【法語字幕】這才是法語人該看的名人傳記! P4 - 阿蘭(傳記) 亨利四世的明星哲學教師,教過偉大的思想家

法語之旅
21粉絲
1 次觀看·2026年2月26日
Philosophy has had a poor reputation among non-philosophers for a long time
When Plato delivers a public lecture in Athens his fame draws a large crowd
Then the listeners drift away repelled by the abstraction of the speech
"Philosopher " according to the dictionary of the Académie française
It also means "to talk in a tedious and pedantic way getting lost in unnecessary subtleties "
The philosopher discusses abstract matters in a complicated way He never
talks about everyday things and he never gets straight to the point
But imagine a philosopher discussing everyday life
And imagine him speaking plainly not with long-winded
sentences or jargon but with short everyday language
What would that result in
It yields Alain's style a style which André-Comte Sponville considers to be
e most beautiful prose of ideas of the century
Alain whose real name was Émile-Auguste Chartier is more than a
popular philosopher he is a true institution in French philosophy
He is furthermore the first 20th-century philosopher to have entered
the Pléiade We chiefly know him as the author of these remarks
which stands among the greatest achievements in philosophical
popularization Alain is also one of the most renowned philosophy teachers
otherwise the most renowned philosophy teacher of
the 20th century He influenced numerous students
Some of these thinkers will become major figures in Western thought
He even had followers known as Alinists
And there are still other surprising aspects to Alain's life
Evidence of courage that makes him admirable
but also hidden scandals capable of destroying his reputation forever
I'll share both the positive and the less favorable aspects to reveal telling anecdotes about Alain's fate
It is the dawn of the 1880s in Mortagne-aux-Perches
a small town about 150 kilometers west of Paris
The young Alain explores a private library
rich in the classics of French literature
He particularly discovers Balzac the great novelist of the Romantic era
which would become one of his references for the rest of his
life and which he would even use in his philosophy classes
It was through this library that Alain first became introduced to literature
Or it's not the library of his parents nor that of
his grandparents nor even that of other family members
It's the library of a young city lawyer a bourgeois bachelor
with the intellect and charisma to build a career in politics
but one who fails to realize their potential
Alain finding in this man a true mentor
The young lawyer introduces her to hunting and of course to literature
He's somewhat of a substitute
father since Alain's family life is difficult His parents don't get along
They're so deep in debt that bailiffs sometimes have to be called in
Yet Alain's father has a stable job as a veterinarian
He is highly respected by the local bourgeoisie many of whom trust him with caring for their horses
Moreover the father is highly educated as he reads extensively on a wide range of topics
Yet his strengths are undermined by two major addictions—alcohol and gambling
That is where the family's debts originated
Moreover Alain will inherit his debts and he will
repay them year after year down to the last cent
o cleanse his father's honor
Although his father was not his mentor
he nonetheless shaped his mind in his own way
He taught him the basics of his veterinary profession
And through this he conveyed the Cartesian pragmatism that permeates his words
On the other hand young Alain is neglected by his mother
She devotes herself to dancing and social events which often keeps her away
As a child Alain prepares his own breakfast before heading off to school
It is 1886 and Alain is eighteen years old As a
brilliant student hypermnesic and generally gifted
He will take two baccalaureates first the literature baccalaureate then the science one
At the time this was common among top students
Somewhat like how some people nowadays pile up multiple master's degrees
The literary baccalaureate is a formality for Alain
It is easily passed in both written and oral exams
The scientific baccalaureate however is a different matter
He barely passed the written exams thanks to an outstanding score in physics
Then comes the part with the euros and it gets complicated
In chemistry he can no longer recall the definition of
salts and he's so flustered that the examiner mocks him
Same situation in math— he can't recall the definition of a parabola
And the examiner twists the knife in the wound
As a result Alain fails his scientific baccalaureate
His failure causes a scandal at his high school
Yes because the young Alain is the hope of his teachers
He is clearly gifted and has excellent grades in scientific subjects
us the teachers aimed him at the pinnacle of the French academic system of the time
The country's elite academic gateway Polytechnique
Only Alain is traumatized by his failure in the scientific baccalaureate
And he will remain so until adulthood
Since he still dreams of Polytechnique he remains determined to enter a scientific preparatory program
But a chance encounter changes his fate A old friend of his father
tells him that given his failure in the science baccalaureate
The scientific preparatory year is going to be hell Why not switch
to the literature track to prepare for the École Normale Supérieure
At the time it was a step below Polytechnique in terms of prestige
