It’s time to fundamentally rethink America’s approach to the Chinese Communist Party, argues Sam Brownback, former U.S. senator, Kansas governor, U.S. ambassador-at-large for international religious freedom, and author of the new book “China’s War on Faith.”
Ahead of President Donald Trump’s high-stakes summit with Chinese leader Xi Jinping in Beijing, I’m sitting down with Brownback to understand what’s really at stake and why he believes America is wasting the greatest leverage it has had.
“I think we’ve just got to recognize: ... This is an evil regime. They've killed more of their own people than any other regime in the history of mankind, and we've been treating them like a normal country,” Brownback says.
Brownback lays out the case that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is currently conducting three genocides—against the Uyghur Muslims, Falun Gong practitioners, and Tibetan Buddhists—through mass detention, torture, cultural eradication, and forced organ harvesting. At the same time, the regime is escalating its war on Christianity, arresting pastors, and crushing underground churches, Brownback says.
Now, the CCP is also exporting the technologies it uses to surveil and persecute dissidents to at least 80 other countries, he says.
For decades, human rights and religious freedom has been a “red line” for the Chinese regime that American leaders and diplomats have tiptoed around.
But the reality is that human rights and religious freedom are the CCP’s deepest vulnerability and insecurity—and America’s most potent weapon and leverage against this regime, Brownback argues.
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
<html>
<head><title>404 Not Found</title></head>
<body>
<center><h1>404 Not Found</h1></center>
<hr><center>nginx</center>
</body>
</html>
We've just got to recognize this is an evil regime. They've killed more of their own people
than any other regime in the history of mankind, and we've been treating them like a normal country.
Ahead of President Trump's visit to China, I'm sitting down with Sam Brownback,
former ambassador, governor, and senator, and author of the new book, China's War on Faith.
Human rights when it comes to the Chinese regime are basically the no-go zone publicly, aren't they?
This is a strategy of the Chinese Communist Party,
and it's one that we should turn around and use as an offensive tool against them.
After decades in public service,
Brownback says he's now confronting the biggest beast of his career.
They've built a satellite set of countries, and they're exporting this digital
authoritarianism technology to at least 80 different countries that we've tracked.
They are at war with us, whether we realize we're at war with them or not.
This is American Thought Leaders, and I'm Jan Jekielek.
Sam Brownback, such a pleasure to have you on American Thought Leaders.
Thanks, John. It's great to be back with you. I always enjoy our conversations and
how we look at the world and some of the huge dangers in the world today.
I appreciate your willingness to surface them and to shine a light on it for people.
Huge congratulations on today's launch of China's War on Faith, your new book.
Before we go talking about it, let's talk about the visit of President Trump to China,
meeting with Xi Jinping. Do you expect that human rights issues might be raised there?
I have pretty low expectations on this first meeting. I think President Trump is going to
try to really be as bromance-oriented as possible, probably just trying to, okay, let's try to be
nice to each other. Let's try to settle things down in the world. I hope he raises some of these
issues. He said he's going to raise Pastor Ezra Jin. I wouldn't doubt he'll raise some
of the individual isolated cases, but I'm just not expecting too much because
the Chinese Communist Party has set their face. They're arresting hundreds of Christian pastors
now. They've beat on all these other people of faith. They've done wolf diplomacy around the
world. Their long-term strategy has been pretty obvious for some time, and to abruptly move away
from that at this point in time seems unlikely to me. Something that's really interesting,
which I hadn't thought about recently, the NTD White House correspondent, Mary Atsu,
got a question in to Secretary Rubio about whether human rights were raised. I'm going
to mention that in a moment. But basically, human rights when it comes to the Chinese regime
are basically the no-go zone publicly, aren't they?
They really are. They want to raise Taiwan all the time, but you're going,
okay, we'll let you raise Taiwan. We want to talk about Tibet and East Turkestan then.
