Everyone in the room was bullish on housing, then we actually walked through the data.
This video is a live housing market debate where I take the bear case against two bullish perspectives and focus on the one question that matters more than anything else:
Who buys next?
We are not talking about headlines or opinions. We are talking about transaction volume, affordability, buyer behavior, and why markets stall long before prices fall.
In this debate we cover:
Why housing markets stop clearing before prices move
The difference between sentiment and actual demand
Why first time buyers are disappearing
What falling transaction volume really signals
Bullish arguments around AI, rates, and productivity
Why those narratives may not translate into buyers
Single family vs multifamily risks over the next three years
What a real estate bear market actually looks like in real life
If you are a buyer, seller, investor, or agent, this conversation matters because the market does not move on hope. It moves when buyers can afford payments and transactions clear.
Watch the full debate and decide for yourself.
Read my Substack for what I can’t say here: jonbrooks.substack.com
**Disclaimer**: This video reflects my personal opinions based on my experience and research. It should not be taken as financial, legal, or real estate advice. Always do your own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making decisions.
I'm going to do the housing market in three years. Within the next three years,
what is going to happen? United States housing market. So here's who we got on the panel. We got
Mr. John Brooks, former Wall Street real estate investment banker. Wolf of Wall Street at that.
He owns and operates a real estate brokerage, Momentum. Is that it? Momentum. Basically,
close three billions in real estate volume, 8,500 transactions. Just exited a 200-unit
multifamily building. You got what? 270. 270 agents. That's a lot of agents. And JB is the
bear. The market is going to tag on the bull side. By the way, he has the balls to take on
two of these guys. So on the bull side- You can arm wrestle at the end. You won't need to.
Too soon. We got Mr. Mike Arndorfer. Mike's a Phoenix-based private markets investor, LP and
GP coach, has a fan club. He is a co-founder of North 40 Capital, multifamily operator, H&M,
QP. I don't know what the **** that means, but they're A2. Anyways, Mike is disciplined.
Give it up for Mike. And then we got Mr. Moe Chomil, CEO of Alltech, national title company,
national. 25 years in the real estate and title biz. 150,000 transactions he's done,
tech-driven. He's got offices in Africa and what? You got offices in Morocco. Is it Morocco?
Anyways, he's got a lot of people working for him doing title work. And he also has a podcast
called Title Agents Podcast. It's the number one podcast for title company people. So give it up
for Moe. All right, let's get right into it. So first of all, we're going to do a survey. I'm
going to put up a QR code. Everybody hit this QR code. You're going to vote right now, whether
you are a bull or a bear on the housing market in the next three years in the United States.
Everybody vote. Single family, multifamily, just housing, single family and multifamily.
It's single family and multifamily. It's housing. It's where people live.
I agree with you. We split it.
Oh, 86%. Come on. Let's see if you get it up to a hundred. Not that confident. All right. So
obviously you guys are bull. I don't know if everybody here is objective. I'm not taking
sides. There's a lot of real estate people that are motivated by raising money or they're hoping
that their rental properties don't get squatted on or something. Okay. 70-30. Those are good,
clean numbers. Okay. Thank you for that. So right now we're 70-30. I'm going to see what it does
in a half hour after these guys eloquently tell you their statistics of why you're wrong and maybe
your mind has changed. Does that make sense? So first question I got for them. Let's go.
The one thing these guys agree on, the only thing these guys agree on is in the next three years,
the number of transactions will increase, right? We're kind of in a transactional recession right
now. Would you agree? So is everyone in the room agreed that the transactions will increase in the
next three years? Right. So that's the only thing they would agree on. Okay. Next slide.
Now we're going to disagree. How will the values of single family homes change?
How will the values of single family homes change? We'll start off with Mike.
Two minutes. I defer to Mo. Thanks a lot. He's scared. What we decided to do is this,
where I'm going to cover all the multifamily and Mo's covering all. All right. Go ahead, Mo.
Four minutes. Give him two minutes and we'll go back for it. Go ahead. Two minutes for Mo. Go.
By the way, he's looking at his chat GPT right now because he couldn't
good content. Even he doesn't even believe what he's saying. Well, I believe we have a lot of
tailwind behind us. And for simple fact of Trump economics, love, hate the guy. It doesn't matter.
We have a lot of tailwind behind us. GDP third quarter of 2024, 2025 was 4.4 for third quarter
and a five. I think they're predicting above 5% GDP in the fourth quarter 2025. That's massive.
And there is a rumor. If you listen to all in podcasts, there is a hint, maybe 10, 15%,
which would be insane. That's kind of pushing it too much. There's a lot of tailwind behind us.
