Barbecue In Early America

History Of Food
342 followers
Barbecue in America is hundreds of years old.
We have so many ubiquitous dishes in America that we think of as common eating,
things like pizza, spaghetti, or tacos. But those are actually very, very new dishes.
So much of what we eat today is only 50 or 75 years old in its popularity.
But barbecue, that goes back a long way.
Now the problem with barbecue is it can mean different things to different people.
Sometimes it's a food specifically. Other times barbecue really means an event,
a social gathering. So we have to tease out these issues and figure out what barbecue
really means to people today and what barbecue means to people in the 18th century.
The word barbecue probably comes from the Spanish,
likely 16th century or so. And it really has to do specifically with cooking things over
a kind of raised grill, probably made with sticks.
And it's likely the process that I used for the dried beef episode,
where I made the sort of gridiron out of sticks.
It's over the fire and it's meant for drying and smoking.
That's the very, very original purpose. And that happens in the Caribbean,
with Caribbean Native Americans and with other populations in that area.
That concept and that word gets kind of altered and changed and it moves into the 18th century.
And it actually starts to mean a social gathering and not necessarily a specific kind of cooking,
but definitely a social gathering. We see references to that in, say, the 1730s.
Or if we look at the writings of George Washington, he talks about going to barbecues,
these are social events, and even throwing one himself.
Now this is also getting popular in Great Britain and in other parts of Europe,
this picnic concept where we're going to eat things outdoors.
That's getting popular in the 18th century.
So somewhere from, say, about 1680 to the time where we get to the 18th century,
this term barbecue, at least in cooking, not necessarily a social event, but the cooking
aspect, goes from we're going to be drying meat and smoking it to we're going to be smoking meat,
but keeping it very, very moist, cooking it with lots of fats and making something very tender.
Now that's the opposite of what's going on if you're preserving meat.
You're going to make it very, very hard and very, very dry.
But if we're going to be eating these things right away, which is what's happening with
barbecue later on, then we want a completely different cooking method.
Yes, we're still cooking on this gridiron or kind of rack above the fire,
but we don't want it to dry out. We want it to stay very moist.
So not only just the cooking method is changing or even the definition,
but also the kind of meat that's being cooked.
In the 17th century, the first English reference that we have to barbecue
is talking about barbecuing birds like pheasants, even turkey.
But when we get to the 18th century, the term barbecue,
especially when we're talking about cooking something specifically, is almost always pork.
So sometimes we're cooking whole hogs.
In fact, that kind of really is the definition of barbecue in the 18th century.
But as we move into the 19th century,
the gates open up and all sorts of things can be barbecued.
And especially today, boy, we can put anything on the grill, right?
In the 18th century, I'm not sure that beef ribs actually fit into the concept of barbecue.
When we find many mentions of barbecue in the time period,
we're talking about two different things.
And it seems that one of them is just a process of slow cooking something.
And generally, it's talking about pork.
And then the other thing that we're talking about is an event.
We're going to a barbecue.
And that is usually upper class people roasting a whole hog and celebrating all day long.
And a lot of times there's dancing and there are games and there are different things involved,
but it's an event that they're excited about.
So beef ribs don't really fit into that conversation because it's not pork.
But when we think about barbecue now,
we think about all sorts of things like beef and chicken and pork and what have you.
We even have barbecue sauces.
That is a whole culture that is created now that did not exist in the time period.
And so during this video, we have to think a lot about,
OK, do I mean barbecue in the sense of how we think about it now?
Or do we do we mean it in the 18th century?
So what we're making today is we're making some beef short ribs,
which they would not have barbecued in the time period.
And this is not going to have a modern day barbecue sauce.
This is something that's living all on its own.
But what we are doing is we're slow cooking this with a really,
really interesting process.
We're going to have a lot of fun and I can't wait to get into it.
Today's recipe comes from The Complete Family Cook by S. Taylor.
And this was written in 1796.
To dress a rib of beef and papillote,
take a rib of beef cut neatly and stew it with some broth or a pint of water
and a little pepper and salt.