Taiwan, you own that? Well, you don't own these other guys then. No, no, you can't raise those
issues. You can't talk about any of those issues, and you can't talk about Tibetan Buddhism,
and you can't talk about how we're treating the Uyghurs. So yeah, it's all duplicity on their
part. I think we've just got to recognize, look, this is an evil regime. They've killed
more of their own people than any other regime in the history of mankind, and we've been treating
them like a normal country. I think we're not ready for the full square off right now,
but these two systems are inevitably headed for that.
Let me read to you what Mari asked and how Secretary Rubio responded
in that recent press briefing at the White House.
You've long been a leading voice on human rights in China, including religious persecution and
forced organ harvesting. President Trump prepares to meet Xi Jinping next week.
Do you expect human rights concerns to be on the table?
We always raise those issues, and they remain true. I think we've proven in some cases it's
most effective to raise them in the appropriate setting, but we always raise those issues. They're
important to us, among with others, of course. But those issues remain prominent in our view
and in our conversation about these things, and we'll continue to raise them in the appropriate
forms. What do you take from that?
I take there's not going to be much said about it from that. You know,
Marco Rubio can't change his spots. He's a hot-blooded American with Cuban descent.
He does not like communism. His family has felt directly the impact of communism
on them. He has no love for that system whatsoever, and he doesn't have any love
for it in China either. But I take from that sort of statement, I'm sure there'll be some
mention of it somewhere. I'm sure there'll be some discussion of it, but I wouldn't have high
expectations that there'll be much put on it.
You argue in the book that there are three genocides happening in China,
which is a pretty significant thing to say. I happen to agree with you exactly on this,
actually. But why don't you lay out the argument for me?
The three are the Uyghur genocide, and it's primarily Muslim Uyghurs. They're kind of fine
with the Uyghur culture, but they're not with Islam. It's the only country in the world I've
been able to find you cannot name a child Muhammad. But that's one that's been publicly
declared. But there's a genocide that's been going on in Tibet, a Tibetan Buddhist. Initially,
they slaughtered so many of the Tibetan Buddhists and the leaders, and now it's a cultural genocide,
just really trying to rid the place of Buddhism, Tibetan Buddhism. They want to name the next
Dalai Lama, the Chinese Communist Party, an officially atheistic group wants to name the
next official leader of Tibetan Buddhism and faith, which is just galling and ironic at the
same time. And then Falun Gong, they have decimated this group that got up by Chinese numbers to 90
million at one point in time, probably down 20 million, who knows really what the actual number
is. And on the most diabolical, barbaric ways of locking people up, throwing them in jail,
forced organ harvesting, as you've written about. If somebody wrote about this and said
it happened in the 15th century, you'd kind of go, I can see that. But today,
and it's happening. And that's why I say these are three genocides, because the intent is there
to literally wipe out this group, this culture. Just to talk about that for a moment. You're
using the word genocide very specifically, according to its original intent. This word
is used flippantly these days, usually to describe significant amounts of death,
but what you're talking about is something different.
Well, I'm talking about the legal definition of it, where there is an intent to specifically
wipe out or destroy a group of people. That's the official measure you're supposed to look at
and you can see that in these three cases. There is a specific intent to destroy this group of
people. And that's what's taking place and that's why it fits the definition of having a third
genocide. And it just bothers me no end that then we still kind of treat them as a normal country.
I went to a movie last week, Hail Mary, and I'm not highly recommending the movie,
but the lead pilot of the rocket, it's a sci-fi movie, has a Chinese communist flag
on his sleeve. And he's the lead pilot for this rocket and he's the good guy. And I'm going,
what are you doing here? What is this flag doing in this movie, saving the earth? And why is
Hollywood putting this out? I make the point in the book, Hollywood hadn't put out a film that's
negative towards the Chinese Communist Party or the CCP since 1997, seven years in Tibet
in Kandun. That's the last time, because they're so tied economically in the marketing of the
films. And I'm saying, it's time to stop this, guys. Come on.
Well, it's interesting. I recently watched The Martian. I think the book is by the same author
that wrote Hail Mary, I think so, if I recall correctly. But there's also a kind of a subplot
where they have to get help from the Chinese, some sort of booster. And the Chinese are shown
to be very benevolently wanting to help the Americans, which I wish were true. And certainly,
there's Chinese people in China that would do that, but the regime absolutely would not.
