The History of Gumbo in New Orleans

History Of Food
342 followers
#History #food
Journey through New Orleans' rich culinary history with this gumbo recipe from an 1885 cookbook. Learn the origins of gumbo's name and ingredients, exploring its evolution through various cultures. Discover diverse thickening methods and historical context behind this iconic dish.
By https://www.youtube.com/@TastingHistory
With Mardi Gras right around the corner, my mind always goes to one of my favorite food cities,
New Orleans. Beignets, jambalaya, and gumbo. A rich, thick, and savory dish that is the
embodiment of many of the cultures that have populated that city. Native Americans to Africans,
French, Spanish, Acadians, and a whole lot more. So today I am going way back to make
one of the earliest New Orleans gumbo recipes from La Cuisine Creole, published in 1885.
So thank you to Trade Copy for sponsoring this video as I cook up a historic pot of gumbo,
this time on Tasting History.
So the recipe that I chose to cook today comes from the first cookbook which focused
on New Orleans cuisine. It was published in 1885 and it's called La Cuisine Creole,
and the book actually includes nine versions of gumbo, which is spelled
gombo, so I just chose the one that sounded most delicious to me, gumbo with crabs or shrimp.
To a pound of beef, add half a pound knuckle of ham. Chop up both in inch pieces and fry them
brown in two tablespoons of boiling lard. Add to them four large crabs cut up or a pound of
peeled shrimps or both if desired. Cut into this four dozen small okra pods, one large onion,
a little red pepper, and salt to taste. Let all simmer on a slow fire for about 20 minutes,
then fill up with warm water, enough to cover the contents two inches deep.
Let this boil for two hours. If it becomes too thick, add as much water as required.
If preferred, a chicken can be used instead of the beef.
So this recipe includes what many people consider to be a key ingredient of gumbo,
and that is okra, though not all gumbo recipes actually do include okra.
Now besides adding a flavor it is also going to be a thickening agent,
and what's cool about this cookbook is it seems to be the first that includes
all three main thickening agents of gumbo.
So the first method is the okra, and okra is a pod that grows in the mallow family,
as in the group of plants that marshmallows were originally made of.
Okra first grew in East Africa and was one of the key foods of the people of Central and West Africa,
and during the Atlantic slave trade it was brought to the Americas where it was growing
in Brazil by the 1650s and as far north as Philadelphia by the 1740s.
In the Caribbean and the American South it remained a staple crop used by the enslaved
people which is how it entered into gumbo.
In fact many people believe that that is actually where the word gumbo comes from,
but more on that later.
Now okra was one of those foods that is much maligned,
and that is because when you cut it open it is filled with this sticky,
viscous substance called mucilage or mucilage,
and it can make both the okra and the actual gumbo itself rather slimy,
but if it is cooked properly then it doesn't make it slimy but simply thickens it.
Now the second method of thickening is called filet or dried ground sassafras leaves.
This also both enhances the flavor and the texture,
and was originally used by the Choctaw Native Americans of the region to thicken their own soups.
Then when the French arrived in the 18th century they called it filet which means
ropey or filament-like, and this is the more popular thickening agent for
the Acadian style or Cajun style of gumbo.
Now there are two main styles.
There's the Creole style and the Cajun style,
and there is a lot of overlap between the two,
and really the type of cuisine and the people themselves,
it's very, very complicated how they are different and how they are alike,
so this is a super simplification.
When it comes to their cuisine you can think of
Creole as kind of being New Orleans centric,
and Acadian or later Cajun, currently it's Cajun,
being more rural and outside of the city.
Again super simplification but there is that,
and there is a lot of overlap like the third thickening agent,
and that is flour.
They both use it very often.
Now sometimes this flour is added in a form called roux which is fat and flour
mixed together and then cooked for a long time,
and the Cajuns they like to cook theirs for so long
that it becomes a really, really dark chocolatey brown,
sometimes almost black,
whereas the Creole style of roux is more of a light brown,
kind of a they often say like a peanut butter color.
Now in older recipes the Creole style doesn't call for roux at all
but calls for browned flour,
and this recipe that I'm making today does not call for an actual roux
though the cookbook does include a recipe that does use roux,
but it does say that all gumbo should be thickened with a little flour,
browned if preferred.
So I'm going to make some brown flour which will not only thicken and color the soup
but will also give it a lot of flavor.
As far as the word soup goes many people will tell you that
gumbo is not a soup but a stew,
and others will say it's neither,
it is gumbo.
Gumbo is gumbo,
and if that makes you happy then by all means,
but historically it was always considered a soup
at least when written about in different cookbooks from the 19th century
even as far back as the 18th century.
Like this cookbook from 1885 says remarks on gumbos of okra and filet.
This is a most excellent form of soup
and is an economical way of using up the remains of any cold roasted chicken,
turkey, game, or other meats.
