Cost Drivers That Are Pushing California Housing Above the National Average

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
16 Video Views·Feb 13, 2026
California’s housing costs are among the highest in the nation, while single-family construction continues to lag demand. If land is not the only constraint, what is driving the gap between need and supply?
In this episode, we sit down with Michael Capaldi, Partner at FBT Gibbons, to examine the approval process, local fees, and state mandates that influence what gets built. We trace how those choices translate into the price of a home and the calculation families make about staying in California.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Cost of housing in California
is significantly higher than other states.
And at the same time,
we are not building a lot of single family housing.
What's the impact of this?
And are there big consequences down the line
potentially for California society?
Our guest today is Michael Capaldi, real estate attorney,
who has been studying what's happening
with single family housing in California
and its impacts on family formation
California voters aged 18 to 39,
54% of them have considered moving out of California
because of the high housing costs.
More than half.
Politicians talk incessantly about the cost of housing.
They're just not doing anything about it.
They're not peeling back these layers of regulation
that have built up over the last 40 years
like an iron net to keep people
out of housing in California.
I'm Siamak, welcome to California Insider.
Michael, it's great to have you on, welcome.
Good to be here.
We wanna talk to you about housing.
This is an issue in California.
The housing cost here is now double the national average.
And what's puzzling to us is that even in ruler areas,
in areas that the land is not limited,
we still have a housing issue
and the cost of building housing is very high.
You develop housing here
and you've done a lot of entitlements in the state,
a lot of projects as a lawyer.
Can you tell us what's happening?
Well, a lot is happening.
Over the last 40 years,
the state of California has adopted a lot of cases,
a lot of statutes, a lot of regulation
that really when you put them all together,
make housing very scarce and very expensive
in the state of California.
You've got laws like the California
Environmental Equality Act,
which makes just about every housing development out there
vulnerable to lawsuits.
Got environmental regulations that crowd Californians,
take them out of the less dense areas
and put them into crowded urban centers.
So the whole system really from top to bottom
has been constructed over the last 40, maybe 50 years
to discourage construction of houses,
particularly affordable houses that ordinary families,
middle-class families can afford in California.
Can you point to where these policies are?
Like, especially you mentioned that
it's hard to build houses in the suburbs.
Can you tell us?
Yeah.
Well, you can start with a set of laws
that create good areas to build and bad areas to build
and really do try to push that development
into crowded cities.
There are these basically local planning commissions
or regional planning commissions
called local area formation commissions,
which really are engineered by the state.
They're imposed all over the state.
There are 58 of them in the state of California
to discourage development in open areas.
They're legislated to prevent urban sprawl, they call it,
which are really single family, you know, homes and suburbs.
The legislature in California,
Sacramento has had enough of those.
So they're really trying to create apartments
in dense parts of the state.
That's an example.
It's produced some really notorious problems.
There was a famous case of something called
the Newhall Ranch Company,
which proposed 20,000 homes, seven schools,
thousands of square feet of open space,
an ideal little community.
It took 24 years from the date they filed for those permits
to the time they got the approvals
and lasted long enough to get through the lawsuits
that were filed against that particular project.
So after 24 years, you finally get your project.
If you're a developer,
that's a long, expensive gamble to take
and developers increasingly will not do that.
In fact, you find a lot of developers of apartments
and homes moving from California
because the whole process is so unpredictable.
You're not gonna find a developer
who's going to bet millions and millions of dollars
on a particular project
and then go out and borrow money from a lender
who can live with that kind of uncertainty.
Michael, when you are building and you're seeing the price,
how much of it has to do with California laws
and how much was the construction cost?
Because in other parts of the country,
the construction is the same, right?
Yeah, construction costs in this state,
according to the Rand Corporation last year,
were 2.3 times the average construction cost
for the same kinds of units in Texas.
Wow.
You compare California to Colorado.
Colorado's a relatively difficult state to do business,
but California, we're still 1.5 times higher
for construction costs.
So if you looked at the average low cost
of a home to build in California, maybe 2,000 square feet,
that home would cost you $300,000 in Texas to build,
construction costs.
Colorado, it might be $320,000 per unit to build.
California, it's $500,000.
That's 40% more than the cost of construction in Colorado.
There's a reason for that.
California faces a lot of regulations
that drive those prices up.
A lot of environmental regulations,
lots of regulations of all kinds
that really push that number.
Can you tell us more about those regulations,
some examples for our audience to understand?