Fannie Mae believes, well not believe, through the stats and data, they think the real estate
value is correct. They're going to go modestly in the next three years, about 6% to 8%,
2.4 in 2026 and 2.2 in 2027. As I said, there is a lot of tailwind behind us.
The rate's going to keep driving down. And also what Trump is pushing for all his agenda from,
I know a lot of you guys are going to hate this and trying to take all the institutional buy-in
of single family homes, but he's very, very driven to lower interest rates and also kind
of affordability for the homeowners. Is that it? We're betting on the government bailing us out?
It's not a bailout. It's facts. It's a tailwind.
In the last... Can I go in?
Yep, you go.
All right, let's go.
Two minutes.
So the bet that you're making is that the government will manipulate
mortgage rates lower. Is that correct?
It is not manipulation. Have you heard of a thing called AI?
Okay.
I think you just said GPT. I forgot. It's not GPT. Yeah.
Use your cat GPT.
Goldman Sachs, so far, we haven't really seen productivity yet, like the impact of productivity
in the economy. So far, they're predicting about 2.5% of increase in productivity. You know what
that means? $700 to $800 billion into the economy with zero additional cost.
Oh, damn!
Does anybody else feel like this just sounds like a bunch of hope?
This is factual, Goldman Sachs.
Or do we just get into what the reality of what the market is actually doing?
Has anybody heard of Goldman Sachs? They're very reputable, very respectable.
I hope that AI comes in and saves us.
I hope that the government comes in and saves us.
Why don't we talk about what's actually happening right now in the single-family space?
And there's a lot of talk, right? Because you talk about Trump out there and
let's do assumable mortgages. Let's do 50-year mortgages. Let's do institutional ban on buyers.
All these ideas, nothing's going to stick. This is an executive order. None of this stuff is
actually going to happen. This is talk to get votes about affordability before the midterms.
None of this will actually be executed in the marketplace.
But AI productivity is real. You cannot tell me, use AI, correct?
So are you saying that because of productivity comes up,
one of the eight major factors is wages? So you're saying because productivity will go
up is that wages will go up and that will make it more affordable for people to be able to purchase?
All I'm saying is 1% of productivity means $300 billion into the economy,
to the bottom line, with no additional costs. That's massive. Do the math.
The buyers of single-family homes are retail buyers primarily. So are you saying,
again, that their wages are... What is the purpose of saying AI? Because are we talking
the gains in the stock market will go to the top 10% who already have the majority of the
wealth in this country? Or is it going to be spread out amongst the next marginal buyer?
Because we all know that real estate is all about the next marginal buyer. That's the only thing
that matters in this industry. So who is the next buyer of these overinflated assets that we have
right now? You have to ask yourself, who's that going to be over the next one to three years?
It's not going to be the first-time homebuyers. That statistic has dropped from 50% first-time
homebuyers over the last two decades to now 20% of buyers are first-time homebuyers.
And the median household age for the homebuyer is now 61 years old.
So John is saying prices are going to go down, correct? Or the economy is going to crash?
They're already going down.
How much equity...
This is the first event I've been to where I haven't been pitched by a syndicator. Thank God.
How much equity... I mean, come on.
There is $34 trillion in equity in home ownership in the U.S. right now.
You know how much it was back in 2008?
$8 trillion.
Okay, cool. Right. So there's something called phantom equity, right? You only realize it when
you sell it.
How's the phantom?
You only realize the money when you sell it. And hey, Mike, you actually did this exercise with me.
He's actually a great guy and he gave me a lot of advice on my portfolio. He said, sell that
at my single family rental portfolio.
He's like, oh, your return on equity is only like 3%.
That sucks. You can get higher in the treasury.
And John had the ability to take that money from the equity of what he sold
and start lending it directly, which he could turn it into about 16%.
And his current portfolio did not make that. But that doesn't mean anything's going down.
So markets can still go way up and you can make 16% and still have the 16%.
Right. But we were just talking about before coming up here about how equity evaporates.
And a lot of people are underwater in their stuff now.
And the buyers who bought from 2022 to today,
they're experiencing tons of distress when they try to go resell their asset, right?
Because we're talking about single family home values.
Round trip on buying and selling residential real estate is about 10%.
And prices have been coming down, especially in the Sunbelt over the last few years,
ever since March 2022, when the Fed started raising rates, prices started coming down.
And then we've had this kind of equilibrium moment.
That's history. We're talking about now.
Okay, sure. Right. Well, it's important to understand where we are in the market cycle.
Pending sales are the lowest. Look this up, guys. This is all out there.