But it's still the prestigious school that shapes
the nation's literary elite Alain is persuaded
Thus at the last minute he chooses literature over science
He finally arrives at the literature preparatory school in Venves in the southwest of Paris
He then attends the lectures of Jules Lagnaud who becomes his intellectual mentor The philosophy
teacher himself a former student of the preparatory program and École Normale Supérieure
Initiate Alain into the works of the great authors beginning with Spinoza and Plato
It is 1889 Alain is 21
years old He receives
exciting news—he has been
accepted into NormalSup
He is ranked 23rd out of 24
In other words he is the second-to-last admitted
He came very close
And wait that's not all This was
the third time he had taken the exam
He had already failed the NormalSup entrance exam twice at the ages of 19 and 20
He always passes the written exam but fails the oral
just like in the science baccalaureate He's exceptionally skilled at essay writing
His struggles lie in Latin poetry and history
Fortunately his perseverance is rewarded
Alain is so persistent that two years after entering
NormalSup he passed the scientific baccalaureate
That really traumatized him as it turned out
I was greatly surprised to discover in Sartre's biography
He read 300 books a year during his studies at NormalSup
Also I've posted a video about Sartre's life—if you're interested
Three hundred pounds a year amounts to almost one per day
Of course it's not Harry Potter or Fifty Shades of Grey that Sartre is rushing through
No he mainly read high-level literature often
hefty tomes written in sophisticated language
Hence the question when reading books of this kind at the
pace at which Sartre read them are we truly reading well
And importantly Sartre is by no means a library rat at NormalSup
On the contrary he leads a very active extracurricular life
He keeps piling on the parties and the binges
So I'll ask again: what's truly left of those 300 readings per year
At this pace are we truly grasping the most important ideas
Here let's compare with Alain—how does he work at NormalSup
Well then he carries out what he calls his schoolboy duties
It's almost a self-taught method With this approach
at NormalSup Alain reads Plato in its entirety
Almost all of Aristotle and a significant portion of Kant's works
So that's a lot but we're still far from 300 books per year
With blistered fingers one can get closer to reading a book per week which is already a lot
Alain maintains this pace because he's an incredibly hard worker
Throughout his intellectual career he devoted considerable
time and effort to carefully reading the major philosophers
Hours upon hours sitting with a book in front of him either
for his own personal enrichment or to prepare his lessons
Then he will work with the same intensity when he begins writing
As the English term "workaholic" better suggests
derived from the English word meaning "alcoholic "
Alain works with intensity and consistency
which stem from dependence at the expense of his health
At NormalSup in his early twenties his meticulous reading of the classics
His scholarship impresses his peers Some begin adopting the
same approach while others
directly ask Alain to mentor them
Although he barely passed the entrance exam for NormalSup
He ranked third in the philosophy aggregation in 1892
Durkheim one of the founders of sociology corrected one of Alain's papers
He added next to the grade "written too well "
In contrast Sartre will fail the agrégation competition
the jury criticizing him for having imprecise knowledge
It is 1927 and Alain is 59
years old He has given one
of his students a nickname—
the Martian Why the Martian
Because he had never met a student so brilliant
The Martian shared a commentary on Spinoza that left Alain astounded
It's simply impossible to compare her to the other students who are by no means
unintelligent But the Martian is in a league
of her own which is why she has that nickname
Who is this exceptional young woman
She is Simone Veil who alongside another Simone Simone de Beauvoir
is considered France's greatest philosopher of the 20th century
She is not only Alain's student but also his disciple
That is he exerts a significant influence on Simone Veil's thinking
And she is not the only one
Having taught literature in the preparatory program at Henri IV since
the start of his forties Alain has seen countless brilliant students
Yet his influence extends far beyond the walls of Henri IV Alain is
a celebrated teacher in the early decades of the twentieth century
The students and not just his own revere him
How can this be explained
First of all Alain possesses a natural charisma that commands respect
He is tall for his time standing at approximately 180 centimeters
He is well-built which allows him to physically command his audience
Moreover he is also an original educator
He speaks clearly often concisely as in his remarks because he
absolutely wants his students to understand what he is teaching them
He also places great emphasis on style He frequently assigns writing
exercises that he returns with the
same dedication the very next class
As for the substance Alain isn't afraid to depart from the academic methods of his time
Despite being a philosophy teacher
He quite likes talking about novels or
poems rather than purely philosophical texts
Let me tell you this doesn't please the national education
