同是華裔冬奧生,兩種人生選擇:劉美賢金牌榮耀 vs 谷愛凌中國爭議

希望之聲灣區電台
333 followers
25 Video Views·Feb 12, 2026
米蘭冬奧,兩位華裔混血女孩在同一賽場上書寫不同故事,美國花滑新星劉美賢奪金,彰顯自由與家族信念;中國自由式滑雪名將谷愛凌摘銀,卻因國籍選擇和政治言論引發熱議。相同背景,不同選擇,她們的故事背後,折射出華裔運動員的多重抉擇與輿論風暴。詳情請點擊收聽【話說美國】
▧ Spotify播客連結:https://open.spotify.com/episode/17szybiotLOCqcLC0JaEsP?si=j1jHdMBXTyWbl8bHyTyJPw
☞ 可至Apple Podcast搜尋「熱點大家談」
⊹ ⊹ ⊹ ⊹ ⊹ ⊹ ⊹ ⊹
希望之声需要您的捐助和支持:
请捐款给希望之聲,捐款网站:https://donatecarsoh.org/cn/捐款支持/
咨询电话:888 -851-2128
支持希望之聲,您可以捐款/捐車,幫助我們做更多的好節目,還可以獲得聯邦抵稅。感謝您的支持!
www.donatecarsoh.org
Stay informed about current events politics and American community life — join us
for relaxed insightful conversations Tune
in to Voice of Hope’s "Words on America "
He's criticizing Gu Ailing and we can discuss that in more detail later
So why are we talking about Gu Ailing
This is the ongoing Winter Olympics currently taking place in Milan
The contrast between the two
biracial girls sparked intense online
discussion one being American-born Chinese athlete Liu Meixian
The other one representing China was actually freestyle skier Gu Ailing who is
from the United States thus both individuals
were performing on the same icy stage
Yet they are writing their own stories in entirely different ways—
their nationality choices family backgrounds life trajectories and so on
They all became the focus of attention—what was going on Let's start
with Gu Ailing Yes Gu Ailing has
recently been at the center of it all
Mainly as Xintian also mentioned just now she was harshly denounced by that NBA star
Kanter calling her a traitor wearing China'
s jersey — that's quite a serious accusation
The controversy mainly stemmed from
comments made by another American
skier Hunter Hess who was asked about
the situation during an interview
Right now the U S isn't going through intense immigration
enforcement or major political controversies so how
does he feel about representing the country on the field
I get the sense this question is a bit of a trap don't you
Then in response Hayes stated
he did not认同 the events unfolding in the United States
his emotions were deeply conflicted
shortly afterward President Trump posted on Truth Social saying
He’s a real loser absolutely shouldn
’t have entered this competition at all
and then Trump said it’s hard for me to cheer for someone like him
As a result Trump's remarks ignited
the public debate but
it was actually Gu Ailing who truly escalated the conflict to a peak
Because of this achievement in securing the women 's
breakthrough obstacle technique silver medal
she also gave an interview
in which she expressed her regret
The spotlight at the Winter Olympics was
overshadowed by this news which contradicted the
very spirit of the Games she mentioned having been involved in similar situations before
Similar public opinions and controversies
After Gu Ailing made these remarks
the social media sphere too
began to ferment across various public discourses
The main reason is Gu Ailing's unique
identity—being of Chinese
-American heritage—she
was born in the United States and holds
American citizenship yet she competes for China
Moreover she has never publicly spoken out on
China's human rights issues yet she suddenly made
critical remarks about the U S president at this
moment leading many to question her credibility
Why are you choosing to take a selective stance
The most serious allegation mentioned is
that former NBA star Kanter
directly criticized on X
by condemning Gu Ailing saying
She's a traitor wearing China's uniform
—born and raised in the U S achieved
fame there yet chose to compete for
China and now profits from China's market
Then there's Michael Soblik
a Washington-based think
tank scholar who also sharply criticized stating
that it's not uncommon for an athlete to criticize
the U S president but the issue lies with Gu Ailing
She was trained in the United States but
competes for China and never speaks out on
human rights issues Then
I came
across another critique which was also quite interesting
Calling her a strategist for the
Republican Party he asked Matt
Whitlock: would she use the
same tone to criticize Xi Jinping
Would she Obviously we'
re not seeing it now but
she can publicly criticize Trump Then there 's
another point—just as we discussed earlier—
Gu Ailing's position is particularly unique
She's already a major celebrity
in English-language media
not just in the Bay Area but
across the entire United States
and around the world simply
because she was born in our Bay
Area and has this unique dual Chinese-American background
And after her rise to fame following the Olympics she
received numerous commercial partnerships and she is
now ranked among the highest-earning Winter Olympians
globally earning a significant
income—just in 2025 alone
She is projected to earn 23
million U S dollars and now she's
enrolled at Stanford University so
indeed regardless of her background
Her standing in the
sports world her reputation
the uniqueness and controversy surrounding
her identity—all of these make her one of the
most talked-about stars of the Winter Olympics
The other one is Alisa Liu Liu Meixian
she has won the U S National Gold
Championship twice and has also stood on