No, they wouldn't. The regime wouldn't do that. And I am for the Chinese people. I have
adopted a Chinese daughter, who I love dearly. I love the Chinese people. I love the Chinese
culture. I do not like the Chinese Communist Party, nor what they've done to the Chinese
people or the country itself. And that's really a critical point to make, that this is the problem,
is the Chinese Communist Party. And for all President Xi's talk about sinicization of it,
which I find really amazing in many respects, because the real interlocutor and the real
stranger in China is communism. It's a European invention, industrialized European invention
that they've put in on the Chinese people. That's the one that needs to be
sinicized and sinicized out of the place.
You're just reminding me, this is something I haven't really covered yet, and I'm going to go
astray a little bit of religion, which is their faith, which is the main focus of our talk today.
But there are these new rules in China around assimilation of ethnic minorities. I'm wondering
if you want to comment on that.
Yeah, what a horrible idea.
I mean, what exactly are they doing? I mean, this is official. They're
implementing some kind of official policy on this. It wasn't so horrible, it would be comical.
Well, and if it wasn't something that places in the world had already done and failed and hurt
people doing, I mean, you can look at our treatment of the American Indians,
the Native Americans in this country, and where we said, okay, we're going to really try to make
you like European settlers. We're going to try to make you like us. And it hurt people, it killed
them. We tried to make their culture our culture. It was a horrible, failed, deadly thing that we
did 100 years ago, and I carried the apology bill for it. And there's still remnants of it, and
China's trying to do that today. And why are you doing it? Why not let these cultures live and
thrive? Why not let people practice the faith the way they want to practice it?
And it's because the Chinese Communist Party must, they believe, maintain strict, tight control over
everybody and every thought. And that's the way they're going to press it in that country,
and that's what they're exporting to their satellite countries around the world.
One thing I wanted to mention is the way that the Chinese regime is very,
very effective at using its propaganda. So they would say, for example, hey, look at the
effects of multicultural policy in America. Look at the discord and the problems that's created
here. That's what they'd say. Well, that's what they would say.
Which it has, in fact. But what they're doing is not the same thing.
And I would argue that this country has assimilated more people of different cultures
from around the world than any country in history of mankind, and by and large successfully,
not without our problems and not without our miscues and missteps at different times
that's happened when we first brought Chinese into this country and the mistreatment of Chinese.
Or you could say that about the Irish or the Italians, or you could kind of almost say that
about any group. But over time, the salad bowl, the mixing pot kind of worked, and it brought
people together, and people came together around a common set of thoughts and ideas,
not around a land mass. And it's about freedom. We believe in freedom. We believe in freedom
for everybody. We believe in the human dignity of each and every individual to be able to decide
that. They're doing nothing of that nature. They're trying to homogenize everybody into
a communist Han Chinese. And it's not going to work. It's not going to be helpful for their
society. It's punitive. It's damaging. It is deadly. And it really should be stopped and also
just called out for what it is. This is just you guys trying to bring everybody in under the
Chinese Han umbrella and make them all atheist communists.
I know so many people that risked a lot to come here, to be able to
basically make something of themselves, live that American dream. This was something,
it was not a forced assimilation. It was a highly willing assimilation,
as long as Americans remained proud. And of course, it was encouraged because it's a great system.
Your juxtaposition here is very apt because over there, this is a strictly coercive idea
in the first place, that policy. Again, I marvel at the way the communists are so good at fostering
this propaganda and kind of twisting whatever is happening to kind of suit their own needs.
Yeah. But we've got to confront it and we should confront it. It's been interesting
me to watch the AI move because you put a question in on AI and it answers it.
But in their closed system that they have, because they control all the media and they've got the
great Chinese firewall on the internet and you can't get inside of that. But the AI searches
everything. So you plug in, what's the Chinese dream? And the answer came back to move to
America. Really?
Yeah. Oh, like on the American ones?