Serve gumbo with plain boiled rice.
So historically it was a soup and who am I to argue with history.
Now let's get to browning that flour which does take a while.
Now we only need a half cup of the brown flour
but you want to brown at least a full cup because much less than that
and it does have a tendency to burn.
So take your cup or 120 grams of all-purpose flour
and put it in an oven safe pan and spread it evenly
and then set it in the oven at 400 degrees Fahrenheit, 205 Celsius
and cook for about 90 minutes to two hours
but every 15 or 20 minutes you need to take it out of the oven,
stir up the flour a little bit and then put it back in.
This will make it so it doesn't burn.
Eventually your flour should have the color of light brown sugar
and it is going to have a deep sweet nutty flavor
similar to some of the coffees that I get from today's sponsor Trade.
Just like gumbo has lots and lots of varieties so too does coffee
and that is one of the things I love most about Trade
because you get to experience all sorts of different coffees
discovering new ones every month because they work with 55 local roasters
to bring you 500 different coffees.
All you do is take Trades quick quiz letting them know what your tastes are
and then they have a team of people who will personally match you with coffees
that you are sure to love and each bag is roasted to order every time
and if you don't like your first bag they will replace it for free
and I just love that Trade is always sending me new coffees
in addition to many of the coffees that I have grown to love
and right now Trade is offering up to 40% off of your first order
when you use my link in the description drinktrade.com
slash maxmiller that is drinktrade.com slash maxmiller
that's me Max Miller and you will get up to 40% off of your first order
and now with our brown flour all set we can move on to the rest of the recipe
for which you will need one pound or 450 grams of beef cut into about one inch pieces
some stew meat like short rib is perfect for this
one large ham knuckle cut into small pieces
one pound of peeled shrimp and or some crab legs
you can also use whole crabs if you want it just kind of depends on what you want to eat
then four dozen small okra pods or three dozen if they're large
one large yellow onion and one red bell pepper or one red hot pepper without the seeds
the recipe actually is not clear and they used both the hot pepper without the seeds
and red bell pepper in different recipes from this period so it's not entirely clear
so use whichever one you want
now the traditional vegetables used in today's gumbo is often called the holy trinity
and that is onion, red or green bell pepper I usually see green now actually
and celery this recipe does not use celery
now partly it was because celery was oddly expensive in the 19th century
like really expensive people would actually just put it out for show
but it was also incredibly popular to eat
there are recipes in this book that do include celery but none of the gumbo recipes have celery
so it maybe just wasn't really popular in gumbo at the time
also let me know if you want me to do a whole video on the celery craze of the 19th century
and just how celery got to be sometimes as expensive as caviar for celery
now the recipe has us start by browning the meat
so melt a couple of tablespoons of the lard in a large pot over high heat
and once sizzling add in about half the meat
if you have a really wide pot you can do all the beef and pork at once
but you don't want to crowd the pot so best to do it in a couple shifts
let the meat cook for a minute or so and then turn each piece
making sure you get a nice browning all over it
and it doesn't need to be fully cooked we're just going to want some color on the outside
then because we are going to add brown flour we need to remove the meat from the pot
and add in the rest of the lard
once it's really hot then add the half cup of brown flour and whisk it together
now we are not making a roux per se we are just mixing the fat and the flour
it's kind of like a proto-roux but we're not going to let it cook for a long period of time
other recipes in the book do have you do that this one does not
so just mix it together let it cook for a minute
and then add the meat back in along with the onion, the okra, and the bell pepper
along with some salt I'd say about two or three teaspoons will be a good start
and then make sure to stir all of that up together nice and well
you'll notice that there is a slight deviation in what I'm doing versus what the recipe says to do
because the recipe actually says to add the shrimp and the crab right now
and I don't know if that's because that's actually what they want you to do
or if it's just sloppy recipe writing I think it's that because
if you add the shrimp and crab right now it is going to cook for two and a half hours
and that will just leave you with lumps of rubber
it will be inedible and I don't want to do that
so I'm going to wait to add those until closer to the end
for now it's just the meat and the vegetables
and do not yet add any water because if you do then all that
mucilage in the okra will leak out into the water and it will make for a
mucusy gumbo at the end very slimy not pretty
but if you just let it cook without the liquid for a while it kind of reabsorbs all of that stuff
and then it just acts as a thickener which is what we want but we don't get the slimy texture
which is not what we want and the recipe says to just let it cook without the water for 20 minutes
just make sure to give it a good stir every minute or so so nothing burns to the bottom of the pot
then after 20 minutes you can add about two liters of hot water more or less
and as soon as you do stir it in and scrape the bottom of the pot
to get off the fond that formed when you were browning the meat
again this is going to add some flavor and we need all the flavor that we can get in this
because you'll notice there are no spices really added to this gumbo
and most of the old recipes don't have any kind of spice or even herbs very often added