international podiums
on multiple occasions
At this year's Milan Winter Olympics she won the
Grand Prix title in women
's singles figure skating
with a near-perfect free skate—essentially
securing the world championship in figure skating
and helped the U S team win the gold medal in the figure skating team event
Liu Meixian was born in August 2005
and grew up in California a talented
She is the youngest woman in U S history to win the
singles figure skating championship her name Liu
Meixian is not a transliteration but a Chinese name
given by her family meaning
"beautiful and virtuous "
Who is her father His name is Arthur Liu also known as Liu Jun
Some of our Chinese-speaking listeners may be familiar with this name
Liu Jun is from Sichuan Province in China
He participated in the Guangzhou Students' United Front in 1989
For participating in anti-CCP activities he was forced to leave China and
later obtained political asylum in the
United States where he became a lawyer
So this Liu Meixian is the eldest child
in the family and she has four younger
siblings What's
particularly unique is that
all five of the siblings are named using
Born through anonymous surrogacy and egg donation
she was legally raised by her father and his
former wife who served as guardians Liu Meixian
began practicing figure skating from a young age
His talent was evident from an early age winning
competitions young while Arthur Liu single
-handedly raised his five children fully
supporting Liu Meixian's figure skating career
She began cultivating this technical advantage from a young age
Let me elaborate further on Liu Jun's background
During the 1989 student movement she served
as chairman of the Guangzhou Student Union
Later through the Yellow Sparrow Operation he fled to the
United States obtained political asylum and became an immigration
lawyer As for Liu Meixian's mother—she remains anonymous
having been born through anonymous egg donation and surrogacy
Liu Meixian started skating at the age of five
Her father Liu Jun was
fully supportive pouring all
his savings into her upbringing but on the other
hand Liu Jun refused any funding or recruitment
from China The FBI had previously been involved in
Although she's also a Sino-American
her stance and attitude toward China
are quite different from what we discussed earlier regarding Gu Ailing
Exactly the opposite—back in 2021 the Federal Bureau of
Investigation (FBI) had actually issued a warning to Liu Jun
CCP government agents have attempted to gather information
about him and his daughter—likely trying to recruit
them—and she even posed as an American immigration
official to contact them which is extremely reprehensible
As a lawyer Liu Jun is especially
alert—like touching a tiger 's
whiskers the moment you do
it immediately strikes back
because official disclosures have made this behavior part
of an ongoing investigation by the U S Department of Justice
and whether the CCP's Foreign Ministry acknowledges these allegations
So these two
athletes — they actually share
many similarities yet also have striking
differences both were born in California
right Both are of mixed Chinese heritage
And they're all top-tier Winter Olympics athletes
What's strikingly different
is that Liu Meixian
draped herself in the American flag whereas
Wu Ailing wrapped herself in China's national
flag—the CCP's flag What does this reflect
I think this is also worth our discussion
So what do our listeners think How do they view it
Regarding these two young women
who are now both at the center of public conversation
Which do you find more compelling
—or how do you view their
differing choices and positions Call us at 888-275-1628
888-275-1628
or leave a message at FM961 net
Okay let's hear Fang Wei's opinion first how about that
Before I share my own thoughts
Can I tell the third story — What story
does it matter to your
opinion — It matters a great deal
— Okay then please go ahead
— Right what exactly is this third story
It's also about a story of a foreign immigrant who grew up in the United States
and the main character is Marco Rubio You
know at the World Economic Forum in Davos
When Trump spoke he joked
I've finally become an ambassador for the first time
What does it mean to be an ambassador for the first time
Our country's ambassador is Marco Rubio
He said "You know who taught me "
It was Marco Rubio He told me
"Let me teach you the ways of diplomacy "
So everyone burst out laughing
In short this Marco Rubio—
Trump has repeatedly said in recent weeks that he will become the greatest
Secretary of State in history Well let'
s talk about Rubio—very powerful indeed
Including the operation to arrest Venezuela's so-called
dictator Maduro who
is the key architect now effectively
serving as the U S governor of Venezuela
He's just kidding He's
in charge of overseeing
the interim president of Venezuela In
short the reshaping is extremely effective
Trump appointed him
national security advisor
Let him be this Secretary of State
Let him be head of that thing what's it called the U S Agency for International Development
Let him be director of the National Crime Squad
Just a few days ago he was saying