Well, on the Chinese ones.
On the Chinese ones.
Yeah. And so they go, okay, we got to get this answer cleaned up. And so whenever you control
all the means of information, you can't let the cat slip out of the bag anywhere. And so they've
got like 900 questions that any AI system must first answer and answer properly before they'll
let it use. This was the article I was reading and I haven't verified the article, but I was
laughing at it when I was reading because that's what would actually happen. If you've got an open
system and you can search anywhere, well, okay, we can't have an open system then, can we?
We're going to have to have a controlled type AI system that can't just search all the various
open databases. And it must be programmed to come up with these correct answers. You just
keep having to work at controlling the message that people can get. And in this society, in this
world, I think really ultimately it just doesn't work. And it's just so harmful to people that they
can't get the truth.
I deeply believe that the truth is contagious. When there's a dearth of good information,
there's always an interest in finding out what the reality is. A testament to that is actually
at the founding of the Epoch Times. The Chinese Americans at Georgia Tech spin up this student
website to talk about the reality when the Chinese regime began this Falun Gong persecution. This
little website, thankfully, they had great tech people there. It just kind of exploded as one of
the few venues where you could actually know what was really going on. Today, as another testament
to that, we use some of the best technologies to break through that great firewall that you
mentioned. Unfortunately, because it costs money just to run those things, they're always maxed
out. Millions of people read the Epoch Times Chinese from China, but they have to break
through this tightly controlled system, which requires resources. But we can't open up enough
of those holes for people to read, basically.
Absolutely. I'm so proud of those guys doing that. I used to work with them. I was in the Senate
on breaking through the great Chinese firewall and got some appropriations for them to be able
to help with that mission because the truth was just so powerful. People wanted it, and they're
hungry for it. Your point is that, that they will seek it out, and they will pursue that.
Epoch Times, I think you told me, was something like the fourth largest subscription newspaper
in the country now.
It is.
From a 20-year start against these venerable institutions well over 100 years old, that's
amazing. But it also speaks to the moment. You're really out there putting forward clear
information, it's truthful, and people are going, that's what I'm looking for, and that's what I'll
pay for.
Speaking of truthful information, we're both going to be testifying at a Congressional
Executive Commission on China hearing this coming Thursday. It's titled,
A Market Built on Victims, Stopping Illegal Organ Trafficking in China and Beyond.
So what do you think you're going to be talking about?
I'm going to be talking about the broader picture of this. I know you're speaking there,
Ethan Gutman is speaking there, who's been great on writing about these topics.
But I'm going to talk about that this is a strategy of the Chinese Communist Party,
and it's one that we should turn around and use as an offensive tool against them.
And by that, I mean, most of the time we're kind of pleading with the Chinese Communist Party,
don't do this. Stop the organ. We're trying to shame them into something or pleading with them
not to do it. And from a kind of a position of weakness, and we ought to go in from a position
of strength on this saying, this is illegitimate for a regime to contend for global leadership
that does this to its own people. This should disqualify them from global leadership. And we
should go on the offense on things like this instead of really kind of shying away from it.
And Ronald Reagan did this towards the Soviet Union. He would travel the country before he
was ever president talking about the godless commies and what they were doing to the Jewish
refuseniks. And they also made this point, which I think is the point we're at right now.
They are at war with us, whether we realize we're at war with them or not,
that he said of the Soviet Union at the time. And it's the truth for us with the Chinese Communist
Party. They are at war with us, whether we realize we're at war with them or not.
And we should mount up. And we're always best when we stand on principles, and we stand on
our basic principles. And one of them is religious freedom, that everybody's entitled to do with
their own soul what they see fit. We should take that message directly to the Chinese Communist
Party and say, you signed the original declaration of UN Declaration of Human Rights. This is a part
of it. Stand by it. Do it. Or you forfeit your leadership in the world.
It's interesting that you say that because Nina Shia, who you have a chapter in your
book about as the advocate, she recently has a piece in the New York Post arguing exactly that.