When it is done, reduce the sauces till it sticks to the rib
and then steep the rib in sweet oil or butter
with parsley, scallions, shallots and mushrooms.
Shred fine and a little basil and powder.
Wrap the rib in a sheet of white paper with its seasoning,
folding the paper around in the form of a papillote.
Grease the outside and lay it upon the gridiron
on another sheet of greased paper over a slow fire.
When it is done, serve it in the paper.
We have never, that I can remember, done a papillote on the channel before.
So I'm really excited about it.
It's a cooking style that basically we're going to take a piece of paper
and make a pouch that we steam food in.
And that's what's going to get our rib nice and tender.
So the first thing that we're going to do is we're going to stew our rib.
And for me, I am going to, I've already done this, actually.
You can see that I have chopped this rib into three different pieces
because I'm going to put it into a smaller Dutch oven.
I'm going to use less resources and just heat that small area up.
Now, if you wanted to do lots of ribs, you can cut it up like this
or you can probably find a vessel.
I just don't have one for the time period that puts a whole rib
and can fit into the bottom.
So that's why I chopped mine up.
When I'm seasoning this, the first thing that I want to do is
I want to get the seasoning right on the rib.
I don't want to just pour some salt in the broth.
I'm going to put my salt and pepper onto this rib.
I'm going to push it in so that it stays.
Then I'm going to pour my broth in the pot,
but not on top of the ribs to wash everything off
because I want that seasoning right on the meat.
We're going to get this with about a pint of broth or a pint of water.
I'm going to use broth, some salt and pepper,
and we're going to get it into our stew pot.
We're going to braise this for anywhere between about an hour and an hour and a half.
We're putting this in the liquid and what we want to do is
we want to get it up to a boil and then we want to drop it down to a simmer.
We just want it to simmer the whole time,
just little heat bubbles in that broth.
And so what that's going to start to do is break down the sinew,
break down the fat inside of these ribs,
but it's not going to get them completely tender.
That's the next part.
Right now, we're just trying to cook them through
and we're not going to worry if they pull apart.
Today, one of the definitional parts of barbecue is the barbecue sauce
and we have these wonderful regional differences to barbecue sauces.
Some people want it sweet.
Other people want it to have a lot of zing in it with vinegar.
Maybe the spicing is different from one region to another.
Now, what's happening in the 18th century
with the sauces of a barbecue is very, very different.
Sometimes it's just basically a gravy.
Maybe it's got lots of butter to it.
Maybe it does have some spicing.
That's changing and altering as we go through the 18th century
and it really isn't until we get to the 19th century
that we start to get to what we think of as a classic barbecue sauce.
So in the 18th century, we're still cooking.
We're cooking low and slow, but the spices are very, very simple.
They're really relying on the flavor of the meat itself to carry us into that
and the sort of very, very tender meat aspect to it.
The other big challenge I have with barbecue and understanding it
is the idea of eating with our hands.
Now, in this outdoor eating environment,
we many times, even in restaurants, eat something like ribs with our hands.
We're going to, you know, take it apart.
We're going to hold on to the bone like we're eating corn on the cob or something
and eat around it and get all the wonderful meat, and it's a challenge.
But in the 18th century, most people are not eating like that,
at least people that are middle class or well-to-do.
In these, you know, kind of fancy parties that you can expect in the 18th century,
certainly they're probably not eating with their hands
and they're eating these things on a plate with knives and forks and all that.
But much more difficult to understand is where the roots of our eating barbecue with our hands is.
And I think that really comes from poorer people, even enslaved Africans,
eating the barbecue in a different way than, say,
the people that are eating barbecue in the recipe books that we see.
It's so much harder to research where some of these things come from
because we don't have writings that point to these things
as explicitly as we have in the cookbooks of the 18th century.
So the recipe that we're going to be using today,
we're going to be taking the bones out, which today we would definitely not do that.
We want to have the flavors of the bones coming through and,
you know, affecting both the experience of eating and the flavor.
