Solar Panels Plus Farming Agrivoltaics Explained

Agriculture
95 followers
This video is brought to you by all my great patrons at patreon.com. We have a world population
expected to grow by 1.2 billion people within 15 years, coupled with a growing demand for meat,
eggs, and dairy, which soak up over 70% of fresh water for crops,
plus electricity demand that's growing even faster than the population growth.
What are we supposed to do about all of that? Well, we can combine two of my favorite things,
technology and food, both of which I've been accused of having too much of.
But could combining solar panels plus farming be a viable solution to all of those problems?
Let's take a closer look at electrifying our crops. Not literally electrifying our crops.
Let's take a closer look at adding solar to our farmland, as well as some of the side benefits
and challenges that it creates. I'm Matt Ferrell. Welcome to Undecided.
The problem with solar panels is that they need a lot of space to generate a serious amount of
electricity. Agrivoltaics, or APV for short, combines agriculture with electricity generation
by farming under a canopy of solar panels. And there's some really interesting recent
examples that make a compelling case for it, but before getting into that, it's a good idea to
understand the challenges around solar parks in general and some of the solutions that have been
developed. Solar parks in rural areas have been around for almost two decades. The major problem
with this type of solar installation is that the ground beneath the panels can't be used,
mainly due to the small amount of space between the rows of panels which aren't large enough for
modern farming equipment to pass through. It's possible to convert a typical solar park into
dual land use when it's designated as a living area for grazing by small livestock like chicken,
geese, and sheep, as well as for beekeeping. These animals are beneficial to solar farms
because they reduce the cost of maintaining vegetation growth and don't introduce any risk
to the panels themselves. The same can't be said of something a bit larger like pigs, goats,
horses, or cattle. It's a known fact that cattle hate solar panels.
And when more space is allowed between the solar panel rows, crops can be grown there.
However, the space beneath the panels still isn't usable and needs to be maintained.
This is considered alternating land use instead of dual land use because there are areas of the
land that are one or the other, not both solar and crops at the same time. The land between the
rows will be shaded during some hours of the day, meaning you're altering the characteristics of the
types of crops that can be grown there. So what if we started to go vertical with
our solar panels? That's where we start to get some interesting alternatives to standard ground
mounted solar park style installations. Using vertically mounted bifacial modules allows for
more arable land. If you don't know what bifacial solar panels are, they can collect solar energy
from both sides of the panel. This type of installation would work particularly well in
areas that suffer from wind erosion, since structures reduce wind speeds, which can help
protect the land and the crops that are grown there. The bifacial panels can also generate
more power per square meter than traditional single-faced panels and don't require any moving
parts. Then there's also the option of mounting panels on stilts, which allows farming machinery
to pass underneath. In this design you have to maintain a certain clearance between the rows
to protect the stilts from the machinery. So there's still a modest arable land surface loss,
which is usually about 3-10%. Many variations on this theme are currently under active research.
Instead of fixed panel mounting, panels can be mounted with actuators. It allows the panels to
tilt in one or two directions, which allows for both solar energy and plant growth optimization.
This can be very important for some crops during the initial stages of growth.
But what about growing crops under the elevated panels? You'd think that solar panels casting
shade on plants would be a bad thing, but the way photosynthesis works makes things
a little interesting. Plants grow their mass out of CO2 with the help of sunlight.