There's a concept called vehicle miles traveled,
which is really meant as a way to reduce development impacts
on greenhouse gas emissions in California.
So if you're designing a 4,000 home,
single family home development,
the local government has to count the number
of anticipated miles driven
by each of those future residents.
That's a major concept in California
because it ends up in a very odd way
restricting the number of units that you can build.
One of the oddities is that it focuses
on vehicle miles traveled,
the number of miles that a particular vehicle
is gonna travel.
Whether it's a clean electric vehicle
or whether it's a gas guzzling 1971 Chevrolet Impala,
treats them the same way, right?
Doesn't make much sense.
But ultimately the state step in and they say,
well, we've got to cut the total number
of vehicle miles traveled by Californians
by 15% by I think it's 2050.
Well, what that really means is you're not going
to be able to build new homes for people.
The County of San Diego a couple of years ago
estimated the impact of this VMT
that it will add a minimum of $50,000 per home,
per apartment, per single family home
in San Diego County, $50,000 or more,
sometimes a couple of hundred thousands,
depending on the type of development that it is.
So those regulations that I'm talking about,
they directly affect the cost of a home
or an apartment to an ordinary family.
So to make this clear,
so if I wanna build a community in San Diego
or Riverside, that's a little bit outside
or even in the outskirts,
somebody will calculate how many miles
the residents will travel and then there's a fee.
Right, yeah, yeah.
What they do is they really discourage building homes.
It's not so much a fee associated with the VMT
that I'm talking, there are plenty of other fees
that we can talk about that government charges development.
But in this case, what it really does is it says,
you can't build there, you can't build
in the Inland Empire, you can't build
in the Central Valley of California
where land is expensive and construction costs
are likely to be lower, you can't build there
because you're gonna generate too many car trips.
People are gonna travel to LA
or they're gonna travel to the local town
and we just can't tolerate that number of car trips.
So what they're really doing with the VMT
is encouraging building in the most impacted urban areas,
downtown Los Angeles, Long Beach, San Francisco,
the Bay Area that are already built up
and they're telling families, you cannot live,
you cannot own a home in an area where you can afford it,
you're going to have to rent an apartment
in a congested city where you've got crime problems
and homelessness and all the other problems
that big cities have.
So California legislation, that's a good example,
is forcing Californians out of the suburban homes
where they can kind of control their neighborhood
and raise their kids into really dense apartment buildings
and places where most families don't wanna go.
People who feel it most critically in a state
are young people.
Sacramento is essentially telling young people,
young men and women in California
that they will never own a home,
that they will be permanent renters all of their lives
and that they're gonna have to live in a city
where most families really don't wanna go.
It slows down marriages, family formation,
it's had huge social impacts on the state of California.
Michael, you mentioned that the state wants to have
more housing in the city centers.
Everyone talks about lowering the housing costs.
What's the difference between constructing
in these environments, in the downtown LA,
what's the cost difference?
It's such a good question
because the assumption that's being made
is that not only the big apartment buildings,
the high-rise apartment buildings
are gonna be less expensive than a single-family home,
they think it's going to have less environmental impact.
None of those are true.
You go, you're building a building,
let's say it's an apartment building,
and you go from two stories to four stories,
that cost of construction from two stories to four stories
goes up 25%, 25% more expensive
to go from two stories to four stories.
If you wanna go from five stories to 10 stories,
your cost of construction alone
are going to increase by 50%.
So it's clearly, clearly not more,
less costly to build an apartment in an urban center
than it is to build a new for-sale home in the suburbs.
It is a dramatically more expensive thing.
And when you think about it,
you drive by a high-rise apartment building
under construction, what do you notice?
Well, you notice a lot of steel
and you'll notice a lot of concrete.
Those are really expensive materials.
They use five times more petroleum products
and emit five times more greenhouse gases than wood,
which is what you use to build a single-family home
in the suburbs.
So they're not only more expensive to build,
they are much tougher on the California environment
than single-family homes.
Single-family homes are about the most cost-effective
and least environmentally impactful kind of building
that you're ever gonna get.
From what you're saying,
it looks like there is a dilemma
because California, there's a lot of talk
about lowering the cost of housing,
but then at the same time,
we have these environmental goals
that these homes cannot be built.
When you mentioned VMT,
is it that they get charged a very high fee
if you're building a single-family community
outside in a suburban area,
or is it that you cannot build
because the mileage, you're gonna be driving a lot?