There's this amazing difference for what we think of as barbecue,
and specifically ribs, today versus what's happening in the 18th century.
The ribs cut of meat is not a good and easy cut of meat to work with, to cook and make it good.
And so it's a real challenge.
You have to do special things to make things like ribs or brisket
turn out to be a good food to eat.
And in the 18th century, these things were left behind,
or they were inexpensive cuts of meat that poor people would eat.
Today, wow, they're expensive because we really crave the way we can cook them.
We've really taken 200 years of cooking expertise
and changed the way these cuts of meats are thought of today.
I think that's an amazing way to think about it, how it's totally changed.
Lobster is the same, right?
Today, it's an expensive dish.
In the 18th century, it was.
Why would anybody want to eat that?
Today, we'll be cooking en papillote.
We're going to be cooking in paper.
It's a French term that goes back a long way as a cooking method.
Both the Italians and the French, and then in the 18th century,
the English are doing it, and possibly even later on in North America.
It is a great cooking method for cooking things low and slow,
and keeping those juices in and making sure it doesn't get too dry.
If we look at some of the English cookery books,
we find all sorts of things being cooked in paper.
Specifically, there's this great recipe for cooking fish in paper,
or cooking possibly vegetables or birds in paper.
We even have this classic Chinese chicken recipe
where the chicken is cooked in paper.
So this is a cooking method that goes way back,
and one that we should probably do much more often.
We even cooked a turkey in paper, and it came out so good.
Let's talk about bones in the time period.
It's funny because we don't see ribs going up to a table
and being served with bones in them.
Now, it's so funny because we see in other recipes,
we see entire pigeons in a pie, bones and all, but not ribs.
And we think about ribs as finger food now, right?
So that whole concept of sitting at a table
and having this sloppy sauce on you and napkins everywhere,
that's not going on.
I think that in a frontier setting or something like that,
in the hunting setting, they probably work.
But over 100 years of researching ribs now from 1730s to 1830s,
I haven't found one recipe where the ribs go to the table.
They're not going to in this.
But what we are going to do is we're going to cook these with the bones
because I want all the collagen.
I want all of the juices from those ribs
because at the end of the stewing process,
we need to thicken that sauce.
We're going to cook it down,
and I want something to hold it all together.
Our ribs are in the Dutch oven.
They are cooking away.
Now, we need to prepare the next step of this recipe,
and it reads a little strangely.
What I would call this is a chutney,
and that's probably not,
there's probably some foodie out there
who's going to say that's the wrong thing,
but that's what I'm going with.
We're going to chop all these vegetables up really small,
and then we're going to mix them together with oil.
Now, this says to steep the ribs in oil,
but it also says to have a sauce on the ribs that sticks to them.
So I think what we're achieving here
is we're making a marinade
that we're then going to put onto the ribs and cook it with that.
So I'm just going to go ahead and put the oil in
with all the chopped vegetables,
mix that up really well,
and then we're going to put that in the pouches with the ribs.
Now, this marinade you could use at home anytime,
and let me tell you,
this is something special,
so you're going to want to try it.
Our ribs are done stewing here.
They look really wonderful.
They're nice and tender.
We don't want to hammer these guys.
That's why we're putting broth in
and putting a nice heavy lid on top
and just simmering it for a while.
So they're going to get even more tender
as we continue to cook them.
It's just time to move on to the next step.
In the meantime, though,
what you have to do is take some of this broth
either out of here or take the ribs out,
and you need to reduce it
because we want a nice thick sauce
that's going to stick to the ribs,
and so when you first get this off of the flame,
it's going to be a pretty watery broth.
It's very loose.
We're going to continue to reduce it
until it thickens up.
Now it's time to take the bones out,
and we're just going to set those aside.
I'll give them to the dog later.
They'll be really happy.
We're going to talk real quick about empapillote.
This is not something that we've done on the channel before,
so we're just going to slow down
and spell it out a little bit
so that everybody knows how to do it.