They literally are growing from the air. But not all available sunlight can be converted
into biomass. After a certain threshold, which is called the light saturation point,
plants can't absorb any more energy, so they need to get rid of that excess energy by evaporating
water. If we oversimplify this, we can divide the plants into two groups. The I'll have my
light supersized plants and the Can I order my light off the kids menu plants. That group,
the so-called shade plants, are particularly useful in combination with solar panels,
since the panels obviously block some of the available sunlight. Sun plants are sometimes
referred to as shade intolerant plants, which makes them sound like jerks. But this is a slight
misnomer since these plants just require more sunlight than shade plants, but they can also
suffer from too much sunlight. When any plant reaches their threshold, they can suffer from
sunburn and heat stress, just like me, causing increased amounts of water evaporation, just like
me. According to a report from the German Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy, nearly
all crops can be cultivated under solar panels, but there may be some yield loss during the less
sunny seasons for sun-hungry plants. In a Resola project conducted between 2016 and 2018
in the German area of Lake Constance, or the Bodensee as the Germans call it,
they demonstrated that during the relatively wet and cold year in 2016, APV crop yields were 25%
less than the non-solar reference field. But in the dry and hot years of 2017 and 2018,
the APV crops yielded exceeded the reference field. That's a sign that APV could be a game
changer in hot and arid regions. The amount of experience with agrivoltaics is still fairly
limited, and the big successes have been mainly done with shade tolerant crops like lettuce,
spinach, potatoes, and tomatoes. Which leads us to some of the super promising examples that make
a compelling case for agrivoltaics. But before I get to that, I want to give a quick shout out
to today's sponsor ... me. Seriously though, be sure to check out the follow up podcast based on
your feedback and comments to these videos. It's called Still to be Determined, which you can find
on all the major podcast services that are out there or at stilltbd.fm, as well as a video version
that's here on YouTube. I'll put links in the description in case you want to listen to it or
watch it, and it's a fun way to continue the discussion on all of these topics.
Now let's switch over to the Netherlands. Tiny as it is, it's the second largest
exporter of food in the world. The company Graanleven, a subsidiary of the BayWa Group,
which is headquartered in Munich, Germany, has started several pilot projects with local fruit
farmers. Their largest site is in the village of Baderich in the east of the Netherlands,
which is close to the German border. At a large 4 hectare raspberry farm, which is about 10 acres
for those of us not on metric, they've converted 3 hectares into a 2 MW agrivoltaics farm.
The remaining part was left in a traditional farming setup. Raspberries are fragile,
shade-tolerant fruits that typically grow in rows covered with plastic to help protect them
from the elements and ensure a high yield. In this project the raspberry plants were grown
directly under the solar panels, which have been placed in alternating rows facing east and west.
This maximizes the solar yield, but also protects the plants from the prevailing winds.
They did test traditional solar panels in this project, but they took away too much of the
available sunlight, so they switched to panels with a larger spacing between the solar cells
to let more of the light through. The amount and quality of the fruit produced under the panels
was the same or better as the fruit that was produced under the traditional plastic tunnels.
One big benefit for the farmer was the amount of work saved from managing those plastic tunnels,
which are easily damaged by hail and summer storms. In those cases,
fruits may become unsellable from the damage, but they still have to be harvested anyway.
During the last summer storms, the fruits under the panels didn't sustain any damage,
while the harvest from the reference field was destroyed.
Another major difference between the agrivoltaic test field and the reference field,
the temperature was several degrees cooler under the solar panels. Not only is it more pleasant
for the farm workers, but it also reduced the amount of irrigation water by 50%
compared to the reference field. Even cooler is how the crops affect the solar panels.
The crops and their limited water evaporation actually keep the panels cool. Solar panels
actually don't like the heat, since it reduces their energy efficiency. The cooler a panel can
be, the more energy it will provide. So just based on that, agrivoltaics appears to be a winning
strategy. If we were to convert even a fraction of our current agricultural land into agrivoltaics,
a large portion of our energy needs could be met ... pretty easily. And with these added benefits
and reduced water consumption, agrivoltaics could be a game changer in hot and arid regions of the
world. So what's keeping us from rolling out this dual-purpose, game-changing system at a
massive scale? What's the catch? There's always a catch. Energy production is a different ball
game from agriculture, which can slow down farmers from embracing the technology. But
actual obstacles are, sadly, mundane ... and some frustrating. It boils down to the
not-in-my-backyard effect, or the NIMBY effect. Bureaucracy and the free market.