He could go be this Cuban governor or maybe
even the Iranian governor—how is it that one
person ends up holding seven or eight positions
at once What's Trump calling himself these days
He was Trump's go-to guy before he passed
away because he was just so effective—whenever
you told him to do something he’d get it done
Trump would say "Alright just throw it over "
So there he was sitting in the White House
chair looking kind of
exhausted one time and
everyone just grabbed that image and swapped
him in with this Iranian prime minister
Not the Iranian prime minister
the Iranian supreme religious leader's attire
changed into Xi Jinping's clothes
changed into what Zhang Youxia's clothes
at this point saying I'm living too long that's what it means
Good audience members said what I wanted to talk about was my story from childhood
—just like the one I just shared with Gu Ailing and this woman named Liu Meixian
She was born in Miami in 1971—she
wasn't born in
Cuba but her parents
were both Cuban they fled Cuba
three years before the revolution
So her parents never actually experienced Castro 's
or communist life but her grandfather—her
maternal grandfather—was part of the Cuban
Revolution and didn't flee
until three years after it
So she personally witnessed the stark contrast before and after the Cuban Revolution as portrayed in
Castro's Cuba: A Before-and-After Portrait
having sat as a child on the porch outside her family's
front door with its covered entrance
Because her grandfather liked to
smoke cigars he'd smoke them outside
and she'd sit on the
porch steps where
her grandfather smoked his cigars
Hearing her grandfather tell her stories
What stories he told her
She would tell them every day
She would describe how prosperous Cuba had been before the Communist takeover
And how Castro used the slogan of equality to destroy private property religious
freedom and the rule of law—so she only
understood it clearly when she was very young
Communism is deception and destruction Then her
grandfather would read that newspaper every day—
the Cuban newspaper
a Spanish-language publication
—and begin commenting on international affairs
The little Rubio over there was listening
as she heard her grandfather denounce the
dictator in the newspaper and tell Rubio
if you don't cherish America's democracy
All of this could happen right here so my
grandfather told little
Rubio ever since he was
young that freedom is a very
fragile thing and so Rubio grew up slowly even as a child
She said I already knew how communism worked because I grew
up hearing stories about it so basically her grandfather would
talk about freedom at the dinner table
Puffing on a cigar on the threshold talking about
freedom—this is where her family's legacy began
Ultimately it was her grandfather's words that
inspired her to dedicate herself to public service
Public service exists to
oppose authoritarianism That’s the story of Rubio
That’s why I’m talking
about Rubio You know Gu Ailing
when she was 15 decided to join China’s national team Right
And the Liu Meixian mentioned just now—
she was also very young
at the time barely
in her teens when her
father was threatened and she was
only in her teens then
What I mean is that all their
decisions are made by their
parents— their upbringing is provided by their parents
and even the choice of whether
to cooperate with
the CCP or not is also decided by their parents including Rubio
So in the end three distinct
children emerged—one essentially
being someone who simply follows the money wherever
it is regardless of principles
or countries even though
he speaks eloquently
and claims to represent two nations
He said this time
he didn't win the gold medal
in that Pudohua competition
then the person asked him
the reporter asked him why he hadn't won the gold medal
he replied he was quite good at speaking
He said I was carrying the burden of two nations
so the pressure was too great Many online comments then said he was bearing the heavy responsibility of making big
money and that the weight of
that money was simply too much
So the outcome was simply impossible to control and since there
was no result no one believed he was shouldering the heavy responsibility for both countries
and in fact he wouldn't take on
the burden of either nation because once you know he served China
China's internet celebrities regard him as the perfect
patriot the perfect hero as a result he represented the
United States the previous year in applying for the Los
Angeles Winter Olympics on behalf of a man named Yan Hucheng
Yan Hucheng who applied to represent China in the
Winter Olympics sparked outrage among Chinese internet
celebrities who accused him of disloyalty to China
revealing a case of trying to have it both ways
Where it works best go there How could he
shoulder the responsibilities of two countries He's the one carrying
the burden of earning for both
nations Actually four years
ago it was when he first represented the Chinese team
It sparked a lot of controversy but do you
remember what he said
back then He said "When
I'm in China I'm Chinese when I'm in America
I'm American " But that raises a question
Since China does not recognize dual