inspectors one bit But Alain believes that novels and poems
They are often a better source for intellectual culture
Finally if he is a truly outstanding teacher
it is above all because his teaching goes beyond the academic
He truly wants to teach his students
to think critically to question
like independent citizens who aren't easily misled by grand speeches
And indeed he awakens and
shapes great minds—Simone Veil
the Martian—yet Alain also draws others into his orbit
anks to his academic reputation he attracted outstanding
students who were not directly his
pupils Raymond Aron for example
who would become the defining thinker of liberal
conservatism the archenemy of
Sartre becomes close to Alain
I posted a video about Aron's opinion if you're interested
Finally there's one last thing
which explains Alain's prestige among the students
Sorry to interrupt but I have a question to ask you
Do you really think people have read all the books they talk about Of
course not otherwise we wouldn't be able to discuss much of anything
Yes there are 24 hours in a day— you
have to work eat sleep and walk the dog
So the secret to general
knowledge isn't reading books
Then what is it In fact there isn't just one secret
There are five of them
The students and most educated individuals
the teachers and intellectuals are aware of these five secrets
You know you've read Renan just as I have
Yet he carefully avoids mentioning it
Those who discover them manage to develop quickly
and easily expand their general
knowledge because their relationship
with knowledge has changed Once they apply the five secrets
ey understand all the references cherished by the educated
and they can express themselves with depth on any subject
They stand out through their cultural depth in conversations and debates
and they possess the necessary
perspective to think critically Interested
Well I’m revealing the five
secrets and explaining how to apply
them today to grow ten times faster without overthinking it
To receive the five secrets simply sign up by clicking the
link appearing now in the top right corner of the video
It's the one mentioned in the video description
This is the story of ten seconds
so do it now and you'll uncover the first secret
waiting for you warmly in your
inbox after watching this video
There there I've told you what I wanted to say
Good video
It is the year 1900 in the Orient west of
France Alain 32 is a high school teacher
Politically he is radical just like his father and grandfather
—meaning in simple terms that he advocates for reformism
grounded in the foundations of the French Republic
Fortunately a radical newspaper
Orient Chronicle is seeking reporters
Alain publishes his first column focusing on a train derailment
The result isn't impressive the style is flat But as
Alain himself says every craft
requires learning So he perseveres
He applies a Stendhal maxim he
will later discover: write every
day genius or not So much so that the 32-year-old new journalis
He is passionate about writing articles devoting
all his evenings to them until deep into the night
Here he is now juggling two
roles simultaneously—teacher and
writer Since he has a duty of discretion as a civil servant
The sign Alain refers to the medieval French poet Alain
Chartier And his style is growing increasingly popular
So much so that some journalists from the
daily newspaper take his articles as a model
Six years later in 1906 when Alain is 38
what happened with La Dépêche de l'Orient
It is reproduced with La Dépêche de Rouen
Alain is urgently called in
because the newspaper is short-staffed
He first contributes with weekly articles
then submits an idea to the editorial team
And if he wrote a short article every day
it would mark the birth of an entirely new literary genre
It is Alain's remarks that will make him famous In two
pages he delivers a philosophical analysis of current events
In substance he argues the anecdote
rises to the level of metaphysics
Formally since Alain must deliver a text each day the
style is concise and direct
with plenty of striking phrases
The punchlines as they say today
In short it's highly accessible wisdom
on current topics so people love it
Alain wrote around 3 000 entries in
La Dépêche de Rouen from 1906 to 1914
It's an enormous effort considering he's a teacher
on top of that He's literally killing himself at work
This is possible because he is not a family man
In exchange for these efforts
Alain demands complete freedom of expression
The newspaper sometimes asks
him to make an exception but he
never gives in He can afford to do so because he isn't paid
Finally not directly and not right away In 1910 therefore four
years after the first text a
collection of Alain's remarks appears
which achieved some success
But Alain's real best-seller
was his reflections on happiness
published in 1925
It's almost self-improvement which
explains the book's widespread
popularity Personally my favorite
section is the one on powers
I was impressed by the clarity Alain demonstrates in
this book At the time his
views were so widely popular
at former students of Alain founded in
1920 a weekly pamphlet
called Free Thoughts
o gather together the thoughts of the week
The philosopher's circle is skeptical
but the magazine quickly gains subscribers
Within just a few years it reached 1 200—without
any advertising That’s how
popular Alain had become
At the request of the author the journal opens itself to collaborations