Pending sales for residential real estate are at the lowest level they've ever been
at this time. Contract cancellations are at the highest level
they have ever been in recorded history. This stuff is happening right now.
The first step to a decline is transaction volume slowing. Yes or yes?
And values are starting to show up slower in specific markets first,
and then in other markets later. And that's what we're starting to see already.
But NAR is predicting 14% increase in transactions in 2026.
Okay, look at Yann. I don't even know how people still listen to this guy.
He also did not see what was happening in 2008.
Fannie Mae predicting 4.2%.
You listen to NAR. It's the National Association of Realtors.
Their job is to put out pump pieces for real estate.
How about Zillow? How about Redfin? How about Fannie Mae?
Yeah, Zillow is saying that we're having the highest level of decreases across the country
for prices actually coming down, not just in the Sunbelt, but across the country.
So he's saying Fannie Mae, et cetera, et cetera, saying 2% increase for the next three years.
What do you predict?
So it depends on the area, but we should definitely be seeing-
We're talking the whole national. We're not-
So I can go by area?
Yeah, whatever you guys want.
I mean, if we're talking nationally, it's really hard to predict this stuff.
But if I had to say, we're going to see 2% to 3% declines over the next couple of years.
So they're saying the opposite. One's saying it's going to go up 2% a year on home values,
the other's saying it's going to go down.
But you have no backup data. You're not stating any facts from any source.
You're basing it on the recession of-
You have also, you're just betting on AI creating productivity.
I'm not betting on AI.
You're betting on the government bailing you out by manipulating inflation.
I just named some reputable sources. I gave names zero. I named none.
ChatGPT works.
ChatGPT sucks for this. It's a sad thing.
Well, I have none. It's also subjective to you.
Guys, this is really simple.
All right. Next question. Let's do multifamily. Next question.
How will the values of multifamily investments change?
We're going to start with Mike Orndorfer.
All right. So I'm going to break this into three things.
So number one, I'm going to say you invested in multifamily and say 21, 22, 23.
There is billions of dollars worth of equity.
After he's finished, we're going to vote on what you think is bulletproof.
You don't know what's lost yet.
How is this any different than what you're talking about,
the equity buildup on the single family side?
It's exactly the same.
Give him two minutes on why you think multifamily is going up.
So, okay. First of all, I'm saying it's not going to go up enough to save those deals.
So if you are in a deal that's screwed, you're probably going to lose all your money.
You just don't know it yet.
There is billions of dollars that's going to go that way.
So I'm not talking about saving that.
What I am saying though, is that net operating income is going to go up.
Rents are going up and cap rates are going to be steady to going down.
And so therefore, within a three-year period,
if you own something now that's stable,
you're going to be worth more in three years than it is currently.
Now, the other thing that I'm going to say
is we're starting to see a lot of really good deals come on the market.
People are capitulating that missed the top,
that kept thinking that for a couple of years,
that they would be able to still get those prices.
They're giving in.
And there are deals that are showing up.
We started seeing it about six months ago.
We're going to see it all through this year.
We're going to see it next year.
So this is the biggest thing I would say,
is that this is an amazing time to put money into multifamily
in specific deals with new equity.
All right, beautiful.
Counterpoint?
Multifamily transactions are down about 70 to 80 percent.
And it's the same formula for single family,
where once the transactions slow, prices follow as inventory stacks up.
I think a lot of people get confused that this stuff,
it doesn't happen overnight.
This stuff is liquid.
It takes time to sell.
I agree with you.
They've gone down and we are at the bottom.
We are headed back up.
See, that's where I tend to disagree based on the information that we're looking at.
There's a lot of extend and pretend that's going on right now with the banks.
Okay, I'm going to extend it another 90 days, another 90 days.
Eventually, the bill will be due.
I mean, you're starting to see some of that distress.
You're talking about basically,
hey, you lost all of your equity.
I'm going to recapitalize, put 20, 35 percent down and it cash flows.
And that's what I put in that first bucket.
That's the thing that you bought the building for 30 million.
It's now worth 24.
You're going to lose all your money.
It sucks.
But it's not the price discovery hasn't been there.
And then your debt's like 20 million on it, right?
And then it cash flows at today's rates.
And so that's what I'm saying is new money coming in,
new equity that you're putting into it.
There are deals that are showing up that are going to be
very good deals over the next three years.
So Mike is talking about a future with a very...
Right.
We're talking, what he thinks is we're already at the bottom.
What I'm saying, this is just the beginning of a structural change
in direction for both single family and multifamily.
Well, we've had rents stable to up.
Now, not every market...
It's been down.
Rents have been down one percent nationally for the last three years.
Actually, if you check with Yardy,
rents are actually up one percent nationally over there.