so as much flavor as we can get into this we want to get in
now let that gumbo come to a low boil and leave it to cook uncovered for two full hours
stirring frequently then as your gumbo boils in its gumbo pot we can take a little trip
down history lane to learn about the early origins of this most delicious dish
when looking for the history of a dish i always like to start with the origins of the name
gumbo in this case and there are two prevailing theories on where that word comes from
the first is that it came from the Choctaw word for the ground sassafras or filet
that is used as a thickener that word was combo that's not very far off from gumbo
now the second theory which i find a little bit more convincing comes from another thickening agent
and that would be the okra in the bantu languages which were spoken by many of the enslaved people
from central africa their word for okra was king gumbo or gumbo now i doubt there will ever be a
definitive answer which one was correct but i do think it's interesting that both theories come
from two of the thickening agents used in this soup or stew now the first time that we see this
word gumbo in reference to a dish comes from 1764 and kind of has a bit of a dark past it is in the
document describing the interrogation of a 50 year old enslaved woman named julia also known as comba
she was interrogated regarding her knowledge about a runaway slave named louis also known as
and in the transcript the questioner asks quamba if she had not given him
louis a gumbo with caesar and another black woman now unfortunately while we get the word
we don't get any description of what she was putting into this dish though you wouldn't expect
that in that kind of document of course for that we have to go a little while later to 1784 when a
journal on natural history describes the sassafras tree in louisiana one also makes use of its leaves
which are gathered in july dried in the shade and in open air and then coarsely powdered a
pinch of this powder is enough to make a broth viscous it is this dish that is called in america
gumbo however one must distinguish this american stew from that which is called gumbo fevy the
latter is made with the pods of a species of large mallow all parts of this plant contain
a viscous juice and the pods when green make water even more glutinous than do the leaves of
sassafras the pods of this mallow are of course okra and the author seems to have tried both
versions of gumbo and well the first time one eats these gumbos one feels a strong repugnance
because of this viscosity but after having tasted it two or three times the repugnance disappears
and one would then wish to eat it every day the creoles of louisiana love it passionately they
cannot eat any other soup than that which they make with broth pepper sassafras and maize or
rice cooked in water it must be admitted that this soup is much finer and much better tasting
than all our bread soups gumbo is made with all kinds of meats poultry and fish it is also made
with shrimp and crawfish that made with cabbage is the least esteemed so even as far back as 1784
over 240 years ago there are already many many variations on this dish it had become as varied
as the people that were making this dish and that is one of the things that i really love about new
orleans it is a true melting pot in both the history the architecture the people and the
cuisine there are influences from native americans africans caribbeans the french french speaking
acadians the spanish germans italians and just americans in general now some of these groups
like the germans and the italians don't actually arrive in new orleans until later in the mid and
late 19th century but as early as 1803 new orleans and its cuisine and people are already very
multicultural on december 4th of that year 1803 pierre clement de la salle wrote about a ball he
attended in new orleans he was the last french colonial governor of louisiana and in 1803 was
in the midst of facilitating the handoff of the louisiana territory to the united states and when
he walks into this ball he talks about how he hears all of these different languages different
american languages as well as different dialects of french different dialects of spanish and the
dances themselves were just as varied the guests danced boleros gavats english dances french and
english quadrilles and gallopades in addition hundreds eight standing up here and there as a
local touch 24 gumbos were served six or eight of which were sea turtle now sea turtle is not so
common in gumbos today but back then sure was popular what i love though is that even in 1803
gumbo had already become a metaphor for the cultural mix of louisiana and new orleans now
unfortunately none of those 24 gumbo recipes seemed to have survived and that is partly because
american cookbook writing was still very much in its infancy but also because those recipes
would have been made by enslaved people and very few of their recipes got written down by them
until after the civil war when their recipes did get written down it was by the people for whom
they were cooking those recipes people like mary randolph who while not from new orleans
included one of the first gumbo recipes in her 1824 cookbook the virginia housewife it actually
has two important recipes first being gums a west india dish this is okra stewed with salt and pepper
and then served with butter now it's not a stew but it does make the connection between the word
gumbo or gums and okra but she does have a second recipe that is basically for a stew that is gumbo
but she doesn't call that gumbo she calls that okra soup and it includes pork and fowl veal knuckle
and then also lima beans and squash then it also calls for it to be thickened with a butter mixed
with flour that is a sort of roux so this is not really the gumbo that new orleans would have been
known for but it does seem that similar dishes were being eaten all over the south at the time
now to get that new orleans connection we actually have to go to philadelphia of all places there in