Yeah, it's really both.
The fees are going to go up
because the government really likes to pass fees on
to, they think, the developer,
but ultimately the consumer's gonna have to pay it
either through increased rents or increased housing costs.
But you make a point here that's really crucial
to understand.
Politicians talk incessantly about the cost of housing.
They say they're worried about the cost of housing
to the average family.
They're just not doing anything about it.
They're not peeling back these layers of regulation
that have built up over the last 40 years
like an iron net to keep people out of housing in California.
So there's a lot of talk about it,
but there's very, very little being done about it.
In the last seven years,
we've built maybe 70,000 a year,
80,000 a year at that rate.
It'll take 30 years to build the housing
that everybody recognizes that we need.
Is there a conflict between the ideology
of not wanting people to drive and the housing?
Is there a conflict between the fact
that the state wants to build a lot of housing,
but at the same time, they don't want the suburban housing?
Yeah, there is a tension
between the state's environmental goals,
particularly those VMT goals that you're talking about,
and being able to build,
particularly being able to build affordable apartments
or being able to build homes that are affordable
where a young Californian can start a family.
And the state has not decided to get that balance right.
There is a way to balance your environmental concerns
with sensitivity and still allow people
to own a home in California.
Can you get into the details of these fees?
Yeah.
Because ideally, the thought is
to have these development fees
and these kind of fees to help that community build up,
right?
Sure, yeah.
Development fees were really originally meant,
if you're gonna build 100 homes in a particular area,
well, you should build the schools too.
You should build some parks.
You should build some green belts for the families.
That's how they started.
That's really not where they've ended up.
A lot of cities have become very reliant
on those developer fees
and the fees that they charge the developer,
which, by the way, get passed on to the renter
and to the homeowner because there's no choice.
You've got to pass those along.
Those end up funding the general revenues,
the general needs of the city.
So they're not going to help support, you know,
that burden the new homes are gonna create on the area.
They're not going to build parks.
In large measure, they're really going
to just kind of the general fund
to deal with all the other expenses
that it's got to deal with.
California, how bad is it?
In California, on average,
and we're talking about the entire state,
much worse than the city,
development fees and permit fees will be about 29,000,
almost $30,000 per unit.
Just for the state?
Just for local government.
Those fees are basically local government.
Again, compare it to Texas.
Development fees under Texas are probably about $1,000.
Wow.
$29,000, $30,000 in California, $1,000.
Colorado, about $12,000.
So you can see something isn't going right here.
And some communities absolutely soak the developers.
Fremont, recently there was 100 or some odd, you know,
unit housing development up there.
Median price was $860,000 per home, right?
Pretty expensive.
But $160,000 per unit were fees
that went straight into the city of Fremont.
About half of that to build an apartment.
These are incredible fees.
$160,000 per unit.
Per unit up there in Fremont.
So essentially that's 20% of the housing cost.
So particularly where the jobs are,
those fees, cities just sort of rake them in.
And they can get away with it
because people are willing to pay.
They can get away with it
because they can get away with it.
The developers who can afford to pass those along do that.
If you can't afford those kinds of fees,
you're just not going to build a project.
You're just not going to build homes or apartments.
That's one of the reasons that we have so few homes
in the state of California.
And there is a new change to CEQA.
Yeah.
And supposedly infill homes were able to build them.
It's getting easier.
There's a lot of commercial like shopping centers
that are abandoned or they're not used.
Or warehouses in the middle of cities.
Why don't they get developed?
There are a bunch of reasons for that.
You mentioned CEQA reform.
CEQA reform has been a little bit more aggressive
over the last couple of years.
There's been more flexibility and that's good.
The problem is that CEQA is such a crapshoot.
You know, it involves so much risk.
They have not done enough.
And frankly, I'm a huge advocate
of changing the rules of CEQA
that keep homes from being built.
But it's not the only problem in California.
We talked about these local agency formation commissions,
zoning rules, you know, that they come down.
Those CEQA reforms that you're talking about
aren't going to apply if the project doesn't conform
to a residential zone.
If it's zoned something else, it's much harder,
you know, to change that from a commercial use
to a residential use.
So CEQA is one thing, it's an important thing,
but you've got layer upon layer of disincentives
to take that old, you know, derelict shopping center
and turn it into residential.
They've been focusing in Sacramento on that
for probably about five, six years now, maybe seven years.
Very few of those projects are getting done.
And it's not all because of CEQA.
What is it because?