Let's take a page out of Reagan and take the principled position. Make sure you speak to
the Chinese people, not just to the Chinese regime when you're there, Mr. President.
Absolutely. Absolutely. And I think ultimately, and when I say ultimately, within the next couple
of years, you will see that happen. I don't know that you'll see it happen on this meeting,
but I think you're going to see that happening because you've just got these two giant systems
against each other. And really the fight is between the CCP and Western civilization,
Western civilization built on this Judeo-Christian ethic of every person is created in the image of
God and is entitled to human dignity and its own choices, and the CCP, which is there's nothing
higher than us. We are it. We are the ultimate authority over man, which I say is almost a
laughable concept. I mean, as flawed and failed and as deadly as this system has been to its own
people, and it's the ultimate authority over mankind, that's really the fight we're into.
And my deep concern about this is that the digital surveillance systems and the digital
police state that they can create and have created and spread to other dictators around the world,
they've got tools available to them that no dictator has had available in the past.
They are very deft and good at this. This is the toughest adversary we've ever been up against.
Something just struck me, which I frankly hadn't thought of until I just heard you speaking.
Of course, I've been talking about the value of some of these federal bills,
like for example, the Stop Forced Organ Harvesting Act
and the Falun Gong Protection Act, now called the Falun Gong and Victims of Forced Organ
Harvesting Protection Act on the Senate side. At the federal level, the value of these that
actually kind of curbing this a bit, the whole forced organ harvesting and the value of these
state-level legislations, not that insurance and Medicare, Medicaid can't pay for
transplants in China, this is all good. But actually, in a way, if more states decide to
pass these laws, that's actually giving the president leverage. I think the president
and the administration is looking for more leverage against the CCP. I just hadn't thought
of it that way, because I think that's a good way to think about it. They've built a bunch of
leverage against America, critical minerals, rare earths, the medical precursors, some really
serious things, and that's not it, sort of deeply intertwined into the global economy.
If we go down, you're going to suffer too, all of that. But this is another bit of leverage
for the U.S. side, potentially. If I'm a betting man and you're giving me
their set of cards or my set of American set of cards, I'll take our set of cards
and play in this. But we've got to realize we're in this real fight, and we've got to fight it on
principles. We've got to go at them on these very basic principles. I think what you're seeing
kind of bubble up now organically in the country and in the Congress is that the nation is ahead
of our elites on this. The people have already smelled this one out and said,
these are bad guys. What they have done and what we know that they have done—and there's a lot
of things we don't know—this is an evil system. It produces evil results. The people are already
there. It's now the elites kind of figuring, okay, wait a minute. We've made a lot of money off of
China, and we've got a lot of cheap products in here. We've got to start now figuring out
how you break these systems apart and make people in the world pick. I'm either going
with the China system of authoritarianism, or I'm going with the American system of
Western-style democracy. As many flaws as we may have, you've got to make people start choosing.
As a testament to that, when I first started reporting on this forced organ harvesting
from prisoners of conscience in China, I remember very distinctly how difficult it was
to even talk to people about it. Sometimes people would just leave the conversation mentally
in the middle of the conversation. It was kind of frustrating in a way, but then I kind of
sympathized as well after I thought about it, because I've gotten a bit desensitized to the
whole thing, having reported on it a lot. Part of the reason that I wanted to write Kill to Order
is because I saw that there had been this shift that you're talking about. People suddenly are
willing to accept this. I went on a podcast, notably Mike Rowe became incredibly popular
on this issue. I just didn't expect it, let's say. The book being successful,
I think you're exactly right. I think we're in this moment where people are ready
finally to accept that this Chinese regime is capable of some conventionally unfathomable
things. No, I think we are at that moment. I've been around a number of different human
rights movements. This is the biggest beast I've ever gone after. The Red Dragon of China is the
biggest one. There's just this innate sense in a lot of the American people that they can sense
the difference between good and evil. They know there is good, and they know there is evil
in the world. We are in a position as a country, as a powerful country, to resist evil that a lot
of places can't. We must do that, and we must drag this along. I go even further to say
these two systems are diametrically opposed to each other.