which will notably allow Simone Weil
to publish her first writings there
Here is what Alain writes
in the preface appearing
on July 31 1914 titled The Massacre of the Best
War is no longer a trial for
heroes but a slaughter of
heroes The people whether
victorious or defeated after that
poor in true noble blood
poor in rescuers entrepreneurs generous
souls rich in the prudent
of calculators of hoarders
Alain therefore shares none
of the patriotic fervor
that erupts a few days later
when France entered the First World
War He could not bear to see his
young students his
spiritual children
being called up one after another
o be sacrificed
So Alain enlists in the French army
even though at 46 he is not
eligible for mobilization
He becomes a bombardier meaning
he specializes in bombardment
weapons In his regiment he lives
this reality day in and day out
with men 25 years younger
than him With his experience
his wisdom and his natural
charisma he gradually gains
an ascendant over his fellow soldiers
They admired his kindness
and calmness
Alain is forced to leave the regiment
In mid-1916 after
the wheel of a
munitions transport vehicle ran
over his foot and shattered it
he would always walk with a cane
After that accident he still
returned to the front by
the end of 1916 this time
serving in the weather service
He was demobilized
a year
later at the end of 1917
He therefore acted according to his moral
code with total obedience
total spiritual rebellion
In addition to his disability
Alain returns from the Great
War with a hardened pacifism
In 1914 he
was convinced that diplomatic solutions could have
prevented the conflict The
responsibility
for the slaughter
It is therefore up to those in power
—certainly not the innocent who die
on the front lines—to decide Alain
will share his
experience of war in his
War souvenirs published in
1937 yet it expresses his
radical pacifism much earlier
in Mars or the Trial of War
published in 1921
perhaps the greatest pacifist tract
in Western history
It is December30
1945
—the date of Alain 's
wedding Wait how
old is he in 1945
He is 79 years old
Maybe it's a remarriage
No no this is Alain 's
first marriage
But why get married at 79 Well first of
all she's a woman he'
s deeply in love with
She went to the United
States in the 1930s
to build a career in high fashion then she
revenue in France in 1944
But there is yet another
reason for this marriage being so
late Alain is getting married
I quote him to put an end
to the chaos in his private
life In other words he was
not a committed monogamist
He practices free love
It's first and foremost a
matter of means because Alain
is lucky enough to be very attractive
to women He's never had
making efforts to win them over
they offer themselves to him
Therefore from his earliest
years as a provincial professor
He multiplies his lovers
He does not promise exclusivity
and does not demand it either
On the contrary he prefers
at her lovers go on to see
other men That way he doesn't
bear the responsibility of
fulfilling all their needs alone
e woman's sentiment He fully
enjoys his freedom but sometimes
he feels he's taking advantage
wasting his time on women who
Easy women At 38 he
falls in love with an
18-year-old girl Gabrielle who loves him
secret since she was eleven
But the two lovers
argue constantly Alain is
heartbroken when Gabrielle
pursuing a career in the United States
So when she returns even though
he had fundamentally opposed
marriage he decides
I quote him as saying "to put an end
to the disorder in his private life "
We are in 1908 Alain is
forty years old He is a
philosophy teacher at the
Lycée Michelet in Paris
He has not yet been appointed to Henri
IV A woman from his personal network
the headmistress of
the Sévigné boarding
school a private institution for girls
The principal suggests to Alain
that he create a philosophy
course for his students—an
hour a week out of friendship
Alain agrees but he is not at ease
He has never taught young girls
before and he has no idea how he
will manage to succeed with them
understand philosophy He believes
that girls and boys aren 't
taught in the same way Like
most men of his generation
mes he doubted
women's intellectual
abilities Except that faced
with reality on the ground he
discovers something: girls ca
be very intelligent
Alain goes even
further I quote him: "It was then
that I embraced the idea that women
naturally possess greater wit"
at man " And he hasn't met
Simone Veil yet Alain is
therefore a committed feminist
after teaching young girls
He was however rather misogynistic
Having learned from the example
of the easy girls he collected
in the provinces he concluded
at the woman is trying to
control the man In reality it's
him she wants to control Her
lovers demand that he end his
libertinism Thinking of
her he describes women as
emotional creatures who
try to manipulate men He
Don't trust them his
judgment is clearly
biased by what statisticians
call sampling bias
The group of women who
inspire Alain's reflections
is by no means representative
of women as a whole
That's why his perspective
shifts when he teaches philosophy
to two young girls—he begins
advocating for women's rights
He even considers it a matter of
civilization But in reality he has
held this view for quite some time
already For example he had written
1900 in the dispatch from Lorient
"We must not laugh at feminism
One may conclude
that the condition of freedom"