Oh!
Let's get our...
No, John has no sources.
Somebody check the facts!
John, you have to name certain markets that are down.
One percent up or one percent down nationally over the last three years.
Somebody check that ----.
In Jacksonville, yes, it's down.
And if you look at Phoenix, yes, we're down over the last year, four percent.
What we're having though, a lot of times is we're starting to see some...
So multifamily, as you know,
you've got your base rent and then you've got the concessions.
And what's happened is the rents have stayed fairly steady
to going down a little bit depending on the market.
And you've had a lot of concessions.
But most of the places across the country,
we're now seeing those concessions get burned off
and there's less and less coming.
And so what I am saying is that we are at the bottom at this.
We've been bouncing along it for about the last six to 12 months.
Some markets have already started to go up.
Some are still going down.
But in three years time, we're going to be up in rents.
And the supply...
That's the main reason.
That's a big concern because a lot of people say to me,
hey, you know, I live in this town and all I see is cranes.
Supply is down 70% from 2021 to 26.
And we're going to go down 30% from what we had in 25 to 26 to 27.
So you've got supply.
Supply is continuing to drown.
And what's happened is we've had this excess supply that came into the market.
Where are those numbers coming from?
The supply in the Sunbelt is like...
Who lives in the Sunbelt areas?
This is just such BS.
You drive around, there's apartments on every street corner.
They're building more.
They started their projects two to three years ago.
They're going ahead and having to finish them
because they already broke ground.
They already have their financing.
They already have their contracts in place.
I mean, just drive around these areas.
It's not rocket science to see that we have an oversupply
in the Sunbelt of tons of multifamily.
Rents are down 25% in Austin.
They're down about 25% in Jacksonville.
Florida and Texas are leading the pack.
And there's always a leader whenever the market starts to shift
and then it starts to spread to these other markets.
And we're going to start seeing it show up in the next three years.
And that's why rents are already dropping.
And they'll continue to drop over the next three years.
All right.
So let's vote on this.
Bull or bear on this quest.
Go back to the question that was just there,
was about multifamily.
It's basically, how will the multifamily...
Basically, are you a bull or bear on multifamilies?
Go back to the question.
Are you...
Yeah, go bears.
Oh, here it is.
This is the wrong...
Well, while we're doing that, I'll talk about the facts.
So...
Single family...
Okay.
This is single...
Are you guys voting single family and multifamily?
It says, how will the values of single family homes change?
And they're going down right now.
Okay.
Give the QR code a single family.
Let's do single family.
People in the audience, are you...
You gotta remember, we're talking about the future, not the past.
It's on the next three years.
Yeah, but we're at the most unaffordable level in history ever
from a wage standpoint compared to the prices.
Next three years.
It's like $1,000 cheaper in a lot of markets than it is...
It's 1,000 less to rent than to buy.
And a decade ago, it wasn't that way.
Things have completely flip-flopped.
Why would a renter go out and buy a house and pay $1,000 more?
I believe we keep talking about pockets, not the whole net.
We're talking about national...
This is national data.
I'll send you my charts later and you can look it up on ChatGPT.
Okay.
All right.
Let's see the vote on...
Oh, so single family, guys, it's almost 50-50.
Single family homes are not going to increase in value 50%.
Single family homes won't increase in value 50%.
Okay, now let's do multifamily.
Go to the multifamily QR code, please.
Multifamily.
Do you guys think multifamily values are going to go up within the next three years
or down within the next three years?
Do you guys look at the...
There's a lot of optimism.
Well, of course, they're optimistic.
That's what we're talking to.
We're talking to real estate investors.
You think that's why?
They're talking...
We're talking facts.
We're going to have continued absorption.
You just said everybody got wiped out on their equity the last three years.
That's interesting, though.
Well, that is true.
But that's the history.
We're talking about the future.
It's still not a 70-30.
The distress hasn't even gone through the system.
Okay, let's go to the next question.
We are starting to see it.
Okay, next question is rent, right?
We talk about values.
Now let's talk about the real deal rent.
You know, sometimes I hear people say rents never go down.
I don't know if that's true.
Do they never go down?
Do rents always go up?
Well, let's talk about that.
So I'm going to start with John.
How will rents change in the next three years?
Sell everything.
No, so rents have already been coming down for the last few years.
And this is a great thing.
We need rents and prices to come down for the next generation to come in.
And buyers have opportunity costs.
What you see is household formation is starting to trend down.
You know, affordability is a real issue.
People are not having kids anymore.
They're not getting married anymore at the levels that they were in the past.
There's stats out there that show the number of people who are
married and buying a house at age 30 is only 12%.