These systems do not coexist at this level in the world. You could have a small communist
country in North Korea, Cuba, which I hope doesn't last a whole lot longer. I hope none of
them do. But you're talking about this is the second largest economy in the world that the
CCP has. They've built a satellite set of countries, and they're exporting this digital
authoritarianism technology to at least 80 different countries that we've tracked.
We have got to confront this in this type of integrated world that we're in today.
The book is incredible, China's War on Faith. I found it to be deeply riveting as I'm looking at
these testimonials of people who have overcome unbelievable adversity. Some of it is people who
have decided to be champions. Just tell me a little bit about it. Of course, I've endorsed
the book for the record. I want to make sure people know that because I'm not a disinterested
party. What are people going to find? What is it that you want people to find in the book?
I want them to find truth. I want them to see in the stories that we put forward
the incredible durability of faith in face of death. It's a profiles of faith book more than
anything. It's Christians, Muslims, Buddhists, and Falun Gong are the key faith communities that
we portray in it. In each of them, you see people trying to be crushed, a system trying to crush
them. They persevere through it. Ultimately, this war on faith, China will lose it. You don't know
how many people they're going to kill along the way. You don't know what carnage is going to be
left. Every one of these people have been deeply wounded. One of them is still in jail. We didn't
report on him directly. He's a guy I'd met, Pastor Wang Yi, an incredible public intellectual.
Well, in fact, I think picked up in early 2026, right? If I recall correctly.
No, Pastor Ezra Jin is who was picked up earlier and is still in jail. Now,
they've expanded the web of Christian pastors are picking up.
Tell me more about these pastors. You have quite a number of chapters dedicated to various
Christian pastors.
I did that because it's one of the largest groups still operating in China that's dominantly Han
Chinese. The Falun Gong had huge growth when the government allowed them to grow, and then just
really smashed them as much as they possibly could. But there's still the underground church
going on in China, both Catholic and Protestant. What has changed recently is now you're seeing
the hammer come down on these Christian leaders, even some in the state-sponsored church, if they're
not towing the line right. And the expansion of the arrest has taken place. So Pastor Wang Yi
was one that was arrested in 2019 that we feature in the book. I kind of laughed at it when I
heard he said it. I'm sure he didn't get a laugh in Beijing, but he said,
we're all sinners, including Xi Jinping. And he says that from the pulpit in China.
And I thought, man, I'm impressed, buddy, because you know what that's going to get.
It's not going to get a laugh in Beijing. And of course, he's arrested, but he's a public
intellectual. So they got to kind of treat him a little bit cautiously, but he's still in jail
from that point on forward. But now they're rounding up a lot more of the pastors. So
we feature Pastor Pan, who got his whole congregation out through South Korea to a
place they didn't need to get visas, then eventually Thailand, and now in Midland, Texas.
But he could see it coming. He says, this is coming. And now his
fellow pastors in a lot of the areas are being arrested and put in jail.
And it's this control mechanism. They cannot stand a higher authority than the government.
And they're at the point, too, of this is all out in the open. It used to be pretty quietly done
and subtly and kind of trying to freeze people out. Now it's arrest them, put them in jail.
Some of them disappear. It's very aggressive and very open now.
Tell me about a little more of kind of the details. I mean, one of the characters,
I always not sure how to pronounce her name exactly right, but Myrgle. So I mean,
what an unbelievable story. I mean, at so many levels.
That is. Myrgle Tursun, Uyghur woman. It really is kind of a classic case to study
of what the Chinese did try and what they're doing now. So she's taken out of her homeland,
Xinjiang, East Turkestan, when she's 10 years old, because she's very smart. She passes the top of
test. And so, OK, we're taking you to Guangzhou, you know, thousands of miles away from your
homeland, and we're going to educate you here. And she hated it, didn't want to do that. We're
going to make you into a government apparatchik and send you back. And we're going to get all
the Uyghur out of you. We're going to get all the Muslim out of you. And we're sending you back
because you're a bright, bright kid. Well, other Uyghurs that went with her, a couple of the girls
at 12 years of age committed suicide, jumped out of the building. It's just, I don't want this.