nationality if a foreigner such as an
American competes for China's national
team he would need to undergo naturalization
That plan is it right What do we mean by a plan You
simply become a Chinese national Now
the reporter asks him since he returned to
Stanford to study after
completing the Olympics
You know 丁嶽 we always talk about immigration issues
immigration issues—how easy do you think it is
to stay in the U S If someone doesn't have Chinese
citizenship and also doesn't have U citizenship
He came back on an F1 visa but you know this
actually exploits a loophole
in the U S immigration
system—because I used to work at an aviation law
firm and interviewed many immigration lawyers
Then I went through the naturalization process
myself because the immigration law is very
clear on this— the United States does not recognize
dual nationality so technically speaking he
If he acquired citizenship of another country
it would mean he gave up his U S citizenship
but the issue is that the United States lacks a system or oversight body
Saying this person gave up U S citizenship—well
then I’d kick him out That’s because we don’t have a follow-up mechanism so the U just doesn’
t enforce the law strictly
right Yes yes exactly
Alright then we'll need to pause here for a moment
And I can see many listeners are eager to join in
with their comments
and if there are any callers
We also warmly welcome you to call
888-275-1628 if you like Gu Ailing and
Liu Meixian are a biracial individual with dual Chinese-American identity
But the paths they've chosen are entirely
different Then there are
figures like Rubio rising
onto the international political stage destined to lead
a nation—why do they end up this way
You're more supportive or in favor
of which path you'd like your child
to take Call us at 888-275-1628 and
we'll continue this conversation
Stay informed about current events and
politics plus life in
American communities—let’s
chat effortlessly and stay fully up to date
Tune in to Voice of Hope’s “Words on America ”
I'm Xingtian
I'm Tianyue
Hello everyone we're back again
Just now this topic
I think it's really worth discussing
We've also seen comments from our listeners
Li Yan said that fence-sitters ultimately won'
t be liked by either side she pointed out that
some people driven by money take no stand at
all—something I've seen among certain Americans
On some Facebook platforms
I've seen many Americans
commenting and indeed some of them believe
it's a personal choice—
right What opportunities
can you get if you're born in another country
Some say he'll represent the
U S team in
America while others argue he spends half his time in the U and
half in China making it
unlikely he'll qualify for
the American team but
possible for the Chinese team
Don't think that way don't blame him
As for those kinds of statements
Some people also say
Aina was also after money
Her endorsement fees
for light products
are said to have reached a staggering
23 million dollars—just
from last year alone with 30 million in 2021
Someone then asked a question: he said
"My real question is where exactly did
all this money go Did it stay in China
Is it now避ing
U S and California taxes "
That should be the issue
under investigation — I was
just reminded of what that
friend said earlier about
the fence-sitters right It made me think of how many
of these so-called little pink ones there are online
Then they rant about America while
simultaneously
enjoying life there and
they have this sarcastic internet
phrase—“anti-Americanism is my job ”
But in America living
is life in America
life is living anti-Americanism is
work as Si Ma Nan
said right it's like
this it's no longer just about saying
This so-called fence-sitting
group or rather those who try to
benefit from both sides has become a common reality that many
people find themselves in—how should I put it —it's just a
widespread situation really I'm not sure how to fully grasp it
I'm not sure how our listeners feel but
I don't think it's safe to say there are many of them yet
—people like Sima Nan are what they call "big
five-hundredths " openly
serving as CCP supporters
There are special assignments involved—only someone loyal to the
CCP would act this way they outwardly support
the CCP shouting loudly about their love for the
motherland but underneath it'
s a completely different story
But I think for someone like Liu Jun who is
essentially just an
ordinary person—a student
back then later a lawyer—his actions were
always clean aboveboard
and clearly principled
So I just wonder what kind of parents produce
what kind of children—I suppose I don't know that old saying what exactly happened with Old
Ailing's mother—I'll just
make an educated guess
That old saying Liu
Jun and the grandfather
of Rubio mentioned just now—right he 's
Garcia—these are all completely different people
What kind of people are they
Their child would turn out to be just like that—basically that's how it is Yeah I was
thinking about something like Gu
Ailing's mother Of course we can only speculate for now and
we'd be very fortunate to actually get an interview with her
See what she really thinks