It's showing up.
And what people are doing is they're moving back in with their parents.
The number is 30-year-olds who are living with their parents.
It's now 25%.
So, you know, you think that, okay, all these people, they're not buying to be renters.
They're actually moving in together.
And they're moving, you know, they're getting apartments and doing things like that.
So I think that's going to have a huge impact on rents moving forward.
And the amount of supply that's coming on the market is really high.
So I think rents will be coming down at a pretty similar rate.
It depends on the area.
Obviously, the Sunbelt where we're completely overbuilt is going to be a big difference.
The other thing that we're starting to see is
institutional investors are doing the build to rent, which is great.
So they're building a lot of inventory out there.
So we're overbuilding on the single-family side.
We're overbuilding on the multifamily side.
And the demand just isn't there.
The migration isn't there.
The immigration just isn't there.
Who are all these people you think are going to occupy these homes?
They're not having kids.
They're not coming to the country.
And so you're trying to figure out what's going to happen in the next few years.
It's just the demand.
There's more supply and less demand.
And we know what that equals.
All right.
Who wants a rebuttal?
How will rents change?
Beau.
Okay.
So I'm just talking about multifamily.
So multifamily rents, as I said, in most markets are already stable to going up.
And I think over the next three years, we're going to be looking at increases.
So definitely an increase in rents.
What we have from that is if you look at Origin, their multilitics,
they were some of the best in the country,
especially in predicting the huge increases that we had in rents that no one else saw coming.
And so they've been one of the more accurate things,
but they're thinking that Charlotte's going to be up 5.7% by January, 2027.
Houston, 4.9.
Even Las Vegas, 4.9.
So we're looking at probably three to 4% rents increasing across the board
when we're looking at this every year at a time.
Over between now and February of 27.
And most of that is coming from...
Who's predicting that?
That was from Origin.
But there's also Yardi and CBRE are all predicting rents increased over that timeframe.
Let's do a QR code.
Would you guys think rents are going up or down rents?
Money's to talk about single family though, too.
Oh, you want to talk about single family rents?
I mean, it's the same.
What's the difference, right?
So the bulls...
I can't wait to watch this in three years.
I was the bear on stage in 2022 and everybody's just going to keep going up.
It was great.
That was a great one.
We should get the recording of that and put it up.
Pretty bullish on rents increasing.
You'll be able to up your rents even a couple of percentage points.
They have to.
Otherwise, they have to put the rents down and feel bad.
I mean, their net worth's down on their one sheet.
Nobody wants to write it down.
So this is going to be your last opportunity to spit any statistical data.
What's the statistics that you point to or to prove your case more?
I'll start with John.
Which topic?
Just anything.
Just the point.
Just the overall point.
We live in a payment economy.
Not a lot of us in this room live in that payment economy.
The 90% of Americans live in a payment economy.
There's 72% of Americans that are living paycheck to paycheck right now.
The funds are getting tight.
The saving rates are going down.
The affordability crisis is absolutely real.
When you hang out with real people and talk to them about what's going on,
they're spending up to 50% of their income on shelter costs already.
So it's kind of delusional to me to think, at 50%, have you ever heard of the rule of 28%?
About 28% of your income is supposed to go to shelter costs.
We're at 38% right now.
That was exactly what it was in 2008.
Whenever that ratio gets to that point, we start to see changes
in prices of rentals and changes of prices of valuations of real estate.
So this is coming.
I think it is not surprising to me the way you guys are voting at all,
because most people do kind of vote in their own self-interest.
But I created a YouTube channel about six months ago,
showing all the charts and data and all the statistics that they're pulling up on their chat,
and just telling the story of what's happening in my local market in Jacksonville.
It's changing really quickly.
It's nuanced.
Every market is very micro and has different situations.
The Northeast is not the same as the Sunbelt at all.
There's just a different setup, but they have different risks.
But that doesn't mean that this...
Maybe the magnitude of the direction of the change will be different in each market,
but it is starting to change.
And the consumer sentiment is the lowest level it's ever been in 14 years.
And so you need to ask yourself,
who is the next buyer at today's prices and today's rates who's actually going to purchase?
And if you can't really come up with that narrative,
then you need to really start rethinking your investment strategy.
All right.
Bold.
I'm going to go back to our boy Trump.
So I can say, there's a lot of...
All you can say.
Oh, well, I heard the facts coming.
I'm very bullish on the economy as a whole.
There's a lot of tailwind from manufacturing to the US,
from the very, very set and very...
Like, literally, he's so determined to drive interest rates down recently to the...
It didn't work.