She survived it, eventually gets further educated in Egypt, marries an Egyptian man,
and they decide, you know what? She's just way too Muslim for us. And then she gets on the hit
list. She has triplets. She goes back to China. They deceive her to come back. They take her
triplets from her, kill one of her children. She was a nursing mother at the time. They kill one
of her children. They beat her. They put her in prison multiple times. When she is out,
they have police living in her home, sleeping in her bedroom with her. Just these horrible stories.
And then to top it all off, this one just really amazes me. They said, okay, we're going to kill
you. We've decided we're done. But you can pick the way. We can do a forced injection with you,
or we can shoot you. But you have to pay for each of the three bullets. We use three bullets to
shoot people with. And this sort of just kind of mundane, okay, you get to pick which way you go.
Now, if she picks the route of the injection, she doesn't have to pay for it, but they get all her
organs. And she signs the paper that, okay, yeah, I'm giving my body to science. Or you can pay,
and it's a pretty high price for the three bullets on top of it. You're just going,
how does somebody even think of something like that? The rawness of it. And she denies it all.
She said, just go ahead and shoot me. But these children are actually Egyptians. They're born in
Egypt. And the Egyptian government's going to want these children back. And somebody's going to have
to take care of them. And that kind of slows them down for a little bit. And they're like, oh,
rats. I hadn't really thought of that. And that kind of slows the process. And she doesn't get
killed. And they ultimately actually release her with her two children. But
her story is just, on so many levels, it's at a place where you can't imagine a system that can
produce these types of ideas. And yet it does, and has, and executes on them. It's like a modern
Auschwitz running story of, okay, we're going to kill all these Jews. Now we ought to get the hair,
and we ought to get the fillings out of their teeth. And we'll see the old shoes. Yeah,
we can still use those. It is so industrial scale and so immoral. And yet you've got people
executing that in the system. This is something that I really love about
China's war on faith, because this is something I also tried to explain through writing Kill to
Order, which is just this sort of very kind of cold instrumentalization of the very basic
eradication of human dignity, treating bodies as fodder just to be kind of used in whatever way.
This is something very difficult for people to understand.
It is almost impossible for me to understand when I look at it. Or in your book,
we can make these senior communist officials be able to live to be 150 if we can get enough
spare body parts. What makes you think you're that good? That you should be killing other people for
their body parts for you? I mean, it's just inconceivable to me, really, that people could
think of themselves as that much better than somebody else, that I will kill you for your
organs, and this is a good thing. Unbelievable. But that's what I mean about it's the CCP versus
Western civilization. In a Western civilization concept, no, everybody's created equal. We don't
have equal skills. We don't have equal abilities, but we're all created equal in the eyes of God.
We have a human dignity that is inalienable to each of us. To each of us, no matter who you are,
no matter what your skill level is, you are created equal. In that system, no,
the masters are better than the people.
I also, as I read the book, and you already started talking about this earlier, I get a lot
of hope because the people have gone through a lot and survived and are really fighting the good
fight afterwards. Despite the darkness that you just described, there's a lot of light to be
inspired by. A lot of light to be inspired by. That's what gives me hope in it, too,
is that these are people seeking something above what is here on earth and willing to fight and
willing to die for it. In many cases, like Marigold, who we just talked about, when I've
been with her, she says, they've already killed me. They killed one of my children. I'm dead.
Then she gets transnational oppression, and they say, we know where you are.