Well I'm thinking that some Chinese who come to America
aren't necessarily as clear about things as they might seem
They might just be thinking it's a way to make money
He wanted to earn more money to secure a better
future for his daughter—more funds more
resources more
reputation Reputation after all could be attained too
But I think perhaps he should step back and reconsider
Seriously take a moment to think about it—
because the country he represents isn't just
any nation right The country he represents
is the CCP the People's
Republic of China is a
That is it could fairly be said that it's an adversary of the United States
an enemy state
I believe there would be no disagreement on that
So what I'm saying is
Actually I came across a comment
that I found quite interesting
—this person named Timothy Lai
said you should stay loyal
to the country that gives you the chance to fulfill your potential and pursue
your dreams he went on to say in essence that ultimately
Each of us can make our own choices in life
I mean people like Gu Ailing and Liu Meixian
they’ve been able to have this kind of freedom
right This freedom to fully express their
potential and excel so brilliantly on the ice rink
Actually a lot of it comes down to the opportunities
this country the United States has provided them right
Freedom for instance But if you ignore those factors everyone just assumes it's all
solely due to their own efforts
He could think that way too but look at
what he's actually
achieved now—Gu Ailing has
won two golds and one silver for the Chinese
team and her value has soared accordingly
For her personally fame and fortune came hand in hand yet she also
became a major focus of the CCP's external propaganda efforts As
for Liu Meixian and her father the gold medal she won for the United
States represented a profound personal and political significance
For them it's not just a sporting achievement—it symbolizes their
contribution to this land of freedom
and a continuation of their values right
Yes I think in the long run nobody really
likes fence-sitters you can always tell who's
trying to please whom and of course Gu Ailing
is just aiming to benefit from both sides
That's right so you praise everyone you meet saying nice things about them
You might get by for a while
but in the long run it won't
work just like how she is now torn between two sides
Including her simply helping this American named Yan Hucheng
apply for the Winter Olympics — a completely ordinary thing in the U S —
still manages to anger many Chinese netizens
So the same applies in reverse This time there's someone named Liu
Meixian who's relatively more prominent
I see it's the Americans' English
The English-speaking community reacted much more
strongly so she ended up offending both sides meaning
she might not actually gain anything in the end Of
course judging from everyone's opinions about her
The negative buzz will gradually
fade away but this bad reputation will
definitely hurt her advertising deals Of course in life you always
have to consider what kind of person you're willing to marry You say I just care about money and couldn't care less about what people think of me
Or values—well I'd be happy
with just money that 's
also a choice right So everyone has their own
take on this matter and each person forms their own
judgment about you Yes but I think as I just said—
Xintian pointed out a crucial issue: if you're between two
typical countries—say the United
States and the United Kingdom
—taking a neutral stance might
not spark much controversy
but now it's becoming more pronounced between the U S and Canada
But the CCP is considered by the U S to
be its greatest threat and just recently we
reported on how it infiltrates from all
directions and conducts
transnational repression
It's actually a threat to the Chinese community as well—
many Chinese people think they 're
safe because they're under
this big tree but in reality the CCP is using us to achieve
its own goals So I don't know what everyone else thinks but
Have you realized that in this situation trying to stay neutral and please
both sides is extremely
risky or perhaps you don't yet understand that at some point you'll have to
make a definitive choice
Otherwise as we discussed a moment
ago it's simply about identity— for
instance whether Gu Ailing ultimately
wants to be considered American or Chinese
It's actually a necessary choice not something where
you can simply claim both
options equally because the
laws of both countries—including that of the United
States—do not recognize dual citizenship simultaneously
So in this situation I wonder our listeners
if it were up to you to
make this choice which
side would you pick Or as I see some of our
listeners are already sharing their thoughts—
From an early age we teach children right from wrong don't we
Maybe for you it's not really a choice at all
So what are your thoughts on this issue
We welcome you to contact us at 8882751628
8882751628
It's time to take a break
Back soon
We need to make up for
the homework we missed
yesterday—Newtan will teach us how to make that soup
you know the raw chicken soup right How exactly is it made We’ll be back shortly