And manufacturing jobs have actually been lost since he came out with those policies.
About $200 billion of mortgage bond purchases.
$200 billion only equals about a 0.25%...
AI, again, Chai TPT is real.
Productivity is real.
Every 1% of productivity is literally $300 billion to the economy
with no increase in inflation.
It's very displanitionary.
Transactions.
And I don't like NAR, but they're predicting 14% increase in transaction...
Because prices are going to come down.
There'll be more transactions.
And again, Fannie Mae predicting 7% in 2026 and 7.4% in 2027.
These are facts.
That's our sources.
I'm not just throwing stuff out of the air.
So I'm very bullish.
And at the end of the day, as you all badasses,
it all matters what you do.
Not what the economy does or Trump or John or me.
It's up to you.
All right.
So from the multifamily perspective, what we had was historic overbuilding
that happened in 21, 22.
We are currently at about 70% down from what those levels were.
Now the market during that timeframe, historically,
we were at about 95%, 95.5% to 96% occupancy across the country.
We have that drop by about 100 basis points.
So we're down about 1% from that.
But when you look at this historic number of new units coming in,
we've really absorbed them really well.
Now over the next few years, we're going to drop another 30%
from where we are right now.
So the big bubble is already here.
We've done a great job of absorbing those.
And as more and more time goes by,
and you've got less units coming on that are new,
we're going to have rents go up.
All right.
Let's go to the next slide.
Does everybody understand the concept of a steel man?
It's basically arguing the other side's point in their favor.
Warren Buffett says he never buys a stock
unless he can argue vehemently why it would fail
and why he shouldn't buy it.
Same idea on the opposite of a straw man,
which is like, yeah, go.
Good job.
We're going to do steel man.
So I'm going to let you guys steel man the bear.
Go ahead.
Both of you want to do it or one of you?
Yeah.
So what I'll give John is that there's a chance
that some markets are not going to come back as quickly.
So historically, when you look at it,
when somebody comes in and overbuilds in an area,
it's because there's long-term migration to that area.
It's just they got ahead of themselves.
That it is.
So I'm going to say it is possible
that we're going to have pockets
that don't recover as much as what we thought.
So such as Austin, maybe Jacksonville.
Don is awesome.
And there's some places like that.
So I'm going to say it is possible
that in those select markets,
we don't have increased rents.
We don't have increased prices in a three-year timeframe.
I still think we will.
But I would say if we didn't,
that would be what it was.
Is there are certain pockets
that maybe they got so overbuilt
that we're not going to be able to absorb as much
and that the net migration to those areas will not continue.
But historically, that's never happened.
The people-
Steel man, stay focused.
Okay.
Go ahead.
That's it.
Steel man.
Bear.
Totally gets your affordability
and you keep asking who's going to buy the next home.
But you really keep forgetting how much wealth there's in the U.S.
Like we do-
Are you steel manning him?
What are you talking about?
You're supposed to say you can't do it.
He's too nice of a guy.
I'll steel man my own argument.
Because it is an affordability crisis,
there is pent-up demand.
There's a whole generation of buyers out there
who are on the margin and they want to buy.
They just can't get the payment to make sense.
So if there's a way to get the payment to make sense,
and I'm not sure how far rates would have to drop.
The estimates I've seen get them down in the fours
and they'll bring back a lot of marginal buyers.
Maybe we get there.
And the Fed does step in and start buying mortgage-backed securities.
And we have a bunch of immigration to this country
to fill up these empty homes that are sitting.
I'm trying to be the steel man.
It's like, I'm going to bet on the government making rates lower
and I'm going to bet on a ton of immigration
to fill up all these homes that are currently sitting vacant,
which is about 15 million.
All right, let's do a vote.
See if anybody's mind has been changed overall.
Let's get the last QR code up here.
Last vote of the night.
Go ahead, let's vote.
Things like change like 10% of minds.
So John won the argument on account of the fact
he got 12% of you guys to switch teams.
He can still be wrong though.
Let's keep this on tape and come back in three years.
What do you want me to do?
Is there time for questions and answers
or do you want me to kill it?
First of all, give it up for John for getting a 12% swing.
Good job.
Give it up for the Bulls for their valiant effort.
And now let's do some Q&A.
Go ahead.
Great job.
John, I have a question.
Trump's going after the Fed and pumping a lot of cash into the world.
So that's number one.
I think interest rates are going to go down
and then he's going to feed the markets in every which way.
Does that at all shift your perspective on asset values increasing?
I think there's a lot of obstacles for Trump to actually get that to happen, right?
He has to get his person that he wants in there confirmed by the Senate.