So let's start with the NIMBY crowd. Not all renewable energy solutions are receiving a warm
reception. A prime example is obviously the sight and sound of giant wind turbines in the vicinity
of your home. Community pushback from the residents of Reno County in Kansas killed the
next-era energy wind farm. Also in agriculture, there are examples where current laws enabled
building giant biogas plants that weren't always welcomed by the local community.
No matter the reason behind the community outrage and pushback, it's this type of reaction that has
killed or delayed many projects, as well as made many local governments gun-shy of pushing them
forward. So in order to prevent communities turning against agrivoltaics, it's important
to control its spread, especially pseudo-agrivoltaics, which is a practice of
building large solar farms under the guise of agriculture. In protecting the people's interest,
it helps build community support, which is essential. The Fraunhofer Institute recommends
that 1. Agrivoltaics should be deployed mainly where synergistic effects can be achieved,
for instance by reducing the water demand from crop production. 2. To maintain proper
local support, agrivoltaic systems should be preferably operated by local farms,
energy cooperatives, or regional investors. With these guidelines in mind, community resistance
against agrivoltaics can be kept to a minimum. Next are rules, regulations, and bureaucracy,
that can also hold everything back, which varies from country to country or even from city to city.
As part of its agricultural policy, the EU grants direct payments for land use primarily
for agriculture. So an important question is whether farmland loses its eligibility for
financial support due to the use of agrivoltaics. Whether the land is mostly used for agricultural
purposes is decisive here. In the EU, agrivoltaic systems are usually considered to be a physical
structure in terms of the building regulation laws, so they need a building permit. In Germany,
for instance, it's usually prohibited in rural areas unless it doesn't conflict with a list of
public interests. Agrivoltaics, however, is not on that list of public interests yet.
And lastly, and maybe most important, is the free market, which is
pretty easy to wrap your head around, because it all comes down to costs and investment.
Just like putting solar on your home, the big number to look at is the cost per kWh.
Because agrivoltaic solar doesn't yield as much energy per square meter compared to a
traditional solar park, on top of the construction costs, the cost per kWh can be about 10-20% higher.
And then there's the big question of who owns the solar panels. In the Dutch example,
the farmer wasn't the investor or owner of the installation. A farmer's willingness to participate
all comes down to avoiding negative impacts on the crop yield and having lower operational costs
from the solar panels. In this case, the solar array owner was able to demonstrate those benefits.
The Fraunhofer Institute found that farmers are only willing to engage in a project if the crop
yield never falls below 80% of their reference field. But that's only if the farmer owns the
solar array. That's because the farmer can make up the crop shortfall from the energy produced.
But that also raises the question, if they own the array, how are they going to optimize the solar
panels for solar energy production or crop yield? For the highest energy production per square meter,
solar parks win out. For the highest guaranteed crop production, dedicated farming wins out.
It all comes down to costs and investments. Without government intervention through subsidies
or price guarantees, agrivoltaics may not stand a chance against other solar initiatives.
Agrivoltaics is a very promising concept that has the potential to kill two birds with one stone.
Helping our food supply and transitioning us to cleaner energy sources. The main benefit comes
from the fact that solar panels are great at reducing greenhouse gas emissions without
sacrificing arable land. Especially if we convert that land that's currently being used to grow
biofuel crops like palm oil and corn farms into land for actual human food production and
consumption. Or even reforestation. That would be a huge win. Dave Borlase over the Just Have
It Think YouTube channel created an incredible introductory video on the agrivoltaics concept as
well, so be sure to check out his video too. But what do you think? Should we be trying to
use agrivoltaics everywhere? Are there any other dual use renewable energy examples that you know
about? Jump into the comments and let me know. And special thanks to Patreon producer Rob
VanderWaal for helping to pull this script together. Thank you Rob. And thanks to all
my patrons for helping to make these videos possible. If you liked this video, be sure
to check out one of the ones I have linked right here. Be sure to subscribe and hit that
notification bell if you think I've earned it. Thanks so much for watching, I'll see you in the next one.