Some of those fees.
The CEQA relief allows you to avoid CEQA
if the property is already zoned residential.
Those commercial, you know, shopping centers are not,
so you really can't avail yourself to that.
But the other thing too that you have to understand
is this sort of crazy zoo-like atmosphere in California
where government is so divided.
Step back and kind of look at the map.
In California, you've got 58 counties.
Well, it doesn't seem too bad, right?
But in California, you also have within those counties
483 separate cities.
Every one of those cities has discretion at some level
to approve or disapprove of a particular development,
any development, housing or otherwise.
And the truth is that the nature of local politics
is such that, you know, neighbors don't wanna see
new homes being created in their neighborhood.
Maybe they think that it's going to compete
with their own home values.
Maybe they just don't wanna see apartments built up
because they don't want struggling people
to move in down the street.
So we've created this political environment
where you've empowered city councils
and planning commissions to say no
to projects even if they comply
with the underlining zoning, right?
There is every way to stop these projects
and neighbors very often organize.
They go to their city council members and they say,
oh, we cannot possibly have more new housing in the city.
Say no, and they say no.
So that is a big reason that you find so many projects
just wandering around and never get built.
So there's different components.
There's an element of the community members
don't want housing.
At the same time, there's laws that make it more expensive.
Laws and regulations, almost at every level
in the state of California,
you have created really important disincentives,
roadblocks, hurdles to overcome if you wanna build homes.
What's the result of it?
Well, homes, particularly four cell homes for families,
they're just not getting built.
Michael, if we wanted to build, do we have enough land?
Because certain parts of California are landlocked.
Yeah, California has only 6% of its total surface area
with anything built on it, a city, a town, suburb,
6% of the state of California.
That means 94% of the state is totally untouched.
Some of that land's agricultural,
some of it's owned by the federal government,
but there is a lot of land in California.
If you kind of compared it to other states,
Texas is less dense, Alaska is less dense,
but in the state of California,
we're number three in the entire rest of the country.
North Dakota, South Dakota,
they're all more built on as a percentage than California.
There's plenty of room to build new homes.
We've got enough water.
If we properly conserve it, we properly dam it,
we properly manage it,
a whole lot of rainfall falls on the Sierra Mountains.
This state could be built,
we could see new homes built in the desert,
built in the Central Valley of California,
all around the suburbs, Orange County, LA County.
There's plenty of room in California
to build new homes for new families.
What do you think is the impact of this on California?
It's forcing a lot of kids out of state,
a lot of young people out of state,
far different than when I was a young man
growing up in the state and thinking about marriage.
Something like 54% of Californian,
California voters aged 18 to 39,
that age group that has many years of productivity
and growth ahead of them,
54% of them are considering
or have considered moving out of California
because of the high housing costs.
More than half.
Half of young people.
Where the state is not creating opportunities to own,
it really falls hardest on young people
who wanna start their lives, get a good job,
start a family, be a member of a community.
When you think about a home,
a home that a family can purchase,
it's a place to live,
it's a place where you can secure the future of your family.
But here's the secret,
a home is also an asset.
A home is something that you can refinance
if you wanna start a business
and you need capital to start a business.
A home is something that you can refinance
to help with your kid's education.
When you don't have that asset,
you're not owning equity.
So you're telling young families
they will never own a home
and they will never have that equity.
I'll give you an example.
The Census Bureau not long ago surveyed Americans
and they found that the net worth,
the net worth of the average family that owns a home
is about $260,000 per family.
The net worth of a renter is about $3,000.
The Federal Reserve says that if you're a homeowner,
your net worth is going to be 44 times
the net worth of a renter.
Why?
Because you own that equity in the home.
People who own homes, they form families quicker,
they have their children quicker
because they have room, they have space.
They're around schools that they want to send their kids to.
They're more likely to be involved in the community,
to volunteer at community events and the schools.
Suburbs are the places where families are comfortable
and this is one of the reasons
so many young Californians are deferring
starting a family, deferring getting married
because they can't afford to have something of their own
and that little bit of financial security
that owning something like a home affords.
What do you think is the impact of this
in the long run for California?
Well, the population's aging.
It really means that because so many young people are gone,
there's not a lot of pressure on the schools to get better
so our education system slips year after year after year
in terms of achievement in educating children.
It really creates ultimately two classes in California,
the super rich or those who are lucky enough
like in earlier generations,
boomers and Gen Xers to have been able to afford their home
maybe 20, 30 years ago.