There's also 12 voting members of the FOMC,
so they have to get a majority there
even if the Fed chair is somebody that Trump is putting in there himself.
The mortgage-backed securities that are being bought by Freddie and Fannie,
their balance sheet, $200 billion.
That's a drop in the bucket, guys.
It's not enough to move rates more than 25 bps.
The announcement came out and it already went right back up to where it was before.
I think we're miscalculating how much influence
the government can have at this phase of the market cycle
to really push things along further.
They were just about there where there's not much left to do,
which is why they keep throwing spaghetti at the wall,
praying that something will help the affordability problem.
Because at the end of the day, that's what we're really talking about here
because we live in a payment economy.
But I don't think they have as much control as they think they have.
The bond markets are in control.
For every quarter percent interest rate going down,
there's 250,000 new buyers that qualify in the market.
The reason that rates are as high as they are right now
is because the spread has been inflated
because of the uncertainty that's been happening
with the economy and the inflation.
As inflation cools, which it is,
there's going to be a lot more certainty
in the long-term view of a new buyer buying a home.
They're not going to be refinancing in two years.
They're going to be staying for five or seven years.
As that continues to drop,
we're going to have the same number of homes on the market.
You all said that, well, in most markets,
they're not building like they were in Austin and the Sunbelt.
In the Northeast, yeah, they're not building as much.
And in most other markets, they're not as well.
And in some of the big cities, they are,
but they're not going to be building because they're overbuilt now.
So you're going to have some absorption that happens.
In the rest of the country, other than those 10,
as those rates drop and these new buyers come into the market,
how can you not say with supply and demand
that we're going to see an increase in prices?
It's a great question.
One of the largest trends out there is the silver tsunami.
According to a Harvard study,
there's about 48 million baby boomers
who will be passing in the next decade,
and 40% of them own a home,
and 15% of those own multiple homes.
These are homes that are usually outdated.
They're in the suburbs or 3,000 plus square feet.
There's going to be a massive supply
that comes on the market over the next decade
as they sadly pass away in the silent generation,
but for different reasons.
We both agreed that there's going to be
more transactions in the future,
but for different reasons.
My reason is because I believe prices will come down
and the marginal buyer will start to come into the market.
We're about 4 million existing home sales annually right now.
We've been grinding along the bottom since 2022.
We're going to come back as sellers start to capitulate.
This stuff takes time to play out.
It takes about eight months for sellers
to really get a grip on what's actually happening,
and then they decide to sell.
The marginal seller declined,
and they wait until the next person in the community sells,
and it starts to snowball down
and show up in the appraisals,
and then the buyers are coming back in
because the affordability is there.
That's why I believe that transactions will rotate more.
All right, let's go over here.
You cited AI productivity gains
as a reason of why things are going to do better,
but Amazon just laid off 16,000 people today,
citing productivity gains from AI.
I'm starting to see that across the industry.
It's attacking more and more jobs.
So if that job loss does occur,
do you still believe the productivity gains
are going to flow into a bull market?
That's a tough question.
It's a good question.
Well, come sit right here, man.
I mean, the AI is here.
Robots are going to buy that house.
That train that left the station a long time ago.
According to Elon Musk-
He's speechless now.
What?
We're going to have robots doing all the work.
It's going to be like universal welfare, basically.
That's what he's predicting.
But I agree with you that that will support the bear case
when you have a lot of unemployment.
But I'm talking about productivity
as far as being able, as a country,
being able to do more with less.
And when we add 1% productivity,
that's literally $300 billion to the economy
with zero addition to inflation.
That's massive.
And we're only at the beginning of AI.
It's like year three.
They're not even really measuring
the impacts of AI as of yet.
Let's go right here, straight in the back.
Probably geared for you.
How many homeowners with refinanced mortgages
during COVID, 3%, 3.5% are still sitting on those
because flipping to a new house
is going to be a mortgage at 350 bps higher.
How much do you think that is locking up
the sell side of the single family market?
The lock-in effect is very real.
Great question, John.
And it's actually,
there's a great chart I can send out
where people actually starting to give up their 3%
because the sellers are just,
like, they want to move, right?
They have a lot of equity in their house.
They're willing to give some of it up.
And they're using that equity
to go buy their next house, right?
We see this with the baby boomers, 62 years old.
Plus this is happening across the board.
The median age of a home buyer
is now 61 years old in the United States,
which is a crazy statistic.
And those home buyers are basically
the people who bought 20 years ago.
And now they have a ton of equity.
And then they're selling that house
and buying another house.
But we're starting to actually see that shift
in transactions move up.
So I think they will start capitulating over time.
They're going to move
and they're going to find a way to do it.