She says, shoot me. You've already killed me. But she continues to speak out at great price to her
and to her family that's left back in the country. To me, that's the key piece of what we've got to
get right in the United States. China's at war with faith, and we should clearly be on the side
of their opponents. That's these people of faith who are in that country, and the religious people
are most of the time the first ones attacked and the last ones left standing. It's the only civil
society left there. They're not a rebel cause, but they don't agree with this system. This system is
diabolical, and they don't want it. We should clearly—and I put forward a number of policy
ideas—what we should do to elevate these people who are standing against this beast from inside
its belly. Just on one little note as we finish up, I wanted to mention this because
in China, there's something called the United Front Work Department, which of course you're
very familiar with. But again, it's one of these institutions that's very difficult for us to
conceive. Imagine having a department or a ministry that's one of the top-funded ministries
or departments in the government. Its exclusive purpose is to destroy all civil society, to subvert,
i.e. control, i.e. make not civil society, or destroy all civil society both within the country
and in the diaspora, and frankly, beyond, into even American institutions that are beyond the
diaspora, so to speak. Again, it's sort of inconceivable. We don't have an analogous,
massively funded magic weapon, as Mao called its system.
Yeah, we don't. I guess we could conceive of it, but in my Western mind, I can't. Why would you
even think of something like that with all of the social capital that civil society and civil
institutions do? And you're going, no, we don't want that. We want this all controlled and
answerable to the government.
It's very difficult for Americans to conceive in particular, because this is de Tocqueville.
This is what he pointed out back when he wrote Democracy in America, that this sort of Americans
getting together to create institutions to solve whatever problem they happen to find
important. That's the beating heart of America. That was what would make America great.
He was right. He was prescient. But that's precisely the thing that this United Front,
that the CCP seeks to subvert and destroy in its entirety. I find that fascinating.
Yeah, I do too. And on a scale that you're just going, how do you maintain a functioning society
then if you don't have local people answering local problems? And then it's got to be somebody
from Beijing decides, okay, you got a problem, we will solve it for you. Well, you got to get
their attention. You got to get enough resources. You got to keep enough resources coming and just
going, this is just not going to work. And it doesn't work. And it didn't work in the Soviet
Union. And it didn't work in Eastern Europe. And it's not going to work ultimately in China.
Now, near term, they figured out enough how you can make an economy go by this top down system.
But ultimately, you're really sucking the soul out of people and you're just making them part
of a big machine that is human and is going to make all sorts of flaws and mistakes. And you
take away the invisible hand, the Adam Smith invisible hand of solving the problems and make
it all one visible hand. And it's the government's going to solve it. And this has failed everywhere.
It's been used around the world and it ultimately will fail in China too, just at what cost.
So now as we actually finish up, you said something interesting earlier,
and I just want to finish up this note. You said when it comes to human rights,
or forced organ harvesting, or things like that, we tend to kind of plead, hey, please stop this,
this is bad, and so forth. You said, turn the tables or flip it around. Can you explain that
a little more to me as we finish? I think we need to elevate the issue
and use it as an offensive tool. I think President Trump needs to bring into the White House people
that have been persecuted for their faith from China in public meetings and have them tell the
story and have it broadcast around the world and have him bring in group individuals from
Falun Gong and from Tibetan Buddhists and Christians and Muslims, have them tell the
story, bring in world leaders, bring in world religious leaders, showcase what is taking place
in so many places around the world of religious persecution, particularly China,
and ask them to stand against this and for religious freedom for everybody, everywhere,
all the time. I think he should present to Xi Jinping the nine Catholic bishops
that are held somewhere, we don't know where, in prison, and ask that they be released and press
the Vatican to do the same thing and also to press them to plead against these and call for
the end of these three genocides that are taking place in China.
I think we ought to send the Secretary of State, the Vice President, one of the two,
to Dharamsala, India for substantive talks with the Dalai Lama about the future of Tibet.
I think we start elevating these in various forums and formats to make the clear point,
we are serious about this, and China, you've declared this a red line, a no-go zone, and we
don't agree with you, and we're not going to do it that way, because what you're doing is completely
wrong and it's evil. I think you ought to call it out. I think you ought to do a Ronald Reagan
and say, this is an evil regime. This is an evil empire. And I would love to see the Pope
stand up in Taiwan and say, be not afraid, like Pope John Paul did in Poland. Be not afraid.
Sam Brownback, it's such a pleasure to have had you on.
My pleasure to be with you.
Thank you all for joining Sam Brownback and me on this episode of American Thought Leaders.