Lt. Col. Darin Gaub (Ret.) joined NTD News Today to discuss the Supreme Court’s ruling against President Donald Trump’s use of the International Emergency Economic Powers Act to tariff other nations. -- 📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
Welcome back.
I'm Paul Greene.
In response to today's Supreme Court decision, the House Select Committee on the Chinese
Communist Party is stressing that China is not an equal trading partner.
The committee warns that China continues to engage with predatory trade practices that's
harming American workers, gutting a manufacturing base, and endangering national security.
It argues that tariffs on China help laying the playing field for American workers.
President Trump has proven tariffs are one of the few effective tools to confront Beijing.
Now Chairman John Muellner is urging Congress to pass a bipartisan bill revoking China's
privileged trade status, putting American workers first, rebuilding our manufacturing
strength, and creating a consistent, tough trade policy toward China.
With us now to talk about the Supreme Court's ruling against President Trump's tariff
is geopolitical strategist and national security analyst, Colonel Darren Gobb.
Darren, great to see you.
Colonel, what an amazing and incredible ruling.
The implications, not just for us here in America, but globally.
Your reaction?
Yeah.
Hey, good afternoon, Paul.
Frankly, I'm not surprised.
I kind of saw how this was going in some of the discussions that we'd seen over the past
months and the powers that were being challenged.
I'm not surprised at all that this is how the ruling went.
What I'm curious about will be how the Treasury Secretary and the team there have built that
backup plan, as you highlighted earlier there in that Fox News recording.
We'll see what that says.
I think in some ways, this will hurt temporarily in the long run, the Supreme Court checking
is mandated and what the executive powers are mandated and what the difference is.
That can be healthy for a nation like ours, because what can be used for good now could
be used for not so good later by a different administration.
So by the letter of law, I think this is probably close to right.
But the question will be, what's plan B?
Colonel, you made an interesting point since this ruling came down.
The president has used the tariffs as, you could say, his main point of leverage in negotiations,
geopolitical tactic, strategy.
Now if the president does not have such power over tariffs or if that has been limited,
perhaps America's main leverage may now revert to its military strength.
It might.
And that's frankly what the president has used mostly throughout history, because that's
the one they have the greatest control over.
It's the one they can give an order to immediately and have it responded to virtually immediately
as well.
And so when you're thinking about the elements of national power that could be exercised,
you've got diplomacy, information, military, and economic.
If you take out part of the economic or maybe in total the economic, then you're left really
with diplomacy and military.
Information kind of wraps it all together.
But when you deal with diplomacy, there's no or very few carrot and sticks there.
It's not a point where there's a lot of leverage you can gain.
It's a game of niceties, and it may or may not work.
And what does that leave as far as potentially having to push through a major point of leverage?
It comes down to the military, and that's unfortunate because it shouldn't be the leading
edge of our foreign policy, frankly.
The economics should be.
And that's where Congress has given up its power in the first place.
I would think most Americans would agree with you on that, Darren.
To not have to use the military as a piece of leverage is obviously the ideal situation.
An interesting point is the tariffs may need to go through Congress.
Can you imagine the difficulty and the speed or lack thereof of trying to get something
like the President's broad and sweeping tariff policy and agenda through Congress?
Getting anything through Congress can be difficult, it seems.
And of course, that's partly by design.
But when it comes to Congress working and using one of their few powers when it comes
to foreign policy, which is tariffs, they have given up that responsibility entirely
and never even exercised, much like they've given up their responsibility towards declaring
war in accordance with our Constitution.
When they give up those powers, they actually give up some of the greatest powers they have
towards influencing things like our foreign policy in one of the few ways that they can.
So I don't expect Congress to take any action to actually do anything to use tariffs and
other similar items to help enhance America's national security interests.
In fact, I think they're just going to continue down the same road they always have been and
you're not going to see much change.
And they're going to push the President back into using primarily the military once again.
Such a fascinating point.
Colonel, the President said to visit China next month.
What do you think this ruling is going to mean for negotiation?
Well, no doubt that our foreign adversaries have seen this and said, yeah, they like our
Supreme Court all of a sudden.
And Trump has, you know, you can argue whether it's been successful or not and who's paid
the price on various things, but our foreign adversaries who have been dealing with us
on an economic front for a long time now are looking at this going, great.
They have taken away, actually, one of the powers the President has been using against
us quite successfully.
China has paid a big price under the tariff wars, as I call them.
And to have that removed from the table, that takes a big leverage point for the President
off that table when he meets with them in person.
China knows it.
There's no doubt whatsoever that they will use it to their advantage as well.
And look, we have the whole economics of it.
There's Darin, right?
This is trade.
This is economics.
The President also, though, using these tariffs to dissuade China from allowing fentanyl precursors
to reach Mexico and other places and then make it to America.
I think another interesting point, the President, you know, he takes a lot of pride in ending
conflicts and preventing conflicts.
A big use of his tariffs was, you know, anybody who does business with Iran, anybody who does
business with Russia, you're going to get a tariff.
We saw India kind of bending to this recently.
How do you see this ruling impacting the President's ability to actually achieve peace where he
wants to?
Well, it will depend on what their plan B is within the Treasury, and I think they knew
all along that this tariff fight in the Supreme Court was going to ultimately be a loss.
It's not as clear cut as you can't use tariffs in general at all.
There are some nuances to it when it comes to emergency powers versus the things he can
push through Article 2 presidential powers and regulation.
But ultimately, this is not going to help our national security in relationship with
some of these nations, because, you know, now how do you how do you talk to them?
How do you potentially try to influence some of the things that other nations are doing
that could be negative, that are negative, without now that you have to skip past the
economics and go via other means that some of these nations may not care about, because
in the end, what's what's one of the truisms of politics, power and influence is always
follow the money.
And if you can't influence that, well, it's going to be a lot harder to influence other
nations.
It's just incredible to think of everything, notes here, Darren, about, you know, you brought
up the fiscal situation and people perhaps looking forward to tariff rebate checks, talking
about refunding the businesses who've already paid these tariffs.
We had the UK and the EU saying, oh, we're going to contact the America, contact the
Trump administration, see how this impacts us.
It's just a sweeping.
It's just a sweeping change.
That's Colonel Darren Gobb, a colonel, as always.
Great to speak with you.
Take care.
You too, Paul.
Thank you.