It's really easy,
and it's a great way to steam food,
so if you have something
that you just want to soften and cook,
but you don't want to boil it,
and you don't want to throw
a whole lot of different methods at it,
you can use a simple piece of paper at home.
You can have parchment paper,
and you can steam inside of that.
It's really easy.
So you're going to take a piece of paper,
and you're going to fold it in half,
and then you're going to cut around.
This is the half crease right here,
and you're going to cut a half heart,
and then eventually when you unfold it,
you have a whole heart.
It's whole hearted.
So first things first,
we want to get the sauce all over our ribs
and get that to stick to them.
Then we're going to place our ribs on the parchment,
and you're basically just going to use
half of your heart here.
You're going to put the ribs in,
and then a few really healthy portions
of this marinade or chutney that we've made.
And so basically all the juices
are coming out of those onions.
Those mushrooms are going to give it
a nice earthy tone.
We're going to pile that high,
and then we're going to close this up.
And the way to close it is
we're going to start at the very V
that goes inward at the top of the heart,
and we're going to start folding the sides together
all the way around.
And so we're making a pouch,
and we're going to braid that
all the way around the hump
till we get to the tail.
At the tail, the next step is to just twist it.
We're going to twist that
until it won't twist anymore,
and that's going to close it up.
We're going to be able to move it
then to the gridiron
where we're going to put it really close
to the heat,
but not directly over the heat
because we don't want this paper to burn.
How does this affect how we cook today?
Is this important?
It's very important.
This dish, it isn't easy,
it isn't fast,
and it isn't cheap,
but it's important.
It's something we should do
because the food we eat,
how we eat it,
who we eat it with
is very, very important.
We have lost track today.
In the 18th century,
people were eating together.
Heck, barbecue,
the whole fact of barbecue
in the 18th century so many times
was it was a social event.
We're getting together,
we're talking,
we're watching this thing being cooked.
It's taking a lot of time.
We get to talk to each other
while that's happening.
This is what life is supposed to be like.
Here we are.
Our ribs are finished.
They look really good.
They smell way better than I thought they would,
and you really get that,
the aromatics from the onions and the mushrooms
now that they've all cooked down,
and it's kind of just turned into,
I mean, it's soft.
It's like, it's almost like
it's just crusting the outside of it.
When we opened the bag,
I haven't cooked it probably an hour
next to the fire in the bag,
and you could just hear it steaming the whole time,
and when we opened it,
it just, there was so much steam in there.
It's like this little pocket,
and there was a lot of liquid even on the top
where you could see that it was steaming up
and catching and circulating inside the bag.
I think that they're quite tender.
I think they're going to taste really great,
and I'm excited to try them.
This does smell tremendous,
and I'm excited about the texture of it
and the tenderness of it.
It's so hard sometimes to get beef
to do what you want it to do.
This cut's difficult to work with,
and this cooking method, I think,
did the perfect thing for it,
so let's try this out.
Wow.
Way more tender than I thought it would be.
And the flavors are really over the top.
It's got some wonderful saltiness
and the other kind of flavors that we're getting with it.
Sometimes when you put a rub or something like that
on the outside of beef,
it feels like it doesn't really penetrate
into the meat itself.
It's just kind of on the outside as a coating.
This is all the way through.
And some of them can be very fake tasting, right?
This is a very authentic flavors
of the individual components that we put into it.
It isn't, like, contrived.
Right, and I'm not a mushroom person,
so this has a lot of mushrooms in it,
but I can't pick out a mushroom flavor.
It just feels like they've all combined
to become one, I don't know,
like, one seasoning.
Right, so can you imagine a sauce
that could go with this?
So that's one of the things we didn't put in here
because we knew it would extend this out too much.
And we'll probably come back
and revisit this concept of a sauce
that would go with this.
Yeah, absolutely.
This is way better than I'd hoped for.
Yeah.
I really want to thank Ryan
for doing all the hard work cooking this.
It turned out so spectacular.
I cannot recommend enough trying this out at home
and trying it with people you know and love.
