blends
goes into this whiskey.
It's pretty serious whiskey for $20 cheaper.
So let's take a walk through the whiskey aisle.
It's a well-stocked shop.
We've got a credit in our pocket
for the value of a Johnny Walker Blue label.
I'm gonna start looking around, see what jumps out at me,
and I'm gonna start by checking out
a Ardbeg committee release at No. 10.
It's gonna be the Heavy Vapor.
It's a 2023 committee release.
I'm starting here.
This is No. 10, and it's $160.
This is gonna be a limited sort of run Ardbeg,
but, you know, the hype around these,
you know, the reviews weren't spectacular.
Maybe I'm not that into the Heavy Vapors,
but also, if it's still around,
last year's release, the 2022 release, the Ardcore,
is also about the same price, $160, significantly less
than the Johnny Walker Blue.
At No. 10, sort of A here,
we can add this 46% limited release Ardbeg,
but we could probably do better than that,
so we're gonna keep looking around,
and I am going to go in the opposite direction,
go a little sweeter now, and I see a Tamdue 15 here, okay?
This is $150 bottle.
It's even cheaper, and I could probably buy a Tamdue 15
and a Port Charlotte 10 with the value that I have here,
but focus on this Tamdue.
It's gonna be 46%.
It's non-chill filters, no color added,
that age statement, very quality, solid whiskey,
but I'm gonna keep looking,
and I'm gonna look for a little bit more
in terms of the age statement,
and that's where I'm gonna check out Talisker 18 here,
which I can also buy for about $185.
That's that standard weird Talisker ABV of 45.8%,
and it is chill filtered, you know, Biagio,
but a pretty significant still discount
from that Johnny Walker,
but I'm still looking around.
There might be something that's even better,
and save me a little bit more money,
and that's where I'm gonna be looking for this bottle.
If I can find it for retail price in the $170 range,
easier said than done, but if I can find it,
Springbank 15 at number seven, we're only at number seven.
If you can find, this is a whiskey I like, I don't love.
I'm gonna keep looking around,
but it's certainly a very good value here at about $170,
maybe $175, so I'm going to space out
for Glen Allakey 18 year.
That is right, 18 year Glen Allakey
for less than the cost of the Johnny Walker Blue Label.
This is a 46% whiskey.
It is a batting of Oloroso, Pedro Jimenez, and Virgin Oak.
Some people are more partial to the 15,
think it's a better value,
but there's no debate that we have a whiskey
that is a very substantial whiskey
from a very, very respectable distillery
coming in with that 18 year age statement
for less than the cost of the Johnny Walker Blue.
That is sort of the first half.
We're now sort of at an intermission
before we crack the top five,
and it's a lot of quality bottles
that haven't even inched up against
that Johnny Walker price tag, so entering the top five.
Now, things are getting serious,
and we're gonna start with Ball Blair 18.
It's 192-ish dollars relative to these other ones.
Should be less than 200 retail.
46% bourbon matured.
It's finished in Spanish oak.
It's non-chill filtered.
This is a serious whiskey as an alternative.
Speaking of serious whiskeys,
we haven't talked about Bergladi yet,
and that's gotta be fixed,
so we got the Port Charlotte Cask Exploration Series.
Here I have the Pack 01.
This is the one with the Sequoia Wine Cask
that I reviewed on the channel,
and there is an alternative in this price category.
It should be about 170,
and for about $170, I can get the OLC.
55.1% Syrah vin du natural.
Bourbon cask matured, finished in Oloroso.
These are pretty special whiskeys.
They are serious whiskeys,
and they are a lot more substantial
than our Johnny Walker that we talked about before.
Little bit of sherry influence here.
It's sherry matured, bourbon matured.
Let's see a knock 18 here.
It's 46% whiskey.
It's gonna take pretty much every dollar
of that Johnny Walker price tag.
I've got about 207, 208.
It's right underneath.
That's a lot.
It's a lot of whiskey for the same price.
So this next whiskey is ducking under the price threshold
we're talking about as close as probably is possible.
A lot of 18-year whiskeys did not make this list.
They were priced just beyond where I had pegged
the threshold for the Johnny Walker Blue or well beyond,
and this one is one that's a little hard to come by.
It's not everywhere, so it makes it a little harder
to make that one for comparison,
but I have identified it as being available
in the same inventory as the Johnny Walker Blue label
at less, not just equal to,
so I have included the Lecheg 18-year.
This is a whiskey that should cost, if you can find it,
more than the 200, $210, $212, right up against
where I have that Johnny Walker Blue label bottle priced,
but for that price, you are getting 18-year whiskey, 46.3%.
It's bourbon matured in sherry finish.
This is the peated whiskey from Tobermory,
and it is a very serious whiskey to be compared
in the same category with the Johnny Walker Blue.
So number one, kind of gonna go in the opposite direction
from Johnny Walker Blue.
You kind of go with a whiskey a little bit younger
from Campbelltown.
This is a Kilkerran 16-year.
This is a $200 bottle of whiskey.
If you can find it, then you can get it
at its sort of retail price, 46%, all the specs.
It's Springbank Cistern Distillery,
and this is sort of the really sort of hot whiskeys
recently for people who are not in the market
for Johnny Walker Blue.
So just kind of to kind of finish it off with that contrast,
but honestly, nothing on this list
is really a viable alternative.
There's not a lot of overlap between the markets
for these whiskeys and something like the Johnny Walker Blue.
It's more to just have a little fun
with how much that whiskey bottle costs.
And if you had fun with this list, you enjoyed it,
I'd love it if you subscribe.
You can press this button right here.
Won't miss any future videos like this one.
I will see you then.