And I think if interest rates do come down,
then that will actually speed up that process.
All right, Gabe.
I want to start by saying I love all three of you guys.
That said,
regardless of my personal beliefs on real estate,
Moe and Mike, I think John kicked your ass on stage.
That aside.
What things, Gabe?
What did we miss?
All of it.
I don't have time for that, Mike.
Okay.
Because I didn't hear John bring any statistics forward.
Yeah.
Which data points do you remember?
I think John is a great debater.
My question is actually for John.
I do love, I genuinely love all three of you guys.
John, I know that you hate multifamily real estate
and I know why you hate multifamily real estate.
And I know you maybe can't spend time talking about that.
But I want to know in the next three years,
do you personally plan to invest in real estate?
It doesn't have to be multifamily,
but any asset class because of the obvious benefits
of cashflow real estate.
Yes, there is an asset.
What?
That I would buy.
What?
It would be mobile home parks.
It would just be the pants.
Because look, if you have all this unaffordability,
what's affordable?
Where's the movement going to go towards?
And there's a lot of demand for affordable housing right now.
We're building in the wrong price point.
So I think it's a great spot.
And the modular homes are great too,
if you can build the modular homes and things like that.
So if you can build a product in an affordable price point,
the demand is there for it.
I agree with John.
Mobile home parks are also a great place to invest
in the next three years.
Jordan and then over here.
John, too.
John, obviously, I agree with you on the residential side
because I live it every day and I've seen it.
Austin was first to losing value,
and it continues to lose value.
Hopefully, that's done soon, but I actually have no idea.
My question, though, is it seems that there's
some conflicting arguments here.
Because if single family is too expensive to buy
and people can't buy, and I see this, they can't.
It's about half as much to rent as to buy in Austin.
And they're giving away insane concessions.
Yeah, two to three months free rent.
Half.
Gift cards, all sorts of stuff.
People dancing in the street with flip signs.
We see it every day.
Yeah, but to that point, Hans points this out.
There's not a lot of new permits for building.
These are being finished, all these developments.
People are moving into them.
So it seems like we will see multi-family,
and I know this is market specific,
but multi-family values increase as interest rates drop,
the rents stabilize, occupancy stabilizes,
and rents do eventually go up.
Because it seems like if you can't buy a single family house,
where are you going to go?
You're going to rent an apartment.
Agree.
Actually, somebody said you're going to live with your mom.
That's exactly what they're doing.
They're moving into their parents' houses.
Also, regarding to the permits,
we're actually at a record high of approved permits.
They're just not moving into the construction phase.
And single family.
Because it's definitely not happening in multi-family.
Okay, we got one more back here somewhere, right there.
There we go.
My question is for John,
and it goes along with what Mo was saying about the AI stuff.
And the question is really, who gets these productivity gains?
Are they going to go to the guy buying the single family
entry-level housing that's being built everywhere,
at least around where we are in Florida?
Or is it going to go to the owner of the companies
that are using the AI, laying off the 15,000 people?
The AI thing, like Mo said, the train's left the station.
These big changes are coming,
things that we've never seen before in our nation's history,
in the world ever, actually.
And it's how long is it going to take to transition
before wages come up to where they can...
I feel like a lot of people are going to lose their jobs.
And how long is that going to take for our country to absorb
and give those people new jobs or some form of new income
to allow them to buy again?
How long is that process going to take?
Yeah, it's a great question.
We're at a record number of layoffs.
Do you guys see that report that came out?
We're at a record number of layoffs since 2020.
A lot of these AI companies laying off these middle managers
and they're having to find other jobs.
But I mean, it's a great question.
That's why I said,
do you really think the AI will lead to increased wages
that'll make it more affordable?
Maybe I didn't eloquently make that connection,
but I believe that the companies will get the vast majority
of the gains and not the workers.
There's going to be people who can do 10 times
as much as a single person.
What do you do with the other nine people?
How do you repurpose them into something
that's going to have a wage that's going to be high enough
for the shelter costs at today's prices?
I also think, by the way, I think self-driving cars
are going to change the entire real estate game,
but that's for another conversation.
Just real quick, what's that have to do with real estate?
If you have to go work in person
and now you can live outside of the city 45, 50 minutes,
why would you pay double to live inside the city?
You can just hop in the car and it brings you there.
I think it's going to change the way that-
For all the ---- that's around there to go do.
It just makes it way easier to get around
and you're going to be more productive
and you can do stuff in the car.
I think it's going to change the dynamic over the next decade
as the adoption goes through.
Okay. All right, guys.
Let's give it up for our panelists here.
They've prepared.
Round of applause.
Good job, buddy.