You've got that class and you've got people
who are just struggling before them
and it hollows out that middle class.
Any democracy needs a strong middle class
that is committed to families,
that's committed to their communities and invested,
looking forward to living the rest of their lives
in a state, California.
We don't have that anymore.
It's like we're a statewide Manhattan.
It's a great place to live if you're super rich.
It's a place if you have to live there
and you're struggling, you'll live there.
But the folks in the middle,
there's just no room for them in California.
You mentioned their families,
the kids that are moving into other states.
What's the impact of that in the long run in California?
When I was growing up in the state,
I'm born and raised here in Southern California
and I grew up, I was fortunate to grow up in that area
where the city of LA built new roads, new boulevards.
On one side of those streets,
you would have nice middle-class communities
like Canoga Park or Downey or Torrance.
On the other side, great jobs at Raytheon
or at Lockheed or Paramount Pictures.
You'd have schools around the corner
that offered a good education to these kids.
California was about infrastructure and growth.
It was about jobs and growth.
You know, it was about people.
It was about bringing individuals up
who wanted to be middle-class into the middle-class
and giving them something to own.
That is the California.
That's the promise of California.
That's really what the state has always been for 175 years.
Today, those roads are cracked,
they're potholed, they're falling apart.
We've got the most technologically advanced civilization
the planet's ever known here in California,
the most innovation.
We can't keep the lights on.
When our cities burn, we can't find the water
to put the fires out.
So what we're doing is telling Californians
they can't live in the old California.
They can't have the same advantages that I had.
You know, young people are leaving the state in droves.
They're breaking up families, grandparents.
They have to pack their kids,
you know, watch their kids pack their cars,
put the grandchildren in the car seat
and drive off to Tennessee or to North Dakota
or Idaho or wherever.
That family's gone.
That family's broken up.
Those grandchildren will never be raised
around their grandparents.
These are policies that change the way people live.
It makes them pessimistic about their future.
And people who are pessimistic leave.
Can't have that in a state like this.
This state was built for the middle class.
It should be again.
What California needs to do to solve this?
Well, California politicians need to start
by listening to their constituents.
They need to be listening to the families
that are losing kids to Tennessee, you know,
or Arizona or Texas.
The California voter really needs to understand
that none of this is necessary.
That if we changed several important rules,
we would get all the housing, you know,
that 3.5 million number of new homes
that Gavin Newsom said he wanted to construct.
We'd be able to do that.
For example, we were talking a little bit
about VMT, that VMT, you know,
vehicle miles traveled concept.
Nobody in the state of California voted
for VMT regulations.
Not one person.
The legislature, believe it or not,
voted for very little of that regulatory regime.
That VMT concept was imposed by a series
of executive orders that the governors
of the state have signed over the years.
A new governor could step in
and very quickly, by the stroke of a pen,
rescind a lot of those orders and change that mandate.
You could erase big pieces of the VMT roadblock,
really overnight, if you were a governor,
and create opportunities to build
new communities in California.
That's one reform.
We were talking a little bit about CEQA.
CEQA has to be reformed to do a couple of things.
You cannot have just anybody, you know,
a competitor from down the street
doesn't want to see your apartments built
because he likes his rent and doesn't want the competition.
A competitor can sue under CEQA to stop your project.
Neighbors who simply don't want to see
blue-collar families moving into their neighborhood
because they think they're pretty rich
and they're pretty happy, they can stop.
They can sue you under CEQA.
Whether you've got a good claim or not, doesn't matter.
So you've got to stop that.
You have to require, under CEQA,
the plaintiffs to say who they are.
Right now, they do not have to tell the court
their actual identities or what their interests are,
how the project is harming them.
You've got to change that.
The public ought to be able to know
who's bringing those lawsuits.
And frankly, fewer people ought to be entitled.
It's called the California Environmental Quality Act.
It's supposed to be focusing on environmental concerns.
Very few of the plaintiffs who bring these suits
are environmental groups that are recognized.
You know, it's not the Audubon Society.
You know, it's not the Sierra Club very often.
It's usually some neighbor
who just doesn't want to see the thing get built.
That's got to change.
Michael Capaldi, partner at FBT Gibbons.
It was great to have you on California Saturday.
Pleasure. Thank you for the opportunity.
What are your thoughts on Michael's argument
about housing and family formation
and families staying together?
Make sure to email us at siamakiacaliforniasatter.com
or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Korami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.