The true measure of a people is the level
of education
and emancipation of its women
Alain the Jews Hitler
and the Occupation by
Michel Onfray This is not
a eulogy but a pamphlet
Onfray has read Alain's previously unpublished
journal published in the
same year 2018 and he reveals
The allure of Nazism
on Alain He firmly
believes it utterly
destroys his reputation
e philosopher he once admired
Is this attack serious
To put it simply I will first
discuss the arguments
d'Onfray then I will discuss
the nuances introduced by
Thomas Chalin Alain's biographer
So what are the differences
What are Onfray's main arguments
He accuses Alain of making
antisemitic remarks and perpetuating
the prejudices of the time
But there's more serious matter In 1940
Alain read Mein Kampf
and judged it a success
He even praises Hitler
Finally Alain
hopes De Gaulle won't succeed
in his bet on resistance
And silence on all this
Once the war is over
Well we must admit there is still
substantial weight to Onfray's attack
How does the biographer
defend Alain Regarding
antisemitism first of all it was widespread
pre-World War II France and
Alain himself acknowledged
that he had allowed himself
to be influenced by prejudices
Thomas Chalin recalls that Alain had
close friends and Jewish students and
even supported certain
Jewish students
such as Émile Herzog alias André
Moroy and of course the Martienne
Simone Veil If Alain
has made antisemitic
remarks or written antisemitic passages
it doesn't appear he has acted on them
as antisemite Regarding the
praise of Mein Kampf and Hitler
the biographer criticizes
Onfray for failing to account for
account of every instance where Alain
criticizes the Nazi leader he also
explains that it is
not out of sympathy
for Nazism but rather out of pacifism
o avoid a massacre
the slaughter
of the finest Alain advocates
peace with Hitler As for
resistance Thomas Chalin finally
remember that few French
people believed in De
Gaulle in 1940 There's
still one point worth noting
o reconcile the two perspectives
Alain's mental health—was he
of sound mind when he wrote the
controversial passages For Onfray
Yes The proof is that Alain was
still reading advanced philosophy Hegel
in particular Even if I'm not
sure whether one really needs to be
A mind sharp enough to grasp Hegel
In fact I made a video about
Hegel's life if you're interested
Therefore Onfray believes Alain
is perfectly lucid when writing the
controversial passages But the
biographer on the other hand reveals
at Alain had suffered
multiple strokes at the
time and that in addition he was sinking into
depression There are therefore solid
arguments on both sides Personally
I don't see an
obvious conclusion but
I find it interesting to understand
e arguments presented by both sides
If you enjoy the spirit of this video
—discovering interesting things by
getting to the heart of the matter
without overthinking—then you'll love it
probably my Culture Express program
It's a systematic program to
effortlessly become a cultured person
in just a few months It covers
all areas of general knowledge you will master
the essential understanding of human history
on the history of France in economics in political
science in psychology in
science in literature in art
religion and philosophy You will never again run out of
things to say and you will gain
the confidence needed to shine
under any circumstances You can learn more by clicking the
link displayed in the top right
corner or the one located below
the description or even by directly
typing the address displayed on screen
into the search bar But I think the best way is
giving you an idea of the program
is to listen to what the members
have to say Valentin who acknowledges the enormous amount of wor
what this program has meant to me he said quoting
it's a real goldmine the essence is right there
everything is simple and convenient
Very well explained and focused—now it's just a matter of copying it
down and memorizing it This task
is truly outstanding and fascinating
Maxence messages me directly in the comments below
a video from the program your training is truly
Remarkable—I was a bit skeptical at
first given the initial price but
I don’t regret it at all This is truly a masterful synthesis you’ve presented us with
and the video format is perfectly suited for me as I have
essentially an auditory memory The
selection of themes and chapters
It's relevant and I think you've struck the perfect balance
in depth—precise yet without
unnecessary embellishment Vincent
He's actually doing my promotion in fact I've recommended your
course to my sister who works as a
diplomat Last week she already had
e opportunity to draw on the knowledge you've shared during these
discussions You'll see other
testimonials like these in the comments
f you join the program
and sign up you receive
a results guarantee Once you've completed the
program I will fully refund
you if you feel you haven 't
gained a solid general knowledge If you wish to
Learn more click the link displayed in the
top right corner or the
one in the description
Simply type the address displayed
on screen directly
into the search bar Over 800 members have already taken advantage of this program
And I'd be delighted if it were the same for
you In any case I hope you enjoyed the video
I'm Romain and you were on
1000 general knowledge ideas Remember you didn't
I don't need to hassle you to get
you interested in the best of thought