1840 miss eliza leslie included two recipes for gumbo in her cookbook these both included okra
and tomatoes or she called them tomatoes and then one had beef and the other had no meat
a green gumbo meant for lent but she does say of both types that it should be like a jelly
and is a favorite new orleans dish a few years later in 1847 the carolina housewife included
another recipe for new orleans gumbo but this time it did not include okra instead it called
for turkey beef and oysters cooked with onion and then season to your taste and just before
taking up the soup stir in until it becomes mucilaginous two teaspoons of pulverized
sassafras leaves so it's clear that by then both methods of thickening were around as well as an
early version of the third that is the rue now most of the recipes of the 19th century don't
really talk about making a rue but rather just mixing fat and flour but then you don't cook it
for a long time like a rue is supposed to be done until you get to the cookbook that we're cooking
from today 1885 where in one of the nine recipes for gumbo it does describe making a rue it's in
the recipe for gumbo filet with oyster number two and it says fry a tablespoon of flour in a
tablespoon full of lard let it brown slowly so as not to scorch but really rue does not become
super common in gumbos until the 20th century but then and now it's very, very standard in
most recipes that i've seen and very often it is cooked so long that it becomes super dark
especially in the cajun style even black and it's absolutely delicious also a little side note about
the book that we're working from today La Cuisine Creole and the man who compiled it. He didn't
actually write the recipes he just gathered them. He was a fascinating fellow. His name was Patrick
Lafcadio Hearn and he was actually born on the Greek island of Lafcada before moving to Ireland
where his father was from. Later he was abandoned by his family and sent to America and after some
hard times in Cincinnati he became a reporter. Well after the civil war he became one of the
people to write a lot about the life of the formerly enslaved people and he went around the
area gathering lyrics to the songs that they sang preserving them for posterity because many of them
had never been written down. He basically did the same thing when then he went to New Orleans but
instead of song lyrics he did it with recipes and other bits of New Orleans history that was starting
to be lost. Then later in life he moved to Japan, became a Buddhist and studied jujutsu until he
died at 54. Just a really interesting guy I think. As for his gumbo recipes they are missing one
ingredient that has since become very popular in many gumbos and that is sausage. Now there are
questions to where exactly the sausage in gumbo came from but many people believe that it started
with the Germans when they came in the 1850s because they did bring a lot of sausage making
to New Orleans but both Spanish and French sausages did already exist in New Orleans as
well. There just doesn't seem to be a lot of evidence of them going into gumbo and the first
time that we do see sausage put into gumbo it doesn't really specify a type. Today it is very
often andouille sausage which is absolutely wonderful and that is actually my favorite part
of gumbos. Unfortunately it is not in the one that I'm making today. It is in the ones that I had in
New Orleans. Loved it. It's not the one I'm making today so I will have to content myself with other
things that I love like the crab and the shrimp, and now after two hours of simmering you can add
those shrimp and crab into the pot along with any more salt that you might need. Stir it all in and
let it cook for five to seven minutes or just until the shrimp have curled up nicely and then it is
ready to serve with some Carolina rice, and here we are New Orleans gumbo from 1885. I'm starting
with a shrimp. Now the look is is right but it is not nearly as dark as a Cajun style. Those are
really, really dark brown gumbos and that's very often actually what I got in New Orleans but
it smells good. Oh my god, I'm shocked at how much flavor. Where's it coming from?
Okay, okay that is fantastic. Let me get some meat and rice here. That's really lovely.
The texture, it is viscous but it's like silky. It is not slimy. It is exactly what I want
it to be. It isn't oily because so often you can get a lot of oil especially when you're
cooking with sausage. You can get a lot of oil on the top. This doesn't have any of that.
Yeah, oh man, another shrimp. I just don't know where all this flavor is coming from.
It's so good. It's not a very complicated dish. Now you've got the okra which has some flavor,
and then you've got the brown flour which has some flavor, and the meat's everything but
this is so much more than the sum of its parts. What's crazy is that, and it does cook for a long
time, I couldn't even pick out a piece of okra in here. It's all of the vegetables have just kind of
cooked down to their... maybe that's where the flavor is coming from. It's just so concentrated.
Oh man, it doesn't even need the rice honestly. I'm a mess and I don't care. Now if you've never
been to New Orleans, I gotta say it is one of the most unique places in the world that I've been to,
definitely in the United States. It is so different from every other city in the U.S.
Both the people, the architecture, the culture, the amount of music that's going on,
and the food. There is so much food. I mean the Simpsons did a whole thing where Homer went and
names off like a hundred different things. They're all there. Within like walking distance you can
get to all of those places. So if you get a chance go to New Orleans, even just for a few days,
just see it, and then the history. Amazing, amazing history there, and yeah I've been a
couple times. I'd love to go back. Don't go during the summer, the weather's horrible,
but during the spring, fall, just lovely, and eat while you're there, and if you can't get there
yet, then make some gumbo at home because it's absolutely worth it,
and I will see you next time on Tasting History.
